Back to California Disability

Logan Greenburg

Can you start new SDI claim after returning to work briefly

So here's my situation and I'm honestly not sure how this works. I had a back injury back in the spring, filed my SDI claim, got my payments, eventually felt okay enough to go back to my warehouse job for about three weeks. Then my back went out again, worse this time, and my doctor's pulling me out again. So I'm sitting here wondering, can you start new SDI claim after returning to work briefly, or does EDD just reopen the old one somehow? The original claim is closed, final payment was issued a while back. Do I file a whole new claim through SDI Online, go through the whole waiting period again, everything? My doctor said she'd submit the certification but I want to make sure I'm doing the right thing on my end first.

Three weeks back on the job before the injury flared up again, and EDD will treat that as a new disability period, which means a new claim. You'd file through SDI Online just as you did the first time, give the new claim receipt number to your doctor so she can submit the medical certification, and yes, the seven-day waiting period starts over. When I had a question about which quarter of my wages they'd use for the new benefit amount, I tried the disability line for days with nothing. Eventually I went through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and got to a live EDD agent. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent looked up my account and confirmed which base period quarter they were pulling from, so I knew what to expect before my Notice of Computation arrived.

0 coins

Claimyr sorted out the same kind of thing for me. After my medical leave ended and I tried to return but had to stop again, I'd been wondering about the DE 2593 and whether I still had to return it even though the first claim closed. The agent confirmed the DE 2593 goes with an open ongoing claim and that my new claim would start its own cycle, so I didn't need to worry about the old one.

0 coins

Can I ask, did the agent say anything about how the new base period gets calculated compared to your first claim? Just wondering if the wages from the weeks you worked in between get counted.

0 coins

Wages you earned and paid SDI taxes on go into whichever base period applies to your new claim start date. The agent didn't walk me through the math but pointed me to the calculator on EDD's site and said the Notice of Computation would show the actual number.

0 coins

Okay so it's definitely a brand new claim, not some kind of reopening. That actually makes more sense. I'll get into SDI Online today and start Part A.

0 coins

New claim. Full stop. Three weeks back at work resets everything. File it like it's your first time, same process.

0 coins

Got it. And I assume I still have to do the waiting period even though it's the same injury?

0 coins

Yep. Seven days, every new claim, doesn't matter if it's the same body part.

0 coins

Wait, so the waiting period isn't just like a processing delay? I thought EDD was just taking time to review it those first days. It's actually seven days you just don't get paid for no matter what?

0 coins

Correct. The waiting period is built into every new claim by rule, not tied to how fast EDD processes anything. First payable day is day eight.

0 coins

Filing a second claim for the same underlying condition is pretty common actually. What matters for EDD is that there was a gap where you were back working, so it's treated as a new disability period. You'll want to file within 49 days of this new start date to stay in the window.

0 coins

The 49-day thing is stressing me out a little, not sure I realized there was a hard deadline. Does the clock start from when you stopped working or from when the doctor officially says you're disabled?

0 coins

From when the disability itself begins, so usually when you stopped working because of it. File and get the receipt number to your doctor sooner rather than later.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. And the doctor has to submit their part within 49 days too?

0 coins

Same 49-day window for the medical certification. That's why getting the receipt number to them quickly matters.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. I spent three mornings trying to reach someone about nearly this exact thing and kept getting the recording that just ends the call. I finally sent a message through Ask EDD and got a generic reply about five days later that didn't answer anything specific.

0 coins

Five days for a useless answer is actually better than my record.

0 coins

I feel that so much. I had the same run of bad luck when I went back to work and my claim got complicated. Eventually I just kept trying different times of day but it was weeks before I actually got someone.

0 coins

Weeks sounds about right. At least after all that I did get confirmation that going back to work and stopping again means a new claim, not an extension of the old one.

0 coins

Just file the new claim. Don't overthink it. Same injury or not, EDD doesn't care, they look at whether you're currently unable to work.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll stop second-guessing and just go do it.

0 coins

Exactly right. Each disability period stands on its own.

0 coins

My coworker went through something similar after a surgery where she went back too soon and had to stop again after a couple of weeks. She filed a whole new claim and said the main thing that tripped her up was forgetting to give the doctor's office the new receipt number. They almost submitted the certification under the old closed claim.

0 coins

That receipt number step is easy to overlook. The doctor's office searches SDI Online with it to find the right claim, so if you give them an old one or none at all, the certification either goes nowhere or gets matched to the wrong claim.

0 coins

I'll double-check with the office before they submit anything. Last thing I need is a matching problem slowing this down.

0 coins

Is the receipt number the same as a claim ID? I've seen both terms floating around.

0 coins

They're different. The receipt number is what SDI Online gives you right after you submit Part A, and it's what the provider uses to find and complete the medical certification. The claim ID comes later once EDD actually opens the claim.

0 coins

Pending status on SDI Online kept me up at night on my first claim, so I figured out fast that the payment method question matters more than people think. Mine defaulted to the Money Network card but I wanted direct deposit. Spent almost two weeks trying to reach someone on the disability line to confirm the switch had gone through before I tried Claimyr, and an EDD agent was actually on the other end of the line. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the direct deposit information was set, so I stopped worrying about checks going to the wrong address.

0 coins

This sounds like paid marketing to me, honestly. Getting a live EDD agent in under however long, that's not how the line actually works for the rest of us.

0 coins

I had exactly the same thought the first time I saw Claimyr mentioned somewhere. Then I was stuck on a payment method question of my own and tried it. The agent confirmed that my direct deposit had been updated correctly and that the next payment should reflect it. That's not something Ask EDD could tell me in time.

0 coins

Okay, fair enough. I've been trying that line since Tuesday and getting nowhere, so maybe I'll give it a shot. I want to ask about which weeks on my claim are still showing pending.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and your Social Security number ready. That's what the agent asked me for right away.

0 coins

yeah new claim for sure, i went back for like two weeks after my shoulder thing and edd made me file all over again, annoying but thats just how it works

0 coins

Two weeks is about what I had too. Sounds like three weeks gets the same result.

0 coins

yeah doesnt matter how long, once youre back and then out again its a new one

0 coins

The base period for the new claim is worth looking at before you file. If the brief return to work landed in a quarter with solid wages, that could actually push your weekly benefit amount higher than the first claim. EDD's disability calculator on their site can give you a rough estimate.

0 coins

The calculator is a good sanity check but the Notice of Computation is what EDD actually commits to. It shows the exact quarter they used and your weekly amount.

0 coins

I'll run the calculator just to get a ballpark. At least I'll know roughly what to expect while I wait for the notice.

0 coins

The notice arrives fairly quickly once EDD processes the claim. Keep an eye on SDI Online and your mail around the same time.

0 coins

Okay wait, I'm reading through this and I'm confused about something. If the old claim is totally closed, does EDD even know the two injuries are connected? Or do they just see a fresh claim like nothing happened before?

0 coins

EDD sees your full claim history, but for the new claim their question is whether you currently can't do your regular work because of a medical condition your doctor certifies. The connection to a prior claim doesn't change that evaluation.

0 coins

So I shouldn't worry about whether it looks like I'm double-dipping or anything like that?

0 coins

You were working in between, so there's a clear gap. That's the whole reason it's a new claim rather than a continuation.

0 coins

Filing a second claim felt so intimidating to me but honestly the SDI Online process is basically the same as the first time! Once I remembered my myEDD login it was straightforward.

0 coins

Good to know it's not a totally different process. I still have my login from before.

0 coins

Perfect! Just make sure your contact info and banking info are still current in there before you submit.

0 coins

Three weeks back at work and then out again happens more than people admit. Pushing back too soon and then paying for it.

0 coins

Real talk. Doctors clear you and you feel okay and then week three hits.

0 coins

And then you're starting the whole claim process over again from scratch.

0 coins

The medical certification on my second claim took longer for my doctor to submit than the first time, and I was nervous the whole wait. Used Claimyr to get to someone at EDD and ask whether the certification had come in yet. The agent checked and said nothing had been received under my new claim number, so I let the office know and they resubmitted the same day.

0 coins

Can I ask what you told the office exactly when you said they needed to resubmit? Did they push back at all?

0 coins

Just told them EDD showed no certification on file for the new claim receipt number, and asked them to check whether they'd submitted under the old one by mistake. They figured it out and fixed it.

0 coins

been trying that disability line since monday and nothing gets through. four mornings now and the same recording every time

0 coins

Worth mentioning for anyone reading later: the medical certification for the new claim has to come from a licensed provider. Physical therapists aren't on EDD's list, so if someone sends you to your PT for the certification, it won't count.

0 coins

Good catch. Physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, and a few others are authorized. PT is not on the list.

0 coins

I had no idea a PT couldn't do it. I was going to ask mine since I see her more often than my doctor.

0 coins

Your primary care doctor or the specialist treating you for the injury is usually the right person. They sign the medical certification and EDD contacts them or accepts the submission through SDI Online.

0 coins

Waiting period catches people off guard every single time on a second claim. They assume since they're not new to the system EDD might skip it.

0 coins

I definitely assumed that. First claim, sure, waiting period, fine. Second claim for the same thing felt like it should be different. It is not.

0 coins

Seven days. Every claim. That's the rule.

0 coins

I'd actually forgotten about it completely until this thread. Good reminder to plan for that gap.

0 coins

My situation was way less complicated than yours but I still panicked when SDI Online showed pending for almost two weeks on my new claim. Turns out EDD hadn't matched the medical certification yet. Once it was matched the status moved.

0 coins

Two weeks of pending is apparently pretty normal from what I've seen people say here.

0 coins

Yeah my doctor's office confirmed they'd submitted but EDD's side just hadn't caught up. No action needed, just waiting.

0 coins

For anyone filing a second claim after a return to work, the SDI Online guide EDD has walks through every step of Part A. The key detail is using your current disability start date, not the date of the original injury.

0 coins

So the date I stopped working this time, not the date way back when this whole thing started?

0 coins

Exactly. The date your work stopped because of this new period of disability. Your doctor will also put that date on the medical certification.

0 coins

I got this wrong on a question before filing and it caused a small delay. Worth slowing down on that field.

0 coins

If your doctor's office drags their feet on submitting, don't just wait. Touch base with them every few days. The 49-day clock is on you too.

0 coins

My first claim I didn't realize the deadline applied to the doctor's part as well. I thought once I submitted my piece I was done.

0 coins

You're done with your part, but the whole claim isn't complete until the certification is in.

0 coins

been dealing with edd since july and the thing nobody tells you is that the status on sdi online lags behind whatever is actually happening on their end. i thought my claim was stuck for weeks and payments just showed up one day.

0 coins

This is both reassuring and stressful. So I could be in better shape than the screen is telling me?

0 coins

could be. payments showed up without any status change warning for me.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation arriving is usually a good sign the claim is moving along even before you see payment activity.

0 coins

Nobody tells you going back to work for a few weeks before you're really ready is essentially gambling with your SDI status. If you can't hold out, you can't hold out, but know that you're resetting everything.

0 coins

Doctors say you're good, your body says otherwise. Not always a choice.

0 coins

True enough. Just saying EDD doesn't give you credit for trying.

0 coins

Filed my new claim this afternoon. Got the receipt number and texted it to the doctor's office right away. They said they'd submit the certification within the next day or two. Waiting period math is not fun but at least I know what I'm dealing with now.

0 coins

Getting the receipt number to them same day was exactly the right move.

0 coins

Day two is usually when you can start checking SDI Online for confirmation the certification was received.

0 coins

Fingers crossed for a smooth process for you!

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure