Can I get unemployment after SDI if employer treated FMLA leave as resignation
So I'm in a really stressful situation and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I went out on SDI back in the spring for a back injury, my doctor certified everything and I had been getting payments. My employer has this policy where if you're out more than a certain number of weeks they basically classify your leave as a voluntary resignation. I didn't sign anything saying I was resigning, I just couldn't come back yet because I was still under my doctor's care. Now my SDI is wrapping up and I went to look into what comes next and found out my employer already marked me as terminated for abandoning my position. I genuinely don't know if I can even file for unemployment once I'm cleared to work again, because the separation reason says resignation. Has anyone dealt with this where the employer treated FMLA leave as resignation while you were still on SDI? I feel like I should be able to get unemployment after SDI ends since I didn't actually quit, but I'm not sure how EDD looks at it. Do I just file and let EDD decide, or is there something I should do first?
88 comments

Anna Stewart
Filing for unemployment once your doctor clears you is the right move. EDD makes its own determination on the separation reason, and 'voluntary quit' versus 'involuntary termination' is exactly the kind of thing they investigate. Your employer's characterization is a starting point, not the final word. When you file, describe the situation accurately in your own words, that you were on approved disability leave and did not submit a resignation.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI didn't even realize EDD investigates the separation reason independently. I assumed if the employer said resignation that was just what EDD would accept.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
EDD does look at both sides. They send a questionnaire to the employer too, so make everything you say consistent and factual.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorGood to know they contact the employer as well. I need to put together what I have in writing before I file.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
File. You can't receive unemployment and disability for the same days, but once disability ends and you're able and available to work, unemployment is a separate question entirely. The separation facts are what matter.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
I think I had this backwards, I assumed SDI ending automatically opened unemployment. But the separation reason could block it, right?
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Separation reason is what EDD weighs. File and answer every question accurately.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
Makes sense. File first, let them sort it.
0 coins
Lara Woods
DE 2593 showed up in my SDI Online portal around week ten of my own injury claim and I almost missed it. Had a 20-day window to return it or benefits stop. I'd been trying to get through to EDD's disability line for three separate mornings and hit a recording that dropped every time. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live agent on the line. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed they had received my form and told me which weeks were still pending on my account.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Sounds like a service that gets paid to put their number in front of yours in a queue. I've seen things like that before and wondered if EDD even recognizes the contact.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
I had the exact same doubt about it, honestly. Then I tried it because I'd been at that same line for eight mornings straight and kept getting the recording. The agent I reached was EDD's own person. She pulled up my claim and told me my DE 2525XX extension had been received and was processing. That was the confirmation I needed.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
Okay, that's actually useful. The employment situation here is messier than a straight disability extension, but I want to verify my final weeks before anything else. Might give it a shot.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
The 20-day return window on the DE 2593 is spelled out in the SDI materials. Easy form to miss if you're not watching the portal.
0 coins
Eli Butler
The employer calling a leave a resignation when no one actually resigned is unfortunately not rare. Document everything you have, the date your leave started, any written communications from HR, your doctor's certification period. When unemployment asks why you stopped working, 'employer treated medical leave as resignation without my consent' is a straight factual statement.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI do have emails from HR referencing the leave policy. I didn't save everything but I can pull the email chain. That should help, right?
0 coins
Eli Butler
Keep every piece of it. Policy documents, the HR emails, anything timestamped. EDD's going to want specifics.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
HR email chains are gold in these situations. Screenshot them somewhere safe, anyway.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Unemployment requires being able and available to work every week you claim it. So the sequencing matters: SDI while you can't work, then once your doctor releases you, that's when unemployment begins. The two programs can't cover the same days.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
I had been thinking about filing unemployment while still technically on SDI to cover the gap, glad I read this before doing something wrong.
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Don't overlap them. File unemployment the week after your last SDI period.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorThe gap between SDI ending and being cleared was what worried me. So I just wait until I'm actually released and then file?
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Correct. Your doctor's release date is your start point for unemployment eligibility.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
The FMLA angle and what it means for your job protection is a question for your employer's HR or the Civil Rights Department's CFRA page, not EDD. EDD only decides whether the separation counts as a quit or a discharge and whether you're eligible for benefits under their rules. Those are two different tracks and you may want to look at both.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI didn't realize the job protection question went somewhere other than EDD. So EDD handles the benefits piece and the CFRA question is handled separately?
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Exactly. EDD rules on your unemployment eligibility. The leave protection question is under CFRA and that's outside EDD's scope entirely.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Well put. Keeping those two tracks separate will save a lot of confusion when you're filing and describing the separation.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Don't overthink the form. Under reason for leaving, say medical leave, employer marked it as resignation, you did not quit. Plain and simple. EDD's heard this before.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorPlain language like that feels right. I was trying to draft something complicated and probably making it sound worse.
0 coins
Sofia Price
Short and factual beats long and complicated every time with these forms.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
my employer pulled something similar, had a 90 day leave max written in a handbook nobody showed me when i got hired. edd still let me file when my sdi ended, they sent a questionnaire about the separation and asked for dates. just be really specific with your dates
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorDates are something I have. I know exactly when I went out, when I stopped getting communications from HR, when the resignation notation appeared.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
write all that down before you file so its easy to put in the form
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Dates matter a lot in those questionnaires. The clearer your timeline the easier it is for EDD to follow.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Appeals exist for a reason. If EDD comes back with a denial, you've got 30 days from the date on the notice to file your appeal. The appeal form DE 1000A comes with the denial notice. Use it.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
I keep reading about the 30 day window and it makes me nervous. What if mail gets delayed and I see it late?
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
File as soon as you get it. Don't sit on it. If you're past 30 days you can still explain why, but tight is better.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
The 30-day clock runs from the date printed on the notice, not the day you receive it, so opening mail quickly matters.
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
Notice of Determination came through on my injury claim after I'd already gone back to work part time, and I genuinely could not tell if EDD had processed the right weeks. Tried the disability line twice with no luck. Went through Claimyr and an agent pulled up my claim right there, confirmed which weeks had been paid and what the determination covered.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Did the agent say anything about whether going back part time affected the determination itself?
0 coins
Lilah Brooks
She told me the weeks I reported partial wages on were processed differently but that was between me and EDD's calculation. She wasn't going to give me a number right there.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
I've been hitting that line every day for two weeks and nothing, good to know there's another way, anyway.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Honestly the scariest part of my SDI claim was not knowing if anything was going through. HR at my job was not exactly helpful either. I ended up filing the unemployment claim the week my SDI ended and listed the reason honestly. EDD sent me a letter asking for more detail and I wrote out the timeline.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorDid EDD come back pretty quickly once you gave them the timeline in writing?
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Took a couple weeks but yeah they did. Keep copies of everything you send them.
0 coins
Oliver Alexander
Two weeks isn't bad compared to some of the waits I've heard about.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
There's a note on EDD's site worth finding: you cannot receive unemployment and disability benefits for the same days. The transition has to be clean, SDI ends, you're medically released, then you file for unemployment. If there's overlap in dates EDD will catch it.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorMy SDI end date and my doctor's release date should line up closely, but I need to double-check. What if the SDI end date is a few days before the doctor formally clears me?
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
File unemployment starting with the week you're actually cleared and available. The dates on the medical release are what EDD looks at.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Keeping those two dates aligned and documented protects you from an overpayment notice down the road.
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
went through almost the same thing last year. edd asked about the separation, i told them what happened, they paid me. wasnt fast but it worked.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorHearing that it worked for someone else helps. How long did the whole separation investigation take roughly?
0 coins
Evelyn Rivera
few weeks i think, maybe three. they mailed a letter asking for more detail once.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Pay stubs showing the SDI deduction on your CASDI line also confirm you were paying into the system the whole time you were employed. Keeps that detail clear when you get to the unemployment filing.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI do have pay stubs saved going back a couple of years. Good reminder to pull those out.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Any quarter you're in a wage dispute, those stubs are your ground truth.
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Worth mentioning: the base period for SDI and the base period for unemployment are calculated differently. Have your wage history ready and let EDD run the numbers.
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Receipt number on my SDI claim was something I'd basically forgotten about by the time my doctor's office called needing it. Panicked a little looking through emails. Used Claimyr to reach EDD's disability line and the agent read me back the number tied to my account so my provider could match the certification properly.
0 coins
Molly Chambers
Payment dates on my own claim are what I need verified. Going to use Claimyr for that. What should I have in front of me before I call through it?
0 coins
Kolton Murphy
Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and the specific dates or form numbers you're asking about. The agent pulled things up fast once I had all of that ready.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorUseful even for me to know, I may need to call EDD before my SDI ends to get the final week situation clear.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Having everything pulled up before the call makes such a difference, any call with any agency really.
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
The voluntary quit versus discharge distinction is one EDD takes seriously. 'Treated FMLA leave as resignation' reads to EDD as a constructive discharge situation, not a voluntary quit. File, and in your own explanation use the word 'discharged' or 'terminated involuntarily' rather than any language that sounds like you chose to leave.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI had been writing my description in a way that said 'my employer ended my employment,' which feels accurate but maybe not strong enough?
0 coins
Adrian Hughes
My employer ended my employment while I was on approved medical leave and I did not' resign is factual and clear. That languageworks.
0 coins
Eli Butler
EDD's questionnaire is not the place for hedging. Say what happened directly.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
My cousin went through something with leave and EDD and ended up getting both the unemployment and filing for CFRA separately. Can you do both at the same time?
0 coins
Mateo Warren
Those are entirely separate processes. Unemployment is filed with EDD and covers lost wages. CFRA is a job protection question handled outside EDD. Filing one doesn't prevent filing the other but they go to different places.
0 coins
Jackson Carter
Got it, didn't realize they were completely different tracks.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Keeping them separate in your head from the start saves a lot of confusion later on.
0 coins
Owen Jenkins
Payment date on my injury claim went two weeks longer than the Notice of Computation said it should, and I didn't know if EDD had extended it or if something was stuck. Tried phoning four mornings in a row and each time the recording ended the call before I got anywhere. Went through Claimyr and the agent told me the last payment had been issued on a specific date and that the claim had closed on that date.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Payment dates on mine look off too, and I've used Claimyr on a different step of my own claim. Once the agent confirmed the payment method on file was current, I stopped worrying about where the money was going. Had to follow up with SDI Online to verify the deposit landed.
0 coins
Sofia Price
EDD's disability line is brutal most mornings. Four days sounds about right for how long it takes to give up.
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Two weeks of mornings for me before I found another way. The line just ends the call without anyone picking up.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
does the waiting period count toward unemployment too or is that just sdi
0 coins
Lydia Bailey
Waiting period is specific to SDI. The first seven days of a disability claim are unpaid, that's EDD's rule. Unemployment has different eligibility criteria altogether.
0 coins
Alice Coleman
ok so its not like a universal thing across all edd programs, got it
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
Correct, and it's worth knowing the waiting period is not processing time either. EDD says it plainly: those first seven days are just not payable, no matter how fast the claim is processed.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Pulling together the timeline your employer created, the HR emails, your SDI claim dates, and your doctor's release date before you file unemployment will make the whole process a lot smoother. EDD's questionnaire moves faster when every date you give them checks out against documents.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI've started a document with every date I can find. Feels better having it all in one place.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
That's the move. Add the SDI claim ID and the period your claim covered while you're at it.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Just want to flag that if your employer has short-term disability or a voluntary plan through work that's separate from EDD's SDI, anyway, that's a whole other layer. Hopefully not your situation but worth confirming which plan your payments came from.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorMine came through EDD's SDI, I can see it in SDI Online and I have the EDD correspondence. Not a private plan.
0 coins
Marcus Patterson
Good, that keeps it cleaner. Some people find out mid-process that their plan was employer-run and the EDD rules don't directly apply, anyway.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Verifying the source of your disability payments before filing unemployment is smart. Sounds like you're already clear on that.
0 coins
Lara Woods
One thing that tripped me up early was thinking the Notice of Computation meant I was approved. It doesn't. It just shows what your potential weekly amount could be. Approval is a separate determination.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
AuthorI made that exact mistake. I thought receiving the Notice of Computation meant everything was settled.
0 coins
Ian Armstrong
The notice even says 'potential' benefit amount right on it. Easy to miss when you're stressed and just looking for good news.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
A lot of people read it as an approval letter. EDD's actual determination comes separately, by a different notice.
0 coins