Back to California Disability

Demi Hall

Can military veteran medically retired from army get SDI without contributions

Retired medically from the army about eight months ago after a back injury that finally got bad enough they couldn't keep me on. Civilian life has been a whole adjustment and now my back situation has gotten worse to the point my doctor says I can't work right now. Friend of mine said to look into SDI but I never had a California civilian job before, so I never paid into the CASDI system. I was active duty the whole time, federal payroll, no SDI deductions ever. Does that mean I'm completely locked out, or is there some way a veteran in my situation can still file? I see the EDD site mentions needing wages subject to SDI in the base period but I'm not clear what counts. Anyone dealt with this coming out of the military?

The base period question is the key one here. EDD looks at wages earned in California covered employment, meaning work where SDI was withheld from your pay. Federal military pay doesn't have that deduction, so those wages don't count toward the SDI base period. If you haven't had any California civilian employment since separation, there likely aren't any covered wages to draw on. That said, if you did any civilian work in California after retirement, even a few months, it's worth checking whether SDI was withheld from those checks.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

No civilian work yet, went straight from retirement to dealing with the back thing. So sounds like I'm probably out unless I find something first.

0 coins

The rule EDD publishes is at least $300 in wages subject to SDI deductions during the base period. That figure is on their FAQ page. No covered wages, no eligible claim. The military's federal exemption is the core issue, not the veteran status itself.

0 coins

That clears it up. Frustrating but at least now I know why.

0 coins

VA disability compensation is separate from SDI. Some veterans assume they're the same bucket. They're not. SDI is a California worker payroll program, VA is federal. If your back got worse after a civilian job starts, that's when SDI would apply.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Yeah I figured they were different, just hoped there was some overlap or exception I was missing.

0 coins

Wait, so even if someone has a VA rating they still have to pay into SDI separately through a civilian job? I thought maybe the federal disability rating carried over somehow. Not sure why I assumed that.

0 coins

Correct. The VA rating and SDI are completely separate systems. One doesn't substitute for the other.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came back on my own claim last month and I had no idea what it meant or what my options were. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at EDD's disability line. Video on reaching someone at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent told me the notice was a denial and that I had 30 days from the date printed on it to file an appeal using the DE 1000A form. Ended up sending it in with a detailed explanation the same week.

0 coins

The start date on my claim got flagged too and I used Claimyr to get through to EDD. Once I had an agent, they confirmed the exact date EDD had recorded as my disability start and that it matched what my doctor submitted. Helped me know nothing was off before I started worrying. Spent probably a week trying that line on my own before that.

0 coins

How many times did you try the regular number before going that route?

0 coins

Mornings, afternoons, tried a few different days. Line either rang forever or the recording ended the call. At some point I just needed an answer.

0 coins

The disability line and I have a complicated relationship. Mostly one-sided.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is a full-time job on its own. Called nine times over two weeks on my own claim, got a live person exactly zero times. I don't know how people are supposed to handle real questions about their situation without spending half the day redialing.

0 coins

ive had the same thing happen, call at 8am it just cuts out or rings forever, so annoying

0 coins

Eight in the morning is supposed to be when they open. First call of the day and still nothing. The whole setup is exhausting.

0 coins

lol I thought early morning was the magic hour but nope, same result. Tried for three weeks straight on a pending issue.

0 coins

To add some context to the original question, the base period EDD uses covers about a year's worth of your wages, specifically the highest-paid quarter inside a 12-month window that ends a few months before your claim starts. If none of those quarters had California covered wages with CASDI withheld, the system has nothing to calculate a benefit from. It's a structural thing, not anything against veterans specifically.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Makes sense the way you lay it out. The military pay was federal the whole time so none of it feeds that calculation at all.

0 coins

Does that mean if someone worked a civilian California job for even one full quarter they might qualify? Or does it have to be more than that? Sorry if that's obvious, I'm just trying to understand how the quarters work.

0 coins

EDD needs at least $300 in SDI-covered wages during the base period, so even a partial quarter could count if the wages were covered. The weekly benefit amount would be low if the wages were low, but it wouldn't be zero. The calculator on EDD's site can estimate it.

0 coins

Thank you, that actually helps me think through my own situation too.

0 coins

Filed for SDI in October after a knee surgery. The base period question came up for me too because I had some gaps in employment. EDD counted my highest quarter from about 14 months back and that was enough to get the claim moving. The Notice of Computation showed the weekly amount based on that quarter.

0 coins

The 12-month base period window and the highest quarter inside it is exactly how it's designed to work. Good that your earlier wages still fell within the window.

0 coins

Came down to timing. If my surgery had been six months later those wages might have dropped out of the window entirely.

0 coins

Short answer to the original post is no, not without covered wages. You'd need to get a California civilian job first, pay into the system, then file when you're unable to work. No shortcut exists.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Blunt but that's what I needed to hear. Appreciate it.

0 coins

Agree. No gray area here.

0 coins

My brother-in-law got out of the military a few years back, got a state job after, paid into SDI for about a year and then had a health thing come up. Filed and it went through. So the path exists, just requires that civilian employment gap first. Anyway, took him a few months but it worked out.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Good to know someone actually walked that path. Gives me a clearer idea of what to plan for.

0 coins

So the waiting isn't forever, just until there's enough covered employment to meet the base period? That's kind of reassuring actually even if it means waiting to find work first.

0 coins

Receipt number on my own SDI claim got lost somehow between me and my doctor's office, and the whole claim stalled. Tried the EDD disability line for days with no luck. Finally went through Claimyr and got an agent on the line. She looked up my claim and read me the receipt number right off the file so I could give it to the provider and they could match the certification to it.

0 coins

The number matching between the claim and the provider is something I didn't realize mattered until my own claim sat there. How certain were you the agent had the right number pulled up?

0 coins

She confirmed my name, the claim ID, and the start date before reading it out. Felt solid. I wrote it down and had the office resubmit the certification the next day.

0 coins

The receipt number is what ties the provider's submission to the claimant's Part A. Without the match, EDD can't connect the two halves. Good that the agent could locate it.

0 coins

Makes sense now. My certification came through fine but I didn't know that receipt number piece was doing so much work behind the scenes.

0 coins

Not exactly the same situation but I'm a first-timer filing for the first time after a procedure and the base period thing confused me too. I kept reading 'highest quarter' and panicking because I had one quarter where I earned almost nothing. Then I realized EDD picks the highest one, not an average or the most recent. Relieved when that clicked.

0 coins

The highest-quarter approach helps most people because a single low-income period doesn't drag the whole calculation down. Your covered wages from stronger quarters still count.

0 coins

Yes exactly. I kept assuming worst case and then found out it wasn't as bad as I feared.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation spells out which quarter they used and what the weekly amount comes to. Worth reading that carefully when it arrives.

0 coins

worked night shifts for two years, every paycheck had CASDI on it. filed SDI when I had a medical issue and it went through. never really thought about those deductions until i needed them

0 coins

same, i never paid attention to the CASDI line until i actually had to file, then suddenly it mattered

0 coins

yeah exactly, easy to ignore until you need it

0 coins

Payment date on my claim showed up later than I expected and I genuinely didn't know if something had gone wrong or if that was normal. Tried the EDD line several mornings in a row and couldn't get through. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and told me the payment for that period had been issued three days earlier and to allow a couple of days for it to post to the card.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned and I'm not clear on how it works.

0 coins

You put your info in and it handles the hold time with EDD's line so your phone rings when an actual EDD person picks up. That's basically it.

0 coins

Honestly that might solve my problem. My claim has a question about the base period quarter EDD used and I've been going back and forth with the SDI Online message system for two weeks with no real answer. I'd rather just ask an agent directly.

0 coins

The online message thing is slow. Sometimes talking to someone is just faster.

0 coins

For the original poster planning ahead: once you have civilian California employment with CASDI withheld, check your paystubs to confirm the deduction is actually showing up. Some jobs are exempt or participate in Voluntary Plans. If yours shows CASDI, you're contributing to the state system.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Good practical tip. I'll know what line to look for when I start working.

0 coins

Voluntary Plan employers run their own disability plan instead of the state one. Benefits are at least equal to SDI. Worth knowing the difference when you start a new job.

0 coins

Exactly. And if you're ever unsure, HR can tell you which plan your employer uses.

0 coins

My claim was pending for like three weeks and I was going a little nuts. Turned out the medical certification was sitting in the system but under a slightly different receipt number. Once that got sorted the payments started within a week or so.

0 coins

The receipt number mismatch seems like it trips up a lot of people. Mine did the same thing.

0 coins

My doctor's office had entered one digit wrong. Tiny mistake, huge delay. lol

0 coins

Giving the provider the exact receipt number from your SDI Online filing confirmation is the best way to prevent that. Even one transposed digit causes the certification not to match.

0 coins

is there any way to file for sdi if youre doing gig work and your 1099 doesnt have CASDI taken out? asking for my own situation not exactly the same as op but seems related

0 coins

Gig work paid on a 1099 generally doesn't have SDI withheld. No withholding means no covered wages for the SDI base period.

0 coins

ugh thats what i was afraid of, so i have nothing to draw on either

0 coins

California has extended SDI coverage to some self-employed workers through an elective program but the details are specific. EDD's site has the information under self-employed coverage, worth looking up.

0 coins

Seven days into every new claim are just gone, non-payable waiting period. I thought that was processing time when I first filed. Nope, it's a rule, those seven days never pay. First payable day is day eight.

0 coins

I made that exact same mistake, I thought the seven days was EDD taking its time processing and I'd eventually see payment for them. Really disappointed when I learned that wasn't how it worked.

0 coins

Yeah the waiting period thing caught me off guard too. Anyway, once you know it you stop wondering where those first days went.

0 coins

EDD could probably put that in bigger letters somewhere. Lots of people seem to miss it.

0 coins

The 49-day window to file matters more than I realized. Had a friend who waited too long after her procedure and by the time she tried to file she was outside that window. EDD denied it right off because of the timing.

0 coins

Filing after the disability starts is fine, EDD says to wait nine days first, but the cutoff is 49 days from the disability start date. Miss that and disqualification is likely.

0 coins

She waited about two months thinking she'd be back at work before needing it. Learned the hard way.

0 coins

That's the kind of thing you don't know until someone tells you, or you find out the hard way.

0 coins

Extensions on existing claims work differently than filing new ones. The doctor handles it on their end with a supplementary form, not the claimant refiling. EDD sends the form with the final payment notice. People sometimes panic and start a new claim when they just needed the provider to submit the extension.

0 coins

Is the extension form something the doctor gets from EDD or does the claimant have to get it to them? I keep seeing references to it and I don't fully understand the flow.

0 coins

EDD sends it with the last payment notice, the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification. Doctor gets it from that or through SDI Online if they're set up there.

0 coins

The form is the DE 2525XX, the Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate. EDD attaches it to the final payment notice specifically so the provider can extend if needed.

0 coins

Nothing about veteran status changes the SDI eligibility rules. It's purely about covered California wages. Sympathize with the situation but there's no exception written into the program for it.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Understood. I'm not looking for special treatment, just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing something that applied.

0 coins

Fair enough. The rules are the rules, they just don't account for military service histories.

0 coins

For anyone reading later who's transitioning out of the military and planning to work in California, start paying attention to the CASDI deduction on your first civilian check. Building up those covered wages is what creates eligibility down the road if you ever need it.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

That's the clearest piece of advice in this whole thread for someone in my position. Start building the covered wage history as soon as work starts.

0 coins

Even a single quarter of covered wages helps toward the base period, though obviously more quarters means a higher potential benefit amount.

0 coins

Demi Hall

Author

Alright, I've got a real plan now. Get the civilian job, confirm CASDI is being withheld, and build up the base period. Thanks everyone.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure