Can my doctor override IME doctor decision to extend SDI?
So I've been on SDI for about six weeks recovering from a back procedure and my own doctor said I need at least four more weeks before I can return to my regular job. The problem is EDD sent me to an independent medical exam and that doctor said I was ready to go back now. My own doctor completely disagrees and has been treating me this whole time. I'm honestly panicking because I still can't do the lifting my job requires and I really need those four weeks. Can my doctor submit something to counter what the IME doctor said? Does EDD even look at my treating physician's opinion when there's a conflict like this? I filed through SDI Online and my claim has been going fine until this point, I just don't know what happens next when two doctors are saying completely opposite things.
85 comments

Mei Wong
Payment method on my SDI claim was showing wrong in SDI Online, like it still had the old card option and I'd switched to direct deposit weeks before. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is how I got an actual person at EDD on the phone, not the hold music forever situation. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed direct deposit was active and that my next payment would go there, not to the old card. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ Anyway, your situation sounds way more stressful than mine. Your treating doctor can absolutely submit a supplementary certificate, and if EDD still denies the extension, you have the right to appeal. Don't let that IME result just sit there if your own doctor disagrees.
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Direct deposit showing wrong is exactly what happened on mine too, same thing. Used Claimyr as well and the agent confirmed which account EDD had on file. After that I got a Notice of Determination saying the claim period was ending, and I wasn't sure if I should appeal or just let it go. Anyway.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
what did you do with the notice, did you appeal it or just wait to see what happened
0 coins
Liam Fitzgerald
Filed the appeal with the DE 1000A before the 30 days were up. Sent it to the address on the notice. Still waiting to hear back but at least it's in.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
The 30-day window is easy to miss if you're not watching for it.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
The 49-day deadline for the medical certification caught me completely off guard on my first claim two years ago. What happens in a situation like yours is that your treating physician can submit additional documentation through SDI Online, and if EDD issues a denial based on the IME result, you have 30 days from the date on that notice to file an appeal using the DE 1000A form. The appeal goes to an administrative law judge who can weigh your treating doctor's findings against the IME. Keep every piece of paper your doctor gives you.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorSo my doctor would submit more through SDI Online even at this stage? I didn't realize the portal stayed open for that after the initial certification.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
The physician/practitioner's supplementary certificate, the DE 2525XX, is what your doctor files when more time is needed. EDD actually sends it with the final payment notice, the DE 2500E, but your doctor's office can also access it in SDI Online. That's the right form for an extension.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
I didn't know there was a specific form for extensions. I thought the doctor just wrote a letter or something. Is the DE 2525XX different from what they filed at the start?
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Yes, the initial certification is the medical certification your doctor submits as Part B of your original claim. The DE 2525XX is only for extending an existing claim that's already been approved. Different form, different purpose.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
IME results aren't automatic. EDD has to issue you a notice if they're going to deny the extension based on it. Watch your mail and your SDI Online account. When that notice shows up, you appeal. Your doctor puts their findings in writing and you send that with the DE 1000A.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
How long does EDD usually take to send that notice after the IME?
0 coins
Dylan Evans
No set timeline I know of. Just check SDI Online regularly and watch the mail. Don't wait around assuming no news is good news.
0 coins
StormChaser
EDD's timeline for anything is basically whenever they feel like it. I've had notices show up two weeks after they mattered.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Worth knowing that the administrative law judge in an appeal does look at the full medical record, not just the IME snapshot. Your treating doctor has weeks of documentation on your condition. That context matters. I'd ask your doctor's office to pull together visit notes from your whole recovery, not just a letter saying you need more time.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorThat's actually really helpful. I was thinking just a note from my doctor but you're right, the whole record would be stronger.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Date every document and keep copies before you mail anything. Appeals can take a while and you want your own record of what you sent and when.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Exactly. I'd also note where the appeal form says to send detailed explanation, write out the specific work duties you can't perform yet. Lifting, standing, whatever applies. Make it concrete.
0 coins
StormChaser
EDD's phone line for disability is a nightmare. I've tried first thing in the morning, middle of the day, end of the day. Half the time it just disconnects. For something as important as an IME dispute you really need to talk to a person, not read tea leaves in SDI Online.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Every single morning for two weeks I tried that line. Got through once and was told to phone again.
0 coins
StormChaser
That's about my experience too. I eventually got through on a Thursday but I couldn't tell you why that day worked and no other day did.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
been trying for a week straight. its exhausting.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Medical certification on my claim was sitting unmatched for 11 days and I had no idea because SDI Online just said pending without explaining anything. Tried the disability line four mornings in a row and each one ended with a recording. Eventually used Claimyr and an agent told me my doctor had used the wrong receipt number when they submitted, so the certification wasn't attached to my claim at all. Got it corrected that week.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
That phone line has hung up on me more times than I can count. I'm having trouble believing anything gets through it. What actually happened when you tried that service?
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
The agent who answered was EDD's own. She pulled up my claim right there and found the mismatched receipt number. That's it. No magic, just finally talking to an actual EDD employee.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Mismatched receipt numbers are more common than people realize. I've seen claimants in this situation before. Once EDD matches the certification to the right claim it usually starts moving. Glad you got it sorted.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Alright. I still think the line being undialable is the actual problem they should fix. But good to know there's a way through it.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
The regulations allow a claimant to present their own medical evidence in an appeal. The IME is one piece of evidence, not the final word. An administrative law judge weighs all of it. EDD's own guidance says if you disagree with a determination you can appeal within 30 days of the date the notice was issued. That's written on the DE 2517.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorSo the DE 2517 is the specific notice I'd be looking for? I keep checking SDI Online but haven't seen anything new yet.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Yes, the Notice of Determination is the DE 2517 and it comes with the Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, attached. You'd see it in SDI Online and get a copy by mail. If you disagree with what it says, 30 days from the date printed on it is your window.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
What if the 30 days pass before you even understand what the notice means? Can you still appeal late?
0 coins
Yara Khalil
A late appeal is possible but you'd have to explain the reason for the delay to the administrative law judge. It's not guaranteed. That's why watching for the notice matters.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
My coworker went through basically this, IME said she was fine, her doctor said no way. She appealed and the ALJ sided with her doctor because she had all her treatment records going back to the injury. Took a few months but she got the extension.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorThat's really encouraging honestly. Did she keep certifying with her own doctor while the appeal was going?
0 coins
Keisha Brown
I think so, yeah. The doctor kept submitting and she just kept documenting everything. Lol, she had a whole folder.
0 coins
Mei Wong
Having that paper trail really does seem to be the thing that makes or breaks these appeals.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Your treating doctor knows your body and your job demands! An IME doctor sees you once for maybe 20 minutes. If your doctor is willing to write a detailed letter describing exactly why you can't do your job tasks yet, that is real evidence. Get everything in writing from them!
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
The more specific the better. 'Patient cannot lift over 15 pounds' lands differently than 'patient is recovering.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
yeah specifics are everything. vague letters dont help anybody
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Exactly! Dates, weight limits, specific movements, all of it!
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Appeal filing doesn't pause or extend the claim on its own. If EDD stops payments while the appeal is pending, you may need to ask EDD how partial payments or interim periods work in your specific case. Keep your doctor updated on where things stand so they can support your documentation.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorWait, so payments could stop while I'm waiting for the appeal decision? That's what I was afraid of.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
It depends on what EDD's determination says. Read the notice carefully when it comes. If you disagree, appeal right away and ask EDD directly what happens to your payments during the appeal.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Filing the appeal as quickly as possible after the notice date is the safest move. Don't wait until day 28.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Waiting period on my claim was flagged wrong in the system, the seven non-payable days weren't calculated from the right start date. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr and she confirmed the actual first day of my disability period and recalculated when the payable days began. If you're heading into an appeal, knowing your exact claim start date and waiting period matters for which weeks are in dispute.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Could you tell me more about how Claimyr works? I've been trying that line myself and I have a question about my own claim's start date that I really need answered.
0 coins
Amina Toure
It waits on hold with EDD for you and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's really the whole thing.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
That's straightforward enough. My claim start date seems off by a few days and I want to ask an agent whether it was entered correctly, because those days affect my waiting period too.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
been trying to reach them about my own start date for days. nothing.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Get the DE 2525XX filed by your physician before anything else. That form is how an extension gets into the system. The appeal covers the denial but the form is what actually documents the additional time your doctor says you need. Both steps matter.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorShould I be asking my doctor to file the DE 2525XX now, before EDD even sends the denial notice?
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Yes. Your doctor can file the extension request regardless of the IME outcome. EDD will decide on it, and if they deny it that's what triggers the notice you'd appeal.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Don't wait on the form. Get it in. The denial and the appeal come later.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Base period on my claim showed the wrong quarter and the weekly amount on the Notice of Computation looked too low. Got through to an agent through Claimyr and she confirmed which 12-month base period EDD used and which quarter came up as my highest-paid one. Turned out they had the right quarter, my wages in that period were just lower than I remembered.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Phoned through Claimyr myself about a receipt number issue, and I want to say I was relieved I did. The agent confirmed EDD had received my doctor's submission but it was matched under a slightly different receipt number than what I'd given the office. Got it corrected same day.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
wait how did you know the receipt number was wrong if the agent was the one who found it
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
The agent compared what was in the system with what I read to her from my SDI Online confirmation. The numbers were off by one digit. The doctor's office had transposed two numbers when they entered it.
0 coins
Ava Williams
November 14 was when I noticed my claim had gone past the automatic payment period without a DE 2593 showing up. That questionnaire comes after five automatic payments, about 10 weeks in, and you have 20 days to return it or benefits can stop. If your extension and appeal both end up running long, keep an eye on that form.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorI didn't even know about the DE 2593. At what point does that get sent?
0 coins
Ava Williams
EDD sends it after five automatic payments have been issued, roughly at the 10-week mark. Watch for it in the mail and in SDI Online.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Returning it within 20 days is important. Missing that one can interrupt payments even when the underlying claim is fine.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
If the IME doctor and your doctor disagree, does EDD always go with the IME? I'm not in the same situation but I'm worried about my own claim if something like this happened to me.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
EDD considers the IME results but it's not automatically final. That's the whole reason the appeal process and the administrative law judge exist. Treating physicians' records carry real weight.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
That's a little reassuring. I think I assumed the IME was just the last word on everything.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
The IME is one input. The ALJ looks at all of it.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
my doctor told me after my surgery that she could write to edd if they pushed back on my time off. i didnt end up needing it but its good to know they can do that. your doctor sounds like they have your back so use that
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorMine really has been great throughout this whole recovery. I think she'll be willing to put together a strong letter and all the visit notes.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
yeah get all of it, every appointment, every note. the more the better
0 coins
Amina Toure
Doctors who have been with you from day one of the injury are the strongest advocates in an appeal situation.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
The DE 1000A is a simple form but the explanation section matters most. Don't just say you disagree. Write out specifically what your doctor's assessment is and how it differs from the IME findings.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorIs there a word limit or page limit on the explanation section?
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Not that I've seen. Write what you need to write. If it goes long, attach a separate page.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Reference specific dates from your treatment history in that explanation. 'As of November 3rd, my treating physician documented X' is clearer than a general statement.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
been dealing with edd on a different thing for three weeks now. every time i call it just ends. the idea that someone actually talks to a person there still kind of amazes me.
0 coins
StormChaser
Three weeks of that line is demoralizing. I've had the same experience, dialed every day for a stretch and got through twice.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
twice out of three weeks is actually more than me honestly
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
The line is what it is. You just have to keep trying.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
For anyone reading this later: appeal deadlines are 30 days from the DATE ON THE NOTICE, not the date you receive it! I learned this the hard way when a notice sat in a stack for a few days. Check your mail the moment you think something might be coming!
0 coins
Yara Khalil
That date distinction is important. The postmark date and the notice date can be different and the 30-day clock runs from the notice date.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Exactly right. Open anything from EDD the day it arrives and note the date printed on the document, not the envelope.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorThat's one I would have gotten wrong for sure. I'll start opening EDD mail the minute it shows up.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
To bring this back to your original question: your treating physician's input absolutely can and should be part of the picture. File the DE 2525XX through your doctor's office now, watch for the DE 2517 in SDI Online and by mail, and if EDD denies the extension, appeal within 30 days with the DE 1000A and your full medical record attached.
0 coins
Jamal Washington
AuthorThank you. This is the clearest summary of what I actually need to do. I'm going to call my doctor's office today about the DE 2525XX.
0 coins
Amina Toure
Acting quickly on both the form and the appeal window puts you in the strongest position.
0 coins
Oliver Weber
Good plan. Document everything you send and when you send it.
0 coins