Back to California Disability

Ryder Everingham

Am I eligible for SDI if employer doesn't pay into SDI — California EDD question

So my coworker mentioned something that's been stressing me out ever since. She said she heard that if your employer doesn't pay into SDI you can't get disability benefits. I've been out of work for almost two weeks with a back injury and I just assumed I was covered since I see CASDI deductions on my own pay stubs. But now I'm second-guessing everything. Like, is it the employer who has to contribute, or is it the employee? I honestly don't know how SDI even works on that level. I filed my claim on SDI Online last week and my doctor's office says they're submitting the medical certification, but now I'm worried it's all going to get denied because of something my employer did or didn't do. Can anyone clarify how SDI eligibility actually works here?

Your coworker has it backwards, actually. SDI is funded by the employee, not the employer. That CASDI line on your own pay stub is the deduction that matters. As long as you have been paying into SDI through your own wages and you earned at least $300 subject to that deduction during the base period, the employer's contribution is not the question EDD is asking. Your filing sounds like it's on the right track.

0 coins

Oh that is such a relief to read. So the CASDI on my check is my contribution, not my employer's? I had no idea it worked that way.

0 coins

Exactly right. The SDI deduction comes out of your wages, so you are the one funding the program. Your employer processes payroll and withholds it, but it is your money going in.

0 coins

Wait so employers never pay into SDI at all? I've been confused about this for weeks and nobody explained it this clearly.

0 coins

EDD's own site spells this out pretty directly. The CASDI deduction on a worker's paystub is what funds Disability Insurance. What your employer does or doesn't contribute separately is not part of the DI eligibility equation. The base period wage requirement is on the worker's side of the ledger.

0 coins

So I should just focus on making sure my doctor gets the medical certification in and not worry about my employer's end?

0 coins

The medical certification is the key piece right now, yes. Make sure your provider used your receipt number from when you filed, and that they submitted it in SDI Online within 49 days of your disability start date.

0 coins

Receipt number matters. Tell your doctor's office to double-check they have the right one.

0 coins

Receipt number on my claim didn't match what my provider had on file. SDI Online kept sitting there with nothing updating. Ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) to find out what was actually holding it up. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. Agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the certification had come in under a different receipt number, so it hadn't been matched to my file. Provider had to resubmit with the correct one.

0 coins

Claimyr is new to me, what does it do exactly?

0 coins

It stays on hold with EDD in your place, then your phone rings when an agent picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Honestly that's exactly what I need. My claim's been sitting pending and I want to ask EDD whether my medical certification even came through on their end.

0 coins

the receipt number thing got me too. provider had the wrong number and nothing moved for like 3 weeks

0 coins

Girl, I went through almost this exact worry when I filed. I kept thinking my salon wasn't paying into something correctly and my claim would tank. Turns out my CASDI deductions from my own checks were what counted, not anything from my employer's side. Once I realized that I stopped panicking and just focused on the doctor's paperwork.

0 coins

This is making me feel so much better. I'm a first-timer and I had the same fear about my employer somehow messing up my coverage.

0 coins

Totally understandable to worry! But your own paystubs showing CASDI is what tells you you're covered. The employer isn't the one writing a check to EDD for DI.

0 coins

My pay stubs definitely show CASDI every period so I think I'm okay on that front.

0 coins

Nobody ever tells you this stuff clearly and then you spend three days trying to call the disability line and get absolutely nowhere. The line rings, plays a recording, and ends the call. Meanwhile you're sitting at home injured with no income and zero answers.

0 coins

Three days is nothing. I tried for over a week before I got anyone.

0 coins

A week. And people wonder why claimants end up posting on forums to find out basic eligibility rules.

0 coins

yeah the line does that thing where it just hangs up after the recording. very fun.

0 coins

To be clear on the eligibility question: SDI covers workers who have SDI deductions taken from their wages. The employer withholds and remits that deduction, but the employee is the one paying into the system. If CASDI shows on your stubs, you have been contributing.

0 coins

Thank you. This is exactly what I needed someone to say plainly.

0 coins

Short and clear. Appreciate that.

0 coins

My wife had this same question when she was out for her surgery last year. She called HR, HR said the wrong thing, she panicked, spent two days worrying, and then it turned out her CASDI deductions were the whole answer. Anyway just wanted to say you're probably fine.

0 coins

That sounds exactly like what I've been doing, calling HR and getting information that may or may not be right.

0 coins

HR means well but they aren't EDD. For the actual eligibility rules, EDD's site or someone who's been through it is usually more accurate anyway.

0 coins

Payment date on my claim got confusing because I didn't realize how the base period worked for calculating my benefit amount. Called EDD through Claimyr and an agent told me the exact date my payment had been issued and which weeks it covered. Honestly the whole Notice of Computation thing made more sense once I could ask someone directly.

0 coins

Used Claimyr too for a Notice of Computation question on my own claim. The agent told me exactly which quarter of my wages they'd used to calculate the amount. Helped me understand why the number on my notice looked the way it did.

0 coins

When you asked about the Notice of Computation, did the agent walk you through the base period math or just tell you what the figure was?

0 coins

She told me which quarter they used and what the weekly amount came out to. That was enough for me to verify it against my own records.

0 coins

i genuinely did not understand the Notice of Computation the first time i got one lol. glad someone finally explained it.

0 coins

Workers' compensation is for on-the-job injuries, which is different from SDI. A lot of people mix those up. SDI covers non-work-related illness, injury or pregnancy. If your back injury happened off the clock, SDI is the right program. If it happened at work, that's a different conversation entirely.

0 coins

Mine happened at home, so I think SDI is the right one. I didn't even think about workers' comp being a separate thing.

0 coins

If it happened on a job site that changes things. But if you're saying it was at home, SDI is where you file.

0 coins

EDD also says getting both at the same time isn't common. Worth knowing if you're ever in a situation that's not clear-cut.

0 coins

There's also a waiting period worth knowing about. The first seven days of your SDI claim don't get paid. That's not a processing delay, it's built into the program. Day one through seven are the non-payable waiting period, and your first payable day is day eight. Some people expect payment to start from their first day out and then get confused when the math doesn't add up.

0 coins

Seven days with nothing? I had no idea. I thought the waiting period was just how long it takes to process the claim.

0 coins

That's one of the most common mix-ups. It's a fixed non-payable period, not EDD taking its time. Processing happens on top of that.

0 coins

I definitely had these confused. I thought the pending status was the waiting period. So there are actually two separate things.

0 coins

The waiting period is the first seven calendar days of the claim, non-payable no matter how fast processing goes. After that, benefits can start if everything is in order.

0 coins

Filing on SDI Online is pretty smooth once you're in myEDD. The main thing to watch is that your provider submits the medical certification with the same receipt number you got when you filed. That number links their submission to your claim.

0 coins

I gave the receipt number to my doctor's office but I haven't confirmed they actually used it. Maybe I should follow up.

0 coins

Worth a quick check with the office. If they submitted without it, the certification won't attach to your claim and things stall.

0 coins

my provider lost the receipt number and i had to email it to them again. dont assume they saved it

0 coins

DE 2593 caught me completely off guard about five months into my claim. EDD sent it after my tenth week of automatic payments, and I almost missed the return deadline. The 20-day window to send it back is not a suggestion. Used Claimyr to reach an agent and confirm EDD had received my returned form, since SDI Online wasn't showing anything had updated.

0 coins

Sounds like marketing to me, that Claimyr thing.

0 coins

thought the same thing at first. but after spending two weeks trying to get someone on that line i used it and an agent told me my claim was past the waiting period and that my first payable day was day eight, not day one. settled a question i'd been going back and forth about for a month.

0 coins

alright. might give it a shot if my next submission doesn't show up in the system.

0 coins

20-day window on the DE 2593 is real. do not sleep on it.

0 coins

my employer told me once that i wasnt eligible for sdi because they handle leave differently. turns out that had nothing to do with EDD's program. the CASDI deductions were still coming out of my check the whole time. HR just mixed up the company's own leave policy with whether i could file a state claim lol

0 coins

HR mixing up the company's leave with EDD eligibility is so common. Those are two totally separate things.

0 coins

yeah i wish someone had told me that before i stressed for a week about it

0 coins

someone told me once that you need to have worked at least a year at the same job to qualify for sdi. is that actually true

0 coins

Not a rule EDD uses. What matters is whether you earned at least $300 subject to SDI deductions during the base period. It doesn't have to be from one employer or over any set length of time at a single job.

0 coins

ok good because i was at my current place for like 7 months before i got hurt

0 coins

The base period looks at a specific 12-month window of your wage history. How long you've been at any one employer is not the question EDD asks.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in and mine was a denial, which I did not expect. Filed an appeal with the DE 1000A within the 30 days. Used Claimyr to get an agent and ask what specifically triggered it. Agent told me EDD had not received a Notice of Determination response from me and walked me through what the notice itself said I needed to do.

0 coins

When you spoke with the agent, did they tell you anything about how long the appeal review takes?

0 coins

No, just that I had to appeal within 30 days of the notice date and that my DE 1000A had been received. Nothing about the timeline.

0 coins

Two months I've been trying to get someone on that line on my own. Two months of mornings wasted hitting redial before giving up.

0 coins

Can I ask a dumb question, is PFL the same as SDI? My sister said I should file for PFL for my injury and I keep seeing both terms on EDD's site.

0 coins

Different programs. SDI, which is Disability Insurance, is for when you can't work because of your own illness, injury or pregnancy. PFL is for bonding with a new baby or caring for a seriously ill family member. For a personal injury you'd file for DI, not PFL.

0 coins

Okay that explains why I was so confused. My sister must have been thinking of when she had her baby. That was PFL, not what I need.

0 coins

Super easy to mix those up! PFL comes up a lot after pregnancy disability ends and people switch over to bond with the baby. But for an injury, definitely the DI side.

0 coins

You mentioned you filed last week and your doctor is submitting the cert. Typical timeframe after EDD gets both pieces is around two weeks before you hear something. That's not a promise but it's what the process generally looks like.

0 coins

Two weeks from when they receive the certification, or two weeks from when I filed?

0 coins

From when EDD has both your part and the medical certification in. The clock doesn't really start until both pieces are there.

0 coins

EDD's site says most payments are issued within two weeks after they receive a properly completed claim, meaning both the claimant's statement and the provider's certification.

0 coins

been out six weeks with something going on with my shoulder and the pending status has not moved in 10 days. starting to wonder if my provider actually submitted anything

0 coins

10 days pending with no update is worth chasing down. Ask your provider's office to confirm they submitted in SDI Online and that they had your receipt number when they did it.

0 coins

i dont even know where my receipt number is. do i need to log back into sdi online to find it?

0 coins

Log into myEDD and open SDI Online, your claim should show the receipt number in your claim details. That's the number your provider needs to match their submission to your record.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation arriving before any payment came in confused me too. I thought the notice meant I was approved and money was coming right away. It doesn't work like that, the notice just shows what the weekly and maximum amount could be, not that the claim is cleared.

0 coins

I got a Notice of Computation and thought the same thing. Good to know it isn't the approval itself.

0 coins

Yep, it's more of an estimate document. The actual eligibility decision shows up through payments starting or a separate denial notice.

0 coins

A lot of people land on forums asking why they got the Notice of Computation but no payment yet. The notice and the approval are two different events.

0 coins

If the certification your doctor submitted is sitting unmatched because of a wrong receipt number, nothing moves. That's worth fixing before you do anything else. Get your receipt number from SDI Online and confirm the office has the right one on file.

0 coins

I'm going back to check on this today. The office may have a different number than what I see in myEDD.

0 coins

Don't wait on that. If the cert isn't matched, EDD has nothing to work with on your claim.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about the base period thing specifically, your wages are looked at over a 12-month window divided into four quarters, and EDD uses the highest-paid quarter to estimate your weekly benefit amount. The calculator on EDD's site gives you a rough idea before the Notice of Computation arrives.

0 coins

The base period calculation tripped me up too. My highest quarter wasn't the most recent one, which is why my benefit amount looked different from what I expected.

0 coins

That's common. The base period is 5 to 18 months before the claim start date, so the most recent few months may not be included at all.

0 coins

This is making my head spin a little but at least I know to look at EDD's calculator.

0 coins

Just want to confirm what my situation turned out to be, employer not paying into SDI is not really a thing that affects your DI claim. It's the deduction from your own wages that matters. Went through all of this worry myself and that was the answer.

0 coins

Seeing that confirmed again from someone who worried about the same thing is really helpful. Thank you.

0 coins

Same conclusion I came to after reading the whole thread. Worker's deduction, not employer's.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure