Back to California Disability

Amina Bah

California EDD alternate base period — will it change what I get?

Filed my SDI claim about three weeks ago after some complications landed me out of work unexpectedly. My work history is kind of inconsistent — I had a gap earlier this year where I picked up freelance gigs and wasn't paying into SDI, so when I looked at the base period EDD normally uses, those quarters are pretty thin. Someone at my doctor's office mentioned there might be an alternate base period option that could pull from more recent earnings. I honestly have no idea how that works or when EDD uses it versus the regular base period. My Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount it's showing seems really low compared to what I've been earning lately. Is there something I'm supposed to request, or does EDD figure out automatically which period gives me the better amount? Has anyone dealt with this and actually gotten a higher benefit from it?

Quarter two of my base period was the one EDD flagged as highest, but it didn't match what I expected at all, so I had Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time and ended up talking to an EDD agent. She pulled up my claim and told me exactly which four quarters made up my base period — and it was the standard one, not the alternate. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed the alternate base period is used when someone doesn't have enough wages in the regular base period to even qualify — it's not a choice you make to get a higher amount, it's a fallback for when the standard calculation leaves you short of the minimum. Knowing which quarters actually counted let me go back and check my wage records against what the Notice of Computation showed.

0 coins

Two weeks into waiting on my own Notice of Computation and I keep second-guessing the same thing. So the alternate base period isn't something you pick — EDD just uses it automatically if your regular quarters are too thin to qualify?

0 coins

Exactly what the agent told me. The alternate shifts the window to include your most recent completed quarter, which the standard period leaves out. If you clear the minimum with the standard quarters, that's what EDD uses, full stop.

0 coins

Spent a lot of time assuming I could choose whichever period gave me more money. Nope. The standard base period is EDD's default — four quarters from about five to seventeen months back. The alternate only kicks in automatically if you'd otherwise fall short of the wage minimum to even file. You can't elect it for a bigger check.

0 coins

The gap in your work history is probably why the quarterly wages look low on the notice. The standard base period goes back roughly five to seventeen months before your claim starts, so recent earnings don't count unless EDD switches to the alternate. If your most recent completed quarter has your highest wages and you didn't have enough in the earlier quarters to qualify, the alternate base period pulls that recent quarter in. But if you already qualified under the standard period, that recent quarter isn't going in regardless.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

That's exactly the situation — I had good months recently but the quarters EDD is looking at are from when I had the gap. So if I already qualified, even barely, the alternate doesn't apply to me?

0 coins

Right, qualifying is the threshold. Clear it under the standard calculation and EDD sticks with standard, doesn't matter that alternate might show higher wages. The notice should spell out which quarters it used — worth checking those against your own records.

0 coins

Payroll records from HR came in handy for me for exactly this. My Notice of Computation had one quarter that looked off and I had to cross-reference it with my W-2 to figure out the employer had reported wages in a different quarter than I expected.

0 coins

Went through almost this identical confusion last spring. The thing that tripped me up was thinking the alternate base period was some kind of upgrade you could apply for. It's not. EDD runs the standard calculation first. If you hit the wage minimum — and EDD's site has a calculator that estimates it — you're done, standard applies. Only if you fall short does EDD automatically try the alternate, which uses your four most recent completed calendar quarters instead of the ones from further back. If you still don't qualify under alternate, that's when EDD sends you a denial.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Mine already shows a weekly amount on the Notice of Computation, so I guess I qualified under the standard period. I'm just frustrated that the amount is low because my recent good earnings aren't in the picture at all.

0 coins

Yep, that's the tradeoff baked into how SDI calculates benefits. Recent wages only matter for alternate, and alternate only matters if you can't qualify otherwise. If you qualified, the amount is what it is based on those earlier quarters.

0 coins

Same frustration here when I came off a leave last year and went back to higher-paying work, then had to file again. The quarters EDD used were from when I was part-time and the weekly amount on my notice was depressing. Nothing to do about it though.

0 coins

Is there any way to dispute what quarter EDD counted as the highest paid one? Like if you think they used wrong wage data?

0 coins

Saw someone above ask about disputing the wage data — yes, you can. If your Notice of Computation shows wages that don't match your records, you can contact EDD and ask them to look at the specific quarter. It's worth getting your pay stubs or a wage summary from your employer for the base period quarters first so you have something concrete to compare. Errors in employer wage reports do happen.

0 coins

Okay that's helpful. Mine shows wages for one quarter that seem too low — my employer switched payroll systems partway through that quarter and I think some pay periods got mis-reported.

0 coins

Payroll system switches are actually a known source of reporting glitches. Get your own records together — pay stubs, your employer's earnings summary — and then contact EDD through SDI Online or the phone line to flag the discrepancy. Have the specific quarter and the difference in dollars ready when you do.

0 coins

Former payroll person here — employer wage reports to EDD go in quarterly and mistakes definitely happen during system transitions. If you have your own stubs, those are the receipts. EDD can request corrected wage data from the employer.

0 coins

My claim had a weird situation where I had one super high-earning quarter and three really low ones. The base period calculation pulls from the highest single quarter to set the weekly amount, so my benefit was actually decent even though most of my base period looked thin. So for anyone worried: EDD isn't averaging all four quarters, it's looking at the peak one.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Wait, so it's based on just the highest quarter, not all four added up?

0 coins

The benefit amount is estimated from your highest-paid quarter in the base period. The other three quarters are still looked at to confirm you have enough total wages to qualify, but the actual weekly benefit is pegged to that peak quarter.

0 coins

Took me a while to understand the same thing. The minimum wage threshold is spread across the whole base period but the payment rate is based on that one best quarter. The calculator on EDD's site shows this if you plug in your own numbers.

0 coins

Nobody seems to have flagged yet that if you're a newer worker or had a lot of time off, it's possible to meet the minimum under alternate but still end up with the same low weekly amount because your best quarter is still from a low-earning period. The alternate base period helps you qualify, it doesn't automatically produce a higher benefit number.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

That's a bit deflating but good to know. So even if EDD had used the alternate for me, the weekly amount might not have been much better if my recent quarters aren't dramatically higher than the ones in the standard window.

0 coins

Exactly. Alternate base period shifts which quarters EDD looks at. If your strongest quarter is in that new window, your benefit goes up. If your strongest quarter was already in the standard window, alternate doesn't help the amount much even though it brings in more recent wages.

0 coins

Went through this after a complicated recovery and kept expecting EDD to recalculate. They don't. Once your benefit is set by the Notice of Computation, that's the number for the life of the claim.

0 coins

Payment method on my claim had an issue after I filed — my direct deposit info didn't transfer from an older claim and EDD defaulted me to the Money Network card. I used Claimyr to get through to the disability line and the agent confirmed the card had already been issued. Had to request the switch to direct deposit through SDI Online before the next payment to make it stick. Anyway on the alternate base period question — the notice really is the document that tells you everything. If the quarters listed on yours don't line up with where your highest wages actually were, that's the thing to flag.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Good point about the notice. I went back and looked at it more carefully and I can now see which four quarters EDD used. The highest one is from about fourteen months ago, which was actually decent, so maybe the weekly amount isn't as off as I thought.

0 coins

Direct deposit switch timing tripped me up too — submitted it and thought it was saved but the payment after my request still went to the card because the cutoff for that cycle had already passed.

0 coins

Timing matters a lot with that. The agent was pretty clear that the switch takes effect for the next payment cycle, not the one already in process, so if a payment is about to go out it's going to the card regardless.

0 coins

Can I ask a related question — my disability started toward the end of a calendar quarter, so a lot of my highest earning weeks fall in a quarter that might not be fully captured. Is there a way to know in advance which quarters EDD will use before you even file?

0 coins

The base period for a standard claim covers the four complete calendar quarters before the quarter your claim starts in — so if you file in, say, October of this year, EDD looks at the full quarters from last year and the year before. The quarter your disability starts in is excluded from the standard base period entirely.

0 coins

So the most recent full quarter before I filed is also excluded?

0 coins

Yes, the quarter right before your claim quarter is the gap — it's in neither the standard nor the alternate base period under standard rules. The alternate base period is the four most recent completed quarters, which does include that most recent one. That's part of why the alternate can help newer workers who are building up wages.

0 coins

EDD's disability benefits calculator on their site lets you model this out if you know your quarterly wages. Worth running it before you file or right after to see if your numbers make sense.

0 coins

The seven day waiting period thing confused me so badly at first — I kept thinking those days would count toward the base period or affect my benefit amount somehow. They don't. The waiting period is just the first week of the claim that's non-payable, full stop. Has nothing to do with how EDD calculates which quarters to use or what your weekly rate is.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Had that exact confusion. I thought the waiting period was EDD's processing time, not an actual built-in unpaid week.

0 coins

Lots of people mix those up. Processing and the waiting period are two completely different things. Processing is how long EDD takes to review your claim after the medical certification is in. The waiting period is day one through seven of your disability — no payment for those days no matter how fast EDD processes you.

0 coins

My waiting period fell over a holiday week and I briefly panicked that it would extend. It doesn't — the seven days are just the first seven days of your claim regardless of weekends or holidays.

0 coins

Three weeks after filing my own claim and still no Notice of Computation in the mail. Everything in SDI Online just says pending. Medical certification went in from my physical therapist's office. Is that normal for the notice to take this long?

0 coins

Physical therapist isn't on EDD's list of providers who can certify a disability claim. The list includes physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, licensed midwives — but not physical therapists. If only the PT submitted the certification, that may be why your claim is stuck.

0 coins

Oh no. That's what I was afraid someone might say. So I need to get an actual physician to submit the certification? My PT was the one doing all my treatment.

0 coins

You'd need a provider from EDD's approved list to certify it. Your PT may work under or alongside a physician who could do it. Contact that office as soon as possible — the medical certification has to be in within 49 days of when your disability started, so the clock matters here.

0 coins

Happened to someone in my household's claim too — a provider submitted who wasn't on EDD's approved list and the whole thing sat pending with no notice. Getting the right provider to submit cleared it within about a week and a half.

0 coins

Medical certification on my claim was showing as not received in SDI Online even though my doctor's office swore they submitted it. Used Claimyr to get an agent on the phone about it and she confirmed the certification had come in but was matched to a different receipt number — the office had used a number from an older claim of mine. The agent told me the office needed to resubmit with the correct receipt number from my current filing. Sorted out within a few days after that.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Receipt number matching is something nobody tells you about when you file. I gave my doctor's office the number from the SDI Online confirmation screen but I didn't know if that was the right one to give them.

0 coins

That confirmation screen receipt number is exactly the right one. It's how EDD links the certification to your specific claim. Tell your provider's office to use that number when they look up the claim in SDI Online to submit Part B.

0 coins

Billing departments at medical offices can be really disorganized about which claim number is current. Worth following up with them in writing so there's a record of which number you gave them.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone who had a gap in employment or switched jobs: wages only count toward SDI if your employer was withholding the CASDI deduction. If you did any work as an independent contractor or if an employer incorrectly classified you, those wages won't show up in EDD's records for the base period. That's a separate fight with the Labor Commissioner if you think you were misclassified, but it explains why some people's Notice of Computation looks way off from what they actually earned.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

That could be part of my situation — some of those freelance quarters I mentioned, I wasn't sure if the deductions were coming out. Worth checking my pay stubs from that period.

0 coins

Definitely check. If you see CASDI on the stub, it was going in. If not, those wages didn't build up your SDI eligibility. For the base period purposes only reported, subject-to-SDI wages matter.

0 coins

Learned this the hard way with a gig platform I used one year. The platform wasn't withholding CASDI and those earnings meant nothing to EDD when I filed later.

0 coins

The confusion between SDI and Paid Family Leave trips everyone up at some point. SDI is for when you can't work because of your own condition — illness, injury, pregnancy itself. PFL kicks in after you recover from childbirth if you want to bond with the baby. They're two separate claims with separate benefit periods. PFL doesn't have the seven day waiting period that SDI has. Keeping those two straight matters because you can't file for unemployment at the same time as SDI either — EDD won't pay both for the same days since unemployment requires you to be able and available to work.

0 coins

Got tripped up by the SDI vs. unemployment overlap rule myself. Was thinking I could file for unemployment while still on disability since my employer let me go. But being unable to work is exactly why you're on SDI — you can't simultaneously be available for work the way unemployment requires.

0 coins

Right, it has to be one or the other for any given day. When you're able to work again, that's when unemployment becomes the right claim if you're out of a job at that point. EDD handles each separately.

0 coins

Employer letting you go while you're on disability is scary. The SDI piece continues based on your medical condition regardless, but the job protection question is a different thing — that's your employer's HR and potentially the Civil Rights Department's CFRA guidance, not EDD.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation listed a weekly benefit amount that seemed reasonable to me when I first got it, and I didn't realize until later that I was supposed to look at which quarters it used to verify accuracy. By the time I noticed an error it had been almost a month. Is there a time limit on raising a wage dispute with EDD?

0 coins

Raise it as soon as you can and document everything. The appeal window for a determination is 30 days from the date on the notice, so if you're within that for the original notice, file the appeal form from the notice. If the dispute is just about correcting wage records rather than appealing a denial, contact EDD through SDI Online to open the correction question — but act quickly.

0 coins

Formal appeal vs. a wage correction request — are those the same process?

0 coins

Not exactly. An appeal (the DE 1000A form or a detailed letter) is for when EDD issued a decision you want to contest. A wage correction is more of an administrative fix where the employer submitted wrong data. EDD can reach out to the employer for a corrected wage report — that's not an appeal, it's a records fix. But if the wrong wages caused a denial or a lower benefit amount, you'd want to appeal that outcome within 30 days too.

0 coins

Filed under the alternate base period last year and wanted to share what that actually looked like. My regular base period had one quarter where I was on unpaid family leave and two where I had reduced hours due to a health issue the year before. Total wages in the standard window were under the minimum to qualify. EDD automatically used the alternate, which pulled in my four most recent completed quarters where I had been working full time again, and I qualified. The notice came in about 12 days after my doctor submitted the certification.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Really helpful to hear from someone who actually went through the alternate. Did the weekly benefit amount end up higher than it would have been under standard?

0 coins

Significantly higher because my most recent quarter was the strongest I'd had in years. Standard would have both disqualified me and given me a lower amount if I'd somehow scraped through. Alternate made a real difference for me.

0 coins

Twelve days from certification to notice is roughly what everyone says. Mine hit on day 11 so that tracks.

0 coins

Workers' comp question adjacent to this thread — if someone gets hurt at work, is SDI even available? My coworker is under the impression that injury at work automatically goes through workers' comp and you can't also get SDI.

0 coins

Work injury does go through workers' comp first. EDD says it's not common to get both at the same time, but there are exceptions. How those two interact in a specific case is something to ask EDD and possibly a workers' comp attorney about — not something a forum can sort out reliably.

0 coins

Fair, that makes sense. I'll point the coworker toward EDD's site and suggest they ask directly.

0 coins

Returned to work part time about six weeks into my claim and had no idea I was supposed to report those earnings. Did it late and ended up with a small overpayment notice. The appeal process for overpayments is the same as any other EDD appeal — 30 days from the date on the notice, DE 1000A form or a detailed letter if you've misplaced the form, mailed to the address on the notice itself. Don't mail it to some random EDD address.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Reporting partial work while on disability was confusing to me too. I thought going back part time might end the whole claim.

0 coins

Partial work doesn't automatically end the claim. You report it, and EDD adjusts for those weeks. What you get paid for a partial week is EDD's call — but not reporting it is what creates the overpayment problem.

0 coins

The 30-day window on overpayment appeals sneaks up on people. I almost missed it because I kept waiting to feel less stressed about the notice before dealing with it.

0 coins

For anyone new to this thread still confused about the alternate base period — the simplest version is: EDD tries your standard base period first. If you qualify, your benefit is set and alternate doesn't come into play at all. If you don't qualify, EDD automatically tries the alternate window. If you qualify under alternate, your benefit is based on the highest quarter in that alternate window. The calculator on EDD's site can help you model both scenarios with your own wage numbers.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

This is the clearest summary in the thread. Bookmarking this for anyone I know who gets confused by it.

0 coins

Eight months on this platform and nobody explained it this cleanly before.

0 coins

Puts the whole thread in one paragraph. The only thing I'd add is that if you don't qualify under either period, EDD sends a Notice of Determination with the denial, and you have 30 days to appeal it if you think the wage data is wrong.

0 coins

Extension on my current claim just came in after my doctor submitted the DE 2525XX. The process was way less painful than I feared — EDD sent the form along with my final payment notice and my doctor's office submitted it through SDI Online. No new claim, no waiting period reset, just a continuation of the same claim.

0 coins

Amina Bah

Author

Good to hear about extensions. My doctor already hinted I might need more time and I had no idea if that meant starting over.

0 coins

No starting over. Same claim ID, same weekly benefit amount, just extended. The form is called the DE 2525XX and it's your doctor's side of it — you don't fill it out yourself.

0 coins

DE 2593 is different from the extension form — that's the continued eligibility questionnaire EDD sends after your fifth payment if you're on automatic payment. Miss the 20-day return window on that one and your benefits pause. Easy to confuse the two since they both arrive late in a claim.

0 coins

Automatic payment setup on my claim meant I hadn't been filling out forms every two weeks, which was a relief. But then around week eleven I got the DE 2593 in the mail and panicked because I didn't understand what it was. It's not a new claim form, it's just EDD checking in that you're still unable to work. Fill it out, return it within 20 days, benefits keep flowing.

0 coins

Week ten for me and I've been bracing for that form. Good to know 20 days is the window — mine might show up any day now.

0 coins

They say to watch for it after your fifth automatic payment, which is ten weeks in. Opens your mailbox regularly around that time.

0 coins

Does it come through SDI Online or only by mail?

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure