Does SDI reject reopened claim from old work injury claim
So I hurt my back at work about two years ago and had a workers comp claim going for a while. That eventually settled and closed. Now I've got a totally separate thing, a disc issue that my doctor says is unrelated to the job, and I'm looking at being out for probably six weeks minimum. Filed in SDI Online last week and my doctor is submitting the certification this week. But I keep reading that SDI and workers comp don't mix, and now I'm panicking that EDD is going to look at that old injury, see it was a work-related back problem, and just reject me outright. The workers comp is fully closed and settled. Does anyone know if SDI will reject a new claim because of a prior workers comp history? Like does the old claim even show up and affect this one at all?
77 comments

Amara Okonkwo
Closed workers comp cases generally don't block a new SDI claim. EDD's concern is whether the current disability is work-related right now, not what happened years ago. If your doctor is certifying that this condition is non-occupational and separate from the prior injury, that's what matters. Keep the settlement paperwork handy just in case, but a fully closed case shouldn't be an automatic bar.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorThat's a relief to hear. My doctor is definitely certifying it as a new, non-work condition. I just worry EDD sees 'back' on the form and starts asking questions.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
EDD is checking if the injury is work-related now. 'Back' as a body part doesn't flag it. The certification is what tells them it's not comp territory.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
Workers comp being closed and settled is exactly the difference. Active comp claim at the same time as SDI is where it gets complicated. You're not in that situation, so file and let the certification do the work.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
This is right. My buddy tried to run both at once and EDD pushed back hard. Settled and done is a whole different thing.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorYeah the comp has been closed for over a year. No active claim, no open case number, nothing. Good to know that changes things.
0 coins
NightOwl42
EDD says themselves it's not common to get paid both at once. Closed means closed, you're not doing both at once.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Payment date on my claim got confusing after a prior workers comp case of my own, so I actually ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent looked up my claim and told me exactly which date my first payment was issued, so I stopped guessing and just waited for the deposit.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
What did you have ready when the agent answered? I always freeze up when I finally get someone live.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Claim ID, Social Security number, and the date my doctor submitted the certification. That was about all they needed to pull it up fast.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
I have been trying that line since Monday morning, two or three times a day, and either get a busy signal or it drops after the menu. Nice to know there are other ways.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
The rule EDD goes by is whether the current disability is non-work-related. Workers comp covers work injuries; SDI covers non-occupational illness or injury. A settled and closed comp case from two years back doesn't make your current condition occupational. Your physician's certification is the document that establishes the nature of the current disability, so make sure it's clear there.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
Does that mean if the doctor phrases something wrong on the certification it could get rejected even if the injury is legitimately separate? That's making me nervous for my own claim.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
The certification asks the provider about the current diagnosis and functional limitations. If the provider states it's non-occupational, that's the determination EDD works from. You'd only run into trouble if the provider accidentally links it back to a job injury.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
I think I read somewhere that EDD can still ask for more info even if the certification looks fine? Not sure if that's common or just rare.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
They can send additional forms if something is unclear. It's not the norm when the certification is complete and straightforward. Answer anything they send quickly and you'll be fine.
0 coins
Yara Nassar
my comp was settled two years ago too and i filed sdi last spring no problem, they didnt ask anything about the old case at all. doctor certified it, went pending for like 10 days then notice showed up
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
Author10 days pending and then the Notice of Computation? That tracks with what others have said. Did you do anything or just wait it out?
0 coins
Yara Nassar
just waited, didnt call or anything. notice came in the mail and then payment hit a few days later
0 coins
StarGazer101
From an administrative standpoint, the base period wages EDD uses to calculate your weekly benefit are the same regardless of comp history. It's the highest-earning quarter in your base period that sets the amount. The old comp case doesn't reach into that calculation. Your Notice of Computation will show you the quarter they used and the estimated weekly amount.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
Where does EDD pull those quarters from exactly? I've seen '5 to 18 months before the claim start date' mentioned but I want to make sure I understand the window.
0 coins
StarGazer101
The base period is four quarters of wages, taken from roughly 5 to 18 months before your claim start date. The highest-paid quarter of those four is what drives the weekly benefit estimate. The Notice of Computation spells out the actual quarter and amount.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
Mine starts in a few weeks and I still don't know what quarter they'll use. Is there a way to estimate it before the notice arrives?
0 coins
StarGazer101
EDD has a benefits calculator on their site. Put in your quarterly wages and it gives you a range. It matched my notice pretty closely.
0 coins
Paolo Romano
DE 2593 came in the mail during my claim and I almost missed it because I thought it was junk mail. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone about it because I had no idea if I'd already been dropped from automatic payment. The agent confirmed I was still on automatic payment and that I had to return the form within 20 days or benefits would stop.
0 coins
StarGazer101
My claim is at week 9 right now and I haven't seen that form yet. Want to ask EDD about where mine is before the deadline hits. Going to try Claimyr for it. What's the best thing to have ready?
0 coins
Paolo Romano
Have your claim ID and the last payment date handy. That's what the agent asked me for right away when I said I had a question about the DE 2593.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
20 days to return it and benefits stop if you don't. That's a rough deadline to miss because you thought it was junk mail.
0 coins
Amina Diop
Glad you caught it. I nearly did the same thing with a form from EDD once.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
EDD's line is a nightmare. I've been out since a knee procedure and trying to ask a simple question about my waiting period for two weeks straight. Half the time the automated system tells me call volume is too high and hangs up on me. For anyone wondering, the waiting period is the first seven days of a claim, those days just don't get paid. It's not EDD processing time. You're not waiting for EDD to do something, you're just burning through seven days before benefits start.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
Wait, so the seven days don't count toward the total weeks they'll pay me? I thought I was losing benefit days.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
The 52-week maximum is on top of the waiting period. The waiting period is day one through seven and unpaid. Benefits can run up to 52 weeks after that.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Exactly. EDD doesn't subtract those seven days from your maximum. They're just not paid. Annoying but that's how it works.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorI had no idea the max was 52 weeks. I was thinking it was much shorter. That's actually helpful context even for my situation.
0 coins
Oliver Schmidt
Clinically, what matters to EDD is what the certifying provider says about the current condition and whether it's occupational. A settled comp case is background history, not a current claim. Your provider needs to certify the current inability to work and that it's non-occupational. That's the box that needs checking.
0 coins
Amina Diop
Short and clear. That's what I needed to hear about my own situation too.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
Provider's certification carries the whole thing. If that's solid, the old history is noise.
0 coins
Natasha Volkov
Honestly I had a coworker worried about the same exact thing after her prior comp case. She filed SDI, doctor certified it, nothing came up about the old case at all. EDD sent the Notice of Computation and payments started. The key thing was her doctor was super specific in the certification that it was a new, unrelated condition.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorSpecificity in the certification from the doctor really seems to be the common thread here. I'm going to call the office and make sure they know to be clear about that.
0 coins
Natasha Volkov
Worth doing for sure. Some office staff are great about it but it doesn't hurt to remind them.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
Filing window is also worth flagging here. You've got 49 days from the start of the disability to get both your part filed and the medical certification submitted. If the comp case history causes EDD to send any additional inquiry letters, respond fast so you don't burn through that window on paperwork delays.
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
That 49-day clock applies to the medical certification too. It's not just the claimant's part. Providers sometimes don't know they're on the same deadline.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorMy doctor's office said they'd submit this week, so I think we're fine on timing. I filed last week so we should be well inside 49 days.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
You're in good shape then. Keep the form receipt number your doctor will need to find the claim in SDI Online.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Got a Notice of Determination last month and I'm still not sure what triggered it. I used Claimyr to get through to an agent at EDD disability about it. The agent said the notice was about a question on my certification and told me I had 30 days from the date on it to file an appeal using the DE 1000A if I disagreed with the determination.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
My claim has a couple of weeks still pending and I've been getting a little anxious that something like a determination might come through. Used Claimyr once before when payment weeks weren't showing right, the agent told me which weeks had actually been paid out versus which were still pending. Filed the question through SDI Online after that for the pending ones.
0 coins
Javier Torres
been trying to reach edd about my own determination for a week. nothing but busy signals
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Yeah the line is rough. Hope you get through eventually.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
The 30-day window on a determination runs from the date printed on the notice, not the day you receive it. Worth noting if the mail takes a few days.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
Does filing SDI right after a workers comp settlement raise any red flags automatically? Like is there a waiting period after comp before you can file SDI?
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
No required waiting period between a comp settlement and filing SDI. The only waiting period in SDI is the first seven unpaid days of the claim itself. If you have a new, non-work-related disability and meet the wage requirements, you can file.
0 coins
Miguel Herrera
The timing of a prior comp settlement doesn't create a SDI embargo period. EDD's concern is the nature and timing of the current disability, not when you last had a comp case.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
That's what I was hoping. My settlement finalized about five months ago and I didn't want to trigger some kind of review just by filing quickly after.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
Paperwork from the settlement, keep it. If EDD ever asks whether that prior back issue is related to the current one, you have something to show it's closed and done. Probably won't come up but worth having in a folder somewhere.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorAlready have everything scanned and saved. Settlement agreement, the closure letter, all of it. Good call.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
Smart move. EDD rarely goes digging but when they do, having the paper trail cuts it short.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
Is there a chance EDD could deny the SDI claim and then I'd have to appeal? I haven't filed yet but I'm going to and I'm already scared of that happening, especially since I had a comp case a couple years ago too.
0 coins
Oliver Schmidt
Denials happen but they're not guaranteed. If EDD denies yours you get a Notice of Determination with an appeal form, the DE 1000A, and 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal. Hold onto every piece of mail from EDD as soon as you file.
0 coins
Sofia Rodriguez
Appeals are more common than people think and plenty get resolved. The notice tells you exactly why they denied it, which helps you respond specifically.
0 coins
Zainab Ali
Okay. So the denial itself explains the reason and then I have 30 days to appeal it. At least there's a path if it goes wrong.
0 coins
Giovanni Marino
Workers comp settled two years ago. Current disability certified as non-occupational. SDI doesn't cross-reference old comp history to reject new claims on that basis alone. File, wait for the Notice of Computation, see what happens.
0 coins
NightOwl42
Yep. EDD's looking at what's in front of them, not digging two years back into comp files.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorThis thread has honestly settled my nerves more than anything I found on Google. Appreciate everyone.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
SDI Online is where you'll see claim status updates once the certification is in. EDD typically reaches out within 14 days of getting a completed claim. If the status hasn't moved after that window, the Request Claim Update tool inside SDI Online is a reasonable first step before sitting on hold.
0 coins
Keisha Jackson
14 days is the benchmark I've seen too. Good to know there's an in-platform way to ask before having to try the phone line.
0 coins
Ava Thompson
Request Claim Update actually got me a response within a few days when the phone line was useless. Not fast but better than nothing.
0 coins
Javier Torres
sdi online showed pending for 12 days on mine and then notice of computation just appeared one morning. no call, no warning, just there
0 coins
Yara Nassar
same thing happened to me, just woke up and it was there. made me check my email like three times thinking id missed something
0 coins
Javier Torres
yeah i kept refreshing expecting some kind of alert. nothing, just showed up
0 coins
Natasha Volkov
Payment method is worth setting up early if you haven't. Direct deposit through SDI Online gets your money faster than waiting for the Money Network card to show up and activate. Can do it when you file or update it in SDI Online after.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorI did direct deposit when I filed. Good tip for anyone else reading this who hasn't filed yet.
0 coins
Amina Diop
Direct deposit was the only thing I got right on my first claim lol. Everything else was a question.
0 coins
Dmitry Ivanov
Is the Money Network card automatic if you don't set up direct deposit?
0 coins
Amara Okonkwo
Yes, EDD sends the Money Network prepaid debit card if you don't choose direct deposit. You'd activate it when it arrives and payments load to it.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Sayed
Bottom line for the original question: prior settled comp case shouldn't sink a new SDI claim for a non-occupational disability. Closed is closed. Get the certification in on time and let EDD process it.
0 coins
Liam O'Sullivan
AuthorThat's the answer I needed. Certification is going in this week. I'll update once the notice arrives.
0 coins
Dylan Hughes
Good. Keep the documentation from the comp settlement in your back pocket just in case and move on.
0 coins