Back to California Disability

Jessica Suarez

Does PFL apply if employer has private voluntary plan disability insurance?

So I've been going back and forth on this for a week now and I'm honestly not sure what I'm dealing with. My company has some kind of private voluntary plan through an insurance carrier instead of the regular state SDI setup. I found out about it kind of late honestly and now I'm pregnant and trying to figure out what this means for my leave. Does PFL apply if employer has private voluntary plan disability insurance? Like does the bonding time after the baby comes still go through EDD or does everything run through the private plan? I'm about 7 weeks from my due date and I haven't even started filing anything. My HR department keeps saying to contact the insurance carrier but the carrier keeps pointing me back to HR and I can't get a straight answer from either of them. I don't want to miss any deadlines and I really don't want to end up with no income after the birth. Any help would be appreciated.

Voluntary plans are employer-sponsored alternatives that have to provide at least the same benefits as the state SDI program. For the disability part covering pregnancy and recovery, your claim goes through the voluntary plan carrier, not EDD. The bonding piece after recovery is a separate question from the disability side, so it's worth asking your carrier and HR specifically about that portion in writing so you have something on record.

0 coins

Thank you, that actually helps me understand why they keep redirecting me. I didn't realize the carrier handles the whole disability side. I'll put the bonding question in writing to both of them like you said.

0 coins

HR really should have explained this at the start. Good that you're getting it in writing now.

0 coins

Wait so if the carrier does the disability part does she still file anything with EDD at all? I'm on a voluntary plan too and not sure if I need to do anything through SDI Online.

0 coins

Notice of Computation came from EDD last month but the amount looked off and I spent three mornings in a row trying to reach someone on 1-800-480-3287 before I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com). The service handles the hold for you so your phone rings once a live EDD agent picks up. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my computation and told me which quarter they used as the high quarter in my base period, and that matched what I'd earned in that stretch, so the number on my notice was actually right. I'd been misreading the estimate.

0 coins

Reads like a paid placement to me. I've tried that line 20 times and nothing has gotten through, so I'm not rushing to believe some tool fixes that.

0 coins

Had the same thought when I first saw it mentioned somewhere. Ended up with the waiting period question on my own claim, the seven days at the start that don't get paid, and the agent confirmed day one for me and said the first payable day was day eight. That's consistent with what EDD publishes. The person I spoke to was an actual EDD employee.

0 coins

Alright, that's specific enough that I'll at least look into it. Still not convinced but I'm not getting anywhere on my own.

0 coins

The quarter thing trips a lot of people up. Your notice shows which one they used. If the high quarter is what you expected, the amount is usually fine.

0 coins

For what it's worth on the broader question here, my understanding is that Paid Family Leave runs through EDD even when the employer has a voluntary plan on the disability side, unless the employer also has an approved voluntary plan specifically for PFL. Those are different approvals. Worth verifying with HR whether the voluntary plan covers only disability or PFL as well.

0 coins

That's the right way to frame it. The approvals are separate and not every employer that has a voluntary disability plan has also set one up for the bonding side.

0 coins

I didn't even know there were two separate approvals. I'm going to ask HR specifically which one they have approval for because nobody has said that to me yet.

0 coins

So she might have to file the bonding claim with EDD even though the disability goes through the carrier? That's kind of a weird split but good to know it's possible.

0 coins

Your carrier should have sent you a packet when you got hired or when you first asked HR. If they haven't sent you anything, ask for the plan document in writing. That document will tell you what you're entitled to and who handles what.

0 coins

I actually never got anything from them directly. HR said to contact the carrier but gave me no documentation. Asking for the plan document is a good call, I'll do that tomorrow.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me when I was figuring out my claim. HR had it the whole time but nobody just handed it over until I asked for it by name.

0 coins

EDD's site does address voluntary plans in the disability section. The key point is that a voluntary plan has to provide benefits that are at least equal to what the state SDI program would pay. If yours doesn't, the employer can be held accountable. The benefit calculator on EDD's site can help you see what state SDI would have given you as a floor to compare against.

0 coins

The base period quarters and the high quarter are what drive that number. If you have your pay stubs from the right window you can run a rough check yourself before the carrier tells you their number.

0 coins

I just ran the EDD calculator and got a rough figure. Now I have something to compare when the carrier finally gives me their number. I didn't know that tool existed.

0 coins

The calculator gives you a solid baseline. It's not binding but it's enough to know if something looks way off.

0 coins

HR dragging you between the carrier is so frustrating, we went through that too with my wife's leave. Eventually she just emailed both at the same time, cc'd the other, and they finally got on the same page about two days later, anyway.

0 coins

The CC trick is underrated. Suddenly everyone finds their answers when they can see each other on the thread.

0 coins

Doing this today. I've been going back and forth separately and it hasn't worked at all.

0 coins

Seven weeks out and no paperwork filed yet is cutting it close. For a typical pregnancy claim you'd want to have things moving about four weeks before the due date.

0 coins

I know, I know. I've been in this loop with HR and the carrier and lost track of the actual deadlines. Starting everything today.

0 coins

For the voluntary plan the carrier sets its own filing deadlines, which is another reason to get the plan document as soon as possible so you're not caught off guard by their cutoff.

0 coins

Weeks two through four of my leave I had a question about which of them had been paid and which were still open, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr about it. The agent looked at my claim and told me exactly which weeks had a payment issued and which were still pending at that point. Having that confirmed meant I stopped stressing over whether something had dropped off.

0 coins

What did you have ready when you spoke to the agent, like claim ID and SSN or something else?

0 coins

Claim ID, the last four of my SSN, and the week dates I was asking about. That was enough for them to pull everything up.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday. three attempts, never got past the automated part.

0 coins

if ur employer has a voluntary plan and it doesnt cover pfl separately u gotta file the bonding claim through edd on your own, my coworker had to do that last year

0 coins

That tracks with how the two programs work. Disability and bonding are separate approvals for voluntary plans, so yes, if the employer only opted into the disability side the bonding claim goes to EDD directly.

0 coins

So wait, the bonding claim through EDD, is that filed on SDI Online too? Under a different claim type?

0 coins

PFL bonding claims are filed through SDI Online under the Paid Family Leave section, not the DI section. Same portal, different claim type. EDD walks you through it once you're in.

0 coins

My pregnancy claim was split the same way and I wish someone had just told me upfront to ask HR for a single sheet that says what plan type they have and who the carrier is. Took me two weeks to get that basic info and I was already really far along.

0 coins

Two weeks is exactly what I'm afraid of wasting. I'm going to send one clear email today asking for the plan type and carrier contact in one shot.

0 coins

HR really should have a one-pager for this. Would save so much confusion.

0 coins

The 49-day window from the disability start date applies to the state SDI medical certification. With a voluntary plan the carrier likely has its own deadline, potentially tighter. Get the plan document and check it against the state rules so you know which deadline is sooner.

0 coins

I didn't know about the 49-day rule at all. So even with a voluntary plan I need to keep that in the back of my mind as a hard outer limit?

0 coins

The state's 49-day limit applies to state SDI claims. With a voluntary plan the carrier's own deadline controls your claim, but it has to be at least as good as state SDI, so the state deadline is a reasonable floor to watch.

0 coins

Don't wait to find out which one's shorter. Get the carrier's paperwork now.

0 coins

DE 2525XX sat in my stack for a week because I didn't realize the extension was my doctor's form to submit, not mine. Got through to an EDD agent through Claimyr on that one. The agent confirmed the extension had come in from my provider and the weeks it covered, so I finally knew where things stood on my claim.

0 coins

I want to try that for my own claim! My question is about whether my doctor's office sent in the right dates for my leave period. I'm going to try Claimyr.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the dates you're asking about written down before you call. That's what made it go smoothly for me.

0 coins

The extension form being the doctor's job and not yours is something I didn't know either. Good to know before I get to that stage.

0 coins

Used to work somewhere that had a voluntary plan and the short version is: the plan document is everything. That document is the actual contract. If anything the carrier does contradicts it you have something to push back with.

0 coins

Exactly. Without that document you're just taking their word for it.

0 coins

If the plan document isn't easy to get you can also ask HR for the Summary Plan Description, which is a required summary version. That will at least tell you the basics.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar boat, I think I'm on a voluntary plan but I've never been sure and I haven't been able to find anything in my onboarding papers. How do you even confirm which kind of plan you have?

0 coins

Your pay stub is one way to check. State SDI shows as CASDI on California pay stubs. If it shows something different, like VPDI, that's a voluntary plan deduction. HR can confirm it either way.

0 coins

I just looked at my stub and it says VPDI. So I am on a voluntary plan. I genuinely had no idea there was a difference on the stub.

0 coins

VPDI on the stub is the clearest signal. Now you know to go to the carrier rather than EDD for the disability part of your claim.

0 coins

The carrier having its own process doesn't mean EDD is completely out of the picture. EDD still oversees voluntary plans and claimants can contact EDD if the plan isn't paying what it should.

0 coins

That's really good to know, I didn't realize EDD still had any role if the plan was voluntary. So they're a backstop in a way.

0 coins

EDD's site has information on filing a complaint if a voluntary plan isn't meeting state minimums. It's not widely known but it exists.

0 coins

Filing the pregnancy disability claim about four weeks before the due date is what EDD recommends as a general starting point. With complications, reduced hours, or work restrictions your provider can certify benefits starting earlier than that.

0 coins

My doctor mentioned reduced hours in the last few weeks, so there might be a reason to start earlier than four weeks out anyway. I'll ask her about certifying that at my next appointment.

0 coins

My provider certified reduced hours for me starting six weeks out. It went through without any issues.

0 coins

Does the provider fill that in on the certification form or do they submit something separate for the reduced hours piece?

0 coins

The provider includes it in the medical certification itself. They note the work restrictions or reduced hours as part of their certification, and EDD goes from there.

0 coins

Has anyone had the carrier and EDD pay overlapping periods? I'm worried about accidentally double-dipping and then getting hit with an overpayment notice later.

0 coins

The voluntary plan is supposed to coordinate with any state benefits to avoid exactly that. EDD's rules say the voluntary plan has to cover at least what state SDI would, and carriers generally know to coordinate so there's no overlap. Ask your carrier specifically how they handle coordination of benefits.

0 coins

Putting that coordination question in writing to the carrier is smart, so you have their answer on record if anything gets disputed later.

0 coins

my buddy said his carrier just paid everything and nothing went to edd at all, he never filed with edd. not sure if thats right for everyone tho

0 coins

That's how it works on the disability side when the voluntary plan covers it. The carrier handles that portion. The piece to watch is the PFL bonding claim after, which may need to go to EDD separately depending on what the employer's plan covers.

0 coins

ok yeah the bonding part is what i wasnt sure about, makes sense it could be different

0 coins

The bonding question is the one worth pinning down before the birth, not after. Easier to sort it out now than scrambling with a newborn.

0 coins

EDD also has an Office Locator on their site if you want to visit an SDI office and talk to someone in person. Sometimes face to face is faster than the phone loop when you have a complicated situation.

0 coins

I didn't know there were physical offices for this. If I can't get a clear answer from HR and the carrier soon I might actually do that.

0 coins

Went in person once for a different issue, took about 45 minutes total and got everything sorted, honestly worth it anyway.

0 coins

the CASDI vs VPDI stub thing is new to me too. been on VPDI for two years and just thought it was the same as everyone else.

0 coins

They function similarly in terms of protecting your wages, but the administration is different. Worth knowing especially before a claim.

0 coins

Same. I've been on VPDI and had no idea what it meant until reading this thread.

0 coins

Updating everyone: I finally got the plan document from HR and confirmed I'm on a voluntary plan that covers only the disability side, not PFL. So my pregnancy recovery claim goes through the carrier and my bonding claim will go through EDD after. I'm filing through SDI Online for the bonding piece as soon as recovery is done. Thanks everyone for the help piecing this together.

0 coins

That's exactly the split to expect. You've got it sorted out at the right time. For the EDD bonding claim, the nine-day wait to file doesn't apply to PFL, so you can file that one right at the start of your bonding period.

0 coins

Glad you got a clear answer. Knowing the split before the birth makes everything so much less chaotic.

0 coins

You're way more prepared than I was before my leave. It's going to go much smoother than the HR runaround made it feel.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure