EDD SDI Independent Medical Exam was a joke - 2-hour wait for 60-second appointment
I just had my EDD-required Independent Medical Exam (IME) today for my SDI claim and I'm completely baffled. Waited over 2 hours in the waiting room only for the doctor to walk in, ask my name, age, and what was causing my pain. Then he just said 'ok' and WALKED OUT! No physical exam, no review of my medical records, nothing. The whole 'examination' took maybe 60 seconds. I'm freaking out that my disability benefits will be denied because this doctor didn't actually evaluate anything. Has anyone else experienced this? Will EDD deny my claim based on this joke of an examination? This is my first time on disability and I'm so confused about what happens next.
18 comments
Sophia Rodriguez
Same thing happened to me last year! Doc barely looked at me. Still got approved tho.
0 coins
James Johnson
•Really? That gives me some hope. Did you have to wait long after your IME to hear about your claim status?
0 coins
Mia Green
This is actually fairly common with EDD-ordered IMEs. These doctors are contracted to perform dozens of these exams daily and they're often looking for specific red flags rather than conducting a comprehensive evaluation. The doctor will submit a report to EDD based on your medical records (which they review before/after seeing you) and those few questions they asked. Your best course of action is to: 1. Document exactly what happened during the appointment (as you did here) 2. Continue following your regular doctor's treatment plan 3. If you receive an adverse determination based on this IME, you can appeal with detailed notes about the inadequate examination In many cases, the IME doctor will simply confirm your regular physician's assessment, especially if your medical documentation is thorough.
0 coins
James Johnson
•Thank you so much for this detailed response! That makes me feel better. My regular doctor has been documenting everything thoroughly. How long after the IME did it take for your claim status to update?
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
These IME doctors get PAID PER APPOINTMENT!!!!! They're not there to help you, they're there to process as many people as possible and collect $$$$. The whole system is CORRUPT. I had an IME where the doctor literally wrote that I was "observed running in the parking lot" when I was using a WALKER that day!! I appealed and WON but it took 3 months of STRESS and NO INCOME!!!!
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
•This happened to me too! The IME doctor completely misrepresented my condition in his report. I requested a copy through my local EDD office and was shocked. Make sure you get a copy of the IME report as soon as possible - you have the right to see what they wrote about you.
0 coins
Olivia Martinez
I handle disability cases professionally, and this type of IME experience is unfortunately common. These doctors are looking for inconsistencies between what's in your medical file and what you report verbally. The brevity doesn't necessarily mean a negative outcome. After an IME, EDD typically takes 5-10 business days to process the report and update your claim status. If your regular treating physician has provided solid documentation of your disability, the IME is often just a verification step rather than the sole determining factor. If you're concerned, you might want to contact EDD to check on your claim status, though reaching them can be challenging with their high call volumes.
0 coins
Charlie Yang
•I got through to EDD last week using Claimyr (claimyr.com). They connected me to an EDD rep in about 20 minutes when I'd been trying for days on my own. Totally worth it for peace of mind. They have a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ?si=1hcSq3KFtCr4oAmd
0 coins
Grace Patel
My IME was exactly like yours but with a twist - the doctor spent more time typing on his computer than actually examining me. When I got my determination letter 2 weeks later, it stated the IME doctor found "no objective medical evidence" of disability despite my MRIs showing herniated discs! Make sure you're documenting everything. If they deny you based on this IME, immediately file an appeal and contact your treating physician to provide additional supporting documentation. The good news is that many appeals are successful if you have proper medical documentation. The bad news is that appeals can take 6-8 weeks to process in 2025. My appeal took exactly 7 weeks.
0 coins
ApolloJackson
•omg 7 weeks? how did u pay bills during that time??? im scared now
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
has anyone else noticed these IME appointments are always in weird office buildings with like no signage? mine was in some random building with no elevator and i have a bad back lol. had to climb stairs and was in so much pain by the time the doc saw me but he still barely examined me
0 coins
Emma Bianchi
•YES!!!! Mine was in a CREEPY old medical building with flickering lights and weird stains on the carpet. These IME doctors are operating out of the cheapest possible locations to MAXIMIZE PROFITS!!! It's all a SCAM to deny hardworking people their BENEFITS!!!
0 coins
Lucas Kowalski
After my experience with an IME last year, I learned it's helpful to bring a copy of all your medical records with you to the appointment. While the doctor should have them already, sometimes they don't review them thoroughly beforehand. I also started keeping a daily symptom journal that documented my disability, which proved invaluable when I had to appeal my initial determination. Did the IME doctor give you any paperwork or tell you what the next steps would be?
0 coins
James Johnson
•No paperwork at all! He just walked out and the receptionist told me I could leave. No explanation of next steps or when I'd hear back. I wish I'd known to bring copies of my records - that's a great tip.
0 coins
Mia Green
Just to follow up on my earlier comment - I've seen many cases where the IME appears rushed but the outcome is still favorable. The doctor may have already reviewed your file thoroughly before you arrived. One important thing to know: California law gives your treating physician's opinion significant weight in disability determinations. So even if the IME doctor disagrees, your regular doctor's assessment can often prevail, especially if they've been documenting your condition consistently. If your claim status doesn't update within 10-14 days after the IME, I'd recommend contacting EDD to check on the status. Make sure to document all communication attempts with EDD.
0 coins
James Johnson
•This is really reassuring, thank you. My regular doctor has been thoroughly documenting everything since my injury in January. I'll give it two weeks before I start trying to contact EDD about the status.
0 coins
Isabella Russo
my uncle had same thing happen last month with his back injury claim and he still got approved so maybe its not as bad as it seems?
0 coins
Rajiv Kumar
•This varies widely! My brother had a similar experience but his claim was denied and he had to appeal. The system seems inconsistent.
0 coins