Back to Medi-Cal

Miguel Castro

Medi-Cal denied over income limit but Covered says contact Medi-Cal — what do I do now?

Went through the whole application process thinking I'd land on Medi-Cal since my income dropped when I went part-time to care for my mom. BenefitsCal sent me a Notice of Action saying I was over the income limit for Medi-Cal. Then Covered CA sent a message saying to contact Medi-Cal because of my household situation. So now I'm stuck in this loop — Medi-Cal says I'm over their limit and Covered CA is pointing me back at Medi-Cal. My mom lives with me and has her own health issues, and I'm honestly not sure if her being in my household changes anything or if I just need to appeal. Has anyone dealt with this kind of back-and-forth between the two?

The ping-pong between those two is incredibly common and genuinely frustrating. What usually happens is that the income calculation depends on exactly who is in your household for Medi-Cal's purposes, which can be different from how Covered CA counts it. If your mom is in your home and you're caring for her, that household composition question is worth taking directly to your county Medi-Cal office, not to Covered CA's line. Covered CA can see that your situation is unusual and flags it back, but they can't change a Medi-Cal eligibility decision. Your county office is the one that actually works those numbers on your case.

0 coins

Ok so Covered CA can't just fix it on their end? I figured since they're both on BenefitsCal it would be more connected than that.

0 coins

They share the application platform but the eligibility decisions are separate. Covered CA sees the Medi-Cal denial and if something looks off about the household, they flag it. The county has to be the one to revisit it.

0 coins

Yep the county is really the only door that opens anything here. Covered CA's hands are tied once Medi-Cal issues a denial.

0 coins

Your Notice of Action from the county should tell you the specific income figure they used and which household members they counted. Worth looking at that number closely, because if your mom's income was included when it shouldn't be, or if someone was left out, that's your basis for asking the county to take another look or for requesting a State Fair Hearing. The NOA will also have a date on it, and you've got 90 days from that date to ask for a hearing if you think the decision was wrong.

0 coins

The NOA came last week so I still have time. The income number on it looks right for just me but I'm not sure if my mom should have been counted or not.

0 coins

Whether your mom counts as part of your household for Medi-Cal is exactly the kind of thing to ask the county directly — there's no one-size answer because it depends on how the household is set up. County office is the place to get that answered for your specific case.

0 coins

Exactly. You can ask the county to walk through how they counted your household before you decide whether to appeal. Sometimes it's a documentation thing that can be corrected without needing a full hearing.

0 coins

Pending status kept showing in BenefitsCal for weeks on my own application before I got any notice, and I had no idea what proof the county was actually waiting for. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with the Medi-Cal line for you so you end up talking to a live Medi-Cal agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent pulled up my case and told me the county still needed proof of my address — a utility bill specifically — which nothing in BenefitsCal had flagged clearly. Got that uploaded the same afternoon and the case moved forward.

0 coins

Appreciate this, I didn't know there was a way to actually get someone on the phone. My NOA didn't mention anything about missing documents but I want to ask about the household question before the 90 days runs out.

0 coins

The hold times on that Medi-Cal line are brutal. I've sat there for over an hour and gotten dropped. Good to know there's another way to get through.

0 coins

The agent was straightforward about what was on my case. No runaround, just the specific document and I took care of it.

0 coins

You said Covered CA told you to contact Medi-Cal — did they put that in writing or was it a message in the system? Because if it's in a letter or a notice from Covered CA, bring that with you when you contact your county office. It can help show the county that there's a question about how your case was categorized, and they can look at the household composition issue with that context.

0 coins

It came through as a message in the BenefitsCal system. I can screenshot it at least.

0 coins

A screenshot works. The county workers can see the BenefitsCal messages on their end too, but having it in front of you when you explain the situation helps keep the conversation focused.

0 coins

Keeping any communication from Covered CA or the county in one place is smart. Medi-Cal cases can get complicated fast when two programs are pointing at each other.

0 coins

I had a denial that turned out to be because the county used an estimated income figure from a previous year instead of my current part-time hours. Had to bring in my actual recent pay stubs showing the reduction. The county can reopen the income calculation if you show them the current numbers, especially if your situation changed recently like going part-time.

0 coins

My pay stubs already showed the part-time hours when I applied. I uploaded them through BenefitsCal. So I don't think it was the documentation — it might genuinely be the household question with my mom.

0 coins

Then it really does come down to whether your mom's income or your mom herself is being counted in a way that's pushing the household income up. County office conversation is the right next step.

0 coins

This is worth pushing on because household composition errors show up more often than people realize. The county doesn't always catch it in the first pass.

0 coins

My neighbor had almost the exact same situation — she was caregiving and got a Medi-Cal denial but then the county reviewed it and the coverage ended up being reinstated because of how the household was reassessed. She didn't even need a formal hearing, just a conversation with her eligibility worker. I'm not saying that always happens but it's worth making that call before filing a formal appeal.

0 coins

That's encouraging honestly. I didn't want to jump straight to a State Fair Hearing if there's a simpler path first.

0 coins

Trying to reach your eligibility worker first makes sense. The hearing is still there if that conversation doesn't get anywhere.

0 coins

Worth knowing the hearing request option stays open for 90 days from the NOA date even while you're trying to work it out with the county first. So talking to the worker doesn't eat into that window.

0 coins

The income limit for Medi-Cal is based on a percentage of the federal poverty level, which DHCS updates and publishes in their eligibility chart. Your denial should reference what income figure they used versus the limit for your household size. If the number of people in your household should be higher than what the county counted, your income might actually fall under the limit for the correct household size.

0 coins

That makes me think the household size is exactly the issue. If my mom is supposed to be counted, the limit for a two-person household would probably be higher.

0 coins

Possibly, yes. That's the question to put to your county worker — how many people did you count in my household and why. The answer to that should tell you pretty quickly if the denial was based on the right number.

0 coins

County workers don't always explain what went into the count unless you ask directly. Calling with that specific question tends to get a more useful answer than a general 'why was I denied.

0 coins

The renewal form on my case had been sitting unprocessed for weeks and I had no idea until coverage nearly ended. Claimyr got me to a live agent on the Medi-Cal line, and she confirmed the form had been received on the 14th but hadn't been marked processed yet — she escalated it on the spot. For situations like yours where something feels off in how the case was handled, getting a live person to actually look at the case record makes a real difference.

0 coins

Good to hear it actually leads somewhere useful. I want to ask specifically about the household count before I do anything else.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of specific question a worker can answer by looking at your case. Ask what household members are listed and what income figure is attached to each.

0 coins

Escalating on the spot is something only an actual worker can do. That's the difference between a phone call and a message sitting in a queue.

0 coins

People sometimes get confused between Medi-Cal and Medicare and assume one denial means they're shut out of everything. These are totally separate programs — Medicare is the federal program for people 65 and older or with certain disabilities, and Medi-Cal is California's Medicaid. A Medi-Cal denial has no effect on Medicare eligibility if you're in a situation where both could apply. And a Medi-Cal denial doesn't prevent you from buying a plan through Covered CA either.

0 coins

Worth clarifying too that if you do end up on a Covered CA plan, that's completely separate from your mom's Medi-Cal situation if she has her own coverage. Each person's eligibility is determined on their own or as part of a household, depending on how they apply.

0 coins

Exactly. And in a household where one person qualifies for Medi-Cal and another doesn't, they can end up on different programs — that's normal and expected.

0 coins

My mom is already on Medicare so she's covered either way. It's just me trying to figure out where I fall.

0 coins

You can ask for a State Fair Hearing while still trying to resolve things with the county — the two aren't mutually exclusive. Filing a hearing request within the 90 days keeps that door open. If you work it out with the county before the hearing date, you can withdraw the request. But if you wait to file until after the county conversation and then it doesn't go well, you could lose the right to a hearing if you've passed the 90 days.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about filing now and withdrawing later. That's a smarter way to protect myself while I try the county route first.

0 coins

The hearing request goes through your county office, online, or you can call 1-800-743-8525. The notice from your denial should also say how to request one.

0 coins

The hearing itself is before a judge who doesn't work for the county, so it's a genuinely independent review. Not something to skip if the county doesn't fix it.

0 coins

My application took nearly the full 45 days before I got my NOA, and I kept refreshing BenefitsCal wondering if something was wrong. For a denial, the timeline still applies — the county has up to 45 days for a standard application, up to 90 if the application was based on disability. If yours came in under that and you got a denial, at least the county moved on it. Now it's about whether the decision itself was right.

0 coins

Mine came in around 30 days. I actually appreciated the speed — I just didn't like the answer.

0 coins

Faster at least means you have more of your 90-day appeal window intact. 60 days left is a reasonable amount of time to try the county conversation first.

0 coins

An income-based Medi-Cal denial when you're a caregiver is one of those situations where the household question really matters. If the county only counted you and used your income against a one-person limit, but you and your mom share expenses and she's in your household, the picture looks different at a two-person limit. The gap between a one-person and two-person limit can be significant enough to change the outcome.

0 coins

That's what I'm hoping — that it's literally just a count of people issue and not something more complicated.

0 coins

Even if it's more complicated, the county eligibility worker is the one who can explain exactly what they counted and why. That conversation will tell you what kind of correction you're actually dealing with.

0 coins

If the worker says the count was correct and you still disagree, that's when the State Fair Hearing becomes the clearest path.

0 coins

The benefits card on my case never showed up after my approval, and I had no idea if it had even been mailed. Used Claimyr to reach a live Medi-Cal agent, and she confirmed the BIC had been sent to an old address on the case — not where I actually live now. She put in the address correction and told me a new card would be mailed out. For anyone with a card that never came, the county has the actual answer on whether and where it was sent.

0 coins

Address errors like that are really common after a move. Good the agent could see it right on the case and get it corrected.

0 coins

The worker confirmed the new card would be mailed once the address update went through, and that the old one would be deactivated. Having the right address on the case matters for more than just the card — notices go there too.

0 coins

That reminds me to double-check that the county has my current address. If anything gets mailed to the wrong place during all this back-and-forth, I could miss something important.

0 coins

For the State Fair Hearing specifically — you can bring someone with you to help, like a friend, a relative or an advocate, as long as you give written permission. The hearing is in front of a judge who is independent from the county and from DHCS. It's not as intimidating as it sounds and plenty of people go through it without a lawyer.

0 coins

Good to know I could bring someone. My mom could probably come with me and explain her own situation if needed.

0 coins

That's actually a good instinct, since her situation in the household is part of what's being questioned. Having her there to answer questions about how you share the household could help.

0 coins

The hearing can also be done by phone rather than in person if that's easier for you and your mom.

0 coins

Moved from one county to another earlier this year and found out the case hadn't transferred cleanly — the new county had no record of my Medi-Cal and my old plan ended. Claimyr got me to an agent who confirmed the inter-county transfer had been initiated but no plan had been assigned yet in the new county. She told me to contact Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263 to get enrolled in a plan in my new county. That number is specifically for choosing or switching plans, not the main Medi-Cal line.

0 coins

The inter-county transfer thing trips a lot of people up. The old county's managed care plan ends at the end of that month, and you have to get into a plan in the new county.

0 coins

Exactly. Health Care Options is the right place for that piece — the Medi-Cal agent told me the same thing. The main Medi-Cal number couldn't do the plan enrollment itself.

0 coins

I didn't know Health Care Options had its own separate line. I've been calling the main number for everything.

0 coins

Covered CA messaging people back toward Medi-Cal sometimes happens when their system sees that someone might qualify for a different kind of Medi-Cal — not necessarily the standard income-based kind. If your mom has a disability and you're her caregiver, there might be a Medi-Cal program that applies to your situation that's different from the one that issued your denial. County office would know which programs they looked at when they processed your application.

0 coins

I hadn't considered that. The denial NOA just said income limit — it didn't mention other programs. I'll ask the county what they actually evaluated.

0 coins

That's a smart question to ask. 'What programs did you look at when you processed my application' is much more useful than a general appeal conversation.

0 coins

Covered CA's routing sometimes works like that — they see a situation that doesn't fit clean income-based Medi-Cal and flag it rather than enroll the person in a Covered CA plan outright.

0 coins

EVERY time I try the Medi-Cal phone line I sit there for 45 minutes and then get cut off. I've tried calling early morning, tried calling right after lunch, and it doesn't matter. The county office line is slightly better but not by much. If you have something time-sensitive like a 90-day window counting down, you really can't afford to have the call drop ten minutes before you get to a person.

0 coins

The 90-day clock is exactly why I'm trying to move on this quickly. I don't want to lose the appeal window because I couldn't get through on the phone.

0 coins

County office in person might be the most reliable option if you're within driving distance. Bring the NOA, any proof of your mom's presence in the household, and your pay stubs showing the part-time income.

0 coins

In-person visits do tend to get faster answers on eligibility questions than phone or BenefitsCal messages. You also walk out with whatever forms you need right there.

0 coins

The Covered CA message pointing you back to Medi-Cal could also just be a system-generated message that fires whenever someone gets a Medi-Cal denial while in the BenefitsCal system. It doesn't necessarily mean Covered CA has identified something specific about your case — it might just be their standard prompt. So I wouldn't read too much into it beyond 'go talk to your county about this denial.

0 coins

That's a bit deflating but also probably realistic. Either way the action is the same — county office to ask about the household count.

0 coins

Yeah the action is the same regardless. If the county recalculates with the right household and you end up still over the limit, Covered CA is there to get you into a plan. If you do qualify after all, the county handles the approval.

0 coins

And if you end up on a Covered CA plan, the enrollment for that is separate from whatever happens with the Medi-Cal case. Two different systems, two different processes, even if BenefitsCal shows them together.

0 coins

Worth knowing that if the county does end up approving you after a denial, you might be able to ask about retroactive Medi-Cal for any medical bills you had in the three months before you applied. It doesn't fix the denial itself but it can help with costs you paid out of pocket during the gap. You'd ask the county office about that specifically.

0 coins

I hadn't heard of that. I did have a couple of appointments in the month before I applied that I paid for myself.

0 coins

Retroactive Medi-Cal covers bills from up to three months before your application date, as long as you ask within a year of the month the service happened. So if you applied in October, services from July forward could potentially be covered. County office handles that request.

0 coins

There's a note on DHCS's site that retroactive Medi-Cal rules for adults 19 to 64 are changing in January 2027, so the current window is worth asking about now if you have bills from before your application.

0 coins

To put it simply for anyone following along: the county decides Medi-Cal eligibility, Covered CA handles Covered CA plans, and when there's a denial, the first call is to your county Medi-Cal office. BenefitsCal is the shared platform but each program's eligibility decision is made separately. If you think the denial was based on the wrong household count or the wrong income figure, you can ask the county to review it and you can request a State Fair Hearing within 90 days of your NOA date — both at the same time if you want to protect yourself while the conversation with the county plays out.

0 coins

Posting an update: I called my county office this morning and asked specifically how many people they counted in my household and what income figure they used for each. Turns out my mom was counted in the household but her income was also included in the total, which pushed me over. The worker said I should bring documentation showing she's on Medicare and has limited other income, and they'll reassess the household income calculation. No hearing needed yet — just a document question.

0 coins

That is exactly the kind of thing a county worker can find in five minutes that the NOA itself never explains clearly. Glad you got a real answer.

0 coins

Updates like this are helpful because a lot of people assume the NOA is the final word. It almost never is on the first pass.

0 coins

Medi-Cal AI

Expert Assistant
Secure