Medi-Cal continuity of care denied after moving counties to care
Moved from Tulare County to Sacramento three months ago for a family situation and reported the new address right away through BenefitsCal. The inter-county transfer went through, my new BIC showed up eventually, and I thought everything was fine. Problem is I had a specialist I'd been seeing regularly through my old managed care plan. I asked the new county's plan to let me keep seeing her at least through my current course of treatment — figured there had to be some rule about that. Got a letter back saying the request was denied. No real explanation, just denied. I don't fully understand what I'm supposed to do now. Do I have a right to keep seeing my old specialist even if the plan says no? Is there an appeal? Who do I even contact — the county or the health plan? I've had this care for over a year and stopping it in the middle feels really wrong. Any help appreciated.
84 comments

Brianna Muhammad
About two weeks after my inter-county transfer completed, the new BIC I was expecting still hadn't come and I had an appointment I didn't want to cancel. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time while I was at work, then talked to a county worker who checked the case and confirmed the new BIC had been mailed four days earlier. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g On the continuity of care question — the plan's denial letter should have come with information about how to appeal it. That appeal goes to the plan itself, not the county. You have 60 days from the date on the plan's denial letter to file. The plan has to answer within 30 days after that. If you're still unhappy after the plan responds, you can ask for a State Fair Hearing within 120 days of the plan's decision. The Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman at 1-888-452-8609 can also help you push back on the plan if you're not sure where to start.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorSixty days from the denial letter date — I need to check when that was. I didn't realize the appeal goes to the plan and not the county. The Ombudsman number is something I hadn't heard of before. Really helpful to know there's a separate office for plan problems.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
Appeals to the plan within 60 days is exactly right. I went through a plan denial last year on a referral and missed that it was the plan handling appeals, not the county office. Spent a week calling the wrong number.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
Two months into my own transfer mess and nobody told me about the Ombudsman line either. Adding it to my contacts now.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
The denial letter is the key document here. Even if the reason feels vague, there's usually a code or a phrase on it that tells you what the plan based it on. If you can't find the reason or the appeal instructions, call the plan's member services line and ask them to explain the denial in writing. That request itself can sometimes shake things loose before you even file a formal appeal.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorLooked at the letter again and there is a code on it I hadn't paid attention to. Going to call the plan's member services and ask what it means and whether there's anything else I need to submit with the appeal.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Asking for the denial reason in writing is a move I hadn't thought of. My plan sent me a vague letter two months back and I just accepted it. Might go back and do the same thing even now.
0 coins
LongPeri
Member services lines for managed care plans can have their own long holds. Worth knowing the Ombudsman number exists as a backup if member services isn't giving you answers.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
The confusion between the county and the health plan is real. The county decides if you're eligible for Medi-Cal. Everything about what care you get and whether a referral or provider gets approved — that's the managed care plan's side. So for a continuity of care denial, the county office can't override it. The appeal path is entirely within the plan until you get to a State Fair Hearing.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorThat distinction makes a lot more sense now. I was calling the county office and they kept redirecting me, which was frustrating. Now I understand why — it really is the plan's call.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
My first year on Medi-Cal I thought the county and the health plan were the same thing. Took a denial to figure out they're completely separate. The plan handles all the coverage questions once eligibility is set.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
State Fair Hearings are the other lever here. Even after the plan denies the appeal, that option is still on the table within 120 days of the plan's decision. Good to lay that out clearly.
0 coins
Liv Park
My plan pulled a similar move on a provider I'd had for two years. What I did was get my doctor to write a letter explaining why interrupting care at that point would affect treatment. I submitted it with the appeal and the plan reversed the denial. No promises that works in every case but the clinical reasoning letter made the difference for me.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorGetting something from my specialist in writing is actually something I hadn't thought to ask for. She's been treating me long enough that she could explain why stopping mid-treatment is a problem. I'm going to ask her office about that this week.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
A letter from the treating provider explaining medical necessity seems to carry weight with plan appeals. My sister-in-law's doctor did the same thing for a denied referral and it got reversed on the first try.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Specialist letters do help but not always. Mine submitted one and the plan still said no the first time. Had to go to the State Fair Hearing stage before anything moved.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
PLEASE keep track of every date on those letters. The 60 days to appeal starts from the date PRINTED on the denial, not the date you got it in the mail. I let that slip once and found out I was closer to the deadline than I thought. Write it on the envelope when it arrives so you have both dates.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorAlready went back and checked — the letter is dated about two and a half weeks ago so I still have time. Marking the deadline on my calendar right now.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Date on the letter not the date it arrives — that tripped me up too. Mailed my appeal thinking I had a week left and it turned out to be three days by the printed date. Got it in just under.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
After my own plan denial I called member services to confirm receipt of my appeal. Didn't want any question about whether it arrived.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
Something to also look at: when you moved counties, did you pick your new managed care plan or did the state assign one? If you were auto-assigned and you hadn't yet made a choice, you might be able to switch plans through Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263. A different plan in Sacramento might have a broader provider network. That doesn't fix the current denial but it's worth knowing for going forward.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorThey assigned me automatically and I didn't know I had a choice. I'll look into what plans are available in Sacramento and whether any of them have a network that fits my care better. Didn't realize Health Care Options was a number I could call to change that.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Auto-assignment happened to me too during my transfer. Health Care Options let me switch within the first 30 days. If that window passed they said I'd have to wait for the annual enrollment period or a qualifying change.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
Provider network differences between plans in the same county can be significant. Worth checking if your specialist is in-network under any of the other plan options before you commit to staying with the assigned one.
0 coins
Raúl Mora
Looking at the share of cost on my notice was something I kept putting off after my own county transfer, and it turned out the amount had changed in the new county without anyone flagging it for me. I let Claimyr wait on the hold for Sacramento's line and the worker pulled up the notice and read me the share of cost figure the new county had on file. Worker said it reflected the updated household information the new county processed after the transfer. On your situation — the State Fair Hearing path is there if the plan appeal doesn't go your way. The request has to go in within 90 days of the date on the county's Notice of Action if it's an eligibility matter, or within 120 days of the plan's decision if it's a plan denial like yours. Those are two separate timelines for two different kinds of decisions.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorThe share of cost piece is something I should double-check too — my new county notice looked different from what Tulare sent and I assumed it was just formatting. Good point that the numbers could have changed in the transfer.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
120 days after the plan's decision for a State Fair Hearing, not 90 — that's the number I always mix up. Good to see it laid out clearly alongside the 90-day one for county eligibility decisions.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
After a plan denial I went straight to asking for a hearing without trying the plan appeal first. The hearing officer actually asked why I hadn't done the plan's own process first. Probably better to go through the plan's appeal before escalating.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
To be clear on the State Fair Hearing process since it came up: you can request one through the county office, by calling 1-800-743-8525, or online through the California Department of Social Services website. The hearing is in front of a judge who doesn't work for the county or the plan, done either in person or by phone. That independence from both the county and the plan is what makes it the right last step if the plan appeal doesn't resolve things.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorHaving the hearing in front of someone who doesn't work for the county or the plan actually makes me feel better about that option as a last resort. I didn't know it was an independent judge.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
The 1-800-743-8525 number is good to have. I didn't know you could request a hearing by phone — I thought you had to go in person or mail something.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Independent hearing officer matters a lot. My neighbor went through one for an eligibility denial and said the judge was genuinely impartial, asked questions of both sides.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
For the Ombudsman route — when I had a managed care dispute I called 1-888-452-8609 and an Ombudsman staff member actually helped me put the appeal letter together in a way that addressed exactly what the plan needed to see. They don't make decisions but they know how the plans are supposed to handle these requests and they can tell you if the plan is not following the right process.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorUsing the Ombudsman to help draft the appeal letter is something I hadn't thought of. If I struggle putting together the right language I'll try calling them first.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Didn't know the Ombudsman could help write the appeal, thought they were just a complaint line. That changes how useful that number is.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Knowing that Ombudsman staff understand how the plan process is supposed to work is reassuring. Sometimes you're dealing with a denial and you're not sure if the plan is even following its own rules.
0 coins
LongPeri
Moving counties and changing plans at the same time is genuinely a lot to navigate. The old plan closes out when the transfer goes through — your Tulare plan ended on the last day of the month the transfer completed. Any appeal about that old plan's coverage is separate from what you can do through the new Sacramento plan. Just want to make sure nobody conflates the two, because the timelines and the contact numbers are completely different.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorThat's a good clarification — I was a little fuzzy on whether my old plan had any role in this or if it was entirely the new plan's decision. Sounds like it's all Sacramento now.
0 coins
Liv Park
Last month of the old plan ending on transfer completion is important. I thought mine had an overlap and tried to use it. It didn't go through, and I had to sort it out with the new plan instead.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Old plan ends clean on the transfer date. New plan questions go to the new plan exclusively. That's clearer than any of the paperwork I got when I moved counties made it sound.
0 coins
Henrietta Beasley
Application timing tripped me up after I moved. I wasn't sure if Sacramento's office had received my transfer paperwork or was treating it as a new application. I had Claimyr wait through the hold on Sacramento's line — 1-800-560-0976 — and the worker confirmed the county had the transfer application date on file from the week I submitted it in BenefitsCal. That was the detail I needed to know my place in the timeline was right. For the continuity question: even if the plan denied it, the treating provider sometimes has a way to submit a continuity of care request directly through the plan's provider portal. It's worth asking your specialist's office if they're willing to submit on their end. Plans sometimes process those differently from member-initiated appeals.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorAsking my specialist's office to submit directly is worth trying alongside the member appeal. I hadn't thought of approaching it from the provider's side.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
Provider-side submissions can move faster through the plan's internal routing in some cases. No guarantee but it's another channel worth opening at the same time as the member appeal, not instead of it.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
Phoning the county to confirm the transfer paperwork date was smart. I assumed mine was fine until a renewal notice came to my old address two months after the move.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
What county did your specialist practice in? If she's actually located in Sacramento County she might already be in-network on your new plan or could be added. It's worth asking member services specifically whether she can be added as an in-network provider for a continuity of care transition period, separate from whatever the formal appeal says.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorShe's actually in Tulare County, which is probably the core of the problem. If she were in Sacramento it might be simpler. But the question about adding her even temporarily for a transition period is something I can ask member services specifically.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
In-network vs. out of county is a big factor for continuity of care requests. Plans in Sacramento have networks built around Sacramento-area providers. A specialist in another county is a harder ask, which is probably why the denial came back quickly.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
Even if the plan can't add her as a network provider permanently, some continuity of care rules allow the plan to authorize out-of-network care for a set transition period. That's the specific thing to ask the plan about — not just whether she's in-network but whether a temporary authorization is possible.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
Are you sure the denial came from the managed care plan and not from the county? I ask because when I moved, I got two separate letters around the same time and I mixed them up at first. One was from the county about eligibility and one was from the plan about a coverage request. If yours is actually a county eligibility decision rather than a plan decision, the timelines and the appeal path are different — 90 days to the county for a State Fair Hearing instead of 60 days to the plan.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorLooked again — the letter has the plan's logo and name on it, not the county's. So it is definitely from the plan. But that's a really important distinction and I could see how easy it is to mix those up when they arrive at the same time.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
Two letters at once is a stressful way to find out you have two separate processes to track. I taped both of mine to the fridge so I didn't lose one.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
The logo check is a fast way to sort them. County letters come from the county office and plans send their own. If you're ever unsure, the phone numbers on the letters will tell you — plan member services numbers are different from the county's Medi-Cal line.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
Not sure if this helps but when I had a continuity of care issue the plan told me to have my doctor submit clinical notes along with the request showing active treatment — not just a letter saying I'd been a patient. Active treatment documentation made it harder for the plan to call it elective or easily transferable. Ask your specialist for visit notes from the last few months, not just a general letter.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorClinical notes from the actual visits versus a general letter — that's a more specific ask than what I had in mind. I'll request those along with whatever letter she can write.
0 coins
Liv Park
Active treatment documentation is exactly what the plan wanted when they reviewed mine. The letter alone didn't do it; the visit notes from the prior three months were what the plan's reviewer actually looked at.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Clinical notes and a letter both together is the stronger package. I sent one without the other on my first appeal and had to resubmit.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Medi-Cal Dental Program is at 1-800-322-6384 if any of your treatment involves dental care — they handle that separately from the managed care plan. Prescriptions go through Medi-Cal Rx at 1-800-977-2273. I bring it up because sometimes people assume the managed care plan handles everything and then get confused when dental or prescriptions go through a different channel.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorMy situation is a medical specialist so the managed care plan is the right path. But good to know about those separate numbers in case dental ever becomes a question.
0 coins
JaylinCharles
Medi-Cal Rx being separate from the managed care plan tripped me up with a prescription right after my transfer. The plan's phone number couldn't answer questions about it — had to call Medi-Cal Rx directly.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Dental being completely separate from the managed care plan was news to me when I first got on Medi-Cal. Spent a whole day calling the wrong number.
0 coins
AaliyahAli
Step back for a second: have you actually talked to your specialist about what happens on her end? Providers sometimes have agreements or prior arrangements with certain plans that let them see patients even during a transition. Her billing staff might already know if there's a path for temporary out-of-network authorization that bypasses the standard member appeal.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorI've been focused on the plan side and haven't fully looped in my specialist's billing staff about the authorization question. Going to call her office tomorrow and ask what they can see on their end.
0 coins
Margot Quinn
Billing staff at specialist offices deal with these plan authorization questions constantly. They often know exactly who to call at the plan and what documentation that reviewer actually wants.
0 coins
Arjun Kurti
My specialist's office handled the entire prior authorization appeal on my behalf when I moved plans. I didn't know that was something providers could do until they offered.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
If the appeal doesn't go well and you do end up needing to find a new specialist in Sacramento, ask the new plan for its provider directory and specifically ask whether the new provider can get your full treatment history from the old specialist. Continuity of care in a broader sense means the information travels even when the provider doesn't. Your old specialist's office can send records to whoever takes over.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorRecords transferring even if the provider doesn't — that's a helpful way to frame what continuity of care means in the worst case. I'm still going to fight for the same specialist but it's good to think about the fallback.
0 coins
LongPeri
Records requests sometimes take a few weeks. If you're at all worried about losing continuity during the appeal, asking your old specialist to send records to a Sacramento-area provider as a backup plan makes sense.
0 coins
Diego Fisher
The plan's provider directory for Sacramento should be requestable by phone or through the plan's member portal. It's worth getting a copy even while the appeal is in process so you're not scrambling if you need to find someone fast.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
BEEN THERE. The letter says denied and you feel like that's the end but it's NOT. I went through two full rounds of plan appeals on a specialist situation after a county transfer and the second one got reversed. The process is exhausting and the hold times on member services are real, but the State Fair Hearing option means the plan can't just say no forever without a real answer. Keep copies of everything you send.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorTwo rounds before a reversal — that's discouraging but also reassuring that it can still turn around. I'm keeping copies of everything from here on.
0 coins
Freya Collins
Keeping copies of every piece of paper you send and every letter you get is the most practical advice in this whole thread. I lost a letter once and it delayed my appeal by weeks.
0 coins
Sara Hellquiem
The plan cannot stall indefinitely — they have to answer within 30 days of a formal appeal. If they miss their own deadline that's something to bring up with the Ombudsman.
0 coins
Theodore Nelson
Just want to add that BenefitsCal at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login lets you see your renewal due date and report changes, but for the plan appeal specifically you're going outside of BenefitsCal entirely. The plan has its own process, its own address, and its own deadlines. BenefitsCal is the county's system; the managed care plan is separate. Don't assume submitting something in BenefitsCal gets to the plan.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorI had been wondering if I could do anything through BenefitsCal for the plan appeal. Good to know it's completely separate and I need to go directly to the plan.
0 coins
Lucas Schmidt
County system and plan system are two completely different tracks. I made the mistake of uploading a document to BenefitsCal thinking it would get to my plan and it didn't. Plan appeals go to the plan's own mailing address or fax number on the denial letter.
0 coins
Ellie Simpson
The denial letter should have an address or fax for submitting the appeal. If it doesn't, ask member services where to send it in writing, and ask them to confirm receipt after you do.
0 coins
Freya Collins
How long ago did you move exactly? Asking because if you're still within a few months of the transfer completing, the Ombudsman and the plan appeal are your main tools right now. But if you've been in Sacramento long enough that your first annual renewal is coming up in BenefitsCal, that's another form to track. BenefitsCal will show the due date. Missing it can end coverage entirely regardless of what's happening with the plan appeal.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorAbout three months since the transfer completed. Went into BenefitsCal and checked — my renewal isn't due for several more months, so that's not an immediate pressure. But I would not have thought to check that while dealing with the plan appeal.
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
Renewal and plan appeal running at the same time would be a lot to manage. Good that the renewal isn't right on top of the appeal deadline in this case.
0 coins
Oscar O'Neil
Yellow envelope for the renewal comes separately from any plan letters. The due date in BenefitsCal is the number to watch. If you haven't set up the account there, it's worth doing just to track that date.
0 coins
Eloise Kendrick
Final thought from me — the 60 days to appeal and 120 days for a hearing are real limits and they don't bend much. But within those windows you have more options than the denial letter makes it look like. Ombudsman, provider-side request, the formal appeal with clinical notes, and ultimately the hearing. Each one is a separate shot. Use as many as you can in parallel, not sequentially waiting for one to fail before you try the next.
0 coins
Camila Castillo
AuthorRunning them in parallel instead of waiting for each to fail before trying the next — that's the mindset shift I needed. I was thinking of these as a strict one-at-a-time sequence.
0 coins
Charlee Coleman
Parallel tracks is exactly right. The formal appeal, the Ombudsman call, and the provider-side submission can all be in motion at the same time. Nothing says you have to wait on one before starting another.
0 coins
Evelyn Kim
Agree with that. And document every step — who you called, what date, what they told you. If you end up at a State Fair Hearing, that log matters.
0 coins