Back to Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim)

CosmosCaptain

Does Medi-Cal application income include siblings who give no money

Okay so I've been going back and forth on this for days and I can't find a straight answer anywhere. I live with my two older sisters. Neither of them gives me any money, we just share the rent so none of us has to pay it alone. I'm the only one applying for Medi-Cal — they already have coverage through their jobs. When I filled out the BenefitsCal application it kept asking about everyone in the household and I didn't know whether to list them or not. I make pretty low wages part time at a grocery store, but if the county adds my sisters' incomes on top of mine I'd probably be over the limit. Does Medi-Cal application income include siblings who give no money, or is it really just about who files taxes together? I submitted the application already but I'm second-guessing what I put down.

Went through almost this exact setup last year — two roommates who happened to be relatives, nobody sharing finances, and I panicked about the same thing. The way Medi-Cal figures the household for a single adult who doesn't claim anyone as a dependent and isn't claimed by anyone else is based on the tax household, not the physical household. So if your sisters don't claim you and you don't claim them, their income doesn't count in your Medi-Cal case at all. The county looks at who is on your tax return, not who sleeps under the same roof. Roommates — even family ones — are separate households for Medi-Cal purposes when you're each filing independently.

0 coins

I do file my own taxes, have for three years, nobody claims me. So if that's right, it's just my part-time wages they're looking at and my sisters don't factor in at all?

0 coins

Filing your own return and not being anyone's dependent is exactly the situation where your household is just you. The county may still ask you to list who lives there on the application, but listing them doesn't pull their income into yours if you're not in the same tax household.

0 coins

My worker told me the same thing when I had a housemate situation years ago. It was my income only once I confirmed I was filing on my own.

0 coins

About two months back my BenefitsCal account showed no update at all and I had no idea whether the county had even looked at my application. I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold so I could actually talk to someone at the county. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The worker pulled up my file and read me the Notice of Action date — it had been mailed already, only to my old address. I updated my address in BenefitsCal that day and asked the county to send a duplicate.

0 coins

The address thing is so easy to miss. Mine's correct in BenefitsCal but now I'm going to double-check.

0 coins

Waiting with no update is the worst part of this whole process. Good to know there's a way to actually find out what's on the case.

0 coins

Address update is crucial. My Notice of Action went to a place I'd moved out of and I nearly missed my window to respond.

0 coins

The tax household rule caught me off guard when I first applied. I had assumed Medi-Cal just added up everyone in the apartment because that's what I thought 'household' meant. Turns out for MAGI Medi-Cal — which covers most working-age adults — the household is built the same way you'd build it on a federal tax return. If you're a single adult filing your own return with no dependents, your Medi-Cal household is one person: you. Your sisters being in the same apartment doesn't change that. What matters is whether anyone claims you or whether you claim anyone.

0 coins

My cousin told me they add up rent-payers, which is completely wrong. Good that this is spelled out here.

0 coins

The rent-payers idea is a really common mix-up. The county doesn't look at lease agreements or rent splits, only at the tax filing relationship.

0 coins

Makes sense now. We each file our own returns, no dependents involved, so I should really just be counted as a household of one.

0 coins

I work at a job where my hours fluctuate a lot and I was worried about how to show my income when I applied. The county can ask for a recent pay stub showing gross pay, pay period and hours. For part-time variable work, they might look at a few stubs to get an average. If your pay is inconsistent, ask the county office what period they want to see — some cases they average a couple months. Getting the proof ready before they ask saves a lot of back and forth.

0 coins

Part-time and variable is exactly my situation. I'll pull the last two months of stubs just in case they want more than one.

0 coins

Variable hours made my application take longer because I could only show some of what they asked at first. Having multiple stubs ready from the start would have helped a lot.

0 coins

Two months is usually enough to give a decent picture. If they want more, the letter from the county will say exactly what they're looking for.

0 coins

The county has up to 45 days to decide a Medi-Cal application, and 90 days if the application is based on a disability. After you submit in BenefitsCal you can check there to see if anything is pending or if they've asked for more documents. If 45 days pass with no Notice of Action in the mail and nothing resolved in BenefitsCal, you have the right to ask for a State Fair Hearing for the delay. Write down the date you submitted so you know when that window opens.

0 coins

I submitted about two weeks ago so I've got time, but I didn't know the State Fair Hearing applied to delays too, not just denials.

0 coins

A lot of people think the hearing is only after a denial but it covers no action at all past the deadline. Worth knowing before you hit day 46.

0 coins

Wrote my submission date on a sticky note on my monitor after my last application. Almost missed it the first time around.

0 coins

My situation was a little different because I have one sister who I do claim as a dependent — she's 17 and I'm her legal guardian. In that case the county did include her in my household for Medi-Cal purposes, and her income, which is zero, got added in too. So for me the household was two people even though it's just the two of us and no other relatives share the place. The rule that matters is really who's on whose tax return, like others said.

0 coins

That makes the distinction really clear. Dependent on your taxes equals in your Medi-Cal household. Not on your taxes equals separate.

0 coins

Exactly. And my sister qualified under children's Medi-Cal rules at a different income threshold anyway, which I didn't expect. The county sorted that out automatically.

0 coins

Children's coverage having its own threshold is news to me. I always assumed the whole household had to be under one income limit together.

0 coins

Something that helped me sort out the household question was going through the BenefitsCal application one screen at a time and reading what it actually says about tax dependents versus people in the home. The prompts are more specific than the paper form. For every person I listed as living there, it asked whether I claim them, whether they claim me, whether we file together. For my two adult roommates — also relatives — the application routed their section out of my income calculation once I answered no to all of those. So the digital form itself kind of walks you through it.

0 coins

I wish I'd read it that carefully the first time. I think I rushed through and might have checked the wrong box somewhere.

0 coins

You can still update information through BenefitsCal or contact the county to correct something before they make a decision. If the application is still pending, there's usually still time.

0 coins

I did the same rush-through and had to phone the county to fix a household member I added incorrectly. Annoying but fixable.

0 coins

Coverage on my case ended after I missed the renewal deadline, and I hadn't sent in everything the county needed. Claimyr held my place in the county's phone queue and I ended up talking to a worker who went through my file and said the renewal form had come in but two proofs were still missing — she named exactly which ones. I sent those in through BenefitsCal the same afternoon. Knowing what was actually outstanding was a lot more useful than the vague pending status I'd been staring at.

0 coins

That gap between 'missing something' and knowing what it actually is must be so frustrating. At least you found out before the 90 days ran out.

0 coins

The 90-day window to fix a renewal without reapplying is real — the county reinstates without a gap in coverage if you get everything in and still qualify. I didn't know about it until that call.

0 coins

My renewal ended the same way and I thought I had to start completely over. Didn't realize there was a window to fix it.

0 coins

The MAGI versus non-MAGI distinction trips a lot of people up when they're asking about household income. For most working-age adults applying on their own — which sounds like your situation — the program uses MAGI rules, meaning everything is based on your federal tax filing: income, dependents, filing status. Non-MAGI rules, which apply to people 65 and older, people with disabilities and some others, work differently and do look at property and assets. If you're 19 through 64 and not applying based on a disability, you're almost certainly under the MAGI rules, and the asset question doesn't come up at all.

0 coins

I always get confused between those two categories. Good to know that the tax-based rules are what apply for regular working adults.

0 coins

The age and disability piece is the main dividing line. If you're a standard working adult under 65, the county is looking at your tax household and income, nothing else.

0 coins

The property piece threw me off too when I first applied. I kept looking for where to put down my savings and the online form just didn't ask, which made me think I was missing something.

0 coins

I got really confused at one point because someone told me my siblings' rent contributions counted as 'in-kind income' for my case. I brought that to the county and the worker said no — Medi-Cal MAGI rules count income from jobs, unemployment benefits, and similar sources, not rent you split equally with people who owe it the same as you. The in-kind income thing is more of a Non-MAGI concern. For a MAGI adult household, equal rent-splitting between adults who each owe their share isn't counted as income to any of them.

0 coins

Someone told me something similar and it had me worried. Good to know the MAGI rules don't count shared rent costs as income.

0 coins

It's a nuance the county worker explained pretty clearly. The in-kind income rules apply in specific Non-MAGI situations, not to a straight rent split between adults.

0 coins

I'd heard the in-kind income thing too from someone who went through a Non-MAGI case. Makes sense it's a different set of rules.

0 coins

My application was pending for about five weeks and I kept refreshing BenefitsCal hoping to see it change. What I didn't know is that the county can ask for more information during those 45 days and the clock can be affected by whether you respond in time. The request for more information showed up in BenefitsCal as a task, but I didn't see it until day 38 because I was only looking at the status and not the action items. Check both.

0 coins

I've been checking the status too but didn't think about action items being separate. Going to look more carefully now.

0 coins

The task or document request can sit there quietly while you're watching the status. Missing it is easy and it can slow things down.

0 coins

Learned this the hard way on my first application. The status said pending for weeks and I had no idea there was a request waiting for me.

0 coins

To answer the original question one more way: the county asks who is in your home partly to know how many people share the household for housing and poverty level purposes, but for income counting it goes back to the tax return. Even when the application lists five people in an address, if they're five separate tax filers with no dependent relationships, Medi-Cal treats them as five separate households. Income for each is counted separately.

0 coins

Five separate households in one building is a weird mental image but that's exactly how it works with my sisters.

0 coins

It really does work that way, as strange as it sounds. The physical address doesn't link your incomes together.

0 coins

I had three roommates on my lease when I applied and was terrified they'd pull all our incomes together. They didn't — only mine counted.

0 coins

There's also the retroactive Medi-Cal piece that can matter once you're approved. If you had medical or dental bills in any of the three months before the month you applied, you can ask the county to look at whether you would have qualified then too. You'd need to ask within a year of the month the service happened. Worth knowing if you have anything outstanding from before the application.

0 coins

I actually had a dentist visit the month before I applied. Didn't know I could ask about that. Will definitely bring it up with the county.

0 coins

A worker I talked to about retroactive Medi-Cal on my own case said the county checks whether you would have been eligible in those months. They told me my request was recorded and to watch for a Notice of Action. That's the step I used Claimyr for — the county's line was a wall of hold music, but I ended up talking to a worker who confirmed the retroactive request was in my file and told me the month it covered.

0 coins

The retroactive piece saved me on a bill from the month before my approval. Absolutely ask the county once you're in.

0 coins

Applications that sit past 30 days with no word sometimes just need a nudge. I went into my county office in person once because BenefitsCal showed nothing new and the phones weren't going through. The lobby wait was long but the worker at the desk could see my case and told me exactly what was still open. For people who can't easily get there in person, having some way to reach the county by phone matters a lot.

0 coins

In-person is an option I hadn't thought about. My county office is a bit of a drive but it's good to know that's on the table if the application stalls.

0 coins

The lobby wait at mine was almost two hours but the face-to-face conversation answered everything the online status couldn't. Sometimes it's the fastest path.

0 coins

Drove 40 minutes to mine and still had to wait. Phone access really should be easier than it is.

0 coins

Covered California is worth knowing about depending on where your income lands once the county finishes looking at it. If your income turns out to be above the Medi-Cal limit, the county sends a Notice of Action and can route you to Covered California, where you might qualify for a plan with premium help. The two programs are connected — the BenefitsCal application feeds into both — so you don't have to start over. But for someone at a part-time grocery wage, Medi-Cal is usually the right fit.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about what happens if I end up just over the limit. Good to know there's a path that way instead of being left with nothing.

0 coins

The handoff between Medi-Cal and Covered California is smoother than it used to be from what I've seen. You'd get a notice explaining the next step.

0 coins

The joint application is one of the better things about BenefitsCal. You put in your information once and it figures out which program fits.

0 coins

Nobody told me when I first applied that I should keep a copy of everything I submit through BenefitsCal or mail in. My first application had a proof that never showed as received and I had no way to prove I'd sent it. Now I save a screenshot or a photo of every document I upload and keep the email confirmation when BenefitsCal says something was submitted.

0 coins

Screenshot habit noted. I sent my pay stub upload without saving anything and now I'm hoping it shows as received.

0 coins

If you log into BenefitsCal and look at your documents section it should show what's been received. If the stub isn't there, you can upload it again.

0 coins

Had a proof disappear on my end too. Re-uploading was straightforward but only because I still had the original file saved on my phone.

0 coins

To be honest the household income question on the application had me stumped for about an hour. I called my county office to ask before I submitted and the person who answered walked me through it in about two minutes. For a situation like yours — independent adult, own tax return, siblings with their own jobs and their own filing — they confirmed I only put my own income. The call itself took forever to get through but the answer was quick once I had someone.

0 coins

Two minutes for the actual answer but forever to get through sounds about right from what I've heard. What time did you call?

0 coins

Tried first thing in the morning and still waited a long time. I'd probably do it differently next time.

0 coins

Morning timing helps a little at some offices. Even then it's not always fast. The question itself is one the workers can answer in seconds once you reach them.

0 coins

The State Fair Hearing option also applies if the county approves you but gets the household size wrong and sets your income limit too low. If your Notice of Action comes back and something looks off — like it seems they included your sisters' income when they shouldn't have — you have 90 days from the date on that notice to file a hearing request. You can call the county first to ask about the specific finding before deciding whether to appeal.

0 coins

If the NOA comes back and something looks off about the household count, I'll know to act within 90 days. That's good to have in my back pocket.

0 coins

The 90 days goes fast if you're waiting to hear back informally first, so read the date on the notice the day it arrives.

0 coins

The county eligibility worker can explain what went into the decision before you file a formal hearing request. That conversation alone sometimes fixes the issue without needing to go further.

0 coins

Went through the renewal side of this last spring. At renewal time I still had the same two sisters in the house and nothing had changed in terms of who claimed who. The renewal form asked some of the same household questions and I just answered them the same way as the original application. The county renewed without issue. So the tax-filing logic holds at renewal too, not just at first application.

0 coins

Good to know the same logic carries forward. I was wondering if renewal might ask it differently or pull more information.

0 coins

The renewal does ask you to confirm what's the same and report what changed. If the household situation is the same, it's pretty straightforward.

0 coins

My renewal was the first time I realized I should read every screen carefully. Some prefilled answers from the year before had changed slightly and I nearly submitted something inaccurate.

0 coins

Had a coworker tell me that Medi-Cal checks with the IRS every year and if your sisters filed with higher incomes it would pull their money into your case automatically. That is not how it works. What DHCS does check is your own income and filing information, not random relatives at the same address. The tax household for your case is built from your return, not from an address match.

0 coins

My coworker said something similar and it's what started my whole panic. Address-based matching would be a nightmare for anyone with roommates.

0 coins

The address-matching idea is widespread and completely wrong. The whole point of MAGI rules is that it follows tax logic, which is person-specific, not building-specific.

0 coins

The IRS data match DHCS does is to verify the applicant's own income information, not to rope in other people at the address. It's confirmation of what's on your own return.

0 coins

Came across a post elsewhere saying that if siblings pay any shared bills — like a streaming service or groceries — that counts as 'support' for Medi-Cal purposes. That's not accurate for MAGI Medi-Cal either. Regular household cost-sharing between adults isn't counted as financial support or income under MAGI rules. If someone did want to flag unusual financial arrangements, they can ask the county directly, but ordinary bill-splitting is not what the income question is about.

0 coins

We split a shared grocery haul sometimes and I genuinely worried that would count. Good to know that's not what the income question means.

0 coins

The income question is about wages, benefits, self-employment income and similar things. It's not about who buys paper towels this week.

0 coins

Someone in a Facebook group told me shared Costco memberships with family were 'in-kind income.' I think people mix up Medi-Cal with other benefit programs that do look at that more strictly.

0 coins

Just want to flag the BIC situation too since you're close to approval hopefully. Once the county approves you, the Benefits Identification Card comes by mail. The managed care plan packet comes separately. If you're in an area with more than one plan, you have 30 days from approval to pick one or the county picks for you. If the BIC doesn't show up after a couple of weeks and you're approved, the county is who to contact about it, not the health plan.

0 coins

I didn't know the plan packet and the BIC were different mailings. I'll watch for both.

0 coins

They come at different times and the BIC is what you bring to appointments. The plan card, if your plan sends one, comes later. The BIC is the main thing to watch for.

0 coins

My BIC took almost three weeks after approval. I called to check and the county confirmed it had been sent. Good that I didn't just wait and assume something was wrong.

0 coins

Related posts

Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim) AI

Expert Assistant
Secure