Back to California Disability

Monique Byrd

Got an award letter unemployment showed on my portal — but I'm still on disability and confused

Okay so I need someone to help me make sense of what I'm looking at. I've been out since mid-September after a back procedure that my surgeon said would keep me down for about three months. Filed my SDI claim through SDI Online maybe a week and a half after the surgery, got my receipt number, forwarded it to the orthopedic office so they could do the medical certification. That part seemed to go fine — my claim moved out of pending and I got the Notice of Computation showing my weekly amount. Here's where it gets weird. I logged into myEDD yesterday to check on things and there's some kind of award letter or determination showing up that mentions unemployment. I'm not on unemployment. I never filed for unemployment. I'm still home recovering and definitely not able to work. My boss has been great about holding my position but I'm not getting paid by them right now — just waiting on SDI payments. Did something get crossed in EDD's system? Can a disability claim and unemployment somehow get linked by mistake? I don't want EDD thinking I'm trying to collect both at the same time because I know that's not how it works. Has anyone seen something like this in myEDD? Not sure if I should just ignore it or if I need to call in and get it sorted before it causes a payment problem.

Claim start date came up for me in a weird way too — there was a mismatch in myEDD between what my SDI claim said and what a letter I got referenced, so I figured I should sort it out before it caused any trouble. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone on the disability line, since I'd been dialing 1-800-480-3287 for days with no luck. The agent pulled up my file and confirmed the claim's start date was entered correctly on EDD's end — the letter I'd gotten was keyed to a different date than the SDI Online screen showed, and she told me to watch for a corrected notice in the mail. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

The start date thing is exactly what worries me here — if there's a mismatch somewhere that's causing an unemployment award to show up on my account, I need to know if EDD has my disability claim's start date right. Might try that number again this week.

0 coins

Mismatches like that happened to two people in my office last year. Both sorted out fine but only after someone actually got EDD on the phone.

0 coins

You cannot collect unemployment and disability at the same time — EDD is pretty clear that you can't get paid for the same days under both programs. So if there's something showing up in your portal that looks like an unemployment award, you're right to be paying attention to it rather than just letting it sit.

0 coins

Right, I know they can't overlap. What's throwing me is that I never filed for unemployment — the determination or award letter or whatever it is just appeared. That's the part I can't explain.

0 coins

Did you have a prior unemployment claim maybe? Like if you filed UI at any point in the last couple years, sometimes old correspondence shows up in the portal when EDD sends a general notice. Might be leftover from a previous claim cycle rather than something new that was opened.

0 coins

Actually — I did file unemployment briefly back in early last year before this job. That could be it. So there might just be old documentation sitting in the same myEDD account rather than something actually being active right now.

0 coins

The 49-day deadline for the medical certification is the thing that caught me off guard when I first filed. I had no idea there was a hard cutoff — I thought the doctor just submitted it whenever. Turns out if the provider misses 49 days from when your disability began, the certification can be late and the claim can run into problems. Worth double-checking that your orthopedic office got it in on time, especially since you said the claim already moved out of pending.

0 coins

Mine cleared pending already so I think the certification came in okay, but the 49-day thing is good to know. My surgeon's office is usually on top of things but I'll confirm the submission date with them anyway.

0 coins

The 49-day window applies to the claimant's part too, not just the doctor. So if someone waits too long to file their own section of the claim, they can get disqualified even if the provider submits fast. File as soon as you're able.

0 coins

My provider almost missed it because they assumed I'd handle everything. Keep reminding them — they see so many patients that yours can easily fall through.

0 coins

Something that might clarify this — myEDD is basically one login that ties to any EDD program you've ever touched. So unemployment, disability, PFL, they're all visible from the same account dashboard. An award letter from an old unemployment claim would show up in that same portal even though it has nothing to do with your current SDI claim. If the award letter has a date from before your disability start date, that's almost certainly what you're looking at.

0 coins

Checked just now — the date on that letter is from earlier this year, well before my surgery. So it really does sound like it's just a document from the old UI claim sitting in there. That's such a relief.

0 coins

The myEDD portal can be confusing like that. When I first saw multiple items in my account I panicked thinking EDD had opened duplicate claims on me. Took me a bit to realize they were just different program records.

0 coins

Glad you found the date — that detail basically settles it. Old UI docs just living in myEDD alongside the active DI stuff.

0 coins

Are you on automatic payments or are you certifying manually every two weeks? Asking because the automatic payment setup works differently and there's a form EDD sends after a certain number of payments that you have to return or the benefits stop. Just want to make sure you're not missing anything on that side while you're focused on the portal mystery.

0 coins

I set up direct deposit when I filed so I think I'm on the automatic payment track. What's the form you're talking about?

0 coins

After five payments — that's about ten weeks of benefits — EDD mails out a questionnaire called the DE 2593 asking if you're still unable to work. You have 20 days to send it back. If you miss it your payments pause. Watch the mail for it.

0 coins

Twenty days sounds like enough time but I'm going to put a reminder in my phone now. The last thing I need is payments stopping over a form I didn't know was coming.

0 coins

The DE 2593 tripped me up hard. Came on a week I was at follow-up appointments all day and I almost missed the return window. Set a physical reminder too, not just a phone one.

0 coins

To confirm what others said about the unemployment and disability overlap — EDD literally will not pay you for the same day under both programs. If somehow both were active, they'd catch it and you'd end up with an overpayment notice to deal with. The good news from your situation is that the unemployment record appears to be from a prior claim, so there's nothing active that would create that conflict.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are brutal. Had one from an overlap situation that wasn't even my fault — a payroll reporting error — and it still took months to sort out through the appeals process.

0 coins

Appeals exist for exactly that reason. If EDD issues an overpayment notice you can appeal within 30 days of the date on it and explain what happened. Keep documentation of everything.

0 coins

How long has it been since the medical certification came in? I'm asking because even after the cert is submitted there can be a gap before payments actually start landing. The claim moving out of pending is a good sign but it's not the same as a payment being issued.

0 coins

About two and a half weeks since it moved out of pending. I've had one payment land so far, covering the first week after the waiting period ended. Waiting on the second one now.

0 coins

Two and a half weeks and one payment is pretty normal from what I've seen. The seven-day waiting period at the start is unpaid regardless, so your first payable day was day eight of the disability. Sounds like things are running on track.

0 coins

The waiting period confusion is real — a lot of people think those first seven days are just slow processing. They're not. EDD doesn't pay for those days at all, it's built into every new claim. Day eight is when the payable period begins.

0 coins

Notice of Computation on my claim had a weekly amount that looked lower than I expected, so I tried calling EDD to understand what base period quarter they used for the calculation. Kept getting disconnected after long holds. Eventually got through to an agent using Claimyr — the agent confirmed which quarter of my wages they'd pulled and that the amount on the notice was what my payments would be based on. Told me to use the calculator on EDD's site if I wanted to check the math myself.

0 coins

That calculator on EDD's site — is it on the main edd.ca.gov page? I want to run my own numbers just to double-check my Notice of Computation since my hours varied a lot last year.

0 coins

It's on edd.ca.gov, there's a disability benefits calculator in the DI section. Just plug in your quarterly wages and it'll show you the estimate. Keep in mind the actual amount on your notice controls, the calculator is just an estimate.

0 coins

The base period thing is confusing — it's not just your most recent paychecks, it's a specific 12-month window that ends a few months before your claim starts. So wages from your most recent quarter might not even be in it.

0 coins

Can workers' comp and SDI overlap at all? I know someone who got hurt doing something technically not at work but EDD flagged her claim and mentioned workers' comp anyway. Just wondering if there's ever a situation where both apply.

0 coins

EDD itself says it's not common to get paid workers' comp and SDI at the same time. There can be exceptions but that's a narrow situation and you'd need to ask EDD directly how your specific case would be treated — nobody on a forum can tell you how EDD handles that for sure.

0 coins

Makes sense. Her situation was complicated, she should probably just contact EDD directly on that one rather than relying on what anyone assumes.

0 coins

Workers' comp is for work-related injuries, SDI is for things that happen off the job. When there's a question about which one applies or whether both do, that really is EDD's call to make, not something to guess at.

0 coins

The receipt number your doctor needs — did you ever confirm they had the right one? I ask because my claim sat pending an extra week and a half because my provider's office had copied down a different number from an earlier visit record I'd brought in. Easy mistake, big delay.

0 coins

My claim already cleared pending but I did specifically give them the receipt number I got from SDI Online right after I filed, not any other number. Sounds like that was the right move.

0 coins

Exactly the right move. The receipt number from SDI Online is what ties the provider's certification to your specific claim. If they submit with anything else EDD can't match it up.

0 coins

My provider submitted twice because of a number issue and the second one was what actually matched. Annoying delay but the second submission fixed it.

0 coins

About the portal showing unemployment stuff — just to pile on the reassurance here, I had the same experience when I went on disability. Saw an old UI correspondence in myEDD and spent two days worried I'd done something wrong. Turns out it was just sitting there from a claim I'd filed three years earlier. Never affected my SDI claim at all.

0 coins

Two days worrying over old paperwork is basically exactly what I did here. Glad to know it's a common thing and not some system error.

0 coins

Forums like this would have saved me a lot of stress. I had no idea that myEDD shows all your EDD history across programs in one place.

0 coins

The all-in-one portal is convenient but it really does cause panic when you see something you don't recognize. Clearer labels on what's current vs. historical would help so much.

0 coins

Trying to figure out which weeks EDD actually paid me for was a whole thing on my own claim — the payment that landed in my account didn't line up with what I expected based on when I filed. Called the automated line at 1-800-480-3287 first but that only tells you so much. Ended up using Claimyr to reach someone in the disability office, and the agent went through each week and told me which ones had been paid and which were still processing. Cleared up the confusion fast.

0 coins

The automated line is where I've been checking too. Good to know there's a way to get more detail on individual weeks if the automated info doesn't match up.

0 coins

Payment timing can vary a little week to week and it's hard to tell from the automated line which specific weeks a payment covers. Having an agent lay it out week by week would actually be really useful.

0 coins

Since your claim is active and you've had a payment come through, the main things to keep an eye on going forward are: the DE 2593 form around the ten-week mark if you end up on that long, and your doctor's office submitting the extension form if you need more time beyond what the original certification covered.

0 coins

What's the extension process like? My surgeon mentioned there might be a few extra weeks after the originally estimated recovery time.

0 coins

Your doctor fills out a form called the DE 2525XX — the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate. EDD typically sends it to you with the final payment notice so you know to bring it to your provider. Your doctor submits it, not you, and it extends the same claim you already have open. No new claim needed.

0 coins

Really helpful — I'll mention the DE 2525XX to my surgeon's office at my next appointment so they're not caught off guard if EDD sends it.

0 coins

How does bonding with the baby work after pregnancy disability ends? My wife is about five weeks out from her due date and we're trying to plan. She's on disability now and we want to know when she'd switch to the other benefit.

0 coins

Pregnancy disability and bonding are two separate programs. After the disability period ends — typically six weeks for a vaginal birth or eight for a C-section, though a provider can extend for complications — bonding is handled through Paid Family Leave, which is its own claim filed separately. PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way SDI does.

0 coins

So she'd file a new claim for PFL after the disability claim ends? They don't automatically link or transfer?

0 coins

Correct, she'd file a new PFL claim. EDD may send information about it but the filing doesn't happen automatically. Worth planning ahead so there's no gap between the disability period ending and PFL starting.

0 coins

Can someone clarify — the Notice of Computation isn't actually an approval, right? I keep seeing people treat it like EDD said yes, the claim is approved, when I thought it just meant they calculated a potential benefit amount.

0 coins

Exactly right. The Notice of Computation shows what your potential weekly and maximum benefit amount would be — it's EDD doing the math, not saying you're eligible. The actual approval comes through payments starting or through a Notice of Determination if there's a problem.

0 coins

Logged into my account and re-read mine after this thread and yeah, it really does just say 'potential.' I'll stop telling people it's the approval notice.

0 coins

The language on EDD's documents is oddly subtle about that. 'Potential' is the key word and it's easy to skip past it.

0 coins

If EDD denies a claim or issues an overpayment notice and you think they got it wrong, 30 days from the date on the notice is your window to appeal. Use the form that comes with the notice — it's the DE 1000A — or write a detailed letter if you can't find the form. That deadline matters a lot and there's no automatic extension just because you didn't see the notice right away.

0 coins

30 days goes fast. Is there any recourse if you miss the window?

0 coins

A late appeal is possible but you have to give reasons for the delay, and an administrative law judge decides whether to accept it. It's not guaranteed. Much easier to just file on time.

0 coins

Missing appeal deadlines is how people end up stuck with overpayments that could have been disputed. Put the date on your calendar the day the notice arrives.

0 coins

Extension situation on my claim — my doctor said I needed another three weeks after my original certification period ended, and I wasn't sure whether to file a whole new SDI claim or just have her submit something additional. DE 2525XX came with my final payment notice just like it's supposed to, and my doctor submitted it. But I had a question about whether EDD had received it, so I went through Claimyr to reach a disability agent. The agent confirmed the DE 2525XX was in and told me which weeks were still pending on my end.

0 coins

Good to hear that actually works the way EDD describes it. I was going to ask my surgeon about the extension process and now I know what form to reference.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX being sent with the final payment notice is the detail most people don't know going in. Easy to miss or throw away if you're not expecting it. Glad the form came through for you.

0 coins

Does filing SDI affect your W-2 or anything for taxes at the end of the year? Asking for a friend who's nervous about a big SDI payment affecting their tax situation.

0 coins

California doesn't tax SDI benefits, but the federal side is a different question that depends on individual circumstances. EDD has tax information on their site, and for anything specific about the federal treatment it's worth talking to a tax professional rather than relying on what someone on a forum says.

0 coins

Makes sense, I'll point them to EDD's site and suggest they ask their tax person about the federal part. Didn't want to guess wrong.

0 coins

The California-not-taxable part is what most people want to hear and that part at least is consistent. Federal side has too many variables to generalize.

0 coins

EDD's payments going to the Money Network prepaid card is something nobody warned me about. I had an old Bank of America EDD debit card from an unemployment claim years ago and I assumed disability would go to something similar or the same card. It didn't — it's the Money Network card now. Set up direct deposit through SDI Online if you want it to go straight to your bank.

0 coins

Good catch — I did set up direct deposit when I filed so I think I bypassed the card entirely. But if I hadn't known, I'd probably have been waiting on a card that wasn't coming.

0 coins

The direct deposit option in SDI Online is definitely the cleaner route. The card works fine too once it arrives but there's always a lag when you're first expecting it.

0 coins

The Bank of America card people remember is from older claims. EDD moved to Money Network and not everyone got the memo. I had to actually read the mailer carefully to figure out it was a different issuer.

0 coins

Physical therapist submitted the cert for someone I know, and EDD didn't process it. Had to go back and get a physician to submit instead. Worth knowing — a PT isn't on EDD's list of who can certify for a disability claim. Has to be someone like an MD, DO, NP, PA, or other provider EDD actually recognizes.

0 coins

Correct — EDD's list includes licensed physicians, osteopathic doctors, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, licensed midwives and certain others. Physical therapists aren't on it. The certification has to come from someone EDD authorizes.

0 coins

The person I know lost about two weeks sorting that out. If your treating provider isn't on the list, get the certification from a supervising physician instead — most PT patients are still seeing an MD too.

0 coins

Having the wrong type of provider submit is a delay nobody wants. Worth confirming before they submit so you don't have to circle back.

0 coins

Can someone who lost their job while on SDI still collect disability? Like if the employer let someone go while they were out recovering, do the SDI payments keep going?

0 coins

DI covers you for the days you can't work due to your condition — that's what the program is for. As for what happens when a layoff or termination happens during a claim, that's something to ask EDD directly since how it affects each case can vary. When you're able to work again, that's when unemployment comes into play.

0 coins

So disability and unemployment cover different situations — disability when you can't work, unemployment when you can but don't have a job. That at least makes sense as a framework.

0 coins

Exactly that framework. EDD decides each claim on its own facts, so if that situation comes up for someone they should contact EDD and ask how their own claim is treated, not go by what anyone assumes the outcome will be.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure