Back to California Disability

Diego Flores

Can you collect unemployment if you have surgery, or is SDI the right claim in California?

So I'm scheduled for abdominal surgery in about three weeks and my doctor already told me I'll be out of work for at least six to eight weeks after. My employer doesn't have any kind of paid leave program so I've been scrambling to figure out what I'm supposed to file for. A coworker told me to just go file for unemployment and that's what EDD is for. But then I looked it up and kept seeing stuff about SDI and disability and I'm honestly confused about whether those are the same thing or completely different. I work in warehouse logistics so there's no way I can lift anything or be on my feet all day while I'm recovering, which means I genuinely can't go back until the doctor clears me. Can you collect unemployment if you have surgery, or is that the wrong program entirely? I don't want to file for the wrong thing and mess up my claim.

Your coworker gave you the wrong info, unfortunately. Unemployment is for people who are able to work and looking for a job. If you can't work because of surgery, you have to be able to work every single week you claim it, so if you're recovering and can't do your job you wouldn't qualify. The right program for surgery recovery is SDI, which is State Disability Insurance. That one is specifically for when you're unable to do your regular job because of a non-work injury, illness or surgery like yours. File SDI Online through myEDD, that's the fastest way in.

0 coins

Wait, so unemployment would actually deny me if I filed while I'm recovering? I had no idea they were that different. I'll go look at SDI Online right now.

0 coins

Yep the able and available requirement is a real thing. Filed unemployment once when I was off for a back thing and got a notice saying I was ineligible. Switched to SDI and that was the right move.

0 coins

Claim start date was something I actually had to phone EDD to sort out because SDI Online showed a date I didn't expect. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an EDD agent since the line just kept cutting out every time I tried on my own. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my start date had been recorded as the day I stopped working, not the day my doctor certified, which was what I'd been worried about. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Didn't realize the start date could get recorded wrong like that. Good to know before I even file.

0 coins

Is the start date supposed to be when you stop working or when the disability began? Mine started the same day I went out but I want to make sure I know what to look for.

0 coins

From what the agent said, it's the first day you're unable to work because of the condition. For surgery mine was the day before the procedure when I technically stopped working, but it depends on what your provider puts in the medical certification too.

0 coins

Before the surgery I didn't realize I needed to do two separate things to get the claim moving. I filed my part in SDI Online right away, got my receipt number, and then completely forgot to give it to my surgeon's office. Almost two weeks went by and nothing happened. Turns out EDD needs the doctor's office to submit the medical certification and they find the claim with that receipt number you get after you file. Without it they can't match the two parts together and the claim just sits there.

0 coins

So I need to give the surgeon's office the receipt number specifically? Not just tell them I filed?

0 coins

Exactly, hand them the receipt number. That's how their office finds your claim in SDI Online to submit their side of it.

0 coins

Had the same thing happen to me. Nurse coordinator at my surgeon's office had no idea what SDI Online even was until I explained it. Worth calling them before the surgery to confirm they know the process.

0 coins

Filing too late almost cost me the whole claim. I didn't know there was a window to file, I assumed I could just do it whenever I felt well enough after surgery. Got back on my feet around day 60 of being out and went to file and it nearly hit the cutoff. EDD says you have to file within 49 days of when the disability starts or you can get disqualified. And you're supposed to wait at least nine days after it starts before filing. So the window is basically nine days in to 49 days in.

0 coins

49 days is not very long. I'm going to file as soon as I hit that nine day mark then.

0 coins

Same thing nearly happened to my husband. He kept saying he'd deal with it when he felt better and I had to basically do it for him on day 40. Don't wait.

0 coins

Doctor also has to get their certification in within those 49 days too. So loop the office in early so they're not scrambling.

0 coins

Does SDI pay your full wages? My rent is due and I'm trying to figure out if I'll be short while I'm out for my knee replacement.

0 coins

Not full wages, it's a percentage of what you earned in a specific base period. EDD has a calculator on their site where you can plug in your wages and get an estimate. The actual number comes on a Notice of Computation they mail you once the claim is in motion.

0 coins

Okay so the Notice of Computation is what tells me the real weekly amount? I'll check the calculator in the meantime then.

0 coins

The estimate on the calculator got me pretty close to what my notice ended up saying. Good enough to plan your budget around while you wait.

0 coins

Is SDI the same as PFL? I keep seeing both terms and can't figure out which one I need for surgery recovery.

0 coins

Different programs. SDI disability is when you personally can't work because of your own condition, like surgery recovery. Paid Family Leave is a separate claim for things like bonding with a new baby or caring for a seriously ill family member. For surgery you want the disability side, not PFL.

0 coins

Got it. I had been looking at PFL information and none of it quite matched what I was going through. Makes a lot more sense now.

0 coins

Confused about these two as well when I first got hurt. The EDD website kind of lumps them together under SDI but they're genuinely two different claims with different rules.

0 coins

NOBODY told me about the seven day waiting period when I filed after my surgery and I was completely blindsided. Sat there waiting for a payment in the first week and nothing came. Called three times trying to figure out what was wrong. Finally someone explained that the first seven days of any new claim are just not paid, period. It's not a glitch, it's not processing time, EDD just doesn't pay those seven days. I lost a whole week of wages before I even got a cent.

0 coins

Seven days with nothing at all? That's rough, especially right after surgery when you're not thinking straight. Good heads up.

0 coins

The waiting period threw me off too. I kept thinking my claim was broken. Wish someone had said upfront that the first week is always non-payable.

0 coins

Exactly. If I'd known that going in I would have set aside a week of savings before my surgery date to cover it. Plan for that gap.

0 coins

Is there any situation where you can get both SDI and unemployment at the same time? Like if your employer lays you off while you're recovering?

0 coins

EDD's rule is that you can't get paid by both for the same days. If you're still unable to work, you're on the disability side. When you're recovered and able and available to work again, you could file for unemployment at that point. EDD decides each claim, so for the specifics of a layoff situation I'd contact them directly.

0 coins

So it's one or the other depending on whether you can work. That makes sense even if the situation is complicated.

0 coins

Notice of Computation took longer than I expected after my appendix surgery last year and I wasn't sure if something had gone wrong with the claim. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent to check on it, and the agent pulled up my file and told me the weekly benefit amount and confirmed which base period quarter they'd used. That was enough for me to figure out my finances while I waited for the official notice to arrive.

0 coins

How far out from filing did the Notice of Computation show up for you?

0 coins

Mine came about two weeks after EDD got both my part and the medical certification from my doctor. The agent confirmed EDD had received everything so I knew the clock was running.

0 coins

Two weeks sounds about right from what I've seen. The notice doesn't mean you're approved though, just that EDD has calculated a potential amount.

0 coins

My physical therapist offered to submit the medical certification for my claim and I let her. Months later I found out that was a problem because physical therapists aren't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. Had to get my actual physician to redo it and there was a whole mess trying to figure out if the claim would be accepted at all. Make sure whoever certifies your claim is a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, or one of the other providers EDD actually accepts.

0 coins

Yikes. My surgeon is a licensed physician so I should be fine, but I had no idea physical therapists couldn't do it.

0 coins

Neither did I, and my PT seemed confident she could. The list includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, psychologists among others. Physical therapist just isn't on it.

0 coins

Worth double checking your provider type before surgery day, not after. Easy thing to confirm with the surgeon's office in advance.

0 coins

After five automatic payments my claim just stopped and I panicked thinking the whole thing had ended. Went back through my mail and found this form called the DE 2593, which EDD sends out at that point asking if you're still unable to work. Had a 20-day window to return it. I'd tossed it thinking it was junk mail. Almost lost my benefits over that.

0 coins

Twenty days to return it, that's a tight window. I'll be way more careful with my mail once I'm on the claim.

0 coins

Open everything EDD sends no matter what it looks like. That form looks pretty plain and I genuinely thought it was routine information at first.

0 coins

The DE 2593 caught my neighbor off guard too. Worth knowing in advance that after about ten weeks on automatic payment EDD checks in that way.

0 coins

Can my husband file SDI if he's self-employed and has surgery coming up?

0 coins

SDI covers workers who have been paying into the program through the CASDI deduction on their paystub. Self-employed people aren't automatically in. There's an elective coverage option but that's something to ask EDD about directly since the specifics depend on his situation.

0 coins

He does show CASDI on his paystubs from a part-time job. Does that count?

0 coins

If he has wages subject to SDI deductions from a job in his base period and meets the minimum earnings requirement, that part of his income would count. EDD's site has a benefits calculator, and he can contact EDD to get the full picture on his specific case.

0 coins

Payments go to a Money Network prepaid debit card unless you pick direct deposit when you're filing in SDI Online. I didn't realize I could choose direct deposit and ended up waiting for the card to arrive in the mail while I had bills due. If you want the money straight to your bank account, set that up during the filing process.

0 coins

Setting up direct deposit during filing sounds much smarter. I'll make sure to do that.

0 coins

Didn't the EDD card used to be Bank of America? I still have that old card somewhere.

0 coins

The card is now through Money Network, not Bank of America. Different card, different setup.

0 coins

My claim ran six weeks and my doctor told me at my follow-up that I actually needed another three weeks before I could safely go back to the warehouse. I didn't know if that meant filing a new claim or what. Turns out the doctor submits a separate form, the DE 2525XX, to extend the existing claim. No new claim from my end. EDD sends that form along with the final payment notice so the timing lines up, but I'd recommend telling your doctor's office about the extension process before you get to that point.

0 coins

So extensions stay on the same claim? I would have definitely filed a new one thinking that was the right move.

0 coins

Same claim, same weekly amount, your doctor just certifies additional time. The DE 2525XX is what they submit.

0 coins

My doctor had never heard of the DE 2525XX and I had to explain it to them. Definitely loop them in early.

0 coins

Which weeks were paid on my claim got completely scrambled after I went back to work part-time while still recovering from my shoulder surgery. SDI Online wasn't showing what I expected and I could not figure out from the portal alone which weeks had actually been paid and which were still pending. Claimyr put me through to an agent who went through each week individually and told me exactly which had been issued and which were still open. Ended up being a data entry timing issue on a couple of weeks that the agent flagged for me.

0 coins

Going back part-time while still on the claim sounds complicated. Do you have to report that to EDD?

0 coins

You do report it, yes. How EDD handles a partial week is their call, but you have to tell them when you're working any hours.

0 coins

Partial weeks while on SDI tripped me up too. Definitely report every hour you work, even a few hours in a week.

0 coins

What happens if EDD denies the claim? Is there any way to fight it?

0 coins

If EDD denies it you get a Notice of Determination, and it comes with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to file your appeal. Send it with a detailed explanation of why you disagree to the address on the notice. If you've lost the form a detailed letter works too. Miss that 30-day window and you'd have to explain why to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

30 days from the notice date, not from when you receive it?

0 coins

From the date on the notice itself, so it's worth appealing as soon as possible rather than waiting to see if anything changes.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the base period for the wage calculation, it's not just your most recent paychecks. It's a 12-month window ending a few months before your claim starts, and they look at which three-month quarter in that window had your highest earnings. So if you had a slow quarter recently it might not drag down the weekly benefit as much as you'd expect. Use the calculator on EDD's site to run the numbers before you panic.

0 coins

Does that mean overtime I worked last spring could actually count toward the calculation?

0 coins

If that spring quarter falls within your base period, yes. That's exactly the kind of thing the calculator can help you estimate.

0 coins

DE 2525XX never showed up for me even though my doctor said she'd submitted the extension after my spinal surgery. Claimyr got me through to an agent and I asked specifically whether the form had been received. The agent said nothing had come in yet under my claim ID and that my doctor's office would need to resubmit it. Called the office that same afternoon and they confirmed their portal had a submission error they hadn't caught. Got it resubmitted that day.

0 coins

Glad you caught that before the extension deadline passed. What number did you use for EDD?

0 coins

EDD disability line is 1-800-480-3287, Monday through Friday 8 to 5. That's the one I used.

0 coins

Doctors offices making submission errors on extensions is surprisingly common. Confirming receipt a few days after the office submits is a good habit.

0 coins

Taxes on SDI benefits confused me after my first full claim. I got my paperwork at tax time and wasn't sure what was taxable. From what I've looked into, California itself doesn't tax SDI benefits. Whether anything is owed federally depends on your situation. I'd check EDD's tax information page and talk to a tax professional before filing rather than assuming either way.

0 coins

Good to know California doesn't tax it at least. I'll look into the federal side closer to tax season.

0 coins

I had an accountant handle mine the first year just to be safe. Probably worth it if the amount is significant.

0 coins

My claim was pending for almost three weeks after my doctor's office submitted the certification and I was getting really anxious. Kept refreshing SDI Online every day waiting for something to change. Eventually it did move and I got the Notice of Computation in the mail. EDD says most payments go out within two weeks after they have both the claimant's part and the medical certification, but that clock doesn't start until they actually have both pieces in. If anything looks stuck past that window it's worth contacting EDD to check.

0 coins

Two weeks from when they have both parts, not two weeks from when I file. That's an important distinction.

0 coins

Exactly. If your doctor's office submits a week after you file, the two weeks starts then, not on the day you filed.

0 coins

Pending can feel endless when you're recovering and watching your bank account. Setting up direct deposit at least means the payment lands fast when it does release.

0 coins

Reached the end of my claim and realized my doctor was going to clear me for light duty but not full duty. Wasn't sure if that counted as going back to work for SDI purposes or if I could stay on the claim while doing limited hours. I reported the light duty work to EDD when I went back and let them determine how to handle my partial weeks. Don't assume you have to either be fully on the claim or fully back at work, just report what's actually happening.

0 coins

I'll probably be in that exact situation, light duty before full duty. Good to know the answer is just to report it and let EDD sort it out.

0 coins

Right, don't try to guess how they'll calculate a partial week. Report your hours and let EDD make the call.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure