Back to Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim)

Fatima Al-Suwaidi

Got Medi-Cal card but letters say not eligible due to income

So I'm genuinely confused and kind of panicking a little. My BIC showed up in the mail about three weeks ago and I was relieved, used it at the pharmacy once and it went through fine. Then two days later I get a Notice of Action saying I'm not eligible because my income is too high. How does that even happen? I reported my hours correctly when I applied — I work part time at a grocery store, usually around 25 hours a week, and my pay varies a little depending on the schedule. Did the county use the wrong pay period or something? Do I actually have coverage right now or not? My next prescription refill is in about a week and I don't know if the card is still going to work. I went into BenefitsCal and the status just says pending which isn't helping me understand anything. Has anyone dealt with getting the card and then getting a denial letter at the same time?

Renewal form came back due faster than I expected last spring, and by the time I actually read it carefully the county had already sent an end notice. I had let it sit while dealing with some stuff at home and by the time I looked at the date on the envelope, the deadline had passed. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to my county's Medi-Cal line — Claimyr waits on hold for you so you end up talking to a live county worker. The worker pulled up my case and told me the renewal form had never been marked received, and gave me the exact due date still on file so I knew how many days I had left in the 90-day window. Video on getting a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. I sent the form in that same afternoon with everything they were waiting for and the county reinstated without a gap.

0 coins

Wait, the form had never been marked received even though you sent it? That's the part I'd be most stressed about. Did they say anything about why it wasn't showing up on their end?

0 coins

The worker just said it wasn't recorded and gave me the date — they don't get into what happened on their side. I took the date and moved on, got the form in again and that was that.

0 coins

The 90-day window after coverage ends is real and not a lot of people know about it. If you give the county what it was waiting for in those 90 days and you still qualify, they put the coverage back like it never lapsed. After that it's a whole new application.

0 coins

Ok so the 90 days is from when coverage actually ended, not from when the NOA is dated?

0 coins

The Notice of Action gives you the date coverage ended, and that's the clock you go by. The letter itself may arrive a few days after the date on it, so read it carefully as soon as you get it.

0 coins

The card showing up and then a denial letter landing the same week sounds like timing on the county's end. What can happen is the approval goes through, they mail the BIC, and then a review catches something on the case — income information doesn't match what the county expected, or a pay stub covered a different period — and they send an NOA. The card being in your hand doesn't lock in the coverage if the county then finds you don't qualify. The notice itself will say the specific reason and there should be a date by which you can ask for a State Fair Hearing if you think it's wrong.

0 coins

The notice says income too high but the amount they listed for my monthly income looks way off. It's higher than what I actually make. Would the county have used an annualized number from one pay stub or something?

0 coins

Annualizing one pay stub is exactly what can trip people up. If you got paid for a week where you worked extra hours and the county multiplied that out to get a yearly figure, it could land higher than your real average. Bring your last several pay stubs to the county office or upload them in BenefitsCal and ask the county to look at the income again.

0 coins

Happened to me too with an hourly job. The county used one stub from a week I picked up a ton of overtime and my income came out looking way higher than normal. Getting them the last three or four stubs fixed it.

0 coins

I didn't even think about them annualizing from a single stub. I'll pull all of mine together.

0 coins

The State Fair Hearing option on that NOA is important. You have 90 days from the date on the Notice of Action to ask for one if you disagree with their income calculation. You can call the number on the back of the notice or ask the county office to file it. The hearing is in front of a judge who doesn't work for the county, so it's separate from whatever your worker decides day to day.

0 coins

Is the hearing only if the county won't fix it, or can I request one while I'm also trying to get the county to look at my stubs again?

0 coins

You can do both at the same time. Send the county your stubs and ask them to review the income, and also file for the hearing so the 90-day window stays open. If the county fixes it before the hearing date you can withdraw the hearing request.

0 coins

Filing for the hearing while still talking to the county is smart. I didn't know you could do that and I let the deadline slip thinking they'd just fix it on their own.

0 coins

Does the BIC actually stop working the day the NOA says you're not eligible, or does it run until end of the month? Because you said your refill is in a week and I'd want to know exactly what day to plan around.

0 coins

Coverage typically ends at the end of the month named on the Notice of Action, not mid-month. Read the notice closely — it should say something like 'coverage will end' on a specific date, usually the last day of a month.

0 coins

The notice says end of this month, so I have about 10 days. That's enough for the refill but I need to figure out the income dispute fast.

0 coins

Ten days is tight but workable if you get your stubs to the county right away. Don't wait on that.

0 coins

I went through a similar thing where my pay changed between when I applied and when the county processed everything. The income on file was from my application date, not what I was actually making when they reviewed it. Worth double-checking whether the amount on the NOA matches what you reported on your application or if it's something else entirely.

0 coins

The number on the NOA is definitely higher than what I put on my application. So either they recalculated it somehow or something got mixed up.

0 coins

If it's higher than what you wrote on the application, that's worth flagging directly with the county. Could be a data entry issue or they pulled a wage match from somewhere. Your stubs are your best evidence.

0 coins

Wage matches from employment records can sometimes pull a different period than you'd expect. Having your actual stubs on hand is the only way to show what your real hours looked like.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused — if the BIC already came does that mean you got approved once and now they're taking it back? I thought once you got the card you were covered

0 coins

Approval and the BIC going out can happen before all the verifications finish on the county's end. If a review after the fact shows income over the limit, they can send an NOA that ends the coverage. It's frustrating but the BIC arriving doesn't mean the case is permanently settled.

0 coins

oh wow I had no idea they could do that. I always thought getting the card meant you were good

0 coins

The Notice of Action is what officially establishes eligibility, not the card itself. If the NOA says not eligible, that's the county's formal decision, and the hearing is how you challenge it.

0 coins

Are you sure this isn't a Medicare issue? My mom got confused between Medi-Cal and Medicare letters and they come from different places and look really different

0 coins

No, I'm only 29, not on Medicare at all. This is definitely Medi-Cal, the notice has the county's name on it.

0 coins

ok sorry was just checking cause my mom had a whole mess with that. hope it gets sorted for you

0 coins

Medi-Cal and Medicare are two completely separate programs and you're right they come from different places. Medi-Cal for someone your age would be through the county, Medicare is federal and mostly for people 65 and older or with certain disabilities. Easy to mix up the names but very different programs.

0 coins

BIC question on my own case — mine never arrived after my renewal was processed, and I wasn't sure if the old one still worked or had been shut off. Claimyr got me on the line with a county worker, who looked up my case and confirmed a new BIC had been mailed and gave me the date it went out, so I knew to keep waiting and not use the old card.

0 coins

Did the worker say how long to wait after the date before calling the county again if it still doesn't show up?

0 coins

She just said to contact the county if it didn't arrive and didn't give a specific number of days. I figured I'd give it another week or so and then go to the office in person.

0 coins

Good to know the county can at least confirm whether a BIC was sent. If mine gets sorted out I'll want to make sure I'm getting the right card.

0 coins

Uploading documents in BenefitsCal is probably your fastest move right now. You can upload the pay stubs directly and add a note that the income figure on the NOA doesn't match your actual earnings. The county can see it in the system and it's faster than mailing anything.

0 coins

Is there a spot in BenefitsCal specifically for responding to an NOA or do I just upload the stubs under my regular documents?

0 coins

There's a way to submit documents and you can include a note with them. I'd also follow up by phone with the county office because uploading alone doesn't always trigger a quick review — a call makes sure someone is actually looking at it.

0 coins

Calling the county after uploading is the move. I uploaded documents once and waited two weeks with nothing happening, then called and the worker said the documents were there but the case hadn't been flagged for review.

0 coins

Share of cost question from my own situation — the amount printed on my Notice of Action seemed way higher than I expected based on my income and I couldn't tell if it was an error. I tried calling the county for a week and kept getting busy signals or long waits. Ended up using Claimyr to reach a worker, who pulled up my case and read me the share of cost figure that was actually on record, confirmed it matched the notice, and told me which income figure the county had used to calculate it.

0 coins

So the worker could actually see the income number they used? That's what I need — to find out where the high number on mine came from.

0 coins

Yes, the worker could see the amount on file for my income. They didn't explain how it was calculated but they told me the number, which helped me figure out where the difference was coming from.

0 coins

Knowing the exact income figure the county used is half the battle. Once you know what number they're working from you know exactly what stubs to bring in to correct it.

0 coins

Ten days is not a lot of time. I'd go into the county office in person with all your pay stubs from the last three months and ask them to review the income. Phone and BenefitsCal are fine but walking in with the documents is sometimes faster when you're up against a date.

0 coins

I've been hesitant to go in because the last time I went to a county office for something unrelated it was a two-hour wait. But you're right that I might not have a choice.

0 coins

Bring something to do and get there right when they open. It's not fun but having a worker look at your stubs while you're standing there is a lot cleaner than waiting to see if something uploaded gets reviewed in time.

0 coins

Going in person with documents is usually the most reliable when you need something reviewed fast. The in-person visit at least gets eyes on your stuff the same day.

0 coins

To be clear on the hearing deadline since a few people are asking — the 90 days runs from the date printed on the Notice of Action, not the day you receive it. So if the letter is dated a few days before you got it, you've already used some of those days. File sooner rather than later.

0 coins

Mine is dated five days before I got it so I've already burned five days on the clock. Filing right away.

0 coins

You can file for the hearing through the county office, by phone with the number on the NOA, or online through the California Department of Social Services. Getting it filed today protects the deadline no matter how long the review with the county takes.

0 coins

Application date came up as an issue on mine — I applied through BenefitsCal and when the 45 days passed with no NOA I wasn't sure if the county even had my application on file. I let Claimyr do the hold with the county line while I did other things, and once I had a worker on the phone she confirmed the application date in the system and said the county had it.

0 coins

Did they say anything about why it was taking so long past 45 days?

0 coins

The worker just said the application was in the system with its date — she didn't go into why it hadn't been decided yet. At least I knew it existed and wasn't lost.

0 coins

If 45 days pass with no NOA you can ask for a State Fair Hearing on the delay itself, separate from whatever the decision ends up being. Good to have confirmation the application is there though.

0 coins

Has the pharmacy been notified of anything or did the last refill go through without issues? Sometimes the pharmacy system picks up an eligibility change before you even get the letter.

0 coins

The last refill went through fine about a week before I got the letter. I haven't tried since so I don't know if it would still work today.

0 coins

If your coverage technically runs through end of the month per the NOA, it should still process. But if the county has already updated the system it might flag differently. Calling your pharmacy ahead of your pickup to confirm is a lot better than finding out at the counter.

0 coins

Calling the pharmacy first is a good call. They can run a quick eligibility check on their end before you make the trip.

0 coins

I want to flag one thing on the Covered California side because a couple people mentioned income being too high — if the income the county has on file for you actually does put you over the Medi-Cal limit and they can't fix the number, you might be able to get a plan through Covered California with premium help depending on where your income falls. The county's NOA sometimes mentions this. Not saying that's your situation but it's not a dead end if the dispute doesn't go your way.

0 coins

The notice does mention Covered California at the bottom actually. I'm hoping the income fix works but it's good to know that's there if not.

0 coins

Their number is 1-800-300-1506 or coveredca.com if it comes to that. They can tell you what you'd qualify for based on your actual income.

0 coins

Covered California is worth looking into as a backup plan. If your income really is over the Medi-Cal threshold, premium assistance there can still make coverage affordable.

0 coins

Does anyone know if you lose the managed care plan assignment too or just the BIC when coverage ends? I got assigned to a plan and don't know if that disappears the same day coverage ends.

0 coins

When coverage ends your managed care plan enrollment ends with it. The plan assignment is tied to your Medi-Cal eligibility, not something that stays on its own.

0 coins

So if the county reinstates coverage after I fix the renewal stuff, do I get put back in the same plan or start over picking?

0 coins

If coverage comes back through the 90-day fix with no gap, your plan should continue. If it's a whole new application, you'd go through plan selection again. The county can confirm which situation you're in.

0 coins

Three months of pay stubs is what the county usually wants to get a full picture of variable income. If you only send one or two they might still use the highest week. Send everything you have from the last three months so the average is clear.

0 coins

My hours really do bounce around week to week, so three months of stubs should show the real picture. I'll pull all of them.

0 coins

If your income varies that much, you can also ask the county about self-attesting or doing an employer letter if stubs alone are confusing. The county office can explain what format works best for a variable schedule.

0 coins

County office in Tulare County, the number is (800) 540-6880 if you're local and need to call in. I know lines get long but sometimes calling first to ask if you can drop documents off is faster than waiting in the lobby.

0 coins

Thank you, that's actually useful. I didn't have that number saved anywhere.

0 coins

You can also find it through DHCS's Find a County Office page if you need to double-check. Hours can vary so it's worth confirming when you call.

0 coins

Calling ahead to ask about document drop-off is a good idea I hadn't thought of. That could save you the whole lobby wait.

0 coins

Updating here in case it helps anyone reading later — once you file the State Fair Hearing request within those 90 days, the hearing itself is in front of a judge who isn't part of the county. You can present your pay stubs there the same way you would to the county, and the judge makes an independent decision. It's not as intimidating as it sounds, it can be done by phone.

0 coins

The by-phone option makes it a lot less scary honestly. I'll file for the hearing today and keep pushing with the county on the stubs at the same time.

0 coins

Filing both tracks at once is exactly the right move. You protect the deadline with the hearing and you give the county the chance to fix it without going that far.

0 coins

I didn't know the hearing could be by phone. That changes things for me too on a different case I've been avoiding dealing with.

0 coins

How long after you send in the stubs does the county usually take to look at them and send a new NOA? Just wondering because 10 days doesn't seem like a lot.

0 coins

There's no guaranteed timeframe for a document review — it depends on the county's workload. That's exactly why going in person or calling to make sure someone is actively looking at your case matters so much. Waiting and hoping isn't a good strategy when coverage is about to end.

0 coins

ugh that's what I was afraid of. No guaranteed timeframe means you just have to keep checking.

0 coins

Calling the county after you submit anything is always worth doing. It doesn't rush their process but it makes sure your case isn't just sitting unreviewed.

0 coins

Related posts

Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim) AI

Expert Assistant
Secure