Medi-Cal and Medicare surgery not accepted by surgeon how to get covered
My dad is 72 and has both Medi-Cal and Medicare Part A and B. He needs a pretty involved knee replacement and we finally found a surgeon we really like who his primary care doc recommended. Called the surgeon's office to schedule the pre-op consult and they told us they don't accept Medi-Cal. They take Medicare but not the Medi-Cal part. Dad's Notice of Action from earlier this year doesn't mention any share of cost so I think he's on full-scope. We're kind of stuck because his knee is getting worse and this is the surgeon his doctor said would be the right fit. Do we have to find a completely different surgeon, or is there some way to get the surgery covered anyway? He's in Tulare County if that matters.
78 comments

CosmicCrusader
Your dad having Medicare plus Medi-Cal is actually a setup where Medicare pays first and Medi-Cal picks up what's left. The surgeon saying no to Medi-Cal means they won't bill Medi-Cal for whatever Medicare doesn't cover, which is usually the coinsurance and deductible. Some surgeons just don't want to deal with the Medi-Cal billing side even when they're fine with Medicare. The first call I'd make is to his managed care plan — the plan assigned through Medi-Cal — and ask them whether they have an in-network surgeon who does knee replacements and also takes both. His plan's member services number is on his BIC.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHe does have a managed care plan card. We haven't called them yet because we were focused on the surgeon his primary care referred. So the plan might have a surgeon that takes both Medicare and Medi-Cal on their list?
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Exactly — ask the plan for a list of orthopedic surgeons who are in network. Some take both and some only Medicare. The plan can tell you which is which. And if there's truly no one in network who does that procedure, the plan has a process to get an out-of-network exception, which is worth asking about.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
I thought if a surgeon takes Medicare they have to take Medi-Cal too? That's not how it works?
0 coins
Diego Flores
They're separate programs with separate enrollment. A provider can be enrolled with Medicare but not with Medi-Cal, so they can legally accept one and not the other. Your dad's plan is the right place to start.
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
Coverage ended on my case last spring because I missed the renewal envelope, and I spent three weeks trying to get through on the phone to find out exactly what was still missing before the 90-day window closed. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with the county's Medi-Cal line so you end up talking to a live worker. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The worker I reached told me exactly which documents were still outstanding on my case and confirmed how many days I had left in the 90-day window. I got those documents in through BenefitsCal the same afternoon.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorThat 90-day thing — does it apply to my dad's situation if the surgeon issue somehow causes a gap in his coverage?
0 coins
Anastasia Kozlov
The 90 days is for when Medi-Cal ends because a renewal wasn't completed. It lets you submit what was missing and get coverage reinstated without starting over. Your dad's situation sounds different — his coverage is active, so that particular window doesn't come into it. The managed care plan route the person above mentioned is probably more relevant for him.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
Waiting 3 weeks on hold sounds exhausting. I've been putting off calling my county office because I assume it'll be the same thing.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
60 days from the date on the plan's denial notice — that's the number that jumped out at me when my dad's plan denied a procedure last year. You have 60 days from that date to file an appeal with the plan. They then have 30 days to give you an answer. If they still say no after that, you can ask for a State Fair Hearing within 120 days of the plan's decision. The Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman at 1-888-452-8609 also helps when you're stuck with a plan problem.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHas your dad's plan actually denied anything yet, or did you go through this after the surgeon refused?
0 coins
Zara Mirza
The surgeon refusing and the plan issuing a denial are two different things. We went through it after we got an actual denial notice from the plan on a specific procedure. If your dad's plan hasn't formally denied anything yet, start with what the first commenter said — call member services and ask who in network does knee replacements. The appeal process kicks in after a formal denial, not after a surgeon's front desk says they don't bill Medi-Cal.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
My mom's plan denied something and I had no idea there was a hearing option beyond appealing the plan itself. The 120 days after the plan's final decision is good to know.
0 coins
Luca Russo
Fee-for-Service is worth asking about too. If your dad isn't locked into a managed care plan in his county, or if there's a temporary window, some providers bill Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal directly rather than through a plan. The provider's office would know whether they take Fee-for-Service. It doesn't solve the original surgeon issue but it might open up more options when you're calling around.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHis BIC has a plan name on it, so I think he's assigned to a plan. Would he still be able to use Fee-for-Service for some things?
0 coins
Luca Russo
Once you're in a managed care plan, most of your care runs through that plan. There can be exceptions for certain services, but member services or his primary care doctor would know whether this surgery qualifies as one. I wouldn't assume it, just ask.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
Didn't know fee for service was even still a thing for people on a plan. Learned something today.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
The surgeon his primary care recommended — did his primary care office know the surgeon doesn't take Medi-Cal when they made the referral? I ask because sometimes the primary care gives a name without checking whether that provider takes both. If you go back to his primary care and explain the situation, they might have a second name on their list who does take both. We went through this with my uncle's situation last year and the primary care actually came up with someone different once we explained the coverage issue.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHonestly, I don't think they checked. They said go see this surgeon and we just assumed. Going back to the primary care with that specific question makes sense.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
Worth calling the primary care's office and asking them to look for someone who is in network with both Medicare and his Medi-Cal plan. They deal with these referrals all the time and usually have a list they work from.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
Primary care offices sometimes just go off their old referral lists and don't always check current network status. Definitely worth asking them to verify before you spend time scheduling with someone new.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
I want to flag one thing — when you say the surgeon doesn't accept Medi-Cal, make sure you're clear on whether they mean they're not enrolled with Medi-Cal at all, or whether they're not in network with your dad's specific managed care plan. Those are slightly different problems. A surgeon who isn't enrolled with Medi-Cal at all won't bill Medi-Cal for anything. But a surgeon who's enrolled with Medi-Cal but just not in your dad's plan might still be reachable through an out-of-network authorization from the plan, which the plan can explain.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHow would I even find out which of those it is? The front desk just said 'we don't take Medi-Cal.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
Ask them directly: are you enrolled with Medi-Cal at all, or just not contracted with this specific health plan? If they say they don't deal with Medi-Cal at all, that's one situation. If they say they're not in this plan's network, that's another, and your dad's plan might be able to authorize a referral out of network for specialized care.
0 coins
AstroAce
I had no idea there was a difference between those two situations. Assumed it all meant the same thing.
0 coins
Yuki Kobayashi
Three months of unpaid bills from before my coverage started were sitting on my account, and I wanted to know whether a request for retroactive Medi-Cal had been recorded on my case. I had Claimyr wait on hold with the county line while I was at work, and when I got on with the county worker she confirmed the request was in the system and told me which months were under review. She also said the county would mail me a Notice of Action once a decision was made and to read it carefully and ask for a State Fair Hearing within 90 days of its date if I disagreed with any part of it.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
Retroactive coverage going back three months — does that mean even before you applied?
0 coins
Yuki Kobayashi
Up to three months before the application date, as long as you qualified in those months. I had to ask the county to look into those earlier months specifically; it doesn't happen automatically. The Notice of Action will tell me what they decided.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorMy dad doesn't have unpaid bills from before right now but this is good to know if something comes up during the gap while we're sorting out the surgeon situation.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
This whole thread is making me realize my mom's setup might have the same problem. She's 68 and has both Medicare and Medi-Cal and her doctor recently referred her to a specialist. We haven't called the specialist yet. Do people with both programs generally have more trouble finding providers who take both, or is it more of a surgery-specific thing?
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Specialists who take Medicare are common, but not all of them are also enrolled with Medi-Cal. Surgery tends to surface it more often because the billing is more complex. For routine specialist visits, many providers just bill Medicare and don't bill Medi-Cal for the remainder, so you might never notice an issue. The bigger lift is for procedures where there's significant cost-sharing that Medi-Cal would normally cover.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
So for the specialist visit she might be fine, but if the specialist then recommends a procedure it could get complicated?
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Possibly, yes. Worth asking the specialist's office upfront when you call whether they bill both programs, before you get deep into the process.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
DOES ANYONE KNOW if Medicare Advantage is different for this kind of situation?? My dad switched to Medicare Advantage a couple years back and I have no idea how that interacts with his Medi-Cal. The coordinator at his senior center said it's the same thing but it doesn't sound the same at all to me.
0 coins
Diego Flores
Medicare Advantage is a private plan that covers Medicare benefits, and how it interacts with Medi-Cal can be different from Original Medicare. The county and his Medicare Advantage plan would both need to be part of the conversation. DHCS has information on its site, and his county worker could clarify what his coverage looks like on the Medi-Cal side.
0 coins
Chloe Robinson
So the senior center coordinator was wrong? Or at least oversimplifying it?
0 coins
Diego Flores
Oversimplifying is the more charitable read. The day-to-day care might look similar on the surface but the billing and coordination rules aren't identical. Worth a call to his county office to make sure they have his Medicare Advantage plan information on file.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
This happened to us last year. My mother-in-law needed gallbladder surgery and the first two surgeons the hospital suggested didn't take her Medi-Cal plan. Her managed care plan's member services rep actually did a live search while we were on the phone and found a surgeon at a different hospital who was in network. Took about a week from that call to get the consult scheduled. The plan's member services line was actually useful once we knew what to ask for.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorDid you have to explain that it was urgent, or did they just do the search when you called?
0 coins
Nia Wilson
We explained that the other surgeons had declined and that her doctor had already said she needed the procedure. The rep took it seriously and searched while we were talking. I think being specific about why you're calling — that you have a referral but the surgeon doesn't take Medi-Cal — helps them understand what you actually need.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
That's a much better experience than I expected. I always assume plan member services will just tell you to look online yourself.
0 coins
AstroAce
I'm confused about something from earlier in this thread. Someone said Medi-Cal pays what Medicare doesn't. But if my dad has a share of cost on his Medi-Cal, would that change things for the surgery? The original poster said his dad has no share of cost but I have one on my case and I'm on Medicare too.
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
Your Notice of Action shows your share of cost amount. If you have one, it's what you pay or promise to pay the provider before Medi-Cal steps in for the rest. It resets every month, and it's paid to the provider, not to Medi-Cal directly. For a big procedure like surgery, that could matter a lot — the provider's billing office and your plan's member services can both explain how it works for a specific procedure.
0 coins
AstroAce
The amount on my notice felt like a lot when I first saw it. Good to know it only applies in months when I actually get care.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
45 days from when I submitted my application — that's the date I had circled on my calendar because I'd heard nothing, no Notice of Action, no BIC, nothing at all. I called the county over and over and the line just rang or put me on hold for an hour. I finally got through on a day I took off work and the worker told me the application was still in review and to watch for the NOA by mail.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHow many days after that call did your NOA actually arrive?
0 coins
NebulaNinja
About two weeks after. The letter said I was approved and my BIC came a few days after that. The hardest part was just not knowing while I waited.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
Two weeks after the 45-day mark — so over 7 weeks total? That feels like a long time to be in the dark.
0 coins
NebulaNinja
It was. And I found out later I could have asked for a State Fair Hearing after the 45 days passed with no letter. I didn't know that was an option at the time.
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
A State Fair Hearing date I'd requested came up faster than I expected, and I wanted to confirm the county had actually received my request before I did anything else to prepare. I let Claimyr handle the hold and ended up talking to a county worker who confirmed the hearing request was on file and told me the county would mail me a Notice of Action with the details and to contact the county eligibility worker first if I wanted to try to resolve it before the hearing date.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorIf we end up appealing the plan's decision on Dad's surgery, is a State Fair Hearing something we'd request through the county or through the plan?
0 coins
Andre Rousseau
The appeal goes to the plan first, within 60 days of their denial notice. After the plan's final decision, you can ask for a State Fair Hearing within 120 days of that. Requests go through the county office, by phone at 1-800-743-8525, or through the California Department of Social Services online. The hearing is before a judge who doesn't work for the county or for the plan.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
The Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman — 1-888-452-8609 — is also worth contacting before you go all the way to a hearing. They specifically help with plan disputes and sometimes can resolve things faster.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
My neighbor told me that if a surgeon doesn't take Medi-Cal you can just not tell them about it and use Medicare only. I really doubt that's right but she was pretty sure.
0 coins
Diego Flores
Other health coverage has to be reported — to DHCS and to the provider. It's not optional. The provider is supposed to know about all coverage so they can bill correctly. And withholding that information could cause billing problems down the line that are much harder to fix than finding the right surgeon now.
0 coins
Carmen Vega
Yeah that didn't sound right to me either. I'll tell her not to try it.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
Exactly right. Both programs need to know about each other. The right path is finding a surgeon who takes both, or going through the managed care plan to get an authorization. Not hiding coverage.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
The date on the Notice of Action I got last month caught me off guard — it said my coverage had ended two weeks earlier, so I had less time than I thought to respond. I let Claimyr wait on hold with the county and spoke to a worker who confirmed the NOA's date and told me the county would need my renewal form and two specific documents before they could act on the 90-day window. I submitted through BenefitsCal that same evening.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorThe 90-day window counting from the NOA date and not the day you got the letter seems like a trap for people who live somewhere mail is slow or who travel.
0 coins
Zoe Stavros
It really is. The county goes by the date printed on the notice, so the sooner you open your mail and check BenefitsCal for any notices, the more of that window you actually have.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
Always open those yellow envelopes right away. I learned that the hard way when my own renewal notice sat under a stack of junk mail for almost two weeks.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
Going back to the original question — if the plan authorizes care with an out-of-network surgeon, does that mean the plan actually pays that surgeon directly, or does the member have to pay and then get reimbursed? I've never understood how out-of-network authorization actually works financially.
0 coins
CosmicCrusader
How the plan pays an out-of-network authorized provider is something to ask the plan's member services directly when you request the authorization. The plan can explain their own process. I wouldn't assume anything about the payment flow until you hear it from them.
0 coins
Aisha Mahmood
Makes sense. So the authorization question and the payment question are both things to ask member services in the same call.
0 coins
Luca Russo
BenefitsCal is worth checking for any pending action items on your dad's case, like whether the county is waiting for anything from him. If there's something flagged there that he hasn't responded to, that could complicate things. The login is at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHis account shows active coverage and no pending items as far as we can tell. The issue is purely the surgeon not accepting Medi-Cal, not anything on the county's end.
0 coins
Luca Russo
Good — that's actually the best starting position. Active coverage with nothing pending means the focus really is just on finding the right provider or getting the plan to authorize. No county paperwork issue to untangle first.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
Has your dad tried calling his health plan's member services and just asking them to find him an in-network orthopedic surgeon who does knee replacements? I know it sounds basic but sometimes just asking that specific question gets you further than trying to figure out the network status yourself by calling individual offices.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorWe haven't done that yet. We've been focused on trying to make the original surgeon work. I think we'll start there — call the plan and ask them to point us to someone who does both.
0 coins
Nia Wilson
That's the most direct path. If the plan can't find anyone in network for that specific procedure, that actually strengthens your case if you need to request an out-of-network exception.
0 coins
AstroAce
Didn't realize a plan's inability to find someone in network could actually help you get an exception approved. That's a useful thing to know going in.
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
DHCS's Medi-Cal Help Center has general information on how Medi-Cal works with Medicare, and you can reach Medi-Cal at 1-800-541-5555 if you want a general question answered on the state level. For the surgery specifically though, the managed care plan is really the right first call because they're the ones who have to authorize it.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorShould we call the plan or DHCS first? Or does it matter?
0 coins
Mateo Sanchez
Plan first, without question. DHCS can answer general questions but they can't authorize a specific procedure for a specific member — that's the plan's job. DHCS is more useful if you end up with a problem the plan isn't resolving and you need to escalate.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
Coming at this from another angle — has your dad's primary care already submitted a formal referral, or did they just verbally recommend the surgeon? A written referral through the plan is different from just being told to call a certain doctor. If the plan hasn't received a referral request yet, starting that process formally might open up more options because the plan would be involved from the beginning.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
AuthorHis primary care gave us the name verbally. We called the surgeon's office ourselves. So no formal referral paperwork went through the plan at all.
0 coins
Ethan Clark
That's worth fixing. Ask the primary care to submit a referral request through your dad's managed care plan. Once the plan is in the loop, they can either confirm an in-network surgeon who does the procedure or start the process for an exception if needed. The plan being involved formally is different from you calling around on your own.
0 coins
Zara Mirza
A formal referral through the plan also creates a paper trail that matters if you end up needing to appeal anything later. Definitely the right move.
0 coins