Back to California Disability

Makayla Shoemaker

Can I get SDI if I was paid as 1099 contractor in California?

So I've been doing delivery work as a 1099 contractor for about two years now, no W-2, no employer withholding anything. Threw my back out last month and my doctor says I'm looking at six to eight weeks before I can even think about getting back in the car. Bills don't stop though. Someone at urgent care mentioned SDI and I figured I'd look into it but the more I read the more confused I get. The whole thing seems built for people with regular jobs where someone takes taxes out of their check. My 1099s never had any CASDI deduction on them. Does that just mean I'm out of luck or is there some other way to file? Anyone dealt with this?

The key question to bring to EDD is whether CASDI was ever withheld from your earnings, because that deduction is what funds SDI eligibility. If your 1099 work was truly independent contracting with no SDI withheld, you likely were not covered. Some workers classified as 1099 were actually misclassified and should have had CASDI taken out, though. That is a separate conversation with EDD or potentially a wage claim.

0 coins

So basically I'd need to show CASDI was deducted somewhere on my pay? None of my 1099s show that at all.

0 coins

Exactly. Without that deduction in your base period, there are no SDI-covered wages to draw from. Your paystubs or 1099s would show nothing because nothing was withheld.

0 coins

EDD's own language on this is worth reading directly on edd.ca.gov. It says SDI is paid for by workers through the CASDI deduction. No deduction, no covered wages, which is what the person above is explaining.

0 coins

Patients ask me about this all the time. If you've only had 1099 income with no CASDI withheld, SDI won't cover it. Worth double-checking your paperwork from every company you contracted with though, just to be sure.

0 coins

Checked everything going back two years. Nothing shows CASDI anywhere.

0 coins

Then you have your answer. Unfortunate but that's how it works.

0 coins

Is there absolutely no path? Like no self-employed SDI option in California at all?

0 coins

DE 2593 came in the mail for me right around week ten, and I nearly missed the 20-day window to send it back because I didn't realize it would stop my payments if I didn't return it fast. Got it handled but only because I'd already talked to an agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) a few days before it arrived, so I knew to watch for it. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed my claim was on automatic payment and told me the DE 2593 was coming, which is the only reason I caught it in time.

0 coins

Wait, you actually got a live person at EDD?! I have a question about my base period quarters and whether my wages even count. Would Claimyr work for that too? What should I have ready?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, your claim ID from SDI Online, and a clear one-line version of your question ready before they pick up. The agent can pull your claim and check the base period details right there.

0 coins

Perfect, thank you! I've been trying that line every morning for a week and getting the same recording every time. Going to give this a try today.

0 coins

To answer the question someone asked above about a self-employed option: California does have an elective coverage program for self-employed people, but you have to sign up for it voluntarily and pay into it yourself. You can't just file a claim after the fact. If you didn't elect coverage before you got hurt, it won't help you now.

0 coins

That's what I was afraid of. I never knew that existed until now.

0 coins

Yeah nobody tells you about it. It's on EDD's site but buried.

0 coins

Sounds like something you have to know to look for before you need it, which is the whole problem.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something. Someone mentioned the base period and quarters. How does that even work for figuring out if you qualify? Like what time frame does EDD look at?

0 coins

EDD looks at a 12-month base period made up of four quarters, and they use the highest-paid quarter to estimate your weekly amount. You need at least $300 in SDI-covered wages in that window. The calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough estimate once you know your numbers.

0 coins

So it has to be wages where CASDI was actually taken out, not just any income I earned?

0 coins

Correct. The wages have to have had CASDI deducted. 1099 income with no withholding doesn't count toward that requirement.

0 coins

The SDI benefit estimate calculator on edd.ca.gov is worth using if you have any W-2 income mixed in. It will show you what a partial work history might produce.

0 coins

Misclassification is real and worth looking into if you think the company treated you like an employee but paid you as a contractor. That's a whole separate fight but some guys I know have won those.

0 coins

Honestly that crossed my mind. The company controlled my hours, my route, everything. Just never gave me a W-2.

0 coins

That's the kind of situation where it's worth asking about. EDD handles some of that, the Labor Commissioner handles some. Not a quick fix but it's not nothing.

0 coins

Labor board or EDD can look at it. No guarantees but if the company controlled everything they may owe you that CASDI coverage.

0 coins

this is a nightmare tbh, all these years driving and nothing to fall back on when you get hurt, the whole 1099 thing is such a trap

0 coins

Exactly how I feel right now.

0 coins

hope you find something man, its messed up

0 coins

To the question about whether any W-2 work would help: if you had any regular job in the past 18 months or so where CASDI was taken out, those wages might still be in your base period window. Worth checking before you assume you're completely out of options.

0 coins

I had a few shifts at a warehouse job in early 2025, like six or seven weeks. Would that even be enough?

0 coins

Possibly! You'd need at least $300 in SDI-covered wages from that period. Run your numbers through EDD's calculator. Even a small amount might get you something.

0 coins

The base period is typically 5 to 18 months before your claim start date, highest quarter counting most. Actual dates matter a lot here, so run the specific numbers before you assume.

0 coins

My coworker switched from 1099 to W-2 last year specifically because of stuff like this. The gig companies really don't tell you what you're giving up when you sign as a contractor lol.

0 coins

Nobody told me any of this when I started. I just needed work.

0 coins

Same story for a lot of people. Hopefully those warehouse weeks help you out.

0 coins

Got a Notice of Determination in the mail after my claim was filed, said there was an issue with my eligibility. I'd been out four weeks already and was panicking. Used Claimyr to get through to someone at EDD and the agent told me my employer hadn't been reporting wages correctly, which is why the determination came out the way it did. That sent me in the right direction to get it fixed.

0 coins

The notice I got mentioned a date discrepancy on my end, so I know how stressful that is. Used Claimyr for my own claim too, specifically when I needed to confirm my DE 2525XX extension had been received. The agent told me it was in the system and gave me the date it was logged. That was such a relief, so I went ahead and filed the appeal form for the earlier notice since I finally had the full picture.

0 coins

been trying that line for days, what did that actually take to get someone on

0 coins

Tried the line most of a week without reaching anyone. The extension being in limbo was really stressful, so once I confirmed it I could actually focus on the appeal.

0 coins

Not sure if this is the right place to ask but I'm kind of in a related situation. I do freelance graphic design, all 1099, and I'm scheduled for a procedure in a few months. I've been thinking about whether I should try to get a part-time W-2 job before then just to have CASDI coverage. Is that something that would even work?

0 coins

Whether those wages would fall in the right base period window depends on when you start and when your disability begins. The timing has to work out so the W-2 wages are in the 5 to 18 month lookback. It's worth running through EDD's calculator with real dates.

0 coins

So I'd need to start working it soon enough that the wages actually show up in that window. That makes sense I think.

0 coins

Look at the base period details on EDD's site and plug in your likely claim start date. The calculator will tell you which quarters it would look at, and you can see whether a few months of W-2 work would land there.

0 coins

Six weeks out with a bad back and no income is rough. Hope those warehouse wages are enough to get you something. Even a partial claim is better than zero.

0 coins

Yeah I'm going to run the numbers today. Fingers crossed.

0 coins

Went and tried to file just to see what EDD's calculator would say and it looks like I might actually have a small base period from a part-time job I forgot about. Filed the claim this morning.

0 coins

Good move. The worst they can do is deny it, and then you'd get a Notice of Determination with appeal rights.

0 coins

That's what I figured. At least then I know for sure.

0 coins

Does the waiting period apply even if you only qualify for a small benefit amount?

0 coins

Yes, the first seven days of a new claim are always the unpaid waiting period, no matter the benefit amount. That's just the first week before anything can be paid.

0 coins

Got it, so day eight is when it could start.

0 coins

Right, day one through seven are the waiting period, payment eligibility starts on day eight.

0 coins

The EDD phone line is a joke. Tried for three mornings straight last month, two of those times it just disconnected me after playing a message. Third time I sat on hold 40 minutes and then got cut off again.

0 coins

That's the standard experience. Hours of your life gone.

0 coins

EDD's line hasn't changed in years. Everyone's been through that.

0 coins

This is what I'm dreading if I do get a claim going and need to ask anything.

0 coins

Receipt number question for anyone who knows: if my doctor submits the medical certification, does she need the receipt number I got when I filed, or does she look up the claim another way?

0 coins

The form receipt number is what your provider uses to find your claim in SDI Online. Give it to your doctor's office when you hand them your paperwork.

0 coins

She kept asking me for a claim number and I wasn't sure if that was the same thing.

0 coins

Same thing in practice. When you filed on SDI Online it gave you that number. That's what she needs.

0 coins

Went through several mornings of trying that EDD line and never got anyone. Receipt number on my claim was showing something unexpected in SDI Online so I needed to confirm it was matched to the right claim. Used Claimyr and got through to an agent who checked my claim and confirmed the receipt number was matched correctly, which was a relief because I'd been worried my doctor submitted it without the right number.

0 coins

I'm a little skeptical about this, I tried that disability line maybe eight or nine times over two weeks and never got past the first menu. How is that even possible through some third-party thing?

0 coins

Honestly I had the same thought. But the person I ended up talking to knew my claim details, confirmed the receipt number status, and was clearly an EDD employee. I didn't expect it to work either.

0 coins

Had a similar reaction when I first tried it. After my Notice of Determination issue I eventually got through to an agent who confirmed the wage reporting problem, and that person was definitely EDD. Went back and checked my SDI Online message log and the information matched what the agent said.

0 coins

Okay that's more convincing than I expected. I want to ask about whether my claim's start date was recorded correctly. Might actually try it.

0 coins

Anyone know if you can file a disability claim while also filing for unemployment? My buddy said he was doing both at the same time.

0 coins

You can't collect both for the same days. EDD is pretty clear that you can only be paid by one of them at a time. Unemployment also requires you to be able and available to work, which you can't be if you're out on disability. If your buddy is collecting both for the same period he may be looking at an overpayment situation.

0 coins

Figured as much. I'll tell him to sort that out.

0 coins

That overpayment notice comes later when people least expect it. Better to get ahead of it.

0 coins

So if someone gets denied, what actually happens next? Do you just lose or is there a way to fight it?

0 coins

You'd get a Notice of Determination with an Appeal Form. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal. Send it back with a detailed explanation of why you disagree. If you miss that window you can still appeal but you'd need to explain why it was late.

0 coins

So 30 days from the date on the letter, not from when you receive it?

0 coins

From the date the notice was issued, yes. So open anything from EDD right away.

0 coins

The appeal form is the DE 1000A. It's included with the determination notice. If you can't find it, a detailed letter sent to the return address on the notice works too, according to EDD.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim showed differently in SDI Online than I expected, so I needed to know which week had actually been issued. Phoned EDD using Claimyr and the agent confirmed the exact payment date and which weeks were covered, which let me reconcile it against what had posted to my account.

0 coins

What is Claimyr? I keep seeing that name here.

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD's disability line so you don't have to, and when an agent picks up your phone rings. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Interesting. My claim has had a pending payment for about two weeks and I haven't gotten any notice about it yet. That might be worth trying for me.

0 coins

so if someone has like half the year on 1099 and half on w2 they might still qualify? asking for someone

0 coins

Whether the W-2 portion hits the base period window and clears the $300 minimum is what matters. Date of disability start, which quarters fall in the lookback, that's the math. EDD's calculator is the right place to run it.

0 coins

ok ill pass that along

0 coins

Tell them to also make sure CASDI was actually withheld on the W-2 portion. A paystub showing that deduction is what confirms it.

0 coins

been dealing with this exact thing. hurt my wrist, had a mix of w2 and 1099 for two years. filed anyway and got a notice of computation so something in my base period worked out

0 coins

That's actually really encouraging. How much W-2 work did you have in the mix?

0 coins

maybe 14 15 weeks total at a coffee shop. enough i guess

0 coins

Okay that's making me feel better about those warehouse weeks.

0 coins

Worth asking EDD directly through the Ask EDD form on their site if you have specific questions about your base period. I got a written answer back within a week and it had my actual claim dates in it.

0 coins

I didn't know you could get claim-specific answers through Ask EDD. That might be faster than the phone.

0 coins

It was for me. Took a few days but the answer was specific to my situation, not just a generic FAQ copy-paste.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure