Back to California Disability

Giovanni Rossi

California EDD claim benefit year ends remaining weeks after returning to work and reapplying

Okay so I need some help figuring this out because I'm getting confused looking at SDI Online. I went out on disability back in the spring for a back issue, got approved, collected for about 14 weeks, then my doctor cleared me and I went back to work in July. Great, right? Except now I'm out again, different issue this time, and I filed a new claim. But when I look at my account it's referencing the same benefit year as my first claim and showing remaining weeks. I genuinely don't understand if EDD is going to pick up where I left off on that old claim or if this is treated as something completely new. And how does the waiting period work when you're coming back for a second claim in the same year? Do I sit through another seven days with no pay? Anyone dealt with this kind of situation?

Returning partway through a benefit year and then needing disability again is more common than people think, especially after surgeries with long recoveries. Each separate period of disability is its own claim, but if the new disability starts within the same benefit year, EDD links it back to that original claim. The remaining weeks you're seeing are what you have left from that 52-week maximum. And yes, the seven-day waiting period applies again for the new period of disability, it is not a one-time thing per year.

0 coins

Wait, so the waiting period hits me again even though I already sat through it in the spring? I had no idea it worked that way.

0 coins

Every new period of disability has its own seven-day wait before the first payable day. It is not a processing delay, just the first seven days being non-payable by rule.

0 coins

I think I assumed the waiting period was just how long EDD takes to process things. So it actually means those days just never get paid no matter what?

0 coins

Exactly right. Those seven days are never paid. The eighth day is when benefits can start.

0 coins

52 weeks total, one benefit year. Whatever you used on the first stretch counts against that. The remaining number on your screen is what's left.

0 coins

So if I used 14 weeks before, I'd have 38 left at most?

0 coins

That's the math, yes. Assuming you qualified for the full amount on that claim.

0 coins

Does the benefit year reset at some point though? Like if I had to go out again next year would I get a fresh 52 weeks?

0 coins

A new claim filed after the benefit year closes would start a new benefit year with its own base period and its own 52-week maximum.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in the mail about two weeks after I filed my second claim and it denied the new period, said the medical certification didn't match the new disability start date I'd listed. I had no idea what to do with that. Ended up reaching EDD through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after the phone line cut me off three mornings in a row. Video on getting a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed the Notice of Determination had been issued and explained I had 30 days from the date on the notice to file an appeal using the DE 1000A. I appealed the same week.

0 coins

Three mornings in a row trying that line and getting nowhere, I completely understand the frustration. Though I have to be honest, I've seen services like that advertised before and I wasn't sure what to make of it. Did you actually reach an EDD employee, not just a third-party rep?

0 coins

The person I spoke with was an EDD agent, they had my claim pulled up and read me exactly what the notice said and what my appeal window was. It wasn't a sales rep or anything like that.

0 coins

Claim start date on mine was listed wrong too and I was told the same thing about the DE 1000A. Had to gather everything and mail it to the return address on the notice before the 30 days were up.

0 coins

That's helpful to hear. The 30-day window on those notices is easy to miss if the letter sits in a pile.

0 coins

If I lost the DE 1000A form is there another way to appeal?

0 coins

A detailed letter mailed to the return address on the notice works if you don't have the form, but include all your claim details and explain clearly why you disagree.

0 coins

The phone line for EDD disability is a joke. Called eight times across two days trying to ask one simple question about whether my new medical certification had been matched to the right claim ID. Hung up on every single time before I even got a human. The 1-800-480-3287 number just loops you into oblivion.

0 coins

Same problem here. I gave up after day three and just sent a message through SDI Online instead.

0 coins

How long did that take to get a response?

0 coins

About a week and a half. Not fast but it did get answered eventually.

0 coins

The Request Claim Update option in SDI Online actually worked for me too! You pick the claim, choose the request type, write your question. Got a reply in around 10 days!

0 coins

When you go back out and file again, make sure you give your doctor the receipt number from the new claim. That's the number they need to submit the medical certification in SDI Online. I learned that the hard way first time around, my surgeon's office used the wrong number and the whole thing got held up.

0 coins

My doctor's office actually asked me for that number right away this time, so at least they're on it.

0 coins

Good. As long as they've got the right one you should be in decent shape.

0 coins

Is the receipt number in SDI Online after you file? I want to make sure I write it down before closing the browser.

0 coins

Yes, it comes up right after you submit your part of the claim. Write it down or screenshot it and send it to the medical office the same day.

0 coins

The base period thing confused me for a long time. When I filed my second claim in the same benefit year, I expected EDD to look at my more recent wages since I'd gone back to work in between. But the base period for a claim that falls in the same benefit year is already set from when the original claim was filed. Your weekly benefit amount on the second period should match what was on your Notice of Computation from the first one.

0 coins

I actually assumed EDD would recalculate using my newer paychecks. Good to know it doesn't work that way.

0 coins

Right, that's what I had wrong too. The Notice of Computation from the first claim is still what governs it.

0 coins

wait so the weekly amount stays the same even if you made more money when you went back to work between claims

0 coins

For a second period within the same benefit year, yes, that's how it works. EDD already set the base period and the benefit amount when you filed the original claim.

0 coins

Fourteen weeks out and then back is a solid return honestly. When I tried to go back too early I ended up needing another three weeks almost immediately and EDD flagged my claim for review which was a whole thing. Anyway, the remaining weeks question is the right one to focus on, make sure you check your Notice of Computation for the max benefit amount so you know exactly what you're working with.

0 coins

That's a good reminder, I haven't pulled that notice up since the spring.

0 coins

Worth finding it because all the numbers are on there. And if you can't find the paper copy it should be in your SDI Online documents.

0 coins

Receipt number on my second claim wasn't matching anything in SDI Online and I sat pending for almost three weeks. Ended up getting through to an EDD agent using Claimyr after I'd spent four mornings trying the disability line. The agent found that my doctor's office had entered a digit wrong in the receipt number when they filed the certification. Once EDD corrected the match the pending status cleared within a few days. The base period start date on that claim was set from my original filing date in January.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? Haven't heard of it.

0 coins

You give EDD's disability line a try while Claimyr stays on it on your behalf, and your phone rings when an actual EDD agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Alright. I've got a question about which weeks on my claim were actually paid versus which ones are still showing pending. That's what I'd use it for.

0 coins

a wrong digit held up your whole claim for three weeks? that seems like it shouldnt be that hard to catch

0 coins

You'd think, but the certification just sat unmatched and EDD doesn't flag it in a way that tells you what went wrong. The agent was the one who spotted the mismatch.

0 coins

Okay can I ask a kind of dumb question here? When you file the second claim, is it completely separate in SDI Online, like a new claim ID, or does it attach to the original somehow? I'm trying to understand what I'd even be looking at in my account.

0 coins

It appears as a new claim with its own ID in SDI Online, but EDD ties it to the same benefit year internally. You'll see both listed if you look at your claim history.

0 coins

That makes sense, thank you. I was afraid I'd done something wrong because I saw two different claim numbers.

0 coins

Two claim numbers for two separate periods is normal. You didn't mess anything up.

0 coins

My second claim in the same year was for something different than the first. EDD still processed it the same way, weekly amount was the same as my original Notice of Computation showed. No surprises there.

0 coins

That's reassuring to hear, it sounds like the process is at least consistent even if the reason you're out is different.

0 coins

Yeah it went through fine. Just had to wait through the seven days again which is annoying but that's how it is.

0 coins

The part that's stressing me out is I don't know exactly how many weeks I used before. My first claim wasn't neat, there were some weeks where I went back part time and reported it. Does that count as full weeks toward the 52?

0 coins

Partial weeks are handled differently. EDD calculates what it paid for each week based on what you earned and what you reported. Your Notice of Computation and your payment history in SDI Online would show the breakdown of how much was paid out total.

0 coins

So I'd need to go through each week in my payment history to add it up? Is there an easier way to see it?

0 coins

The payment history in SDI Online lists each week. If you can't work it out from there, a Request Claim Update through SDI Online would let you ask EDD directly.

0 coins

Sending the Request Claim Update message worked well for me when I had a question about a specific form EDD was waiting on. Response time was around a week to ten days.

0 coins

People keep saying to call EDD like it's just a thing you can do. The line doesn't work. Send the message through SDI Online and move on with your life.

0 coins

Hard agree. I've never once gotten through on a first attempt. SDI Online messaging is at least predictable.

0 coins

Exactly. At least with the message you know something is being looked at eventually.

0 coins

My cousin got confused and thought returning to work meant her whole claim closed and she'd have to start over from scratch! Turned out she still had remaining weeks available and could come back on it when she needed to. She was so relieved!

0 coins

That's exactly what I was afraid of honestly. Glad to hear it doesn't work that way.

0 coins

The remaining weeks stay there! She just had to file and go through the medical certification again for the new period.

0 coins

Good to know it doesn't just disappear when you go back to work.

0 coins

my situation is a little different. i went back for like 6 weeks and then had to stop again but i hadnt technically been cleared by my doctor, i just felt okay enough to try. now im not sure if my new period starts from when i stopped working the second time or from my original disability date

0 coins

The disability start date for the new period is determined by when your doctor certifies that you were unable to work. EDD goes by the medical certification, not just when you stopped working. Your provider's office would need to certify the correct start date for the new period.

0 coins

ok so i need to make sure my doctor puts the right date on the certification, not just todays date

0 coins

Exactly. The start date your provider certifies needs to match when you actually became unable to work again, within what your license holder can certify.

0 coins

The seven-day wait was the thing I had wrong when I filed my second time around. I genuinely thought since I'd already done it once in the same year I wouldn't have to again. Finding out it applies every time was not fun news but at least I knew going in.

0 coins

Ugh, that's what I was hoping wasn't true. So my first week is definitely gone.

0 coins

Afraid so. First seven days of each new period, no payment. But day eight it kicks in.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me, expected to be paid from day one and then had to scramble to cover that first week. Anyway, at least it's only seven days not two weeks or something.

0 coins

Payment dates on my second claim were off and I couldn't figure out if EDD had issued anything or if it was still processing. Used Claimyr to reach the disability line after trying most mornings for a week. The agent told me the payment for weeks three and four of my new period had been issued on the 14th, so it was already on its way to my Money Network card. Didn't have to wonder anymore.

0 coins

Also wanted to add since we were on the call anyway, the medical certification for my second claim was confirmed received and matched correctly. The agent read me the date it came in from my doctor's office.

0 coins

ok wait they could see when the certification actually came in? i need to know that for mine

0 coins

They pulled up the date it was received on their end, yes. I'd had no way of confirming that through SDI Online on my own.

0 coins

that answers a lot. been staring at pending for days not knowing if my doctor even submitted it

0 coins

Two separate disability periods in one year, two sets of paperwork, two rounds of medical certification. It's a lot to manage especially when you're not feeling great to begin with. Hang in there anyway.

0 coins

Yeah it's definitely more paperwork than I expected. At least this thread has helped me understand what I'm actually looking at.

0 coins

The SDI Online message system is worth using if you have a specific question about your claim, slower than a phone call but at least it gets answered.

0 coins

The 52-week limit runs from the start of the benefit year, not from when you personally filed. So if someone files in May the benefit year started then, and any second period of disability in that same year draws down what's left on that same 52-week clock.

0 coins

I had it backwards, I thought the 52 weeks was just 52 weeks from whenever I might need to go back out. So it's actually tied to when the original claim started.

0 coins

Right. The benefit year clock starts when the original disability began, not when you returned to work or when you re-filed.

0 coins

This is probably the most important thing in this whole thread for anyone coming back after a gap. The weeks remaining are what's left in the original benefit year.

0 coins

Before my second period I actually wondered if I should claim unemployment for the gap weeks when I was back at work part time. Unemployment and disability can't cover the same days, so that was out. But I just want to flag that for anyone who might be thinking about it.

0 coins

EDD is pretty clear that you can't collect both for the same period. Good call not trying it.

0 coins

Yeah I read that on EDD's site and decided not to even attempt it. The two programs are completely separate.

0 coins

What if someone was on disability and then got laid off, can they switch to unemployment? Just curious.

0 coins

Disability covers days you can't work. Once you're able and available to work again, you can file for unemployment at that point. While you're still unable to work, disability is the right program, not unemployment.

0 coins

Update from me since I started this thread. Filed the new claim, gave my doctor's office the receipt number right away, and the medical certification came through within four days. SDI Online moved from pending and I got the Notice of Computation showing the same weekly amount as before. Seven-day wait is just what it is. Thanks everyone for explaining how this actually works because EDD's own site isn't super clear about what happens to remaining weeks when you go back to work and then need to re-apply.

0 coins

Glad it worked out. The same benefit amount making sense once you understand the base period is already set.

0 coins

Smooth certification process makes all the difference. Well done getting that receipt number to the office quickly.

0 coins

Good result. Keep an eye on when that DE 2593 questionnaire might come if you're on automatic payments.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure