Back to California Disability

Kevin Bell

Does applying for unemployment after SDI ends reduce benefit amount?

So my SDI claim is wrapping up in a few weeks and my doctor hasn't cleared me to go back full time yet but HR is saying my position might not be there when I return anyway. My wife keeps asking what happens to unemployment after all this and whether starting a UI claim right after SDI would somehow mess up what I already got or lower what I'd get from unemployment. I honestly don't know how the two programs interact. Do they look at the same wages? Does the SDI payout affect what unemployment calculates? I've been googling and getting nowhere, and the EDD line is a wall of busy signals. Anyone gone through this transition?

Medical certification came back unmatched on mine for two weeks and I finally got through to an EDD agent using Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my provider had submitted under a different receipt number, so it hadn't attached. Once I gave her the right one she noted the fix. As for SDI into unemployment, the agent said those are separate claims and your SDI payments don't reduce what unemployment calculates.

0 coins

The receipt number mismatch is the part I'd want to understand better. When the agent noted the fix, did she say EDD would contact the provider, or was your office supposed to resubmit with the correct number?

0 coins

She said the provider's office needed to resubmit under the correct receipt number, which I'd given my doctor's billing department right after. They resubmitted the same afternoon and the certification showed as received by the next morning.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. three mornings, same result every time. glad it worked for you at least.

0 coins

Wait, so unemployment uses completely different wages than SDI? I guess I assumed they all pulled from the same pot somehow. Does that mean you could get a totally different weekly amount from UI than what your Notice of Computation showed for SDI?

0 coins

Unemployment and SDI each calculate from their own base period, and the quarters they look at don't necessarily overlap the same way. Your Notice of Computation is specific to your DI claim. UI will do its own calculation when you file that claim.

0 coins

So the SDI benefit amount on my notice has nothing to do with what unemployment might pay. That actually makes me feel a little better because I was afraid the SDI would somehow count against me.

0 coins

Right, and to be clear, you can't collect both at the same time for the same days. EDD's rule is that UI requires you to be able and available to work. So while you're still on disability, you're on SDI, and once your doctor clears you and SDI ends, that's when unemployment becomes an option.

0 coins

They're two different programs. SDI is for when you can't work. Unemployment is for when you can work but don't have a job. One doesn't shrink the other.

0 coins

Not sure I fully follow. If my doctor clears me and my job is gone, do I file for unemployment right then? Or do I have to wait for SDI to officially close out first?

0 coins

File for UI once SDI ends and you're able to work. Don't file while you're still on disability, you'd be certifying you're able to work every week for UI and that's not accurate if you're still out.

0 coins

The day SDI issues your final payment is a reasonable time to get your UI claim started, since there can be a waiting period on that end too and you don't want a gap in coverage any longer than it has to be.

0 coins

The EDD phone line situation is genuinely something else. Called Monday through Thursday last week before 9am each time, same recording, same dead end. If anyone has a UI question after SDI they'd better have weeks to spare trying to reach a person.

0 coins

ive had the same week. monday and tuesday i got through to the busy signal within like 30 seconds. not even a hold, just done.

0 coins

Fourteen months on SDI and I've made peace with the fact that reaching EDD by phone is basically a hobby now.

0 coins

My cousin works nights and was trying to call on her lunch break which is like 2am her time obviously that wasn't going to work, she kept trying mornings for a full week before she finally got through somehow. The whole setup is exhausting.

0 coins

Waiting period question came up on my own claim and I rang EDD through Claimyr after four days of busy signals. The agent confirmed the first seven days of my claim were the non-payable waiting period, not a processing delay, so my payment count started on day eight. Knowing that stopped me from worrying the wrong payment was missing. For the SDI to unemployment question, the agent also said the two programs don't share a benefit pool.

0 coins

The waiting period is exactly what I need clarity on for my own situation. Seven days non-payable sounds right but I want to confirm which exact dates mine covers. I'll give Claimyr a go for that. Anything specific to have ready before the call?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your claim ID from SDI Online ready, and know the exact date your disability began. The agent can pull up the specific days on the claim from that.

0 coins

Appreciated reading this. I've been confusing the waiting period with EDD just being slow, good to know those are two different things entirely.

0 coins

The waiting period tripped me up too when I first filed! I thought something was wrong when that first week showed no payment. Turns out everything was fine.

0 coins

The rule as EDD lays it out is that you can't receive unemployment and disability for the same days. So once your SDI claim closes and your provider signs off that you're able to return to work, that's the point when unemployment eligibility kicks in, assuming you meet UI's own requirements. Your SDI payments don't factor into what UI would pay.

0 coins

What about if the doctor clears me for light duty but my old job doesn't have light duty work? Does that count as able and available for UI purposes?

0 coins

That's honestly a question for EDD to answer on your specific situation. Generally, being available for some work matters, but whether partial restrictions affect your UI eligibility is something their claims examiners determine. I wouldn't want to guess wrong on that one.

0 coins

Agreed that one needs EDD's answer. File the UI claim and disclose the restrictions. EDD decides from there.

0 coins

my manager told me SDI would basically cancel out my unemployment, like EDD would subtract it. she was wrong lol. they're totally separate. SDI is done by the time you're on unemployment anyway.

0 coins

She probably mixed it up with something else. The two claims don't interact that way.

0 coins

So many people think that too! My coworker told me the same thing when I was on disability last year. The rumor just floats around workplaces.

0 coins

Worth checking EDD's site for the UI benefit calculator once you're ready to file. It'll give you a rough estimate based on your wages. The SDI you received won't appear in that calculation at all because disability benefits aren't wages.

0 coins

That makes sense now. SDI replaced lost wages but it wasn't wages itself, so UI wouldn't count it in the base period earnings.

0 coins

Exactly right. The base period for UI looks at your actual wages subject to taxes, not benefit payments. Your employer still reported your pre-disability wages so those quarters still count.

0 coins

also just to say if ur employer paid you during disability through some kind of company program that might be different. like if wages actually went through payroll. not 100% sure how that works with edd but my manager mentioned it once

0 coins

That gets into voluntary plan territory and each employer's arrangement differs. EDD would need to sort out how wages paid during leave interact with the specific claim. Best not to assume either way.

0 coins

yeah i figured. just throwing it out there in case someone else has that situation

0 coins

Base period question on my own claim had me spinning for a bit. Got on a call with EDD after trying Claimyr and the agent told me exactly which quarter they'd used to calculate my benefit amount. Turned out it was the highest-paid quarter from my base period and the amount on my Notice of Computation reflected that. For your SDI to UI question, those are two separate calculations entirely, UI won't penalize you for what SDI paid.

0 coins

Highest-paid quarter matching the Notice of Computation is the same thing I saw on mine. Used Claimyr for a receipt number question on my claim. Once the agent confirmed EDD had it on file I went ahead and followed up with my doctor's office to make sure everything was matched up on their end too.

0 coins

the line i was hitting before i found anything that worked was unbearable. three weeks of trying before i got actual info on my claim.

0 coins

Knowing which quarter was used is so helpful for understanding where that number on the notice came from. Glad you got that answered.

0 coins

Can I ask something kind of different? My sister went back to work part time before her SDI ended and she reported it to EDD. Does doing that change what unemployment would calculate later? Like does the part-time pay affect the base period for UI?

0 coins

Part-time wages earned while partially on SDI are real wages and would be in the payroll records EDD sees for UI. So yes, they'd factor into whichever quarters they fall in for the UI base period, which could help or not depending on the amounts.

0 coins

Interesting. So reporting part-time work honestly to SDI is the right move and it doesn't hurt the UI calculation, it just reflects actual wages. Good to know she did the right thing.

0 coins

Reporting partial wages to EDD is required, and not doing so can create an overpayment on the SDI side. The UI calculation later is a separate matter and uses the actual wages on record regardless.

0 coins

Kind of panicking reading this thread because my SDI ends next month and I still don't have confirmation from HR whether my job is there. What paperwork do I even start gathering now so I'm not scrambling?

0 coins

Final payment notice from EDD, your last pay stubs before disability started, and your employer's separation information if it comes to that. UI will ask about your last day of work and why you're no longer employed.

0 coins

The final notice EDD sends when your SDI benefit period ends is worth saving. It has your claim dates on it which UI may ask about.

0 coins

I didn't realize the SDI final notice would matter for UI. I was just going to toss it after everything wrapped up.

0 coins

Nobody's SDI benefit amount is affected by what comes after on UI. The two don't touch each other. EDD runs them on parallel tracks.

0 coins

Exactly this. File for UI when SDI is done and you're cleared to work. Don't overthink it.

0 coins

For anyone anxious about timing, you can actually file your UI claim the same week your SDI ends! You don't have to wait and wonder, just get it in right away so the UI waiting period starts as soon as possible.

0 coins

The statement that UI has its own waiting period is the accurate part. File quickly so it doesn't stretch the gap in payments.

0 coins

Wait, UI also has a waiting period? How long?

0 coins

That's something to check on EDD's unemployment side since it's a different program and I don't want to give you a wrong number. The UI FAQs on EDD's site will have the current answer.

0 coins

my SDI ended and i filed UI like four days later. the UI amount was completely different from my SDI weekly amount, more in my case actually because my wages were higher in the quarters UI looked at. so they definitely calculate separately.

0 coins

This is exactly what I was hoping to hear from someone who went through it. Good to know the SDI payments themselves didn't pull the UI number down.

0 coins

yeah it was nothing like i feared. just file, let EDD do its thing, and they calculate UI on its own terms.

0 coins

For the job situation your HR mentioned, that's an employer and HR conversation, possibly touching on CFRA protections. EDD handles the benefits side only. Those are separate tracks.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll keep the HR issue with HR and keep the SDI and UI stuff with EDD. Trying not to let them blur together in my head.

0 coins

Wise to keep them separate. EDD's scope is the benefit calculation, and what your employer owes you for job protection is a different question entirely, worth raising with the Civil Rights Department's CFRA guidance.

0 coins

The EDD disability line is 1-800-480-3287 for anyone who actually manages to get through. Good luck is what I'll say about that.

0 coins

ive had that number memorized since june. doesnt help if nobody picks up

0 coins

spanish line is 1-866-658-8846 for anyone who needs it

0 coins

SDI ending doesn't wipe out your base period wages for UI. Those wages are on record from before your disability began. The SDI payments are not wages, so they don't appear in the base period either way.

0 coins

So my pre-disability wages are still sitting there in the base period waiting for UI to use them? That's honestly a relief.

0 coins

Yes. The wages your employer reported before you went on disability don't disappear because you filed SDI. They're in the system and UI will find them.

0 coins

The clearest way I can put it: SDI pays you while you're unable to work. UI pays you while you're able to work but don't have a job. The two programs hand off at the moment your doctor says you're clear. Neither one reduces what the other calculated.

0 coins

That's the simplest version of it and it's correct. The only rule that connects them is you can't be on both at the same time for the same days.

0 coins

This is the answer I needed honestly. SDI is done, doctor clears me, file UI, two separate calculations. Nothing from SDI drags down UI.

0 coins

Bookmarking this whole exchange mentally. I didn't realize how clearly separated the two were until this thread.

0 coins

One date to track: EDD's automated line at 1-800-480-3287 can tell you when your last SDI payment issued. Keep that date, because UI will likely ask when your most recent employer-related income or benefits period ended.

0 coins

The automated line is actually useful for payment date questions. It doesn't require a live agent and gives real claim status.

0 coins

Didn't know the automated line could actually do that. I've only tried for a live person and given up.

0 coins

Just want to say thank you to everyone here. This thread answered something I've seen confuse a dozen clients at the salon too. They always think SDI somehow follows them into unemployment and lowers what they get.

0 coins

Genuinely a question that comes up a lot. The idea that the two programs share one pot of money is a surprisingly common assumption.

0 coins

EDD could make it clearer on their site. The transition instructions between programs are not exactly front-page material.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure