Back to California Disability

Brandon Parker

Does SDI withhold taxes for maternity leave benefits in California?

So I'm about 32 weeks along and finally sat down to actually figure out the money side of my leave. I know I'll be on SDI for the pregnancy and delivery part, and my HR person mentioned something about taxes but couldn't really answer my question. Does SDI withhold taxes for maternity leave benefits automatically, or does that happen later at tax time? I don't want a surprise bill in April when I'm already stretched thin with a new baby. I filed my claim through SDI Online about two weeks ago and I'm still waiting on the Notice of Computation. Is that where the tax info shows up? I genuinely don't know how any of this works and I keep finding conflicting things when I search online.

The Notice of Computation doesn't have tax withholding details on it, it just shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amounts. California does not tax SDI benefits at the state level, so nothing gets taken out for California income tax. The federal side is a different question and depends on your own situation, so I'd point you to EDD's tax information page or a tax professional rather than guess at it here.

0 coins

Thank you, that's actually really helpful. So the Notice of Computation is just the benefit amount, not any kind of approval? I wasn't sure what it meant when it showed up.

0 coins

Exactly right. The notice showing up means EDD calculated a potential amount, not that the claim is approved. Payments and any eligibility decision come separately after your medical certification is processed.

0 coins

I keep reading things that say SDI benefits are taxable federally and other things that say they're not, I really don't know which is right for my situation. Should I just call EDD and ask?

0 coins

EDD's own site has a tax information section under disability insurance. For the federal question you'd really want to run it by a tax professional since it depends on factors specific to your situation, not something EDD's line is set up to answer.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and I had the same tax question but honestly what I really needed to know was whether the amount on it was what I'd actually get each week. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with an EDD agent after I'd spent three mornings trying that line and getting nowhere. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the weekly benefit amount on the notice matched what my payments would be, based on my highest-earning quarter. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For the tax piece she said to check EDD's tax information page since that's outside what they determine on the claim side.

0 coins

The highest-earning quarter part is what I was stuck on too, I had Claimyr going on a Thursday morning and an agent walked me through which quarter they used. Once I had that I figured out the waiting period question I had, the first seven days don't pay out no matter how fast EDD processes things, it's just a non-payable stretch built into every new claim. Tried that disability line probably six times before that anyway.

0 coins

How many mornings are we actually talking before you got someone. I've redialed that number until my thumb hurt.

0 coins

Four mornings for me, every one of them either rang out or hit that recording that just ends the call.

0 coins

Same story. Redialed for two days straight before my claim got sorted. That line is a joke.

0 coins

To add some context to what was said above about the federal question: the general understanding is that California SDI benefits aren't subject to California income tax, and EDD confirms that on their site. Federal treatment is genuinely case-by-case and a tax pro is the right call there. EDD doesn't withhold anything from your payments automatically, so whatever you might owe federally you'd handle at filing time.

0 coins

So there's no option to have them withhold federal taxes from the SDI payments the way some employers do from a paycheck?

0 coins

Not on the EDD side, no. SDI payments go out without withholding. If you end up owing something federally you'd just deal with it when you file your return.

0 coins

That part about no withholding is what worries me a little, I don't want to underpay estimated taxes. I'll bring it up with my accountant before the baby comes.

0 coins

No withholding comes out of SDI. What you get is what you get. Figure out the federal question with a tax person before your leave starts, not after.

0 coins

Makes sense to get ahead of it. My HR person kept saying they weren't sure and I should ask EDD but EDD's phone line is impossible to get through.

0 coins

Yeah the phone line is rough. Try SDI Online for most stuff, you can send a message through there and get an answer in writing.

0 coins

The SDI Online message option saved me a lot of trouble. Got an answer in a few days without fighting the phone line.

0 coins

Honestly the California no-state-tax thing was news to me when I went on leave last year. I kept expecting to see something taken out and nothing ever was. Ended up setting a little aside myself just in case on the federal side, lol, and it turned out to be about right.

0 coins

That's smart honestly. Better to have a small buffer than to be caught short at filing time.

0 coins

That's what I'm thinking too, just set a portion aside myself rather than be surprised.

0 coins

One thing worth pinning down before your leave: the base period EDD uses to calculate your weekly amount goes back 5 to 18 months from your claim start date, using the highest-paid quarter in a 12-month window. If you had any months with lower wages, like reduced hours, it's worth running your numbers through the disability benefits calculator on EDD's site before you file so the Notice of Computation isn't a surprise.

0 coins

I had about six weeks of reduced hours earlier this year for unrelated reasons. So that quarter might bring the number down?

0 coins

It depends on which quarter EDD lands on as the highest one. The calculator on EDD's site lets you plug in your quarters and see the estimate. Worth doing before your leave starts.

0 coins

The base period thing tripped me up too. I thought it was just my most recent pay but it's a specific lookback window. The calculator really does help clarify it.

0 coins

you file your claim like 4 weeks before your due date right thats what i heard

0 coins

Typically around four weeks before the due date is when EDD suggests filing for pregnancy, yes. If your provider certifies complications or work restrictions earlier than that, benefits can start before the four-week mark.

0 coins

ok good thats what my coworker said i just wasnt sure if it was different now

0 coins

Same thing my doctor told me! She said get the paperwork in around four weeks out and don't wait until the last minute.

0 coins

Pending weeks question was eating at me for a while, couldn't get anyone at EDD to tell me which weeks had actually been paid. Used Claimyr on a Friday, spoke to an agent who went through my claim and read off exactly which weeks had issued and which were still sitting. That was for my maternity claim, same kind as yours.

0 coins

How is that even possible. I have tried that number at eight in the morning, noon, and once at four forty-five and I get either a busy signal or that recording. Something about that sounds like it got lucky.

0 coins

Tried that line eleven times over two weeks before I used Claimyr. The agent was an actual EDD employee, pulled my claim right up. No luck involved.

0 coins

That tracks. Once someone actually gets an agent on the line they can read the claim details directly. I had an agent confirm a payment date that way on my own claim, cleared up which week the deposit would hit.

0 coins

Fine, I'll give it a shot. At this point I've got nothing to lose on that line.

0 coins

The seven-day waiting period is the other thing nobody explains clearly. You don't get paid for the first week of your claim, full stop. It is not EDD being slow, it is not a glitch, it is just how the program works. First payable day is day eight.

0 coins

Wait so if my disability starts on a Monday the first payment would cover starting the following Tuesday?

0 coins

The waiting period covers days one through seven, so yes, your first payable day is day eight. EDD doesn't pay those first seven days under any circumstances.

0 coins

I read somewhere that the waiting period could be waived sometimes, is that true?

0 coins

Not for DI claims. Every new DI claim has a seven-day non-payable waiting period. PFL is different, it has no waiting period, but that's a separate claim for bonding after the disability period ends.

0 coins

My sister just went through her maternity leave on SDI and she said the whole process was smoother than she expected once the medical certification went in! The waiting period part did catch her off guard though.

0 coins

The waiting period catches everyone off guard. Should be clearer on the EDD site.

0 coins

It got me too. I kept thinking something was wrong with my claim.

0 coins

For the medical certification piece: your OB or midwife submits it through SDI Online using the receipt number you got when you filed your claim. Make sure they have that receipt number exactly. If they submit without it or use the wrong one the claim stays pending a lot longer than it should.

0 coins

I gave the receipt number to my OB's office but I didn't confirm they actually used it when they submitted. Should I follow up with them?

0 coins

Yes, worth a quick check. Ask the office to confirm the receipt number they entered matches the one SDI Online gave you at filing.

0 coins

my doctors office lost my receipt number the first time and i had to go back in with it on paper. cost me like a week of extra waiting

0 coins

Payable weeks on a pregnancy DI claim are typically six weeks after a natural delivery and eight weeks after a C-section, with the provider able to certify more time for complications. That's just the postpartum DI piece, the bonding claim after that is PFL and a totally separate filing.

0 coins

So after my DI maternity claim ends I'd file a separate PFL claim for bonding time?

0 coins

Exactly. DI covers the pregnancy disability and recovery period, then PFL is for bonding and that one has no seven-day waiting period.

0 coins

PFL confused me at first because I thought it was part of the same claim. They're separate filings in SDI Online.

0 coins

Does the Notice of Computation actually confirm you're approved? I got mine and it has an amount on it and I was relieved but now reading this thread I'm not sure I should have been.

0 coins

The notice shows a potential benefit amount based on your wages, not an approval. EDD still needs to review your medical certification and eligibility before payments start.

0 coins

So I still have to wait and see even after getting the notice. Good to know, I won't count on it yet.

0 coins

Exact same thing tripped me up. Got the notice, thought I was set, then nothing for another week while the medical certification side got processed.

0 coins

Nobody tells you that most payments are issued within two weeks after EDD gets both the claimant's statement and the medical certification. If you're past that window and nothing's moved, that's when it's worth pushing.

0 coins

Two weeks from when EDD receives both parts? So if my OB is slow getting the certification in that clock doesn't even start yet?

0 coins

Correct. The two-week window starts once both parts are in. Your certification being late is the most common reason claims sit longer than expected.

0 coins

49 days from your disability start date is the deadline for the certification to come in. After that you can be disqualified. Worth telling your provider that number specifically.

0 coins

An extension came up for me near the end of my claim, my provider said I needed more recovery time, and I had no idea how that worked. The DE 2525XX is what the provider submits, and EDD sends it out with the final payment notice. I tried the EDD line for a week straight before I used Claimyr to actually reach someone, and the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX had come in and the extension was processing.

0 coins

What exactly is Claimyr, I haven't heard of it?

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and your phone rings when an actual agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

That would actually help me. My extension question is about whether my provider needs to resubmit the whole certification or just the supplemental form. I've been going back and forth with EDD's online message system for days with no response.

0 coins

the online messages take forever sometimes i waited 5 days once and nothing

0 coins

Direct deposit gets set up in SDI Online if you want payments faster than the Money Network card. Worth doing before your claim approves so the first payment goes straight to your bank account.

0 coins

I didn't even know direct deposit was an option. I'll set that up today.

0 coins

Do that before the first payment hits. Trying to switch it after is a whole thing.

0 coins

the money network card took forever to arrive by mail. wish i had done direct deposit from the start

0 coins

DE 2593 showed up around week ten on my wife's last leave. You get it after five automatic payments. Return it within 20 days or benefits stop. Don't set it aside and forget about it.

0 coins

Is that the form that asks if you're still unable to work? I think I read something about it but didn't realize there was a deadline.

0 coins

That's the one. Twenty days to return it, no exceptions I'm aware of. Missing it means your payments stop until it's sorted.

0 coins

Exactly right. The Disability Claim Continued Eligibility Questionnaire, that's the DE 2593, goes out after your fifth automatic payment, which is around the ten-week mark. Missing that deadline is one of the more common reasons payments stop mid-claim.

0 coins

Circling back to the original tax question since a few people asked variations of it: California confirming it doesn't tax SDI benefits is well established and you can find it on EDD's site. For federal, the guidance genuinely varies by situation and nobody here, including EDD agents, can give you a certain answer. A CPA or tax preparer who knows your full picture is the right resource there.

0 coins

This is where I'll land then: set some aside myself for the federal piece, confirm with my accountant before leave starts. I feel a lot better about the whole thing now.

0 coins

I called my tax preparer and she said the same thing, federal depends on specifics she needs to look at. At least the California side is clear.

0 coins

That's the move! Get the professional opinion and then you're not guessing at tax time.

0 coins

One thing that's worth knowing before you go on leave: SDI Online is at myedd.edd.ca.gov and that's where you file, check your claim status, and send messages to EDD. Don't try to do any of this by phone if you can avoid it, the online route is way less painful.

0 coins

I filed through SDI Online already, I just didn't know all the other things you could do in there. Sending a message through the portal sounds way better than the phone.

0 coins

Phone is a last resort. Use the online message option first and you'll save yourself a lot of frustration.

0 coins

Just wanted to say this thread answered almost everything I had too. I'm six weeks out from my due date and I was nervous about the tax and payment timing questions.

0 coins

Six weeks out you've still got time to get the certification lined up and your direct deposit set before the claim needs to pay out.

0 coins

My OB's office already has my receipt number, they said they submit through SDI Online directly which is good to know.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure