Back to California Disability

Aisha Abdullah

Can I stop PFL and switch to SDI extension if my doctor says I still can't work?

So my situation is kind of complicated and I haven't been able to find a clear answer anywhere. I had a rough delivery and was on SDI for 8 weeks after my c-section. Then I transitioned to PFL for bonding and I've been on that for about 5 weeks now. The problem is my doctor just told me I'm still not fully recovered and there are ongoing complications from the delivery that are making it hard for me to do anything physical. My job is pretty demanding and she doesn't think I should go back yet. I didn't even know this was possible but someone mentioned that maybe I could stop the PFL claim and get an extension on my original SDI instead? I honestly don't understand how that would work or if it's even allowed. Would I lose the PFL weeks I already used? Can my doctor still certify the extension now even though I already switched over to PFL? I'm so confused and I don't want to mess up my payments trying to fix something that maybe can't be fixed.

Stopping PFL to go back onto an extended SDI claim is something I had to look into carefully when my own recovery took longer than expected. The way it works is that your original DI claim can be extended if your physician submits the DE 2525XX, the supplementary certificate, to show you still can't do your regular work. The question in your case is whether you've already closed out the DI claim or whether there's still room on it. EDD sends the DE 2525XX with your final payment notice, the DE 2500E, so if you got that, your doctor would need to complete it. I'd contact EDD directly to ask whether the DI claim is still open for an extension before anything else.

0 coins

I did get a DE 2500E when my SDI ended. Does that mean the DI claim is closed for good or can it still be extended?

0 coins

Getting the DE 2500E just means EDD sent the form for an extension, not that the door is closed. Your physician can still complete and submit the DE 2525XX. Whether EDD will approve the extension is their decision, but it's worth having your doctor certify the ongoing complications now.

0 coins

I'm kind of in a similar spot and I didn't even know the DE 2525XX existed. I thought once you moved to PFL that was just it, the SDI part was done forever.

0 coins

Base period question came up for me when I was figuring out my own DI claim after a complicated pregnancy. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get someone on the phone at EDD because that line had been impossible for me, like two weeks of mornings where it either rang forever or cut me off. The agent pulled up my Notice of Computation and told me exactly which quarter they used and what my weekly amount worked out to. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line if you want it: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For your situation, the agent would be the one to tell you whether the DI claim is still in a state where the DE 2525XX can go in, since that depends on what's actually showing on your claim.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Never heard of it.

0 coins

It stays on hold with EDD's disability line so you end up talking to a live agent without spending your whole morning redialing. I needed to ask about my Notice of Computation and the agent walked me through which quarter of my base period they used.

0 coins

Oh that actually makes sense. I'd want to ask about why my PFL weeks aren't showing right on the claim, that's been stressing me out.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation piece is so important and most people don't realize it doesn't mean you're approved, just that EDD figured out your potential amount. Glad you got that cleared up.

0 coins

PFL and DI are two separate claims. You can't be on both at the same time. If you stop PFL early, those weeks you didn't use may still be available to you later for bonding, but you'd want EDD to confirm that for your specific claim.

0 coins

Wait so the PFL weeks I already took are gone either way, but the ones I haven't used yet might still be there if I stop now?

0 coins

That's the general idea, yeah. EDD would know what's left on your PFL claim. But getting your doctor to certify the DI extension is the first move.

0 coins

I didn't know you could bank the remaining PFL weeks like that. I thought once you started bonding you had to just go straight through.

0 coins

Week 6 of my own postpartum SDI I remember being terrified the claim would just expire and I'd have nothing. The 52-week cap on DI is the outer limit, and most people don't get anywhere close to it, so if your original claim started say 13 weeks ago, there's runway left if your doctor certifies the need. The DE 2525XX is what makes it official.

0 coins

Mine started about 13 weeks ago total between SDI and PFL. So there would theoretically be a lot of time left on the DI side if the extension goes through?

0 coins

Theoretically yes, 52 weeks from the claim start date is the max. The agent at EDD can tell you exactly how many weeks remain on your specific DI claim.

0 coins

52 weeks is actually a lot longer than I realized! I always assumed disability was like a few months tops.

0 coins

The EDD phone line is a full time job in itself and I say that having been on the DI line for a wrist injury last year. Mornings, afternoons, didn't matter. You'd think there was one person answering for the whole state.

0 coins

Three days straight I tried that line when my claim went pending. Same result every time.

0 coins

Sounds about right.

0 coins

And somehow they expect you to handle everything on a line you can't get through.

0 coins

The part I'm confused about is whether a nurse practitioner can certify the extension or if it has to be an MD. My doctor is a nurse practitioner and I'm not sure if that matters for the DE 2525XX.

0 coins

Nurse practitioners are on EDD's list of providers who can certify a DI claim, so they can certify the extension too, as long as it's within the scope of their license.

0 coins

That's a relief. I was worried I'd have to scramble to get a physician to sign off when my regular provider is an NP.

0 coins

Good catch on that. A lot of people assume it has to be an MD and panic unnecessarily.

0 coins

wait so pfl weeks dont just disappear if you stop early? i never knew that i thought once you started bonding it was use it or lose it all at once

0 coins

EDD decides how unused PFL weeks are handled on your specific claim. Don't assume either way, ask them.

0 coins

ok yeah ill message them through sdi online then, didnt think about doing it that way

0 coins

Payment dates on my own postpartum DI claim were confusing me because two weeks showed pending longer than the others. Getting through to EDD about it took persistence but I ended up using Claimyr and spoke to an agent who told me exactly which weeks on my claim had been paid and which were still processing. The agent confirmed the dates the payments were actually issued, which helped me match them to what hit my Money Network card. If you're trying to sort out where your DI versus PFL payments fall on your own claim, that level of detail from an agent is hard to get any other way.

0 coins

Payments landing on the Money Network card without any clear dates attached drove me crazy on my own claim. I actually used Claimyr too and the agent told me my waiting period had already been served in the first week so I wasn't waiting on that, it was just the medical certification that was holding things. That cleared up a lot.

0 coins

Wait the waiting period thing, so that's the first seven days and they're just not payable? I always thought that was processing time and you'd eventually get it.

0 coins

Right, the first seven days are just not paid, full stop. It's not processing time. The agent confirmed that for my claim specifically.

0 coins

Ugh, I wish someone had told me that upfront. I kept thinking that first week's money was coming eventually.

0 coins

Switched from PFL back to a DI extension isn't something EDD makes obvious anywhere. You basically have to know to ask.

0 coins

That's exactly my problem. I had no idea this was even an option until someone mentioned it offhand and now I'm down a rabbit hole.

0 coins

Ask EDD in writing through SDI Online first, then call if you need a faster answer. Paper trail helps.

0 coins

My aunt tried to get her doctor to extend her SDI like a month after she'd already been on PFL and EDD told her the DI claim was still open. So it's definitely happened before, not just theoretical lol

0 coins

That's actually really helpful to hear it worked for someone. Did she have to do anything specific or did EDD just handle it?

0 coins

From what I know the doctor submitted the DE 2525XX and that's what triggered it. EDD reviewed it and went from there.

0 coins

That's the right process. The physician's supplementary certificate is what EDD needs to evaluate the extension, and EDD makes the call on whether it's approved.

0 coins

Two kids and my partner's claim took forever to sort out anyway. Honestly EDD needs about five different explainer pages just for the pregnancy to PFL to extension sequence because nobody has any idea what order things happen in.

0 coins

Seriously. I've read through EDD's site multiple times and I still can't figure out what applies to my specific situation.

0 coins

Their general pages don't really help when your situation is in between categories, that's the problem. Call or message them directly with your claim ID.

0 coins

The site is definitely written for the most standard case and anything unusual just falls off the edge!

0 coins

Postpartum complications are a valid basis for a DI extension. Your physician needs to certify that you're still unable to do your regular work. If she's already told you she doesn't think you should go back, she can put that in writing on the DE 2525XX.

0 coins

She's already said she'll support whatever I need documented. I just want to make sure I'm not accidentally closing out PFL in a way that hurts me before I know the DI extension will actually go through.

0 coins

Reasonable concern. Contact EDD before stopping anything. Find out what's showing on both claims first.

0 coins

This is the most useful thing in this thread honestly. Figure out what's showing on the claims before you make any moves.

0 coins

SDI Online lets you send a message through the Request Claim Update option on your claim. That's how I got a written answer about my own claim status without spending a week on the phone.

0 coins

Is that faster than calling or about the same? I've sent one before and it took a while to get a response.

0 coins

Slower than a live agent but you have something in writing. For something this complicated I'd do both.

0 coins

The written route also gives you a record if there's ever a question later about what EDD said.

0 coins

My cousin was on PFL for bonding and realized she was still having serious health problems and she just had no idea SDI could have covered that. She ended up just pushing through which was not great.

0 coins

If the condition is making her unable to work, DI is the right benefit, not PFL. It's worth knowing for next time.

0 coins

I'll pass that along, she's back now but yeah it would have made a big difference.

0 coins

DE 2525XX sat in my stack of EDD paperwork for two weeks before I realized what it was for. When my recovery ran long I had to phone EDD, spent four mornings just getting cut off, then tried Claimyr and actually ended up talking to an agent. She looked up my claim and confirmed the DE 2525XX hadn't been received yet and that my doctor's office needed to resubmit it through SDI Online.

0 coins

Claimyr sounds like a sponsored post to me honestly. What even is that, an app?

0 coins

thought the same thing at first. then i tried it after like six mornings of that line just ending the call on me. agent told me the date my last payment was actually issued, which i couldnt find anywhere in sdi online. not an ad, just the only way i got through.

0 coins

ok six mornings is about where i'd break too. might give it a shot, my extension paperwork question has been sitting there.

0 coins

EDD not receiving a resubmission of their own form is so on-brand for them.

0 coins

The claim ID is the most important thing to have ready when you contact EDD about something this layered. They can see both the DI and PFL sides from it.

0 coins

Good point, I'll pull that up before I do anything. It's in myEDD right?

0 coins

Yes, log into myEDD and open SDI Online. The claim ID is on the main claim page.

0 coins

The base period for the weekly benefit amount is a thing a lot of people overlook when they're thinking about an extension. The extension runs on the same claim, so the amount won't change from what your Notice of Computation already showed.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. I was worried an extension would recalculate everything and I'd get a lower amount.

0 coins

Same claim, same Notice of Computation. The amount is already locked in from when you filed.

0 coins

This is one of those things that seems obvious after you know it but definitely isn't when you're first figuring it out.

0 coins

four weeks into my own pfl and already dreading the end of it. reading this thread because i didn't know extensions were even a thing if you're still unwell.

0 coins

If your physician can certify that you're still unable to do your regular work when PFL ends, the DI extension is worth asking EDD about. The DE 2525XX is the form involved.

0 coins

ok i'll flag that for my doctor at my next appointment. didn't even know to bring it up before.

0 coins

EDD's answer to 'can I switch back to SDI from PFL' probably isn't written anywhere useful, so you just have to ask them directly and hope whoever answers knows.

0 coins

Pretty much. The answer depends on what's on your specific claim anyway.

0 coins

Which is why a live agent is worth the trouble of getting to.

0 coins

Has anyone actually had EDD approve a DI extension after they were already on PFL? I'm curious if this is common or more of a rare situation!

0 coins

Happened with my aunt, mentioned it earlier up there. Doctor submitted the DE 2525XX and EDD reviewed it.

0 coins

It's not unheard of, especially with postpartum complications that weren't resolved when the initial DI claim ended. EDD decides each one based on the medical certification.

0 coins

That's good to know! I always assumed once you were on PFL the DI chapter was just fully closed.

0 coins

Thank you all so much. My plan is to message EDD through SDI Online first thing tomorrow and ask what's showing on both my DI and PFL claims before I do anything. My doctor is already on board to certify, so I'll ask her office to hold off on submitting the DE 2525XX until I know the DI claim is still open for an extension. Really didn't know any of this was possible two days ago.

0 coins

That's the right order. Confirm with EDD first, then have your physician submit. You've got the right idea.

0 coins

Figuring out the right questions to ask is half the battle with EDD and you've done that. Hope the extension goes through smoothly.

0 coins

Let EDD confirm the status before anything moves. Good approach.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure