Can Medi-Cal deny a peer to peer review for medication — what happens next
My doctor put in for a medication I've been on for two years and the managed care plan denied it. She called to do a peer to peer review with their medical director to explain why I need it and from what I can tell that got denied too or just ignored. I don't even fully understand how that works. Can Medi-Cal deny a peer to peer review for medication or is that something the plan is required to do? And if it goes nowhere what are my options? I'm not trying to switch medications, there's a reason we landed on this one and I really don't want to start over.
85 comments

Ravi Sharma
Your doctor's peer to peer is between her and the plan's medical director, so the plan controls whether and how they do it, and they can decline or say the decision stands after. What matters for you is what the plan puts in writing. If they denied the medication, you should have gotten a Notice of Action from the plan saying why. You have 60 days from that date to file an appeal directly with the plan, and they have to answer within 30 days. If the appeal also goes against you, you can then ask for a State Fair Hearing within 120 days of the plan's decision. That's the path that actually has teeth.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
Author60 days from the date on that notice, got it. I don't think I have that letter, I need to find it. Would the plan have sent it to me or would it come through BenefitsCal?
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Plans send their own denial letters by mail directly to the member. BenefitsCal is the county side, the plan has its own paperwork. Call the member services number on your BIC if you can't find the letter and ask them to resend it and confirm the date.
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
The 120 days for a hearing after the plan denies the appeal, is that 120 days from the first denial or from the plan's answer on the appeal?
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
120 days from the date on the plan's decision on your appeal, not the original denial. The first denial starts your 60 days to appeal to the plan. Keep both letters.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
Plans deny peer to peers more than people realize. The peer to peer is really the doctor advocating, and the plan doesn't have to change its answer. I'd check whether your doctor submitted a prior authorization before or after the peer to peer, because sometimes the sequence matters for how the denial is recorded. Either way, get the written denial in hand first. The appeal process is what actually creates a record and forces the plan to justify it in writing.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorI think she did the prior auth first and the peer to peer was after the denial. So I have a denial for the prior auth at least.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
Prior auth denial is exactly what you need. That's your Notice of Action from the plan. Check the date on it and count your 60 days from there.
0 coins
AstroAce
Does the appeal have to be in writing or can you do it by phone?
0 coins
Omar Zaki
You can usually start it by phone with member services but always follow up in writing so there's a record. Ask member services how they want it submitted.
0 coins
Chloe Martin
Address on my case had been wrong for two months after I moved, so the plan's denial letters were going to the old place. I had no idea the prior auth had even been decided. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on hold with the county line so I could talk to a worker, and they confirmed my new address hadn't made it over from the old county yet — the inter-county transfer was still sitting incomplete. The worker said I'd need to submit my new address in BenefitsCal and that the county would mail a Notice of Action once the case was updated. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorMissing letters because of an address issue is a nightmare I hadn't thought about. Mine should be current but I want to double check now.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
An inter-county transfer taking that long sounds rough. Did the worker give you a timeframe for the NOA?
0 coins
Chloe Martin
The worker said to watch for a Notice of Action by mail but didn't say exactly when. I just made sure the address was updated and watched BenefitsCal for any changes on the case.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
I want to make sure I understand this right — when the plan denies the medication at the peer to peer stage, is that counted as the final denial or is the original prior auth denial the one that starts the clock?
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
The prior authorization denial is what starts your clock for the appeal. The peer to peer doesn't reset it. So if your doctor did peer to peer after the prior auth denial, you're still counting from that original denial date.
0 coins
Anastasia Sokolov
That's what I was afraid of. So someone could technically run out the 60 days while waiting to hear how the peer to peer went.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Exactly, which is why the advice is to file the appeal as soon as you get the written denial, even if the peer to peer is still going on. You can always withdraw the appeal if the plan reverses the denial.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
I had a plan denial for a medication last year and the peer to peer my doctor did changed nothing. What actually helped was my doctor submitting a letter of medical necessity along with the appeal, spelling out why alternatives hadn't worked for me. The plan's appeals department and their medical director who takes peer to peers are not always the same people. A written appeal gives your doctor a chance to put the whole clinical picture in writing.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorLetter of medical necessity during the appeal, that's a good idea. I'll ask my doctor if she's willing to put something together.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Most doctors will do it because they want the same thing you do. Just ask the office specifically for a letter of medical necessity to include with your plan appeal.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
Does Medi-Cal even cover that medication or is this a plan-specific thing? Some stuff just isn't on the formulary.
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
Formulary and prior auth are different issues. Something can be on the formulary but still require prior authorization, and the PA can be denied even if the drug is covered. Worth asking the plan whether the denial is about the formulary or the PA, because those have different appeal paths.
0 coins
StarStrider
I went through something similar last spring and filed the appeal myself in writing directly to the plan after the peer to peer went nowhere. I included a note my doctor wrote and a summary of what we'd tried before. The plan reversed it on appeal without me having to go to a hearing. Didn't feel like it would work but it did.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorReversed on appeal without a hearing — that's what I'm hoping for. How long did it take them to respond after you submitted?
0 coins
StarStrider
Took right around three weeks for me, which is under the 30-day window they have. I sent it certified mail so I had a record of when they got it.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Does the 30-day clock start when they receive it or when you send it?
0 coins
StarStrider
I'd count from when they receive it to be safe, which is why certified mail or some kind of confirmation is useful.
0 coins
Nia Thompson
There's a number for the Medi-Cal Managed Care Ombudsman — 1-888-452-8609. They help specifically with managed care plan problems and they're separate from the plan itself. If you're getting nowhere with member services on the appeal process, they can help you understand your rights with the plan.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorI didn't know about the Ombudsman line. So they're separate from both the plan and from the county?
0 coins
Nia Thompson
Yes, they're through the Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman and they don't work for the plan or for the county. Good resource when you feel like you're hitting a wall with member services.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
I called that number once and they were actually really helpful explaining what my plan was required to do vs. what was discretionary. Worth knowing about.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
isn't a peer to peer just something the doctor does to try to change the plan's mind? i thought medi-cal required them to approve it if the doctor calls
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Plans aren't required to change the decision just because a peer to peer happened. The peer to peer is a clinical conversation the doctor can request, but the plan's medical director can still uphold the denial. The member's appeal rights are the binding part — that's where the plan has to respond in writing within set timeframes.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
oh okay so the appeal is actually the thing with teeth, not the peer to peer. i had that backwards
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
A lot of people think the peer to peer is the official appeal step. It isn't. The appeal to the plan is separate and has the actual deadlines and written response requirements.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Ask your doctor's office for a copy of everything they submitted for the prior auth and the peer to peer request. Having that paper trail in your hands makes the appeal much easier to write because you can reference exactly what was already submitted and what the plan said in response.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorGood point, I should have my own copies of what her office submitted. I'll call and ask them to send me the documentation.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Offices sometimes have to pull it from their system but they can do it. Knowing what codes and clinical notes went in the first time helps if the appeal needs to add anything.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Employer coverage showing up wrong on my case was holding up my plan assignment for weeks. I used Claimyr to reach my county's Medi-Cal line and talked to a worker who looked at the case and told me the other health coverage from my old job was still listed as active. She said I needed to report to DHCS at 1-800-541-5555 to get it corrected. Once I did that the county updated the case and mailed a Notice of Action.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
Old job's coverage still showing as active on the case sounds like exactly the kind of thing that would be invisible until something went wrong. Good that the worker caught it.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
I hadn't even thought to look at that. The worker found it when she pulled up the case details.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorIs other health coverage something that could also affect a prior auth decision at the plan level?
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
A worker told me the county side and the plan side are separate — the county handles eligibility and what's on the case, the plan handles prior auths. But if your coverage info at the county is wrong it can affect which plan you're assigned to, which then affects everything else.
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
If the plan's appeal also gets denied, the State Fair Hearing is actually worth doing. I know it sounds intimidating but it's a phone hearing in front of a judge who doesn't work for the plan or the county. You can present your doctor's documentation and the judge looks at whether the plan followed its own rules and Medi-Cal's requirements. Some people win at the hearing stage after losing two rounds with the plan.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorA hearing by phone makes it less daunting. I was picturing having to show up somewhere formal.
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
Phone or in person, your choice. And you have 90 days from the date on the county's Notice of Action to request one, or 120 days from the plan's appeal decision. You can ask through the county office or call 1-800-743-8525 to request it.
0 coins
AstroAce
Can you bring the doctor to the hearing or is it just the member?
0 coins
Freya Thomsen
You can have someone help you, including a doctor or a patient advocate. The hearing is before an administrative law judge and you can present whatever documentation supports your case.
0 coins
NeonNova
I want to flag for people in this thread that prior auth denials for Medi-Cal prescriptions also have their own line — Medi-Cal Rx at 1-800-977-2273. If the denial is specifically on the pharmacy side rather than through the managed care plan, that's a different process. Worth clarifying with your doctor whether the authorization went through the plan or through Medi-Cal Rx directly.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorMine went through the plan, not Medi-Cal Rx directly. But I didn't know those were different tracks.
0 coins
NeonNova
Fee-for-Service members go through Medi-Cal Rx and managed care plan members go through the plan. Most members are in a managed care plan now, but it's worth confirming.
0 coins
Zara Ahmed
so if you're in a managed care plan the appeal goes to the plan first, not to medi-cal rx?
0 coins
NeonNova
Right, the plan's internal appeal process is the first step if you're in managed care. Medi-Cal Rx is relevant for those not in a managed care plan.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
My doctor tried a peer to peer twice on two different medications over the past year and lost both times. She told me afterward that the plan's medical director is not required to change the decision and that most peer to peers don't. She said the written appeal where she submitted clinical notes was what actually moved things. The peer to peer is worth trying but don't wait on it to file the appeal.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorFiling the appeal while the peer to peer is still going — I keep hearing this. I'll go ahead and start the appeal this week and not wait to hear more from my doctor.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
File it in writing, include your doctor's contact, and ask them to call if they need anything from her. That way you're not racing the 60-day clock.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Does the plan have to tell you in the denial letter what criteria they used to deny it? I ask because sometimes the denial is based on a specific clinical criteria guideline and if your doctor knows which one was applied she might be able to address it directly in the appeal.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
The denial notice is supposed to explain the reason for the denial. If it's vague, your doctor can ask member services which clinical criteria guideline applied. That way the appeal can speak directly to that criteria rather than arguing in general.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Makes sense. So the appeal works better when it's responding to the specific criteria, not just re-arguing that the medication is needed.
0 coins
Ravi Sharma
Exactly. If the denial says the medication doesn't meet criteria for X condition at Y level of care, the appeal should address X and Y directly with the clinical evidence.
0 coins
AstroAce
My plan denied a prior auth and I never got a written notice, it just showed at the pharmacy as rejected. I called member services and they mailed the written denial after I asked. If you don't have a written denial in hand, call and ask them to send it — you need that letter to know your exact appeal deadline.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorShowed as rejected at the pharmacy first — that's how I found out too. I had no idea a letter had been sent or not. Calling to confirm the written denial exists is a good first step.
0 coins
AstroAce
Ask them specifically for the date on the Notice of Action from the plan when you call. That date is what your 60 days counts from.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
The pharmacy rejection and the plan's written denial can have different dates. The written denial date is the one that matters for your appeal.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
December on my case was when I moved counties and the county still had a proof of residency request outstanding that I didn't know about. I had Claimyr wait on hold with the county line for me and spoke with a worker who told me the proof of address was still listed as needed and gave me the due date. I uploaded what they needed in BenefitsCal that same afternoon and got a Notice of Action about two weeks later.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorA proof request you didn't know about with a due date you didn't know — that's the kind of thing that can tank coverage quietly. Glad the worker caught that date.
0 coins
Luca Esposito
I would have missed it completely if I hadn't gotten on the phone. BenefitsCal showed something was pending but not what specifically was needed.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
For anyone also dealing with a plan denial: dental denials follow a different process through the Medi-Cal Dental Program at 1-800-322-6384. If this is about a prescription medication through the managed care plan, the appeal is with the plan itself, as everyone here has said. Just don't want someone to call the dental line for a medication issue.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorMine is a medication, not dental, so I'm in the right lane. But good to flag that because the lines are different.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
The numbers come up together in searches sometimes. Medi-Cal Dental is completely separate from managed care plan appeals.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
My income change I reported in October still hadn't shown as updated on the case by mid-November. I had Claimyr hold for me while I waited and spoke with a worker who checked the case and confirmed the change I'd reported hadn't been recorded yet. She said to resubmit the change in BenefitsCal and that the county would send a Notice of Action after the update was processed. I resubmitted that day.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
A reported change not showing up for six weeks — that's a long gap. At least the worker could see it hadn't been recorded so you knew to resubmit.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
I'd been checking BenefitsCal and not seeing anything change, which is why I wanted to talk to someone directly. The worker found it right away when she pulled the case up.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
After an appeal denial from the plan, the State Fair Hearing request goes through the county office or by calling 1-800-743-8525, or you can file it online through the California Department of Social Services. The hearing is separate from the plan and the county — it's an administrative law judge. Bring every piece of paper you have from the plan and your doctor.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorFiling online through the Department of Social Services — I didn't realize that was an option. I'll keep that link in mind if the plan appeal doesn't go our way.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
The online option makes it easier to submit without having to call or go in person. Just make sure you're within your 120 days from the plan's appeal decision date.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Keep a dated copy of whatever you submit for the hearing request too. The date you file matters if the plan ever argues about whether you were within the window.
0 coins
NeonNova
I reported a change in household members back in September and wanted to make sure it had made it onto the case before my renewal came due. Used Claimyr and spoke with a worker who confirmed the household change was recorded and showed the date it was entered. She also told me my renewal form would be coming in a yellow envelope and to send it back before the due date in BenefitsCal.
0 coins
Diego Rojas
September change confirmed before the renewal — that's the smart move. I always worry something I reported didn't actually go through.
0 coins
NeonNova
That was exactly the worry. The renewal is coming up and I didn't want a discrepancy between what I reported and what the county had on file.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
If you end up at the State Fair Hearing stage, you can ask for a Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman advocate to help you prepare. They're at 1-888-452-8609 and they're free. Having someone who knows the managed care appeal rules walk through your documents before the hearing is useful.
0 coins
Isabella Ferreira
AuthorFree advocate help through the Ombudsman before the hearing — I'll save that number. Hopefully I don't need it but if I get to the hearing stage I'll call them first.
0 coins
Emily Jackson
They're also good to call even before you file the hearing request if you want to understand what the plan was required to do at each step. Sometimes they can tell you whether the plan's process followed Medi-Cal's rules.
0 coins
StarStrider
I've seen the Ombudsman line mentioned before but didn't realize they could help with hearing prep. That's more useful than I thought.
0 coins