Back to Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim)

Dylan Fisher

Does a Roth IRA count as an asset for Medi-Cal eligibility? Renewal coming up for my dad

My dad is 68 and his Medi-Cal renewal is coming up in a few months. He has a Roth IRA that he set up years ago but doesn't really touch, and also a regular savings account with some money in it. His house is paid off and he drives one car. Someone at his senior center told him that since the asset limits came back this year, the county is going to count his retirement account and he might lose coverage. Now he's panicking and asking me if he should close it or take the money out before the renewal form arrives. I don't want him to do something drastic without knowing whether the Roth IRA even matters for Medi-Cal. Does anyone know how retirement accounts are treated when the county checks assets at renewal? He's been on Medi-Cal for about two years and hasn't had any issues before this year.

About six weeks ago my BIC never arrived after my plan reassignment went through, so I had to get on the phone with the county to find out whether a new card had actually been sent. The hold times were brutal — tried three mornings in a row and kept getting cut off after 40-plus minutes. Eventually I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold for me, and I ended up talking to a county worker who pulled up my case and confirmed the new BIC had been sent out and gave me the date it was mailed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. Anyway, on your actual question — the asset limit is real for your dad's age group. The home he lives in and one vehicle don't count at all, so those are off the table. Where the retirement account lands is a bit more complicated and I honestly don't know the exact answer for a Roth specifically, so I'd have him ask his county worker directly when the renewal comes in.

0 coins

The card situation sounds frustrating, glad you got it sorted. And yeah that's what I figured — the house and car aren't the issue, it's really just whether the Roth gets counted. I'm going to have him hold off on doing anything drastic until we get more clarity.

0 coins

The hold time problem is real for anyone trying to reach the county. Spent almost an hour on hold last Tuesday and got nowhere, so good to know that worked for getting through about the BIC.

0 coins

My BIC took forever to arrive once too, I think the county sent it to an old address. Eventually showed up but it had me worried for a bit about whether I could use my coverage.

0 coins

The $130,000 figure surprised me when I first read about it — that's the limit for one person under the asset rules that came back January 1st this year, and each additional household member adds another $65,000 on top of that. What doesn't get counted is the home he lives in, one vehicle, household items, and retirement funds if he's taking regular payments from them. That last part is the piece relevant to your dad's Roth. The county looks at whether he's receiving regular payments from it, not just whether the account exists. If he isn't drawing from it yet, the county will make the determination at renewal — nobody here can tell you for certain how they'll count a Roth he isn't pulling from, so definitely have him ask the county worker directly or confirm it at the renewal appointment.

0 coins

He's not taking any payments from it, that's the thing. It just sits there. So whether 'regular payments' has to be happening for the exception to apply is exactly what we're unsure about.

0 coins

The 'regular payments' language is actually in the DHCS materials, so the question of whether a dormant Roth qualifies under that exception is a real one. I'd want the county to tell me specifically about my own account before I did anything.

0 coins

My mom ran into a similar question on her renewal — county worker told her to bring her most recent account statements to the appointment so they could see the exact balances and what kind of account it was. That's probably the safest move here too.

0 coins

Closing the account or withdrawing everything before the renewal sounds like a terrible idea without knowing what the tax situation looks like — but beyond that, it might not even help if the county looks at assets given away in a certain period before the renewal. I don't know if Medi-Cal has a lookback rule the same way nursing home coverage does, but I'd be very cautious about telling your dad to do anything to that account based on what someone said at a senior center. Get the renewal form, fill it out accurately, and ask the county worker what they need from him about the Roth specifically.

0 coins

Yeah that's my instinct too, do NOT touch anything until we know more. I don't want him to make a move that creates a bigger problem.

0 coins

The lookback thing — that's real but it's specifically for people going into a nursing home, not just for regular Medi-Cal renewal with asset limits. At least that's how I read the DHCS page. Worth confirming with the county either way before moving anything.

0 coins

The lookback for transfers only applies to nursing facility cases, not to the standard renewal for someone living at home. But closing a retirement account has tax consequences totally separate from Medi-Cal, which is another reason to not do it hastily.

0 coins

My dad is also 68 and I went through the asset question at his renewal a few months back. We were scared about his savings account most of all. The worker asked us to report everything — checking, savings, any investment or retirement accounts — and then they applied the rules. I genuinely can't tell you what they said about his retirement account specifically because I'd be guessing, but the process itself wasn't as scary as I expected. The form in the yellow envelope laid out what they needed.

0 coins

How long did the whole renewal process take after you sent in the form? We're trying to figure out the timeline so we're not in limbo.

0 coins

Took about three weeks from when we mailed the form to when the Notice of Action came. The NOA spelled out what counted and what didn't for his case.

0 coins

The yellow envelope sneaks up on you if you're not watching for it. We almost missed it mixed in with junk mail last year.

0 coins

People keep saying 'retirement accounts don't count' like it's a blanket rule and I want to push back on that a little. The specific language from DHCS is retirement funds IF you're getting regular payments — that word 'if' matters. A Roth IRA that someone has been accumulating for years and not drawing from is a different situation than a pension someone gets monthly. The county is the one who decides how that plays out for each case, and they may treat a Roth differently than a traditional IRA or a pension. Please don't go into the renewal assuming it won't count just because someone online said so.

0 coins

The 'if' matters — you're right. The exemption is conditional on receiving payments, and nobody here can confirm how the county applies that to a Roth specifically. County decides, NOA tells you the result.

0 coins

Is there any way to ask the county in advance before the renewal form even comes in? Like can he call ahead and ask a worker how they handle Roth IRAs or does he have to wait for the form?

0 coins

Calling the county ahead of the renewal is completely reasonable. The county's number is on DHCS's Find a County Office page. The worker can explain what documentation to bring and how they evaluate different account types on a case like his.

0 coins

MAGI vs Non-MAGI is what people miss on this whole conversation. Your dad at 68 is in Non-MAGI territory — that's the set of rules that DOES have asset limits, unlike the MAGI rules that apply to working-age adults under 65. MAGI doesn't have any property test at all, so if someone is talking about Medi-Cal with no asset check, they're probably talking about MAGI. Your dad's renewal is under Non-MAGI rules, which is why the asset question exists for him in the first place. Just wanted to make sure nobody reading this thinks asset limits apply to everyone on Medi-Cal.

0 coins

This is the part that confused me for months — I'm 34 and kept reading about asset limits and panicking, then found out they don't apply to my category at all. My case goes by income only.

0 coins

Does the Non-MAGI switch happen automatically when you turn 65 or does the person have to do something? Asking because my mom turns 65 next year and I want to know if anything changes.

0 coins

The county handles that reclassification — when someone in the household reaches the age threshold or qualifies because of a disability, the county applies the right set of rules. The renewal is usually where it gets reviewed. The county worker or the NOA would lay out what changed.

0 coins

After my renewal last spring, the Notice of Action showed a share of cost I wasn't expecting. The number on the letter seemed way too high for my income situation, and I had no idea how they calculated it. I used Claimyr to reach my county's line — ended up talking to a worker who looked at my case and read me the exact amount the county had on file and confirmed which income figure drove it. Turned out a part-time job I'd reported was counted differently than I assumed. The share of cost resets every month and you only owe it in a month you actually get care, to the provider directly. So for anyone with a share of cost on their NOA, make sure the income the county has is accurate.

0 coins

The share of cost piece trips so many people up. I thought I had to pay Medi-Cal directly every month no matter what, didn't realize it only kicks in when you actually use a service that month.

0 coins

My dad doesn't have a share of cost on his current NOA, but I'll keep that in mind if the renewal changes his situation. Good to know the county can explain how they got to that number.

0 coins

The provider is the one you pay, not the county office — I had to explain this to my mom three times before it clicked for her.

0 coins

Went through my own renewal last month and the worker specifically asked about every account type separately — checking, savings, money market, and then investment accounts including retirement accounts. So expect to have statements for all of it when the renewal comes. I had my account statements ready and it went pretty smoothly once I had everything in front of me.

0 coins

Did they want current statements or statements from a specific date? Trying to figure out what documents to pull together now.

0 coins

Current was fine for us — the most recent statement for each account. The worker noted the balance on the date of the renewal meeting.

0 coins

Pulling statements early is smart. I always worry about forgetting something at the last minute and then the county saying a document is missing.

0 coins

I keep seeing people say to call the county but honestly calling is an experience in itself. The line goes busy, or you hold for an hour and nobody picks up, or the system disconnects you. I eventually just drove to the office and waited in line, which took about two hours but I actually got my answer. If your dad can get to the county office in person, that might be more reliable than trying to get through by phone.

0 coins

Drove in person for my renewal question too. Took half a day but I left with a clear answer. Sometimes the in-person option is the only one that works reliably.

0 coins

Two hours in the lobby is brutal though. If there's any way to avoid that trip it's worth trying first.

0 coins

Totally fair — I tried every other option first. The lobby was my last resort after a week of not getting through.

0 coins

The fact that the asset limit for one person is $130,000 means a lot of people who assumed they'd lose Medi-Cal are actually still under it. The savings account alone probably isn't the problem here unless it's very large. The house and one car are excluded entirely. The question really does narrow down to how the county counts that Roth — whether the 'regular payments' exception applies or not.

0 coins

His savings account alone is well under that figure. It's really just the Roth that's the unknown piece.

0 coins

The exclusions for the house and car are pretty significant for a lot of older adults — those are usually the biggest things people are worried about and they come off the table immediately.

0 coins

I'd still want the county to confirm the Roth situation in writing through the NOA rather than just take a worker's word for it on the phone. The NOA is the document that actually matters if there's ever a dispute.

0 coins

If the renewal NOA comes back saying he doesn't qualify because of the Roth, he has 90 days from the date on that notice to ask for a State Fair Hearing. The hearing is before a judge who doesn't work for the county or Medi-Cal, and he could also request it through the county, by phone at 1-800-743-8525, or online with the California Department of Social Services. I'm not saying the renewal will go wrong, but it's good to know that option exists before the form even comes in.

0 coins

90 days from the date on the NOA — I'm writing that down. Didn't realize the clock starts on the notice date, not the date you receive it.

0 coins

The State Fair Hearing option is there for eligibility decisions specifically — if the county decides the Roth pushes him over the asset limit and he thinks that's wrong, that's exactly the kind of dispute it's designed for.

0 coins

Had a family member go through a State Fair Hearing last year for a different reason. The process itself wasn't as intimidating as expected, and having the NOA in hand with the specific reason for the denial made it much easier to organize.

0 coins

My application had been sitting for over five weeks with nothing in BenefitsCal changing from pending, and I had no idea if the county had even received it. I had Claimyr wait on the hold for me and then I was talking to a county worker who found my application by date and confirmed the county had it on file — she told me the date it was recorded and said a Notice of Action would come by mail. Knowing the county actually had the application made the waiting a lot easier.

0 coins

Five weeks with no movement sounds stressful. Good that you got confirmation of the receipt date at least — the 45-day window matters a lot.

0 coins

The pending status sitting still is so anxiety-inducing. At least knowing the county has it gives you something solid.

0 coins

Confirming the application was received is probably the most important call someone can make at the 30-day mark. If it somehow wasn't logged, you'd want to know before the 45-day window runs out.

0 coins

My aunt was in almost the exact situation two years ago before the asset limits came back, so she didn't have to worry about any of this. Now that the limits are in effect again, the landscape is totally different for older adults on Non-MAGI Medi-Cal. What helped her was getting all the documentation organized before the renewal arrived — account statements, the car registration, her home's assessor record — so she could respond quickly when the yellow envelope came.

0 coins

Getting ahead of the documentation is good advice. The renewal form asks for updated proof and having it ready means you can submit the same day instead of scrambling.

0 coins

I'm going to start gathering his account statements now so we're not hunting for them under a deadline.

0 coins

Just want to flag something I've seen come up before in threads like this: some people confuse Medi-Cal asset limits with Medicare rules. Medicare doesn't have an asset limit — it's a federal program based on age and work history, and income or assets don't affect your eligibility. Medi-Cal is California's Medicaid and that's where the Non-MAGI asset limits live. If your dad hears 'retirement account doesn't count for Medicare' that's true but it's the wrong program. The Medi-Cal rules are what apply here.

0 coins

The Medicare vs Medi-Cal confusion is everywhere. Even people who've been on Medi-Cal for years sometimes mix up which program is which.

0 coins

My parents have both and they still call each one by the wrong name half the time. Completely different programs with completely different rules.

0 coins

Knowing which program is making the decision matters because calling the wrong office will just send you in circles. For the asset question at the renewal, the county Medi-Cal office is the right place.

0 coins

Something to keep in mind for the renewal form itself — it comes in a yellow envelope and BenefitsCal shows the due date if you log in. You can also submit the renewal form through BenefitsCal at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login instead of mailing it, which saves time and you get a confirmation that it was received. That said, any new information on assets would need to be reported accurately regardless of how the form is submitted.

0 coins

The BenefitsCal submission is way faster than mailing it, especially if you're close to the due date. I did mine online last renewal and it was confirmed the same day.

0 coins

I didn't know we could do it online through BenefitsCal — I'll make sure he knows that's an option. We can do it together and make sure the asset information is listed correctly.

0 coins

Even when I submit online I still take screenshots of the confirmation page. Just habit at this point after too many situations where something 'sent' but never arrived.

0 coins

The person saying 'just close the Roth' doesn't realize that the act of withdrawing or transferring assets might not even help if the county looks at recent asset movement. And a Roth withdrawal has its own consequences depending on his age and whether the account meets the holding requirements. I am not a tax person and I am not qualified to tell him what will happen there — I'm just saying please do not move that money without actual financial or legal advice first.

0 coins

Heard and noted. He's not moving anything until after we talk to the county worker at the renewal.

0 coins

The tax piece alone should give people pause before touching a retirement account. That's not Medi-Cal territory at all, that's a different conversation with a different kind of professional.

0 coins

After my renewal a few years ago before all these changes, I never had to report any assets at all. This year's renewal is going to be a totally different form for people like your dad. The county may ask for documentation they never asked for before — bank statements, investment account balances. Being caught off guard by that is real, so I'd tell him to expect more questions this time.

0 coins

The county sent my mom a supplemental asset form along with the standard renewal — a whole extra set of questions about accounts and property. It was more paperwork than any previous renewal.

0 coins

Good to know it might be a longer process. We'll set aside time to go through it carefully rather than rushing.

0 coins

The extra documentation requirement is a real shift from the last several years. The asset limits were gone for a while and now they're back, so for a lot of people this is their first renewal where it matters.

0 coins

Does the county look at the Roth at the moment of the renewal application, or do they look at a 30-day average, or what? Because if the balance fluctuates month to month that could matter for someone right at the edge of the limit.

0 coins

How exactly the county assesses account balances at renewal — the specific timing and method — is something only the county can tell you for a specific case. The rules here say what counts and what doesn't, but the mechanics of the assessment are for the county worker to explain.

0 coins

Bringing the most recent statement with an account balance date on it is probably the safest approach, and then the worker can tell you what they need from it.

0 coins

My grandfather just finished his renewal and the whole thing took about five weeks from sending the form to getting the NOA. The notice was pretty clear about what they counted and what they excluded. The only thing that tripped us up was making sure all the account names matched what was on his photo ID, which wasn't something I thought about in advance.

0 coins

Name matching on the accounts — that's a detail I would not have thought of. Adding it to the checklist.

0 coins

The NOA laying it out clearly sounds like the ideal outcome. Five weeks from submission is roughly in line with what I saw on my dad's renewal too.

0 coins

The five-week window seems pretty consistent across a few people in this thread. Good to have a rough estimate for planning.

0 coins

For anyone reading this who is under 65 and worried about asset limits — the rules at the top of this thread are for Non-MAGI cases like the original poster's dad. If you're between 19 and 64 and qualify through the income rules under the Affordable Care Act expansion, there's no asset test for you. The asset limit that came back this year applies to a specific group, not everybody on Medi-Cal.

0 coins

This is worth repeating. I had a coworker panic about the asset limit news and she's 42 and working — the Non-MAGI rules don't apply to her case at all.

0 coins

Knowing which set of rules your case is under is the starting point for every question like this. The county can tell you which category you're in if you're unsure.

0 coins

Is there a way to find out in BenefitsCal which set of rules your case is under, or is that something you'd only see on the NOA?

0 coins

The NOA is the document that tells you which program category you're in. If it's not clear from the notice, the county worker can explain it when you call.

0 coins

Coming back to update: I called the county this morning and the worker confirmed the renewal form will go out next month. She said to list all accounts on the renewal form and include a recent statement for each one, and that the county will apply the rules to his specific account types when they review. She said to watch for the yellow envelope and not to let the due date pass. Still don't have a definitive answer on the Roth specifically but at least I know what to bring and what to expect. We're going to list it accurately and let the county make the determination.

0 coins

Listing everything accurately and letting the county apply the rules is exactly the right approach. Trying to guess in advance and exclude something is what causes problems.

0 coins

The county making the determination based on accurate reporting is how it's supposed to work. The NOA will give you the county's specific finding on each account.

0 coins

If the NOA comes back with something that seems wrong about the Roth, that 90-day window for the State Fair Hearing is there. Keep the envelope with the notice date on it.

0 coins

Related posts

Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim) AI

Expert Assistant
Secure