Back to California Disability

James Martinez

Do I need a notice of determination letter to file an SDI appeal?

Got a denial on my disability claim and I'm kind of panicking because I can't find the letter they mailed me. I remember opening it and seeing something about a DE 2517 but I genuinely cannot find it anywhere now. My question is do I need notice of determination letter to file sdi appeal or can I do something without it? I've been out of work for six weeks with a back injury and the denial came out of nowhere because I thought my doctor submitted everything. I'm not even sure if I have 30 days still or if that window already closed. Really scared I'm going to lose this.

The 30-day window runs from the date printed on that notice, not the day you got it. If you can't find it, check SDI Online for the denial date and work from there. The appeal form is the DE 1000A, but if you've lost it you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the address on the original notice.

0 coins

I don't have the envelope anymore either so I don't know the return address. Is there another way to find where to send it?

0 coins

The Office Locator on EDD's site will show your local SDI office address. That's where it goes.

0 coins

Thank you. Going to look that up right now.

0 coins

The benefit amount on my Notice of Computation looked lower than I expected, so I wanted to confirm which quarter EDD used before deciding anything. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach someone on the disability line, and the agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter of my base period they calculated from and what my weekly amount would be. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability if you haven't seen it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The notice itself doesn't explain the quarter selection in plain language so having the agent confirm it was the only way I actually understood it.

0 coins

Claimyr sounds like it might be a paid marketing thing, honestly. I've seen so many of those pop up on forums and I'm always a little wary of them.

0 coins

My first reaction was similar to yours, I figured it was just an ad. But I actually tried it after three mornings of that line ringing out, and the person I ended up talking to was an EDD agent, not anyone from a third-party service. She confirmed my waiting period days and I finally understood why my first payment was smaller than I thought. If it were a scam I wouldn't have been talking to someone who could see my claim right there.

0 coins

Okay that's actually useful to hear. I've been hesitating to do anything until I know my benefit amount is right. Might look into it.

0 coins

The quarter thing made a real difference on my number. Worth getting confirmed directly.

0 coins

I called that disability line six mornings in a row and either got a busy signal or the recording cut me off. Meanwhile my denial is just sitting there unresolved. This whole process is exhausting.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. Week three of trying and I finally got through on a Tuesday around 8:05. No guarantees though.

0 coins

I've tried early mornings too. Nothing. I'll keep at it.

0 coins

Wait, I'm confused about something. If you lost the letter does that mean you can't appeal at all? Like is the letter the only proof that you were denied? I'm asking because my claim is still pending and I'm terrified of getting a denial I miss.

0 coins

SDI Online will show the denial status on your claim. The letter matters for the deadline and the return address, but EDD can see the denial in the system either way. Keep an eye on your claim there.

0 coins

Okay that helps a little. I didn't realize the status shows up online too.

0 coins

Honestly when I got my denial I didn't even realize what the DE 2517 was at first. I thought it was just another form they send everyone. Read it carefully because the deadline is on there.

0 coins

Lost appeal letter, still appealing. It happens. Write a detailed letter, explain what you're disputing, mail it to your local SDI office. Done.

0 coins

That blunt summary actually helps. I was making it more complicated in my head.

0 coins

EDD does too sometimes. Keep it simple on your end.

0 coins

My denial came because my doctor's office submitted the medical certification late, like past the 49-day window, and EDD said the claim was incomplete. I had no idea there was a hard deadline for the provider side too. Ended up appealing and explaining the delay was on the office's end, not mine.

0 coins

49 days from what date exactly? From when you filed or from when the disability started?

0 coins

From when the disability started, not when you filed. My doctor's office thought it was from the file date and that's what caused the whole mess.

0 coins

The 49-day clock for the medical certification does run from the disability start date. That catches a lot of people off guard.

0 coins

Lost notice, write the letter anyway. Date your letter, explain what the denial was for, sign it. If the deadline's close don't wait around trying to track down the original form.

0 coins

Does the letter need to be certified mail?

0 coins

Wouldn't hurt. At least you have proof it was sent.

0 coins

EDD doesn't require certified mail but having a receipt is smart if the timing is tight.

0 coins

Payments stopped on mine without explanation after my first few weeks, and I needed to know exactly which weeks EDD showed as paid before I could figure out what was missing. After too many dropped calls, I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line. She went through my claim and read off each week that had been issued and the ones still showing pending. Turned out two weeks weren't in there at all, so I knew which period I actually needed to push on.

0 coins

When you got through, did the agent have everything pulled up right away or did you have to give them a lot of info first?

0 coins

She asked for my Social and claim ID and had everything up within maybe a minute. Straightforward once you're actually talking to someone.

0 coins

been trying that line since monday, four mornings, nothing. good to know someone got through eventually.

0 coins

my denial said something about not enough wages in the base period, is that the same kind of denial you got? just wondering if the appeal works differently depending on why they denied you

0 coins

Different denial reasons go through the same appeal process. You still use the DE 1000A or a detailed letter, same 30-day window. The reason matters for what you write in your explanation, not the process itself.

0 coins

ok that makes sense, so i just explain why i think the wage decision is wrong and send it in

0 coins

When I filed my appeal letter I included copies of my pay stubs to show the wages EDD might have missed. The notice of determination listed the base period they used and the wages they found, so I could compare it against my own records. Having that detail in the appeal really helped clarify the dispute.

0 coins

So even without finding my actual denial letter, if I can see the base period info somewhere else I can still make the same argument?

0 coins

If SDI Online shows the denial, the Notice of Computation you got earlier would show the base period and estimated amounts. Use that alongside your pay stubs in your appeal letter.

0 coins

I still have my Notice of Computation, that's actually helpful. Didn't think of using that.

0 coins

my coworker lost her denial notice too and she just walked into the local SDI office with her ID and explained what happened. they were able to look it up and she got the address to send her appeal to. might be faster than trying to track everything down online lol

0 coins

That's actually a decent option if you're close to the deadline and can't get through on the phone.

0 coins

Yeah she said the person at the desk was actually pretty helpful, which surprised her.

0 coins

Okay side question here, can someone appeal and still get paid while the appeal is going? Or do payments stop completely until there's a decision? Asking for my own situation, kids to feed, can't be in limbo for months anyway.

0 coins

An appeal doesn't restart payments automatically. If the claim was denied, EDD isn't paying during the appeal unless the appeal is decided in your favor. That said, if you win it can be retroactive to the denied period.

0 coins

Retroactive is good at least. Stressful to wait but okay.

0 coins

I didn't know it could be retroactive. That changes how I'd think about whether to bother appealing.

0 coins

The DE 2525XX my doctor submitted for my extension showed up in SDI Online but my final payment notice never came through the way I expected, so I didn't know if EDD had actually processed it. I ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr about the extension and she confirmed the form was received and told me the status on that part of my claim. Knowing it was actually in their system meant I could stop second-guessing whether the office had sent it right.

0 coins

My own claim has a question about the extension timing that I need answered directly. Going to try Claimyr for that. What's useful to have ready before making the call?

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the receipt number from when you originally filed. The agent found everything quickly once she had those two things.

0 coins

Good to know. I'll pull those up before I try.

0 coins

Honestly the whole idea that you need the physical letter to appeal is a myth that trips people up. EDD's own appeal instructions say a detailed letter works. The form is easier but it's not required.

0 coins

I really wish I'd known this two days ago when I was spiraling.

0 coins

Most people assume the form is mandatory. It isn't.

0 coins

For anyone counting days, the 30 days is from the date on the notice, not the postmark or when you opened it! I almost miscounted on mine and nearly missed the window. Check the date on the DE 2517 carefully if you have it, or find the denial date in SDI Online!

0 coins

This is the part I didn't understand. So if the letter is dated three days before I got it, those three days count against my 30?

0 coins

Yes, the clock starts on the date EDD printed on the notice. So if you got it late in the mail, your window is already a few days shorter than you think.

0 coins

That's why EDD recommends acting quickly once you receive a denial notice. Waiting to see if anything changes costs you appeal days.

0 coins

If your deadline is legitimately close and you can't find the address, don't forget Ask EDD is an online contact form on EDD's site. I used it to ask a basic question about my claim when I couldn't get anyone on the phone. Not instant but it's something.

0 coins

Does Ask EDD actually respond to appeal questions or just general stuff?

0 coins

In my experience it's general questions. For anything specific to your denial you really need a live person or the SDI office directly.

0 coins

Appeals can feel really daunting when you're already stressed from being out of work. The process is more forgiving than it looks from the outside, though. A late appeal can still be considered if you give a good reason for the delay.

0 coins

What counts as a good reason? I've been out with this injury and not exactly on top of my mail.

0 coins

An injury keeping you from managing paperwork is exactly the kind of thing an administrative law judge can consider. Put it in writing when you file your appeal.

0 coins

Didn't know a late appeal could still work. Thought missing 30 days meant game over.

0 coins

The appeal form itself, the DE 1000A, is listed on EDD's site under forms and publications if anyone needs to download a fresh copy. The instructions on it are pretty clear about where to send it.

0 coins

Is the DE 1000A the same form whether you're appealing a denial or an overpayment decision?

0 coins

Same form, yes. The difference is in what you write in the explanation section.

0 coins

EDD's site also has the appeals information page that walks through the process. Worth reading before you draft your explanation.

0 coins

been dealing with a denial since last month and honestly reading through all this helped more than the EDD website itself. still trying to figure out the base period wages part but at least i know i can write a letter instead of hunting down the form

0 coins

The base period wage question is worth getting sorted before you write the appeal. If you have pay stubs from about five to eighteen months before your claim started, lay them out and compare to what the Notice of Computation listed.

0 coins

i have some of them, not all. guess i start with what i have

0 coins

Quick clarification question since someone mentioned it above. If the appeal is decided in your favor, does EDD automatically recalculate from the original denial date or do you have to ask them to do that?

0 coins

If you win the appeal, EDD issues the benefits for the period covered by the original claim. You don't need to ask separately for the retroactive period, that's part of the decision.

0 coins

Good. That would have been my next worry anyway.

0 coins

does the doctor have to do anything for the appeal or is it just paperwork on your end

0 coins

The appeal itself is filed by the claimant. If the denial was partly because the medical certification was missing or incomplete, getting your provider to submit or correct that could strengthen what you write in the appeal explanation.

0 coins

ok so if my doc messed up the certification i should get that fixed and mention it in the appeal letter got it

0 coins

My provider had to resubmit a corrected certification as part of my appeal evidence. Having the doctor confirm the dates in writing made a real difference.

0 coins

Update from me: found the denial notice in a pile with some other mail. Date on the DE 2517 is from three weeks ago so I still have time. Going to write the appeal letter today and include my Notice of Computation and pay stubs like someone suggested. Really grateful for all of this.

0 coins

Three weeks still on the clock, that's workable. Get specific in that letter about what you're disputing and why.

0 coins

Send it. Don't overthink the letter.

0 coins

So glad you found it! Get that appeal in and keep a copy of everything you send!

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure