Back to Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim)

Mila Walker

Can I have Medi-Cal and a private off exchange plan at the same time?

So I've been on Medi-Cal for about eight months and my partner's new job just added me to their employer plan starting next month. It's not through Covered California, it's one of those private plans the company picked directly — I think they call it off-exchange. I didn't know if accepting it would automatically cancel my Medi-Cal or if I could keep both running at once. My prescriptions are already set up through my Medi-Cal plan and I really don't want to mess anything up mid-treatment. Has anyone had both going at the same time? Do I have to pick one?

When my job gave me benefits last year I had the same panic about losing Medi-Cal. Turns out you can have both at the same time — that's actually allowed. The way my county worker explained it is that the private plan gets billed first, and Medi-Cal picks up whatever the private plan didn't cover. You don't have to drop one to keep the other. The important part nobody told me upfront: you have to report the new coverage to the county within 10 days of getting it. You can do that in BenefitsCal, by phone, in person, or even by fax. And you need to tell your doctors and pharmacy about both cards so they bill in the right order.

0 coins

10 days caught me off guard — I thought I had until my renewal to mention it. So reporting it doesn't end my Medi-Cal, it just puts the other plan on record?

0 coins

Reporting it doesn't end your coverage, it just means the county knows there's another payer. The county figures out how the two work together from there. Report it and ask the worker what happens next on your specific case.

0 coins

Agreed, I went through the same thing. Reporting feels scary but not reporting is actually the bigger problem. County found out anyway when my employer plan showed up in their system.

0 coins

October, the county sent me a Notice of Action after I reported my spouse's employer plan, and I couldn't read the date clearly on the copy I had — I needed to know if the 90-day window to appeal was still open. I tried the county line three mornings in a row and kept hitting a full hold. Eventually I let Claimyr (claimyr.com) wait on hold for me and ended up talking directly to a worker. She pulled up the notice and read me the exact date it was issued, which meant I still had about five weeks left to request a State Fair Hearing if I needed to. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The worker also confirmed the other health coverage had been recorded on my case, so at least that piece was squared away.

0 coins

Five weeks left to appeal — that would have stressed me out not knowing. I'm going to report mine through BenefitsCal first and then see what notice comes.

0 coins

Knowing the exact date on the notice matters a lot. The appeal window is 90 days from that date and once it closes you can't reopen it.

0 coins

My copy was smudged too so I called in and the worker told me the date over the phone. County can see it on their end even when your copy is unreadable.

0 coins

The billing order is the part people miss. My dentist submitted to my private plan first, then Medi-Cal paid the remaining balance. I didn't pay anything out of pocket. But the dentist's office has to know you have both — they won't automatically check. I told them at check-in and they handled it. Same with the pharmacy; I gave them both cards and they figured it out.

0 coins

Both cards to the pharmacy — I hadn't thought about that. My Medi-Cal BIC and the new insurance card at the same time?

0 coins

Exactly, hand them both. They'll run the private plan first and Medi-Cal second. If the pharmacist has questions, Medi-Cal Rx is 1-800-977-2273.

0 coins

My pharmacy had never dealt with Medi-Cal as a secondary before and had to call it in. Took an extra ten minutes but they got it sorted. Bring both cards every time until they have it on file.

0 coins

I want to flag something I got wrong when I first got employer coverage — I assumed Medi-Cal would just automatically become secondary without me doing anything. The county had no idea I had a private plan until I reported it and they processed it. Until then they were the primary payer and my doctor's office was billing them first, which caused a mess I had to clean up later. Report it to the county and also tell DHCS directly at 1-800-541-5555 or through DHCS's Other Health Coverage page. Both.

0 coins

DHCS has its own reporting for other health coverage that's separate from what you tell the county? I've only been reporting through BenefitsCal.

0 coins

DHCS says to report to them at 1-800-541-5555 or on their Other Health Coverage page. I'd do both — the county for your eligibility and DHCS for the coverage coordination. Covering both bases is safer than assuming they talk to each other.

0 coins

I got a letter from DHCS about other health coverage months before my renewal came up. They track it separately from the county. Reporting both places is the right call.

0 coins

My cousin told me I'd lose Medi-Cal the minute I got on her employer plan and I almost turned down the coverage over it. That's not how it works. Having a private plan doesn't disqualify you from Medi-Cal — the two programs are designed to work together. The income and eligibility rules are what determine if you keep Medi-Cal, not whether you also have private insurance. What you do have to do is report the new coverage so the county has it on record.

0 coins

My HR person told me the same wrong thing — that I'd have to pick one. I went ahead and kept both and it was fine. The county just updated my file when I reported it.

0 coins

Glad I asked before I turned down the coverage. My first instinct was to call the county and decline the employer plan just to keep things simple.

0 coins

A lot of people turn down employer coverage because they think it ends Medi-Cal automatically. It doesn't. You report it and the two work together.

0 coins

The 10-day reporting window is real and I'd take it seriously. I reported mine on day 14 and the worker noted the late report on my case. I don't know what it ultimately led to because I never got a letter about it — but I wouldn't gamble on that. Report it as soon as you get the new coverage details, even if the plan hasn't started yet.

0 coins

I have the enrollment paperwork now so I can report it before the plan actually kicks in. Better to do it early than scramble later.

0 coins

Reporting early is fine. The county just notes when the other coverage starts, not when you told them. Getting it in before 10 days is what matters.

0 coins

Sent my report the same day I got the enrollment confirmation email. Worker confirmed it came in. Doing it the moment you have the details is the safest move.

0 coins

Does the off-exchange part matter? Like does Medi-Cal treat a private direct-purchase plan differently than an employer plan? I'm in a similar situation but my partner is buying a plan directly from an insurer, not through Covered California and not from their job. Trying to figure out if that changes anything.

0 coins

What matters for Medi-Cal coordination is that you have other health coverage, not specifically where it comes from. Employer plan, direct private plan, Medicare — all of them need to be reported. The county handles how they coordinate from there.

0 coins

Checked the BenefitsCal account this morning and there's a section to report other health coverage. Added the plan name and effective date. Hoping that's enough or if I need to send proof too.

0 coins

The county may ask for proof of the other coverage — a copy of the insurance card or the enrollment letter. If they need something they'll send you a notice asking for it. Keep the enrollment paperwork handy.

0 coins

Coverage on my case ended in August because I missed a renewal form — I didn't get the yellow envelope until it was too late. When I found out I called the county to figure out what I still needed to send in and what the 90-day clock looked like. The line was impossible all week so I had Claimyr wait on the hold for me. The worker who picked up told me the renewal form hadn't been received and that I had a list of two documents the county was still waiting on, plus she told me which month the 90-day window ran out. I sent everything in that week. The other health coverage question comes up here because the renewal form asks about it — I didn't want to mess that up again.

0 coins

Knowing exactly which documents were still missing would have saved me a lot of guessing. BenefitsCal didn't show that level of detail for me when I was waiting on something.

0 coins

BenefitsCal showed my case as pending but not what specifically they were waiting for. The worker on the phone was the one who told me the actual list.

0 coins

Renewal forms always ask about other health coverage. If you've got a private plan at renewal time, you put it on the form there too, not just when you first got it.

0 coins

My Medi-Cal BIC kept working the whole time I had the employer plan. I half expected it to deactivate when I reported the new coverage, but nothing changed on the Medi-Cal side except that the county had the other plan on file. Same card, same managed care plan. Doctors billed the private insurance first, then sent the remainder to Medi-Cal.

0 coins

BIC staying active was my main worry too. Mine didn't change either after I reported the job coverage. The managed care plan stayed the same.

0 coins

Good to know the BIC doesn't just stop working the moment you report it. I was afraid to report because I thought it would trigger something.

0 coins

My managed care plan was actually the one that got confused, not the county. They kept billing as primary even after I told them about the private plan. I had to call the plan's member services and give them the other insurer's information directly. The county had it right; the health plan needed to be updated separately. If your plan sends you an Explanation of Benefits that looks wrong, that might be why.

0 coins

So the county, the managed care plan, and the doctors all need to know separately? That's more moving parts than I expected.

0 coins

The county for your eligibility record, the managed care plan for how they process your claims, and your providers so they bill in the right order. It sounds like a lot but each one is a pretty short conversation.

0 coins

If the managed care plan is giving you trouble, the Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman is 1-888-452-8609. They help with plan-level problems.

0 coins

Had a situation where my employer plan denied a claim and I wanted Medi-Cal to pick it up. The doctor's office wasn't sure how to handle it because they'd already billed the private plan first and gotten a denial. Eventually they figured out that Medi-Cal could still pay as the secondary. If your private plan denies something, Medi-Cal may still cover it — ask your provider to submit to Medi-Cal after the private plan's decision comes back.

0 coins

So even a denial from the private plan doesn't necessarily mean I'm stuck paying out of pocket if Medi-Cal would have covered it?

0 coins

Medi-Cal makes the call on what it covers as secondary. Ask your provider or health plan — they know how to submit after a primary denial better than most of us do.

0 coins

My provider submitted to Medi-Cal after my private plan paid partial on a claim. Medi-Cal covered the remainder. Provider handled all of it, I just made sure they had both plan numbers.

0 coins

The share of cost question came up for me when I reported other health coverage. I'd been on Medi-Cal with no share of cost and after I reported the employer plan the county sent a Notice of Action. I called in to ask what changed, and the worker told me the share of cost on the notice. It was a different program classification than before. If your Notice of Action changes after you report other coverage, read it carefully — it may be telling you something about how your program classification shifted.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about my program classification possibly changing just from reporting another plan. I'll read whatever notice comes carefully.

0 coins

The notice will spell out the share of cost amount and the reason. If anything looks wrong you have 90 days from the date on the notice to request a State Fair Hearing.

0 coins

Share of cost resets every month too. Even if a notice shows one, it's only owed in months you actually get care, and you pay it to the provider, not to Medi-Cal directly.

0 coins

An ER bill from three months before I applied for Medi-Cal was sitting on my account and I wanted to know if I could get help with it. I'd heard about retroactive Medi-Cal but wasn't sure if the county had my request on file. I used Claimyr to reach a worker after getting nowhere with the hold music three days running. The worker looked up the retroactive request and told me which month it covered and that the application date was on record. She said to watch for the Notice of Action about that specific request. I'd filed the ask for retroactive coverage within the year window, so the month in question was eligible for review. The ER bill was from before I even knew Medi-Cal could cover past months.

0 coins

I didn't know Medi-Cal could reach back for bills before you even applied. How far back does that go?

0 coins

Up to three months before the month you applied, as long as you qualified in that month and you ask the county within a year of the month of the service. After January 2027 the window gets shorter for some adults, so if you have old bills, ask now.

0 coins

Retroactive Medi-Cal for a bill already paid works differently — that's a claim to DHCS Beneficiary Services at 1-916-403-2007 within a year of the service or 90 days after approval, whichever is longer.

0 coins

What about Medicare? My mom has both Medicare and Medi-Cal and her situation is different — Medicare comes first, Medi-Cal is secondary, and Medi-Cal sometimes covers her Medicare premiums. I know that's not exactly what this thread is about but I want people to know Medicare plus Medi-Cal is also a real thing. The county checks for Medicare when you apply if you're old enough or have a disability.

0 coins

Medicare and Medi-Cal together is called dual coverage. It works similarly to what this thread is describing — Medicare is primary, Medi-Cal is secondary. The coordination rules are a bit different but the idea is the same.

0 coins

Right, the county just needs to know about the Medicare when you apply or at renewal. They check eligibility for both programs at the same time.

0 coins

My aunt was surprised Medi-Cal was paying her Medicare premium. She thought having Medicare meant she didn't qualify for Medi-Cal anymore. That's not how it works.

0 coins

Something worth knowing about reporting: when I called the county after reporting my employer coverage, the worker confirmed it was on the case but also mentioned I should tell DHCS's Other Health Coverage team separately. I'd only done BenefitsCal. So I ended up doing three things: BenefitsCal for the county, calling DHCS's other health coverage line, and telling my managed care plan directly. All three are separate.

0 coins

BenefitsCal, DHCS at 1-800-541-5555, and the managed care plan all separately. Writing that down.

0 coins

The managed care plan piece is the one people forget. They don't automatically see what the county has on file. Plan's member services number is on your BIC.

0 coins

My renewal form last year asked specifically whether I had any other health coverage and I almost skipped that section because I thought I'd already reported it mid-year. The instructions say to list all current coverage even if you reported it before. So if you have both a private plan and Medi-Cal and your renewal comes up, don't leave that section blank.

0 coins

I would have skipped that section too thinking it was already on file. Good to know the renewal form treats it as a fresh question.

0 coins

Every renewal is treated like a check of your current situation. Even if the county already knows, the renewal form is asking you to confirm it's still the same.

0 coins

BenefitsCal shows your renewal due date if you want to know how much time you have. Easier than waiting for the yellow envelope to show up and scrambling.

0 coins

There's a thing that happens sometimes where the private plan doesn't know Medi-Cal exists on your account and bills you a co-pay that Medi-Cal was supposed to cover. If you get a bill and you think Medi-Cal should have covered the difference, ask your provider to check whether both plans were billed. Sometimes they just don't have the Medi-Cal information and they bill you instead of submitting.

0 coins

I've gotten bills like that before even without a secondary plan involved. I'll make sure the provider's office has both plan numbers at every visit.

0 coins

Providers sometimes just bill whatever is fastest. Making sure they have both cards at every appointment is easier than tracking down a bill after the fact.

0 coins

Nobody told me when I first got Medi-Cal that I'd need to report other health coverage if I ever got a job with benefits. I found out at my second renewal when the county started asking questions. I had employer coverage for about five months that I never reported. I went to the county office and reported it there in person with the enrollment dates. The worker noted it on the case. If you're in that situation and you're past 10 days, still report it — better late than not at all, and ask the county what it means for your specific case.

0 coins

Going in person with the enrollment papers is smart. You get a worker who can note it right then instead of waiting for something to come back through the mail.

0 coins

Brought a copy of my insurance card and the enrollment letter showing the start date. They made a copy and I got a date-stamped receipt for my own records.

0 coins

Keeping a date-stamped copy of anything you submit to the county is good habit. If something goes sideways later you have proof of when you gave them what.

0 coins

For anyone wondering how the BIC looks when you have two plans — your Medi-Cal BIC doesn't change or get marked differently. It just still says what it says. The coordination happens behind the scenes between the insurers and the providers. You carry both cards and hand both to whoever is treating you.

0 coins

Both cards, every appointment. That's the simplest way to think about it. Thanks for spelling that out.

0 coins

Pharmacy is the one place where it really matters most to have both on file from day one. They bill in a specific order and if they only have one plan they may charge you more than you owe.

0 coins

Called Medi-Cal Rx once when my pharmacy didn't get the billing right and they sorted it out in one call. Keep that number in your phone — 1-800-977-2273.

0 coins

Related posts

Tulare County CA Medi-Cal (No Existing Claim) AI

Expert Assistant
Secure