Back to California Disability

Faith Kingston

Can you file SDI while on unemployment from another job?

So I'm in a situation I haven't seen anyone else ask about and I really hope someone can help. I was working two jobs, a part-time retail position and a full-time office job. The retail job laid me off about six weeks ago and I started collecting unemployment for those lost wages. Then three weeks ago I had to stop working my office job completely because of a back problem my doctor says will keep me out for at least two months. Now I'm trying to figure out if I can file a disability claim through SDI for the office job income I'm losing, even though I'm already getting unemployment payments for the retail job. I went into myEDD and started looking at SDI Online but got nervous halfway through because I didn't want to do something wrong and end up with an overpayment notice from either program. Can you even collect both at the same time? Does the unemployment have to stop first? I haven't filed the DI claim yet because I'm scared of getting it wrong.

You cannot collect unemployment and disability for the same days, full stop. EDD says that plainly on their site. The two programs can't overlap on the same calendar days. So you'd need to stop certifying for unemployment before you start the disability claim, as of the day your back took you out.

0 coins

So I'd lose the unemployment payments entirely from that point forward, even though the layoff is still real?

0 coins

The layoff's real but you have to pick one for each day. You can't work, so disability is the right one right now. When you're better and looking for work again, unemployment is there.

0 coins

Exactly right. EDD's own language is that you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. The retail layoff doesn't change that; it's the daily overlap that isn't allowed.

0 coins

49 days from your disability start date is the deadline to get the medical certification in, and that clock started when your back forced you out of the office job, not today. If you've already used three weeks, you have about four weeks left to file your Part A and get your doctor to submit the certification before you risk disqualification.

0 coins

Wait, the 49 days includes the time I've already been out? I thought I had 49 days from whenever I actually filed.

0 coins

The 49 days runs from when the disability began, not from when you file. EDD is clear on that point. You still need to wait nine days after the disability starts before filing, but that window for the medical certification is ticking from day one of being unable to work.

0 coins

I didn't know that either. I think I almost missed my own window because I kept waiting to feel better before dealing with the paperwork. That's scary.

0 coins

Receipt number on mine didn't match what my doctor's office had, and my claim sat there doing nothing for two weeks before I figured that out. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get an agent on the line about it. Video on reaching someone at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the receipt number my doctor had on file was from an older incomplete attempt, not the one that went through. Got them to resubmit with the right one. Worth knowing that the number SDI Online gives you after you finish Part A is the one your provider needs, anyway.

0 coins

Receipt number mismatch happened on my claim too. Already had an agent confirm my Notice of Computation through that same route, so I knew the weekly amount before the paper copy arrived.

0 coins

I've been redialing that disability line since 8 a.m. two days running and it just cuts off every single time. What is Claimyr exactly, in plain terms?

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD for you and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's the whole thing. What do you need to ask them about?

0 coins

My doctor submitted the certification four days ago and SDI Online still shows nothing changed. That's what I'd want to raise with an agent.

0 coins

The unemployment-plus-disability question trips everyone up. What EDD actually means is that for every single day you claim, you can only be on one program. If you stopped certifying for unemployment the day your back gave out, that's your disability start date, and those two things run separately with no overlap.

0 coins

Okay that actually makes sense the way you said it. So my unemployment claim doesn't get closed, it just pauses while I'm on disability?

0 coins

Pretty much. When you're able and available to work again, you can go back to certifying for unemployment. The claim doesn't disappear.

0 coins

I had the same question when I was juggling two jobs and one ended. The day-by-day framing is what finally made it click for me too.

0 coins

Filing through SDI Online in myEDD is the fastest way to get the claim started. After you finish your part, Part A, the system gives you a receipt number. That number is what your doctor's office needs to find your claim and submit the medical certification. Give it to them the same day if you can.

0 coins

Should I call my doctor's office before I even start Part A, or file first and then contact them?

0 coins

File first so you have the receipt number in hand, then contact the office immediately with it. Some offices are quicker to submit when they already have that number ready to go.

0 coins

My surgeon's office actually asked for it upfront before they'd even look at the form. Good to get it to them fast.

0 coins

Start date on your DI claim matters for the base period calculation too. The weekly benefit amount is estimated from the highest-paid quarter in a 12-month base period that looks back 5 to 18 months before the claim starts. If your office job had the higher wages, filing promptly while that quarter is still in the base period window could affect what shows up on your Notice of Computation.

0 coins

I didn't even think about the timing affecting the amount. Is there a way to estimate it before I file?

0 coins

EDD has a calculator on their site. Plug in your quarterly wages from the office job and it'll give you a rough figure. The real number comes on the Notice of Computation after EDD processes the claim.

0 coins

I used that calculator and was off by a little from what my notice ended up saying, but it got me in the right ballpark for budgeting.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim was showing nothing after 10 days and I couldn't get anyone on the phone without it ringing forever and dropping. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who told me my direct deposit information hadn't been confirmed in the system yet, which was why the payment was sitting. Got that sorted out same day.

0 coins

I've dialed that line more mornings than I want to count and it either rings until it hangs up on me or tells me volume is high and ends the call. How did you even get through? I'm not sure I believe a live person picked up.

0 coins

Claimyr holds the line for you, and when an EDD agent picks up, your phone rings. That's what happened on my end, and the agent was EDD's own person, not a third party.

0 coins

Agent confirmed the payment method wasn't set, which is exactly the kind of thing you can't see clearly in SDI Online yourself. Good to know that's resolvable by phone.

0 coins

Alright, I'll try it. My claim's been pending two weeks and I still have no idea if my doctor's part even arrived.

0 coins

Seven days. That's the waiting period on every new DI claim and it doesn't pay. Day eight is the first day that can be a paid day. It's not the system being slow, it's just the rule.

0 coins

So those seven days are never paid back? Even if the claim eventually gets approved?

0 coins

Correct. Those seven days are gone regardless of what happens after.

0 coins

That part I actually did read somewhere. It still stings though when you're out of a paycheck.

0 coins

My coworker filed while she was out with a wrist injury and said she got her Notice of Computation pretty quickly after her doctor submitted. But she was just on the one job, not dealing with unemployment at the same time.

0 coins

The notice usually comes within about two weeks of EDD getting both parts of the claim, in my experience. It tells you the potential weekly and maximum amounts.

0 coins

Does the notice mean it's approved, or just that they received it?

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows the potential benefit amount only. It is not an approval. If the claim isn't payable, EDD sends a Notice of Determination instead, and that one comes with an appeal form.

0 coins

you cant do both at the same time for the same days, edd is real strict about that. had a buddy try it and got an overpayment notice real fast

0 coins

That tracks. EDD catches it when both claims show the same dates.

0 coins

The overpayment process is rough to deal with after the fact. Way easier to just stop certifying for unemployment on the right day before filing disability.

0 coins

DE 2593 came in my mail after my tenth week on disability and I almost tossed it thinking it was junk! Used Claimyr to get an agent and ask what would happen if I didn't return it in time. Agent said I had 20 days from when EDD sent it to get it back to them or benefits could stop. Got it in the mail the next morning and payments kept going!

0 coins

Claimyr, what does that actually do? I haven't heard of it.

0 coins

You run it and it handles the hold time with EDD, then alerts you when a real agent is on the line. That's the whole deal! What's your situation, is there something about your own claim you'd need to ask?

0 coins

My extension request is out there and I want to know whether EDD received the DE 2525XX from my doctor. That's what I'd ask about.

0 coins

The 20-day window on that form is no joke. I almost let mine slip.

0 coins

the fact that you haven't filed yet is actually fine since you're still within the window, but yeah don't sit on it. get the claim in today and hand the receipt number to your doctor's office same day, lol

0 coins

Okay I'm going to do it this afternoon. I'll stop certifying for unemployment as of my disability start date and file Part A right after.

0 coins

That's the move. And write down exactly which day you stopped certifying for unemployment so there's no overlap to explain later.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in my mail after a denial last year and I nearly missed the appeal window. Claimyr got me to an agent who confirmed the notice was dated about three weeks before it reached me, and I still had just under a week left on the 30-day appeal deadline. Filed the DE 1000A the next day.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice, not the date you receive it. Confirmed both my claim's notice date and which weeks had been paid when I spoke with an EDD agent. Agent read off the specific weeks that were in paid status and the ones still processing.

0 coins

How did you keep track of which weeks they listed?

0 coins

Wrote them down while the agent was talking. Date issued, weeks covered, done. No room for confusion later.

0 coins

The appeal form being attached to that notice is easy to miss if you're not looking for it.

0 coins

Unemployment requires you to be able and available to work every week you certify. If your back is keeping you out, you don't meet that requirement anyway. Disability is the right program for right now.

0 coins

That's actually clarifying. I was thinking of them as competing but they're really just for different situations.

0 coins

Exactly. Disability is for when you can't work. Unemployment is for when you can work but don't have a job. Those are just different facts.

0 coins

Two-job situations are genuinely confusing because the SDI base period looks at wages subject to that payroll deduction. If both jobs were taking out the CASDI deduction, your earnings from both might factor into the base period. But which quarter gets used is EDD's calculation, not something you pick.

0 coins

Right, the highest-paid quarter in the base period is what EDD uses. If the office job paid more, that quarter likely drives the weekly benefit amount on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

And if someone's not sure what their base period quarters look like, the calculator on EDD's site is a reasonable starting point before the notice arrives.

0 coins

stopped certifying for unemployment the day i couldnt go in anymore, filed disability that same week. been fine. no overlap, no notices about it

0 coins

This is reassuring honestly. You didn't have to do anything special to close out the unemployment side?

0 coins

just stopped certifying. didnt call anyone. edd figured it out

0 coins

Same thing my cousin did. Clean break on the certifications and no issues came back on her claim.

0 coins

Your back situation and the retail layoff are two separate things financially but EDD treats them one day at a time. Keeping a note of your exact disability start date, and the last day you certified for unemployment, makes any future questions from EDD much easier to answer.

0 coins

I've been keeping a rough log anyway but I should make it more specific with actual dates.

0 coins

Dates and form names are your best documentation. Keep the receipt number from Part A, note the day you gave it to your doctor, and log when you stopped unemployment certifications.

0 coins

Not sure if this matters but, is there any issue if the reason you can't work has nothing to do with why you were laid off? Like the back problem is totally separate from the retail store closing.

0 coins

They're evaluated separately. The disability claim is about whether your medical condition prevents you from doing your regular work, not about the reason for a prior layoff. EDD looks at each claim on its own facts.

0 coins

That makes me feel better about my own situation too, honestly.

0 coins

Get the claim in. Overthinking it won't help your back and it won't help your bank account.

0 coins

You're right. I'll stop second-guessing and just file today.

0 coins

That's the best update you could post. Good luck with the recovery too.

0 coins

One thing I want to make sure people know: if the retail layoff unemployment and the disability overlap even one day, EDD will find it. The systems are separate but EDD can see both. So be exact about which day you stopped certifying for unemployment before you name your disability start date.

0 coins

Exact dates are everything with EDD. Vague is how you end up explaining an overpayment six months later.

0 coins

Worth double-checking your last unemployment certification date in your EDD account before you fill in the disability start date on Part A. Having both on screen at the same time avoids any accidental overlap.

0 coins

Filed mine a few days after stopping unemployment. No issues. The gap was just me being slow about it.

0 coins

Okay final question, do I actually put the date I stopped being able to work as the start date, even if that's already a few weeks ago?

0 coins

Yes, the disability start date is the actual first day you couldn't do your regular work, even if it's already past. That's what the medical certification has to match too, so your doctor needs to certify from that same date.

0 coins

Make sure the date on the certification your doctor submits lines up with what you put on Part A. A mismatch there can delay everything.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure