Back to California Disability

Drake

California EDD and temporary unemployment due to surgery — am I filing the right thing?

Had a hernia repair three weeks ago and my surgeon has me completely off work for another month at least. I've been trying to figure out what to file and I keep second-guessing myself. My HR person said to look into unemployment, my coworker said it's a disability thing, and now I'm reading about SDI and PFL and I genuinely don't know which one applies when you're out because of surgery. I went into SDI Online and started filling things out but stopped because I wasn't sure if I was in the right place. My job is warehouse work so there's absolutely no way I can go back while I'm still recovering. Can someone clarify — is SDI the right program for surgery recovery, and how do I even start?

SDI Online showed three weeks marked paid and two more still sitting there when I finally got someone at EDD on the phone. I'd been trying to reach them for days about which weeks had actually processed on my own post-op claim. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through — it holds the line with EDD so you end up talking to a live agent. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me weeks four and five were still pending because EDD hadn't received the second part of my certification, so I knew exactly what to chase down with my doctor's office after that.

0 coins

The receipt number was the piece I was missing too. My surgeon's office couldn't find my claim in SDI Online until I texted them the receipt number I got when I filed, then everything matched up and the certification went through the same day.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Wait, there's a receipt number involved? I never saw that come up when I was filling things out. I'll go back into SDI Online and look for it before I do anything else.

0 coins

EDD sends it right when you finish filing your Claimant's Statement — it's on the confirmation screen. Write it down or screenshot it because the doctor's office searches for the claim with that exact number on their side.

0 coins

Your HR person steered you wrong. Unemployment requires you to be ready to work every week you claim it — if your surgeon says you're off, you don't qualify for unemployment while you're still recovering. SDI is exactly what you're describing: you can't do your regular job because of a medical reason, that's what it covers. File your Claimant's Statement in SDI Online through myEDD, then get your surgeon to submit the medical certification, and EDD takes it from there.

0 coins

Drake

Author

That clears up the HR confusion completely. I had a feeling unemployment didn't fit but I didn't want to assume. Going to log into myEDD today.

0 coins

Warehouse work makes it even more clear-cut honestly. There's no modified duty angle when lifting is literally the job, so a surgeon saying you're off is a surgeon saying you can't do your regular work, which is what SDI looks at.

0 coins

Worth adding — the cutoff to file is 49 days from the date your disability started. If your surgery was three weeks ago, don't sit on this. File the Claimant's Statement first, get your receipt number, then loop in the surgeon's office about the certification.

0 coins

I mixed up PFL and SDI when I had my appendix out last year and almost filed the wrong thing. PFL is for caring for a sick family member or bonding with a new baby — not for your own medical situation. Your own surgery is SDI all the way.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Honestly I was looking at PFL too and that would have been the wrong move. Good to know the line is that clear.

0 coins

The number of people who file PFL for their own condition and then get confused when it doesn't work out is pretty high. EDD's site spells it out but those two programs do sound similar until you read carefully.

0 coins

I did the same thing — started a PFL claim for my own knee surgery before someone corrected me. The clue is that DI or SDI is for your own illness or injury, PFL is for someone else's.

0 coins

My disability claim after a rotator cuff repair moved faster once I understood what 'pending' actually meant. I assumed it meant something was wrong. It just means EDD is still processing — usually within two weeks after they have both your Claimant's Statement and the medical certification together. I was refreshing SDI Online every few hours thinking I'd done something wrong when really I just had to let it sit.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Refreshing SDI Online obsessively is exactly what I would do. Good to know pending isn't automatically a red flag.

0 coins

Two weeks is roughly right once both parts are in. The piece that tripped me up was not realizing the medical certification and the claimant's statement have to both be in before EDD really starts processing. I filed my statement and thought the clock was running, but EDD was waiting on my doctor the whole time.

0 coins

And the doctor can't just mail it separately and hope — on SDI Online claims the certification has to be submitted through SDI Online with that receipt number, not faxed or mailed independently.

0 coins

nobody told me about the seven day waiting period and I panicked when my first week came back as non-payable. called EDD in a full spiral thinking my claim was denied. the rep just said thats normal, the first seven days dont get paid on any new claim, its not a processing delay its just the rule

0 coins

I had the same reaction — saw that first week marked non-payable and assumed I'd filled something out wrong. The seven days is baked into every new DI claim, so the first day that actually gets paid is day eight of the disability.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Nobody mentioned this to me either. So I shouldn't expect anything for that first week at all — that's just how it works?

0 coins

Exactly right. It's not a gap in processing, it's a mandatory unpaid period at the start of every new claim. Your first payable day is the eighth day of your disability, full stop.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period was something EDD added for surgeries specifically and that people with other conditions got paid from day one. Had no idea it applied across the board until someone set me straight.

0 coins

FILED MINE THE DAY AFTER SURGERY AND STILL WAITED FOREVER and nobody could explain why. sdionline kept saying pending pending pending. turned out my orthopedic's office submitted the certification but put the wrong date for when I stopped working. one digit off and EDD couldn't match it to my claim. everything had to get re-submitted

0 coins

Dates are brutal for exactly this reason. The disability start date on the medical certification has to line up with what you put on your Claimant's Statement, otherwise EDD sees two things that don't match and the claim just sits.

0 coins

Drake

Author

This is terrifying honestly. I'm going to double-check with my surgeon's office exactly what date they're planning to list before they submit anything.

0 coins

Before your surgeon submits, confirm the date you put on your own statement as the first day you couldn't work. Give them that date in writing, not just verbally, because a one-digit typo is an easy mistake when they're entering it manually.

0 coins

The extension process caught me off guard after my spinal surgery went longer than expected. My surgeon said I needed more time but I didn't know what that meant for SDI — I figured I'd have to file all over again. EDD sent a notice with my final payment saying my doctor needed to submit a Physician/Practitioner's Supplementary Certificate, the DE 2525XX. My doctor's office had no idea what that form was. Spent days trying to explain it to them and finally got on the phone with EDD through Claimyr about the extension — the agent confirmed the DE 2525XX was what EDD was waiting for and told me EDD still hadn't received it. I took that exact information back to the office and they found it in their system the same afternoon.

0 coins

Drake

Author

The DE 2525XX is a form I had no idea existed. So EDD sends the final payment notice and that's when this form becomes relevant — not before?

0 coins

EDD sends the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification with the final payment, and that's what tells your doctor to submit the DE 2525XX if they're extending. The tricky part is your doctor's office might not check for that or know to act on it without you following up.

0 coins

My physical therapist tried to submit the extension for my torn ACL and EDD rejected it. Found out a PT isn't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim at all — it has to be a physician, nurse practitioner, or one of the other licensed types EDD recognizes. My orthopedist had to do it.

0 coins

Physical therapist trying to certify — that's a common one. EDD has a specific list: physician, osteopath, chiropractor, podiatrist, optometrist, dentist, psychologist, nurse practitioner, physician assistant, licensed midwife for pregnancy-related conditions. PT is not there.

0 coins

Orthopedist, spine surgeon, any physician on that list can do it. The key is they submit through SDI Online the same way they did the original certification, with the receipt number linking to the original claim.

0 coins

I was completely wrong about how partial work interacts with SDI. Went back to light desk duty four days a week thinking SDI would just pause and restart when I went back to full duty. Doesn't work that way — if you're working any hours, you have to report it to EDD and they determine how the partial week gets paid. I had to report every hour.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Okay good to know for down the road. I'm not anywhere near that point with this recovery but I'll keep it in mind.

0 coins

The reporting piece is the part people skip and then end up with an overpayment notice six months later. Whatever hours you work, tell EDD. They figure out the payment amount.

0 coins

Overpayment notices after partial work are really common and almost always come from people who assumed SDI would self-adjust. It doesn't — you report, EDD calculates. Miss that step and you're repaying money later.

0 coins

After my gallbladder surgery I worried about the tax angle. Someone at work said SDI money was taxable just like a paycheck and I started setting aside a chunk of every payment. Learned later that California doesn't tax SDI benefits, but the federal side can get complicated depending on your situation. I'd look at EDD's tax information page or talk to a tax person rather than taking anyone's word for it, including mine.

0 coins

Drake

Author

That's a good heads up. I hadn't even gotten to thinking about taxes yet but I'll bookmark that for when payments start coming in.

0 coins

California not taxing it was a relief but I also didn't want to assume on the federal side. EDD's site has a tax info section — that plus a tax professional is the right move rather than guessing.

0 coins

The base period math confused me for a solid week. I'd only been at my warehouse job for eight months when I had my surgery and I panicked thinking I didn't have enough work history to qualify. What matters is whether you had at least $300 in wages subject to SDI during the base period, which looks at wages from about five to eighteen months before your claim starts. EDD's benefit calculator on their site gives you an estimate once you put in your wages — your Notice of Computation will show the real number when it arrives.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Eight months in and you still qualified? That's reassuring because I'm not a super long-tenured employee either. I'll run the numbers in EDD's calculator.

0 coins

the notice of computation is not an approval letter btw, i thought it meant i was good to go when it showed up. it just tells you the potential weekly amount, eligibility is a separate determination

0 coins

Yep, the Notice of Computation shows what your weekly benefit could be, not that EDD has decided you're eligible. Approval comes through payments actually being issued or through a determination notice.

0 coins

workers comp question that always comes up in these threads — if your surgery is for something that happened at work, that's workers comp territory, not SDI. EDD themselves say it's not common to get both at the same time, though there are exceptions. If your hernia is work-related at all, talk to your employer before you file SDI.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Mine is definitely not work-related, it was just a thing that happened. But I appreciate the flag for anyone else reading this.

0 coins

Good callout. The distinction matters because filing the wrong one can create a mess to untangle. Work injury goes through workers comp, non-work injury or illness goes through SDI. If there's any gray area about how it happened, sort that out first.

0 coins

The claim start date on my own post-surgery SDI was off by four days because I listed the surgery date instead of the first day I actually couldn't do my job, which was a couple days before when my surgeon put me on pre-op restrictions. Had to sort that out with EDD. I'd called them through Claimyr about the start date — the agent looked up my claim and read me exactly what date EDD had on file, which was the surgery date, so I knew what needed fixing.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Pre-op restrictions counting as the disability start date is something I never would have thought of. My surgeon had me on lifting restrictions for about five days before the actual procedure.

0 coins

The first day you can't do your regular work is what matters for the start date, not necessarily the surgery itself. If your doctor put restrictions on you before the procedure that kept you from working, that earlier date is the right one.

0 coins

Filing with the wrong start date also affects the waiting period calculation — the seven unpaid days count from the actual start date, so getting it wrong can shift everything downstream.

0 coins

my payment went to a money network card that showed up in the mail and i had no idea what it was, almost threw it out thinking it was junk. if you set up direct deposit in SDI Online when you file you can skip the card, but if you miss that step the money network card is what EDD sends by default

0 coins

Drake

Author

Glad you said this — I would absolutely throw out an unfamiliar card. I'll set up direct deposit when I file so I don't have to worry about it.

0 coins

SAME. i thought it was one of those fake cards they send as mailers. activated it three days late and the money was sitting there the whole time

0 coins

The card is from Money Network now — I keep seeing people mention a Bank of America EDD card but that's not what EDD uses anymore. It's Money Network's card, and it looks like a regular debit card with their branding.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my wrist surgery claim showed a weekly amount that looked lower than I expected and I didn't understand why. The figure comes from the highest-paid quarter inside a twelve-month base period that runs from about five to eighteen months before the claim starts — so recent wages right before you got hurt may not even be in the calculation. Used Claimyr to reach EDD about the Notice of Computation and the agent told me exactly which quarter they'd used for my claim and what the quarterly wages were that produced my weekly amount.

0 coins

Drake

Author

So the amount on the Notice of Computation reflects wages from months ago, not my most recent pay? That could explain a lot if someone got a raise recently.

0 coins

Exactly that. A raise in the last few months before you stop working might not fall inside the base period at all. The calculator on EDD's site lets you try different wage scenarios to see how the quarters line up.

0 coins

My weekly amount looked off for the same reason — I'd switched from part-time to full-time about three months before my surgery and that full-time pay barely counted. The base period was mostly my part-time wages.

0 coins

Filing late is the thing I want to flag for anyone still on the fence about starting. The window is 49 days from when the disability started. If you miss it, EDD can disqualify you outright. And the note in the instructions says to wait nine days after the disability begins before filing — so there's a narrow window between day nine and day forty-nine to get the Claimant's Statement in.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Day nine to day forty-nine — writing that down. I'm still inside that window but not by a lot at this point.

0 coins

The doctor also has to get the medical certification in within 49 days of the disability start. It's not just the claimant's part that has the deadline, both sides do.

0 coins

i filed on day 48 once and my doctor submitted the cert on day 51 and edd did ask about the late cert. it got sorted but it added time and paperwork. file and get the doctor to certify as early as possible

0 coins

EDD has a few ways to contact them when something's stuck — the main disability line is 1-800-480-3287, Spanish speakers can reach them at 1-866-658-8846, and there's also the Request Claim Update option inside SDI Online under your claim ID. Ask EDD is another option on EDD's site for written questions. I've had luck with the Request Claim Update tool for things that weren't super urgent.

0 coins

Drake

Author

I didn't know the Request Claim Update option existed inside SDI Online. That seems like a good first stop before waiting on hold.

0 coins

Request Claim Update is underused. It's not instant but EDD does respond, and for something like a pending certification or a question about a payment date, it's less stressful than the phone.

0 coins

The SDI Online message route worked for my post-op claim question and I got a response within a few days. Calling is better for urgent things or when you need an exact answer about what's on the claim right now.

0 coins

Appeals are something nobody wants to think about upfront but if EDD sends a Notice of Determination saying the claim isn't payable, the Appeal Form comes with it. You have 30 days from the date on the notice to appeal. After my colleague had a claim denied for a hernia repair, he said the form was straightforward but writing out a detailed explanation of the situation alongside it made a difference.

0 coins

Drake

Author

I really hope I don't get to that point but I'll keep this in mind. 30 days from the date on the notice, not the date I receive it?

0 coins

From the date the notice was issued, yes. So if it sat in your mailbox for a few days before you opened it, those days count. Open anything from EDD as soon as it arrives.

0 coins

If the form is lost or you can't find it, EDD says a detailed letter works in its place. Mail it to the return address on the notice. Missing the 30-day window requires explaining the delay to an administrative law judge.

0 coins

My boss kept telling me to just use vacation time and not bother with SDI because 'it takes forever and pays almost nothing.' Ended up filing anyway because the recovery was going to be eight weeks minimum and I couldn't burn that much PTO. SDI paid a share of my wages and the process wasn't as bad as he made it sound once I understood the steps.

0 coins

Drake

Author

Eight weeks of recovery is a long time to try to cover with PTO. My situation is similar and I definitely don't have enough banked for that.

0 coins

The 'it takes forever' reputation comes from people who had issues with the certification or who didn't file within the window. Claims that go in complete — both the claimant statement and the medical cert — tend to move in a couple of weeks.

0 coins

EDD says most payments are issued within two weeks after they have a properly completed claim. That's both parts together. The delay stories usually trace back to one piece being missing.

0 coins

My claim ran for the full stretch of my recovery and I never knew DI could go as long as 52 weeks if the disability lasts that long. I'd assumed it was something like six or eight weeks maximum. The doctor just kept extending with the DE 2525XX each time my recovery hit a setback and EDD kept paying.

0 coins

Drake

Author

52 weeks is a lot longer than I assumed. I thought it was maybe six weeks and that was it.

0 coins

52 weeks is the ceiling for DI benefits on a single claim. The extension process through the DE 2525XX is what keeps it going past the initial certification period — your doctor submits it, not you.

0 coins

Each extension still needs a licensed provider to certify the continued inability to work. It doesn't auto-renew — the provider has to actively submit the supplementary certificate each time.

0 coins

The myEDD login tripped me up at first. SDI Online is inside myEDD — you go to myEDD at the myEDD website, log in, and then open SDI Online from there. I kept trying to find a separate SDI Online URL and going in circles.

0 coins

Drake

Author

I literally did this. Searched 'SDI Online' and found a bunch of things that weren't the right portal. So it's myEDD first, then SDI Online lives inside that?

0 coins

Yes — myEDD is the front door. Once you're in you'll see SDI Online as an option. The address for myEDD is myedd.edd.ca.gov if you want to bookmark it directly.

0 coins

SAME PROBLEM HAD ME GOING CRAZY. the homepage just says edd.ca.gov and then you find myEDD from there. once you're inside its intuitive but getting to the right door took me longer than it should have

0 coins

Drake

Author

Update for anyone following this thread — I filed my Claimant's Statement this afternoon. My surgeon's office already has the receipt number and they said they'd submit the medical certification by end of week. The 49-day clock was tighter than I realized (day 23 today) so I'm glad I stopped overthinking and just did it. Thanks to everyone who answered — this thread saved me from filing unemployment for surgery recovery, which would have been a mess.

0 coins

Day 23 and both pieces moving, you're in good shape. Watch for the Notice of Computation in the mail — it'll show your estimated weekly amount.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation isn't your approval, just a heads up — in case that wasn't clear from the thread. Keep an eye on SDI Online for the actual payment status.

0 coins

Warehouse work and a hernia repair is exactly the scenario SDI is built for. Hope the recovery goes smoothly.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure