Back to California Disability

Julia Hall

Can wrong dates cause a PFL claim denial after SDI ends?

So I'm kind of in a panic right now and hoping someone here has dealt with this. My disability claim through EDD was for my recovery after my c-section, and my doctor certified eight weeks like normal. I filed my PFL bonding claim to start right when the DI ended, but I'm pretty sure I put the wrong start date on the PFL side. Like I may have accidentally overlapped the two by a day or two, or maybe left a gap. My SDI claim end date is showing one thing in SDI Online and I'm second-guessing what I entered for PFL. Has anyone had a PFL claim denied or held up because the dates didn't line up right with the end of their disability? I really can't afford for this to get messed up right now.

Date mismatches between the DI and PFL sides are worth catching early. If you log into SDI Online through myEDD and pull up both claims, you can see the exact end date EDD has for the disability claim and compare it to what you entered for PFL. A one-day overlap is the kind of thing that can stall a PFL claim because EDD won't pay both for the same day. If you spot an error, the Request Claim Update option inside SDI Online lets you flag it before it becomes a denial.

0 coins

I found both claims in there. The DI end date and the PFL start date are literally the same day. Is that an overlap or is that fine?

0 coins

Same day is an overlap in EDD's view. The DI benefit covers that day, so PFL should start the following day. Flag it through Request Claim Update now.

0 coins

Wait, so there's no gap allowed at all? Like PFL has to start the exact next day or you lose bonding time?

0 coins

There's no rule that says you lose the weeks, but you do have to claim them within a year of the birth. A short gap doesn't erase them, it just means those gap days go unpaid.

0 coins

The start date on my PFL claim was off by four days because I mixed up when my DI actually ended, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. The claim's start date EDD had on file was different from what I'd entered, and the agent confirmed the exact date my disability claim closed on their end. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Once I had that confirmed date I went back into SDI Online and submitted a correction through Request Claim Update before anything got denied.

0 coins

Did they let you correct it right on the call, or did you have to do the update yourself in SDI Online after?

0 coins

The agent gave me the confirmed end date and I did the update myself in SDI Online. The agent just told me what was actually on the claim, the fixing part was mine to do.

0 coins

been trying that line for like two weeks. mornings, afternoons, nothing gets through.

0 coins

Dates tripped me up too. I assumed my DI end date was whatever the last payment covered, but it's not always that clean. Check the Notice of Computation and any payment notices EDD sent you, those will show you exactly which days were covered.

0 coins

I didn't even think to look at the payment notices. Where do those show up, in SDI Online or by mail?

0 coins

Both usually. SDI Online shows payment info and EDD mails notices too. The last one should spell out the final covered date.

0 coins

I keep reading about the Notice of Computation but I'm not sure if that's the same as the payment notice or a different thing. I think they're different?

0 coins

They are different. The Notice of Computation comes early in the claim and shows your potential weekly and maximum benefit amount. Payment notices come later and show which weeks were paid.

0 coins

Okay so I'm confused about something related. My DI was for pregnancy and I thought PFL bonding just automatically started after. Does EDD connect them or do you actually have to file a whole separate PFL claim?

0 coins

Completely separate filing, they don't link on their own. You file the PFL bonding claim yourself in SDI Online, and you pick the start date. That's exactly where the date issue in this thread comes in.

0 coins

So if I filed DI for my pregnancy and I want to bond after, I go back into SDI Online and start a brand new claim from scratch?

0 coins

Yes, a new PFL claim. Same system, myEDD and then SDI Online, but it's a separate filing for the bonding portion.

0 coins

This is the part that got me too. I thought maybe EDD would just carry it over automatically and I waited too long to file the PFL side.

0 coins

Wrong dates are fixable if you catch them before a denial goes out. Once you get a denial notice you're dealing with an appeal, and that's a lot more work. Get into SDI Online today and check both sides.

0 coins

How fast does EDD usually move on this stuff? Like if the overlap is there does it get denied fast or does it sit a while?

0 coins

No way to know for certain. Some things process fast, some sit for weeks. Don't wait on it.

0 coins

Fast enough that by the time you notice the denial it's already been issued.

0 coins

The overlap thing is a known issue and EDD's phone line is basically useless for getting ahead of it. I spent three mornings in a row hitting that busy signal before I ever got a person. The Request Claim Update in SDI Online is genuinely the faster move here.

0 coins

yeah ive done the same thing with that line like a full week of mornings and nothing

0 coins

It's not a timing trick, the volume is just brutal. Online tools are going to be more reliable for a date correction than the phone.

0 coins

Request Claim Update is underrated honestly. I used it for a question on my claim and got a response in a couple days lol.

0 coins

Not sure if this applies here but does the waiting period for PFL work the same as it does for DI? Like does PFL also have a seven-day unpaid wait? I think I heard it doesn't but I'm not sure.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period, that's correct. The seven-day unpaid wait is only on DI claims. Your PFL bonding benefits can start from day one of the bonding period.

0 coins

Oh that's actually really good to know. So the first week of PFL doesn't disappear unpaid like it does at the start of a DI claim?

0 coins

Right, PFL starts paying from the first day you claim it, no waiting period.

0 coins

That part at least is a relief. The DI waiting period already cost me a week and I didn't want to lose another one on the PFL side.

0 coins

Something worth noting from my own experience: I keep a simple note with both dates side by side, the last date covered by DI and the first date I entered for PFL. When I did my c-section recovery claim the DI ran through a Saturday. I filed PFL starting the following Sunday. When I checked the payment notices it matched up and I didn't have an overlap.

0 coins

This is exactly what I should have done. I just entered what I thought was right without double-checking the actual DI end date first.

0 coins

The specific date EDD has on the DI side is what matters, not what you remember or estimated. Those two don't always match.

0 coins

Day-of-week timing is something I never thought about but it makes sense that a claim wouldn't end mid-week necessarily.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on a DI claim is what confirmed my actual base period and weekly amount, but when my PFL dates were off I called EDD after using Claimyr and the agent walked me through exactly which quarter was used. Having that number in front of me helped me double-check that the PFL filing date I'd entered was after the DI benefit period closed.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came early in the claim and I didn't really read it. Now I'm wondering if the amount on mine was what I'd expect. Would you say have that document out before you try reaching EDD?

0 coins

Yes, have the Notice of Computation, your SDI Online claim ID, and your dates of disability written down. The agent can pull up what's on file, but you'll follow along better if you have your own records.

0 coins

I didn't keep mine and now I really wish I had. I think it's still in SDI Online somewhere though.

0 coins

It should be accessible in SDI Online under your claim. If you can't find it there, check any mail from EDD around the time your claim was first processing.

0 coins

my partner went through this last year. had a gap of like three days between di ending and pfl starting and those three days just went unpaid. not a denial just unpaid gap days

0 coins

So a gap doesn't automatically cause a denial, it just means those days aren't covered?

0 coins

yeah from what happened with them it was just empty days. no payment no denial just nothing for those three days

0 coins

An overlap is the bigger risk for a denial since EDD won't pay two programs for the same day. A gap just means those days go unclaimed.

0 coins

Honestly I'm not sure the Request Claim Update ever actually gets read in a reasonable timeframe. I sent one and didn't hear anything for almost three weeks.

0 coins

It varies. For a date correction on a pending claim it may move faster than on a claim that's already processing. Worth sending it either way since it creates a record of when you flagged the issue.

0 coins

Fair, I'll give it that. At least there's a timestamp on it.

0 coins

Three weeks is rough. Mine came back in like four days but that might have been timing or luck lol.

0 coins

Two things tripped me up on mine. The PFL start date and also not knowing that my DI claim for my recovery was separate from the bonding part at all. I thought it was one continuous thing. Took me longer than it should have to figure out I needed to file PFL separately, anyway.

0 coins

This is exactly where I am right now. I didn't realize they were two totally separate filings until I read this thread.

0 coins

Yeah nobody tells you clearly upfront. You finish the disability part and assume PFL just picks up, but you have to go back in and file it yourself.

0 coins

EDD really should make this clearer somewhere! The two-step thing is confusing for so many people.

0 coins

Weeks showing paid on my DI claim didn't match what I thought the end date was, so I called through Claimyr to ask which weeks EDD actually had as paid on that claim. The agent pulled up the specific weeks and confirmed the last paid week, which was different from the week I'd entered as my PFL start reference.

0 coins

The last paid week being different from what you assumed, that's exactly what happened with my own claim. I used Claimyr for a different question but the agent confirmed when the medical certification had come in, and that explained why the week count was off from what I expected. Getting that answer helped me figure out the right start point for the next step.

0 coins

ive been redialing that number most days this week and cant get through at all

0 coins

I had the same stretch before that call. It took several mornings before anything worked.

0 coins

EDD pays one program at a time. If the DI end date and the PFL start date collide, PFL loses that day. That's the whole rule.

0 coins

Is there any fix once PFL has actually been denied for this, or is it just gone?

0 coins

Appeal within 30 days of the notice date. The denial notice comes with an appeal form.

0 coins

The denial notice is a DE 2517 and it includes the Appeal Form DE 1000A. The 30-day clock runs from the date printed on the notice, not from when you receive it.

0 coins

For what it's worth, my doctor's office actually flagged this for me before I filed PFL! They told me to get the exact DI end date from SDI Online first and use the day after as my PFL start. Really glad they said something or I would have definitely overlapped.

0 coins

Lucky that they knew to bring it up. Mine didn't say anything about it at all.

0 coins

I think it's not universal, it probably just depends on how familiar the office is with the whole DI to PFL process.

0 coins

That's a good tip to pass on. Confirm the DI end date in SDI Online, then start PFL the next day.

0 coins

The part I still don't have clear is whether EDD will just adjust the PFL start date if the overlap is small, or if they deny the whole claim and make you appeal. My PFL claim is still pending and I found what might be a one-day overlap but I haven't heard anything yet.

0 coins

EDD doesn't automatically adjust dates on your behalf. If the overlap causes a problem you'd receive a Notice of Determination, and from there you'd appeal using the DE 1000A within 30 days. The better path is flagging it yourself now through Request Claim Update while it's still pending.

0 coins

Okay I'm going to do the Request Claim Update today. I also used Claimyr to get through to EDD about the extension my doctor filed on the DI side, the DE 2525XX. The agent confirmed EDD had received it and which weeks it covered.

0 coins

Every time I've tried 1-800-480-3287 at that hour I get the high-volume message and the line drops. I'll believe you get through to someone when I see it.

0 coins

Happened the same way for me for a full week before I tried it. The agent was an actual EDD employee, confirmed the extension dates from my doctor, that was it.

0 coins

The receipt showing the DE 2525XX was received is at least something. I'd still follow up with the Request Claim Update in SDI Online so there's a written record.

0 coins

Can you even edit a PFL claim once it's submitted or does it have to go through the Request Claim Update thing? I feel like I've seen conflicting info on this lol.

0 coins

Request Claim Update is the right path once the claim is submitted. You can't go back and edit the original filing directly.

0 coins

That makes sense, good to know before I need it.

0 coins

Just to close the loop on what I mentioned earlier: after I got the confirmed DI end date from that call and corrected the PFL start date through Request Claim Update, the PFL claim processed and the first payment came through without any denial. The correction happened before EDD got to reviewing the overlap.

0 coins

This is what I'm hoping happens for me. I just submitted the Request Claim Update about an hour ago.

0 coins

Catching it while it's still pending is the best case. You did the right thing.

0 coins

What if EDD processes the claim before they read the Request Claim Update? Is there any way to know which happened first?

0 coins

No way to know the order from your end. If you get a denial notice anyway, appeal within 30 days with the DE 1000A and explain that you flagged the correction before the denial.

0 coins

Don't wait for a denial to tell you something's wrong. The Request Claim Update is there for exactly this, use it and keep a note of when you sent it.

0 coins

Does a Request Claim Update go to a person or is it automated?

0 coins

Goes to EDD staff. It's not instant but a person reviews it.

0 coins

submitted one last week. still waiting. starting to wonder.

0 coins

The status won't necessarily update in SDI Online to confirm it was read, you just have to wait for the response or for the claim to move.

0 coins

Update from me: I got a response to my Request Claim Update this morning. EDD acknowledged the overlap and my PFL claim is still showing as pending, not denied. So flagging it early seems to have done something at least. Still waiting on the actual payment but at least it didn't go straight to denial.

0 coins

Pending is exactly where you want it right now. That means the door is still open.

0 coins

So glad it didn't just immediately deny! Fingers crossed the payment comes through cleanly.

0 coins

Let us know when the payment actually posts. Pending can still go sideways but the fact that they acknowledged the correction is a decent sign.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure