Back to California Disability

Hattie Carson

California EDD SDI denied asking if looking for work while employed and off for disability

So I got a denial notice and I'm honestly baffled. I work at a dental office and I've been out since mid-October after a procedure that left me with complications my doctor says I can't work through. Filed my claim, got the medical certification submitted, thought everything was fine. Then the denial comes and the reason listed is something about whether I was available and looking for work. I'm not on unemployment, I'm on disability. I'm still employed, my job is just waiting for me to get better. Why would they even ask about looking for work on a disability claim? Has anyone seen this before? I have 30 days from the notice date to appeal and I don't want to mess that up.

Medical certification came back unmatched on mine for two weeks before I figured out the receipt number my doctor used was wrong. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to sort it out. Video on reaching a live person on the EDD disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent confirmed my certification was sitting there unlinked and told me what the correct receipt number needed to be so the office could resubmit.

0 coins

What does Claimyr actually do? Never heard of it before seeing this.

0 coins

You stay on hold with EDD in your place, basically it queues for a live agent and your phone rings when one picks up. Gave me a person in under an hour instead of the line dropping on me.

0 coins

Receipt number mismatch is exactly what I'd want to ask about. Mine was submitted by my doctor's PA and I never confirmed the number matched what I got when I filed.

0 coins

DE 2517 is the notice EDD sends when a claim isn't payable, and it comes with a DE 1000A appeal form. The 30-day clock starts from the date printed on the notice itself, not the day you got it.

0 coins

The date on the notice is October 31st and I got it November 4th, so I need to file by November 30th?

0 coins

Exactly that. The 30-day window runs from October 31st, so November 30th is your deadline. Mail it to the return address on the notice.

0 coins

Does the DE 1000A form need anything attached, or just the form itself? I'm worried about sending the wrong things.

0 coins

The form says to include a detailed explanation. Attach anything that supports your situation, pay stubs showing the CASDI deduction, your doctor's notes if you have them, whatever makes the case that you couldn't work and weren't looking for a different job.

0 coins

EDD mixing up DI and unemployment questions on a denial is infuriating. Disability is not unemployment. You don't have to be looking for work, you have to be unable to do your regular job. Those are completely opposite situations.

0 coins

That's what I thought too. My employer hasn't terminated me, I'm just out on medical leave. Why would availability for work even come up?

0 coins

No idea how their system flags it, but it happens. The appeal is where you spell out that you're still employed, still have a job to return to, and that your doctor certified you can't work right now. That's DI, not UI.

0 coins

It happens more than it should. Write it out plainly in the appeal.

0 coins

Years ago when I filed my first disability claim I thought the seven-day waiting period was just slow processing. Filed my appeal over a payment I thought was missing and EDD had to explain it to me. The waiting period is built into every new claim, the first seven days are simply not payable no matter what. It's not a delay, it's a rule.

0 coins

Mine has been open longer than seven days, so that shouldn't be the denial reason right?

0 coins

Correct. The waiting period just means no payment for days one through seven. After that, if everything else is in order, benefits are payable. Your denial sounds like it's about an eligibility question, not the waiting period.

0 coins

So the waiting period doesn't affect the appeal deadline at all?

0 coins

Not at all. The 30-day appeal window runs from the notice date regardless of where you are in your claim.

0 coins

Waiting period question on my own claim sent me to the phone. Claimyr got me to an agent and she confirmed the exact days that counted toward my waiting period and which day my first payable day was. Worth knowing before you assume a payment is late.

0 coins

Used it for a receipt number issue too and the agent told me which receipt number was actually on the claim in their system. Cleared up the whole mismatch same day.

0 coins

Did the agent just read you what was on the screen, or could they actually make a change?

0 coins

Mostly read back what was on the claim, told me which number to give the doctor's office so they could resubmit. EDD made the actual update after the office sent the corrected cert.

0 coins

You're employed and your doctor said you can't work. That's a disability claim, not an unemployment claim. The denial question about looking for work doesn't belong on your claim at all. Put that in writing in your appeal.

0 coins

Should I explain my employment situation, that I still have a job to go back to?

0 coins

Yes. Say you're employed, your position is being held, and you aren't seeking other work. Keep it short and clear.

0 coins

The confusion might come from how the denial was coded. Some claimants get flagged when their answers on the initial claim form leave room for interpretation. The appeal is your chance to clarify that you were off work due to a medical condition, not because of a layoff or job search.

0 coins

My initial form definitely said I was employed and off for a medical reason. Would they have that on file when they review the appeal?

0 coins

EDD has your original claim on file. Your appeal letter can reference that you stated you were employed from the start and that nothing on the form indicated you were seeking other work.

0 coins

Pointing back to what you already filed is a smart move. Keeps the record clear.

0 coins

Had a client go through almost this exact thing last year, denial notice out of nowhere, still had her salon chair waiting for her. She wrote a one-page letter explaining she was out for surgery, still employed, doctor certified she couldn't stand for her shifts. Appeal came back in her favor.

0 coins

That is really reassuring. Did she use the DE 1000A form or just write a letter?

0 coins

She used the form and attached her letter behind it. EDD's instructions say you can send a detailed letter if you can't find the form, but she had the form so she used both.

0 coins

Attaching extra explanation behind the form seems like the smarter move lol

0 coins

Base period question came up on mine when EDD showed a weekly amount that looked too low. Talked to an agent through Claimyr and they read me exactly which quarter of wages they used to calculate it. Turned out a quarter where I worked heavy overtime wasn't the one selected, but the agent explained it was whichever quarter in the base period had the highest wages, and my overtime quarter wasn't the highest one overall.

0 coins

Every time someone mentions an easy fix for EDD's phone line I assume it's a plug. What actually happened on that call?

0 coins

Thought the same thing the first time I saw it mentioned. Tried it when my Notice of Computation showed an amount I didn't recognize and the agent told me exactly which quarter they'd used and what the wages in it were. Matched my W-2 once I looked. Ended up trusting the number after that.

0 coins

Alright, fair enough. I'll give it a shot for my own base period question then.

0 coins

you cant mix up disability and unemployment rules, theyre totally different things. disability youre too sick to work, unemployment youre healthy and looking. edd should know that before sending a denial

0 coins

Agreed. The appeal letter just needs to spell that out plainly.

0 coins

yeah exactly, one paragraph saying im employed and my doctor said i cant work should do it

0 coins

Appeal letter structure matters. Lead with the claim number and the denial notice date. Then one sentence stating you are employed and were not seeking other employment. Then attach the medical certification confirmation if SDI Online shows it was received.

0 coins

SDI Online shows the certification as received. Can I print that screen to attach?

0 coins

Print or screenshot it and include it. Any documentation showing the cert was submitted and that you were on medical leave from an active employer strengthens the appeal.

0 coins

Claim number at the top of the letter, yes. EDD loses things without it, anyway.

0 coins

Not sure if this is relevant but I was worried my employer might have put something on my separation paperwork that made it look like a layoff. Turned out EDD looks at whether you can work, not just what your employer filed. Still, I'd double-check anything your employer might have submitted.

0 coins

That's a reasonable thing to verify. If your employer filed anything that described the leave incorrectly, noting the discrepancy in your appeal letter gives EDD a chance to reconcile it.

0 coins

My employer just put me on a medical leave of absence, nothing about separation or layoff. So that should be fine.

0 coins

Seeing the words 'available for work' on a disability denial is alarming when you're clearly too sick to work. Keep the appeal focused: I am employed, I am medically unable to work, my doctor certified that in writing.

0 coins

That's basically three sentences. Should my appeal be longer than that?

0 coins

Add the specifics, your claim number, your employer's name, the dates you've been off, and what your doctor certified. But the core argument really is just those three things.

0 coins

spent three mornings trying to reach edd before giving up. appeal window kept running. eventually got someone but it took days

0 coins

The line is brutal. Send the appeal by mail and keep the tracking number regardless.

0 coins

yeah that's what i ended up doing

0 coins

DE 1000A instructions say to include a detailed explanation of why you believe the denial was wrong. Vague is not enough. 'I was employed and unable to work, not unemployed and seeking work' is the specific rebuttal to what they flagged.

0 coins

Should I quote the specific denial reason from the DE 2517 in my appeal letter?

0 coins

Reference it directly. Something like 'in response to the denial dated [date] citing availability for work, I was not seeking employment, I was out of work solely due to a medical condition certified by my physician.' That ties your letter directly to the denial reason.

0 coins

Matching your rebuttal to the exact denial code is cleaner than a general letter. EDD's reviewer can see exactly which question you're answering.

0 coins

Workers' comp question came up for me because my injury happened unloading a truck. Someone at my job said I should file workers' comp instead. EDD actually says it's not common to get both SDI and workers' comp at the same time. Ended up filing through my employer's workers' comp process, not SDI, anyway.

0 coins

Work injury goes workers' comp first. Non-work injury or illness is SDI. Different tracks.

0 coins

Mine was definitely not work-related, so I should be squarely in SDI territory.

0 coins

Then you're in the right place. The denial is fixable, appeal it.

0 coins

PFL is different from DI and I see people mix them up all the time. PFL is for bonding with a baby or caring for a sick family member. DI is for when you yourself can't work. No waiting period on PFL either, which trips people up. Yours sounds like a straight DI claim.

0 coins

Yes, mine is definitely DI. I'm the one who can't work, no baby, no family caregiving.

0 coins

Then PFL doesn't touch your situation at all. Focus the appeal on the DI denial.

0 coins

The 30-day appeal clock is one of those things that looks generous until you're dealing with doctor's appointments and trying to reach EDD at the same time. Mail it with tracking at least a few days before the deadline.

0 coins

Filing it this week to be safe. The notice is dated the 31st so I don't want to cut it close.

0 coins

That's the right call. Mailed and tracked before the deadline beats right on time every single time.

0 coins

Denials for 'availability for work' on a disability claim where the person is still employed happen. EDD gets it sorted on appeal when the claimant lays out the facts. It's annoying but it's not the end of the claim.

0 coins

That's good to hear from someone who's seen it before.

0 coins

Appeal clearly, attach the cert confirmation, state you're employed and not job-seeking. That's the whole argument.

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and the amount was lower than I expected! Looked into it and the base period wage calculation can feel counterintuitive when your hours varied a lot by quarter. EDD's site has a calculator that at least gives you a ballpark before the notice arrives.

0 coins

Is the Notice of Computation the same as an approval? I got one before the denial.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation just shows what your potential weekly amount would be. It doesn't mean you're approved, the denial can still come after it. Your appeal is what gets the actual eligibility question resolved.

0 coins

Potential weekly and maximum amounts are on the Notice of Computation. Approval is a separate step.

0 coins

Appeal form, detailed letter, cert confirmation from SDI Online, proof of employment status if you have it. That's the packet. Mailed to the address on the DE 2517 with tracking.

0 coins

Thank you. Putting this all together today.

0 coins

Keep copies of everything before you mail it.

0 coins

Copies first, then mail. Learned that the hard way, anyway.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure