Back to California Disability

Elliott luviBorBatman

Can doctor correct medical certification after SDI claim denied appeal

So my SDI claim got denied and I already filed my appeal, but my doctor's office just told me they think there was an error on the medical certification they originally submitted. Like the dates were off by a week. Now I'm wondering if the administrative law judge can even look at a corrected certification, or if what was filed is just locked in forever. Has anyone dealt with this during an appeal? Do I bring the corrected paperwork to the hearing or does the doctor have to resubmit through SDI Online first? I'm so stressed because I genuinely could not work during those weeks and I feel like a clerical mistake is what tanked my whole claim.

Paperwork errors on the medical certification are more common than people think, and they absolutely can matter at an appeal. The administrative law judge is supposed to look at all the evidence you bring, so a corrected certification from your doctor would be relevant. What I'd suggest is having your doctor submit the correction through SDI Online and also bring printed copies to the hearing. The judge can consider documentation that wasn't part of the original decision as long as it's relevant to the period you're claiming.

0 coins

Thank you, that helps. Do I need to send EDD a copy before the hearing date too, or just bring it that day?

0 coins

Sending it ahead gives EDD time to put it in your file before the hearing. I'd do both, send it and bring copies.

0 coins

Does the judge actually read everything you bring or is it more like you have to explain it out loud? I have my own appeal coming up and I'm panicking about how it works.

0 coins

They read what you submit and you also get to explain your situation. Bring organized copies of everything.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my own claim had a quarter listed that didn't match what I expected, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get it sorted. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which quarter was showing as the basis for the benefit calculation. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For your situation, the corrected certification is definitely something to raise at the appeal hearing, and your doctor can also write a letter explaining the original error.

0 coins

I've dialed that disability line probably fifteen times over three weeks and the recording just cuts off every single time, never once got a person. How does Claimyr even do anything different, that line seems completely impossible to get through.

0 coins

Honestly I didn't expect it to work either. The service stays on the line with EDD while you do other things, and your phone rings once a live agent there picks up. I had tried that number four mornings in a row before I did it.

0 coins

waited on hold with edd for like two hours one morning last spring and still nothing so i feel that, glad something worked for you

0 coins

Okay that makes more sense now. I'm going to give it a shot because I need to ask about the waiting period on my claim, whether those seven days are showing correctly.

0 coins

Bring the corrected cert to the hearing. The judge wants to know what actually happened to you. A date error from the doctor's office shouldn't sink a valid claim if you can show the work stoppage was real.

0 coins

That's what I'm hoping. My surgeon's office even admitted it was their data entry mistake.

0 coins

Get that admission in writing from them if you can. An email works.

0 coins

Yep. Even a short letter from the office saying they entered the wrong date and here's what it should have been.

0 coins

Wait, so when you appeal a denial, can you actually add new documents? I thought the appeal was just about whether EDD made the right call based on what they already had. Doesn't adding a corrected form change things?

0 coins

An appeal in California EDD's process goes before an administrative law judge who can consider new evidence that's relevant to whether you were disabled during the claimed period. A corrected medical certification isn't a brand new claim, it's clarifying what your provider actually intended to certify.

0 coins

Oh that makes way more sense. I was confusing myself thinking it was like a court where you can't bring anything new.

0 coins

The DE 1000A appeal form even has a section for describing why you disagree with the determination. You can reference the certification error right there when you fill it out.

0 coins

EDD denied my claim too and the reason they gave was vague enough that I still don't fully understand what triggered it. I'm not saying that's your situation but sometimes the denial has nothing to do with what you think it does. Make sure you read the Notice of Determination carefully before you go into that hearing.

0 coins

Mine said something about the medical certification not supporting the claimed disability period, which is exactly what a wrong date would cause.

0 coins

Then yeah, a corrected cert is directly on point. That's the clearest case for bringing new documentation.

0 coins

That's actually a pretty clear denial reason. At least you know what you're fixing.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it comes with the denial notice, the Notice of Determination DE 2517. You have 30 days from the date on that notice to file. If your 30 days are still open and you haven't sent the form yet, you can describe the certification date error in your explanation. If you already sent it, you can still submit a written addendum and bring documentation to the hearing itself.

0 coins

Already sent the DE 1000A. So I'll write up an addendum explaining the date issue.

0 coins

Yes, and ask your doctor's office to put the correction in writing with the claim receipt number on it so it ties back to your specific claim.

0 coins

Is there any risk that submitting more documents after the initial appeal form makes things worse? Like could EDD use it against you somehow?

0 coins

Submitting a corrected certification from your own provider that corrects a data entry error supports your case. It doesn't create new liability.

0 coins

Got a denial myself about a year back and went through the whole hearing. The judge asked me specific questions about why I couldn't perform my regular work duties. Your doctor correcting the dates is good, but be ready to explain in your own words what you physically couldn't do and for how long.

0 coins

Good point. I've been so focused on the paperwork that I haven't actually prepared what I'd say about my own condition.

0 coins

Walk through it like a timeline. When you stopped working, what you couldn't do, when your provider cleared you. That narrative matters.

0 coins

Exactly. The judge knows what a certification says. They want to hear from you that the dates on the corrected one actually match what happened.

0 coins

Pending weeks on the payment side were what I couldn't get a straight answer on until I used Claimyr to reach a disability agent directly. The agent went through my account and told me which specific weeks were still showing as unpaid and which had been issued already. For your appeal, knowing exactly which weeks EDD flagged when they denied you will help you match the corrected certification to those exact dates.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

The service takes your place waiting on EDD's line and your phone rings when a live agent there picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Ah okay. I'd want to ask about the weeks in my own claim, two of them have been sitting there for a while.

0 coins

been trying to get through to that line for days anyway

0 coins

My coworker had something similar happen, doctor put the wrong start date on her cert and EDD initially said the dates didn't match. She got the corrected version submitted through SDI Online and it resolved pretty quickly. Though hers wasn't at the appeal stage yet, so I'm not sure if the process is different once you're already in an appeal.

0 coins

That's helpful to know it can be corrected through SDI Online even if the original was wrong.

0 coins

Before the appeal stage the correction goes through SDI Online normally. At the appeal stage you bring it as evidence for the hearing, and your doctor can still submit the corrected version through SDI Online to get it in the system record.

0 coins

Got it, so it's not either-or, do both lol.

0 coins

I'm kind of freaking out reading this thread because I have an appeal pending too and I didn't even know you could bring new documents. Nobody told me that. My claim was for a back injury and I honestly think my provider's notes were incomplete, not necessarily wrong dates but just not enough detail.

0 coins

Incomplete documentation is different from a date error but it still matters. Ask your provider to submit a supplemental letter with more clinical detail about why you couldn't perform your regular work. Bring that to the hearing.

0 coins

So my doctor can still add information even though the denial already happened?

0 coins

For the appeal hearing, yes. The judge considers whether you were actually disabled during the period claimed, and your provider can support that with additional documentation.

0 coins

Okay that's a relief. I've been assuming the original cert was just the final word.

0 coins

my situation was a bit different but i had to get my provider to fix a wrong end date on my cert before edd processed anything, took them a few days to update it in the system but it did go through

0 coins

How did your provider submit the fix, through SDI Online directly?

0 coins

yeah they logged in on their side and updated it, i gave them the receipt number and they found the claim that way

0 coins

The receipt number thing is so important and I feel like nobody talks about it enough! When I filed my claim I almost forgot to give it to my doctor's office and that would have been a mess. For your situation with the appeal, make sure the corrected cert your doctor submits references that same receipt number so EDD can match it to your claim and to the appeal file.

0 coins

My doctor's office already has the receipt number luckily, that part was fine from the start.

0 coins

Great, that's one less thing to worry about then!

0 coins

Extensions on my own pregnancy claim got complicated because the DE 2525XX my provider submitted had an ambiguous end date, and I ended up talking to an EDD agent using Claimyr to get clarity. The agent confirmed the extension form had been received and told me the exact date it was showing as the new end date in my claim. For your appeal question, the same principle applies: a corrected certification that the agent can see in the system is better than one you're describing from memory at a hearing.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself and the agent I spoke with told me which date a specific payment had actually been issued on my claim, cleared up why I hadn't seen it yet. Really glad to have gotten a real person.

0 coins

Wait, the agent could see the specific payment date? So they can actually see when something was issued not just whether the claim is pending?

0 coins

Yes, she told me the exact date it went out. I'd been watching SDI Online and the date she gave me matched up two days later when I checked again.

0 coins

that's good to know, been staring at mine for a week trying to figure out if something actually moved

0 coins

Bring the corrected cert and a letter from the provider explaining the original error. Keep it straightforward at the hearing: what the error was, what the correct dates are, and what your condition prevented you from doing.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of clear summary I needed.

0 coins

You have good documentation if the office is admitting their mistake. Use it.

0 coins

EDD's denial notices are written in a way that's deliberately hard to parse, in my experience anyway. If you have trouble figuring out exactly which dates they're contesting, the SDI Online message center or Request Claim Update feature can sometimes get you a written answer faster than trying to reach someone by phone.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option in myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ is worth using. You pick the request type and type out your question. Responses aren't instant but they're in writing.

0 coins

Yeah I used that too. Takes a few days but at least you have a written record of what they said.

0 coins

Written record matters a lot if you're heading into a hearing.

0 coins

Sorry tangent but does anyone know if the 30 days to appeal is from the date on the notice or the date you actually got it in the mail, because those can be like a week apart and I'm cutting it close on mine anyway.

0 coins

The 30 days runs from the date printed on the notice itself, not the day you receive it. If you're close to that deadline, file first and add more explanation after.

0 coins

Okay filing today then, thanks for the quick answer.

0 coins

If you do miss the 30-day window, you can still file a late appeal and explain the reason for the delay. An administrative law judge reviews whether the reason is acceptable. File as soon as you can either way.

0 coins

The whole system makes you feel like a mistake on anyone's end is somehow your fault. It isn't. Date errors happen all the time in medical offices.

0 coins

Honestly needed to hear that. I've been blaming myself for not catching it earlier.

0 coins

You filed, your doctor filed, somebody typed wrong. That's on them to correct.

0 coins

Appeals with new documentation do get resolved in claimants' favor. It's not a rubber stamp of the original denial. Go in prepared and let the corrected certification do the work.

0 coins

Really appreciate the encouragement. Hearing is next month and I feel a lot more ready after this thread.

0 coins

Good luck, seriously. Post what happens if you feel like it.

0 coins

Bring extra copies of everything. Judges appreciate organized claimants.

0 coins

One thing worth knowing: if you've already sent the DE 1000A and want to add a note about the certification error, a plain letter attached to it works fine. Doesn't have to be a formal form.

0 coins

Good to know. I'll draft a one-pager explaining the date discrepancy and attach the corrected cert.

0 coins

Keep it short. What the error was, what the right dates are, done.

0 coins

just went through a denial last month for a different reason and the whole process is exhausting. hope yours goes smoothly with the corrected paperwork.

0 coins

Thank you. Fingers crossed the judge looks at it and sees a simple clerical fix.

0 coins

the clerical fix ones seem more straightforward than the ones where edd just disagrees with the doctor's assessment entirely

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure