Back to Medi-Cal

Gael Robinson

Medi-Cal and Medicare surgery not accepted by surgeon how to get covered

My dad is 71 and has both Medi-Cal and Medicare. He needs a pretty significant surgery on his hip and we found a surgeon near us who does this procedure, but the surgeon's office told us they don't take Medi-Cal or Medicare. We've been scrambling to figure out what to do because his orthopedic doctor referred him there specifically. Dad's coverage ended a few months back because the renewal form went to an old address, so we're also still trying to sort that mess out at the same time. I honestly don't even know where to start — do we need to find a completely different surgeon, or is there a way to get the surgery covered if we find someone else who does take both? Any guidance would be really appreciated.

Surgeons who don't accept Medi-Cal or Medicare are what's called non-participating providers, and your dad's coverage won't pay them directly in most cases. For someone with both Medicare and Medi-Cal, Medicare is the one that pays first for surgeries and most medical care, and Medi-Cal picks up costs Medicare leaves behind. So the surgeon really needs to accept Medicare at minimum. Your best first step is asking his orthopedic doctor to refer to a surgeon who is in the Medicare network — DHCS says to check with the doctor or health plan about whether a specific provider is covered.

0 coins

His orthopedic doctor's office said the referral was for this one surgeon specifically. So we'd have to go back and ask for a different referral to someone who takes Medicare? That feels like starting over.

0 coins

You'd really want a surgeon who takes both. Medicare pays first and Medi-Cal wraps around it, but if the surgeon won't bill Medicare you'd be on the hook for the full amount. Getting a new referral to someone in the Medicare network is worth the extra step.

0 coins

Also your dad's Medi-Cal being lapsed right now makes this more urgent — even if Medicare pays the bulk, the gap coverage from Medi-Cal is what keeps costs manageable for a 71-year-old on a fixed income. Getting that reinstated matters a lot before any surgery date.

0 coins

Coverage ended on us too a while back for the same reason — the renewal form never reached us and Medi-Cal stopped. I didn't know you could fix it without starting a whole new application, but I looked into it. Claimyr (claimyr.com) waits on hold with the Medi-Cal line for you so you end up speaking to a live Medi-Cal agent — video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent I spoke to checked our case and told me we were still within the 90-day window to submit the missing renewal information and get coverage put back without a gap. I went to the county office the next morning with everything they asked for and got it submitted.

0 coins

90 days from when exactly? His coverage ended about two months ago, so I'm worried we're running out of time. The county hasn't sent anything to the new address yet.

0 coins

The 90 days run from when the coverage ended, so two months in means you likely still have time. The county can reinstate with no gap if he still qualifies and you get the missing renewal info in before the window closes. I'd move fast on that.

0 coins

Definitely get to the county office or into BenefitsCal with the renewal information as soon as you can. Update the address there too — the county needs to have the right one on file so notices go to the right place going forward.

0 coins

90 days sounds like a lot but it goes fast when you're also trying to sort out a surgery situation. The county needs the renewal information — whatever they originally asked for — submitted before that window closes. If your dad still qualifies when you submit it, they put the coverage back as though it never stopped. No gap means the surgery could potentially still be covered by Medi-Cal once coverage is active again, depending on when it's scheduled.

0 coins

We didn't even know there was a window like that. We assumed it was just gone and we'd have to reapply from scratch. This is a relief.

0 coins

A lot of people don't know about those 90 days. The county sends a Notice of Action when coverage ends, and that's what tells you the date and what they need. If you have that letter, the information is in there.

0 coins

If the NOA went to the old address too, the county office can tell you what they need and what date the coverage ended. Worth going in person if getting through by phone is difficult.

0 coins

Finding a surgeon for someone with both Medicare and Medi-Cal can honestly take some patience. The referral process goes through the managed care plan too — your dad's Medi-Cal plan coordinates with Medicare. His health plan's member services line can tell you which surgeons in the area are in network and accept Medicare, so you're not just cold-calling offices. That's the approach that worked for us when my husband needed a specialist.

0 coins

His Medi-Cal plan — does that mean the managed care plan through Medi-Cal? I didn't realize the plan had a member services line separate from the county office. We've been calling the county for everything.

0 coins

Yes, the managed care plan is different from the county office. The county handles eligibility — whether he's on Medi-Cal and for how long. The health plan handles which doctors and hospitals are covered and helps with referrals. Those are two separate calls to two separate numbers.

0 coins

The plan's member services number should be on the BIC, the Benefits Identification Card. If the card went to the old address too, the county office can tell you which plan he's enrolled in and you can contact them directly.

0 coins

I went through something adjacent to this with my mom — she has Medicare too and her surgeon didn't take Medi-Cal. We ended up finding out that because Medicare was paying the primary amount, the surgeon only needed to accept Medicare. What Medi-Cal covers in that situation is basically the cost-sharing that Medicare leaves — things like deductibles and copays. So whether the surgeon needs to accept Medi-Cal specifically depends on the type of service. We asked the health plan and they laid it out pretty clearly.

0 coins

So it's possible this same surgeon might be an option if he accepts Medicare, even if he doesn't take Medi-Cal directly? That would change things. His office said both but maybe they meant something different.

0 coins

I'd go back and ask the surgeon's billing office whether they accept Medicare specifically. The Medi-Cal piece for a dual-eligible person like your dad is handled differently than for someone who only has Medi-Cal. Your dad's health plan can explain how it works for his specific coverage.

0 coins

Worth clarifying with the surgeon's office — sometimes the front desk says they don't take Medi-Cal and they mean they don't take Medi-Cal only, but they do work with patients who have Medicare primary. It's a real distinction and their billing department would know.

0 coins

The referral piece confused me too when my dad was dealing with something similar. His primary care doctor had to send the referral to someone the plan would authorize. The managed care plan actually had to approve the referral before the specialist visit was covered. If your dad's orthopedic doctor sent it to a non-participating surgeon, the plan wouldn't have authorized it anyway, so a new referral to someone in network is probably necessary regardless.

0 coins

His orthopedic doctor never mentioned anything about the plan needing to authorize it. We just assumed the referral was enough. How does he find out if the plan approved or denied a referral?

0 coins

The plan sends a written notice about authorizations. If your dad never got one, it may not have been submitted to the plan at all, or it went to the old address. His health plan's member services can check the status.

0 coins

If the plan denied a service or authorization, there's also an appeal process — 60 days from the date on the plan's written notice to appeal directly to the plan. After that there are further options if needed. But first step is finding out what the plan has on file.

0 coins

Health plan assignment was the issue on my end. I had Medi-Cal and when I looked at BenefitsCal the plan listed wasn't the one I'd been trying to use. I ended up talking to a Medi-Cal agent through Claimyr — I had an issue reaching anyone by phone and that's how I got through. The agent pulled up my case and confirmed which plan was actually showing on my file, and it turned out the plan I had the card for wasn't what the system had. Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263 is who you call to change or confirm your plan.

0 coins

If the plan on file is different from the card he has, would that explain why providers keep having trouble with his coverage? Because sometimes the pharmacy has had issues too.

0 coins

That could absolutely be the issue. If the plan in the system doesn't match what's on the card, providers trying to verify coverage would hit a wall. Getting the county to confirm which plan is actually active, then contacting Health Care Options if there's a mismatch, would be where I'd start.

0 coins

BenefitsCal shows the plan on the case too. If the county address was wrong, it's possible the plan assignment notice went somewhere else and the plan he's enrolled in isn't what anyone in the household knows about.

0 coins

The dual-eligible situation with Medicare and Medi-Cal is a lot to track, honestly. Medicare pays first for inpatient surgery and most specialist visits, and then Medi-Cal steps in for what's left over — like the Medicare cost-sharing amounts. The surgeon needs to participate in Medicare for Medicare to pay him at all. If he won't bill Medicare, your dad would owe the full surgery cost himself. So the Medicare piece is non-negotiable.

0 coins

That makes the question very clear — the surgeon has to accept Medicare, full stop. We're going to go back to the orthopedic doctor and ask for a referral to someone who does.

0 coins

You can also search for Medicare-participating surgeons through Medicare's own resources. The health plan for Medi-Cal can also point you to specialists in network. Doing both checks makes sense.

0 coins

And once his Medi-Cal is reinstated, make sure the new referral goes through the managed care plan for authorization before the surgery is scheduled. That step protects him from unexpected costs.

0 coins

My parents were in a similar dual-coverage situation and the thing that tripped us up was assuming the managed care plan knew about the Medicare coverage automatically. It doesn't always. We had to report to the county that he had Medicare, which counts as other health coverage, and the county updated the case. After that the plan coordination worked the way it was supposed to.

0 coins

His Medicare has been active for years — would the county already have that on file, or would they need us to report it again?

0 coins

If it's been on the case for a while it's likely already there, but it's worth confirming when you go in with the renewal information. Changes like Medicare starting need to be reported within 10 days, so if it was reported when it started you should be fine. Just have them verify the case shows it.

0 coins

Confirming the other health coverage is listed on the Medi-Cal case is worth doing every renewal anyway. It's one of the things that affects how the plan handles claims.

0 coins

I want to flag something nobody's said directly yet — if the county denied the renewal and your dad thinks it was wrong, there's a 90-day window from the date on the Notice of Action to ask for a State Fair Hearing. The hearing lets him argue the decision in front of a judge who doesn't work for the county or Medi-Cal. That's separate from the 90-day window to submit missing renewal information and get coverage reinstated. Two different things, and both have deadlines.

0 coins

His coverage ended because the form never reached us, not because they denied him — does the hearing option still apply in that situation?

0 coins

If the coverage ended because they said he didn't return the renewal form and you think they had the wrong address or made a mistake in how they handled it, then yes, the hearing option is there. But if you can still fix it by submitting the renewal information within the 90-day reinstatement window, that's usually the faster path. Hearing is more for when the county won't reinstate even though you think they should.

0 coins

Exactly right. Submit the renewal information first and try to get the reinstatement. If the county denies it and you disagree with that decision, that's when the NOA from that denial gives you 90 days to ask for a State Fair Hearing.

0 coins

The surgeon situation also makes me wonder if anyone talked to the health plan's care management team. For a planned surgery on someone who is dual-eligible, the managed care plan sometimes has a care coordinator who can help navigate which facility and surgeon would be in network and authorized. We found one through my father-in-law's plan and it made the whole specialist search much less overwhelming.

0 coins

I didn't even know care coordinators were a thing the plan offered. Would that be through member services or a different number?

0 coins

Member services is the starting point — ask if the plan has a care management or care coordination program for planned procedures. Not every plan calls it the same thing but it's worth asking. For a surgery like a hip procedure, some plans actively help with the authorization process.

0 coins

Care coordination is especially useful for dual-eligible members because there are more moving parts — Medicare primary, Medi-Cal secondary, the managed care plan, the surgeon's billing. Having someone at the plan walk through it with you saves a lot of back-and-forth.

0 coins

Has anyone mentioned that the Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman is an option here? If your dad is having trouble getting the health plan to respond or authorize a referral, 1-888-452-8609 is the number. It's specifically for managed care issues and it's separate from the county office and the main Medi-Cal line.

0 coins

1-888-452-8609 — writing that down. What kinds of issues can they help with exactly?

0 coins

Trouble getting the plan to respond, referral authorizations that aren't moving, problems with how the plan is handling a service request — that kind of thing. They're there specifically for Medi-Cal managed care members who are hitting walls with their plan.

0 coins

Good number to have. For the eligibility and renewal side of things, that's still the county office. The Ombudsman is specifically for the plan relationship, not the county eligibility piece.

0 coins

Two months since coverage ended and you still haven't gotten a Notice of Action at the new address — did the county know about the address change before coverage ended? Because if the address was never updated on the case, any notices would still go to the old address, and the 90-day window and the hearing deadline are both running from the date on that notice whether or not you ever received it.

0 coins

We moved about four months ago and I don't think anyone updated the county. That's probably exactly why the renewal form went to the old address in the first place. So we need to report the new address to the county on top of everything else.

0 coins

Reporting the address is a 10-day requirement whenever you move, so yes, that's something to do right away. You can do it in BenefitsCal, by phone with the county, in person, by email or fax. Getting the right address on file will make sure all future notices reach you.

0 coins

The Inter-County Transfer rules apply if you moved to a different county. If it's the same county, it's just an address update on the case. Either way, report it now and confirm the new address is on file before you submit the renewal information.

0 coins

Appeal timeline tripped me up when I was dealing with my own Medi-Cal situation. I used Claimyr to get a live agent on the Medi-Cal line — the county phone line was just ringing and ringing. The agent looked up my case and confirmed a State Fair Hearing request had actually been filed and was in the system, and told me the date it was submitted. I'd been worried it hadn't gone through because I never got a written confirmation.

0 coins

How did you submit the hearing request? I didn't know you could check whether it was received through the Medi-Cal line.

0 coins

I submitted it through the county office in person and then got anxious it wasn't logged. The agent confirmed the date and that it was in the system. You can also submit a hearing request online or at 1-800-743-8525 if the county isn't reachable.

0 coins

Hearing requests have a 90-day deadline from the NOA date so knowing it was confirmed in the system mattered. Good that you checked.

0 coins

For the surgery coverage question specifically — once your dad's Medi-Cal is reinstated and the managed care plan is confirmed, the authorization process for the surgery goes through the plan. The plan's written approval (or denial) is what you'd receive, and if they deny it, the appeal goes to the plan within 60 days of that denial notice. That sequence matters: get coverage reinstated, confirm the plan, get the referral authorized, then proceed with scheduling.

0 coins

That sequence helps a lot. We were trying to figure out the surgeon situation before fixing the coverage, which was probably backwards.

0 coins

Coverage first, then the authorization. If the surgery gets scheduled and coverage isn't active, you'd be dealing with billing issues afterward that are much harder to untangle than if everything is in order beforehand.

0 coins

And make sure the orthopedic doctor's new referral goes to the plan for authorization before any pre-op appointments are booked. Some offices will try to move forward on scheduling before the authorization is confirmed and that creates problems.

0 coins

NOA date was what I needed to figure out when I was in a similar mess — coverage had ended and I couldn't tell from BenefitsCal exactly when the notice was dated because the envelope arrived late. I ended up getting through to a Medi-Cal agent using Claimyr because the county line had a long hold. The agent confirmed the exact date the Notice of Action was issued on my case, which let me calculate exactly how much time I had left.

0 coins

How long was the hold with the county line normally? We've been trying for days and either get a busy signal or stay on hold so long we give up.

0 coins

The hold was really long when I tried on my own. Having the NOA date confirmed from the agent let me know I was still inside the 90-day window and I went straight to the county office with everything the next morning.

0 coins

Going in person to the county office when the phones aren't working is always an option. The county office can confirm the NOA date, the address on file and what renewal information is still needed, all in one visit.

0 coins

Fee-for-Service Medi-Cal is another thing to look into — if your dad's managed care plan doesn't have a surgeon in network who can do the hip procedure, there may be an option to get the surgery covered outside the plan through Fee-for-Service. That's not always straightforward and the health plan and county office would need to be involved, but for specialized procedures it's worth asking about.

0 coins

I didn't know Fee-for-Service was still an option for people in a managed care plan. Is that something the county decides or the plan?

0 coins

It depends on the situation and the plan. The plan would be the first place to ask, and if they can't authorize the surgery through their network, they may have a process for out-of-network or Fee-for-Service authorization. The plan's care coordinator, if they have one, is probably the right person to ask that question.

0 coins

For a dual-eligible member, Medicare's network is actually the first question because Medicare pays primary. If a Medicare-participating surgeon does the procedure, that changes what Medi-Cal needs to cover. The managed care plan for Medi-Cal would still coordinate on the cost-sharing side.

0 coins

You mentioned the BIC might have gone to the old address too. If your dad doesn't have a current Benefits Identification Card, providers will need it to bill Medi-Cal. Once the coverage is reinstated, the county can issue a new BIC to the correct address. The old one can't be used once a new one is issued, so make sure any providers who have the old number know to use the new one when it arrives.

0 coins

The card he has is a few years old. Would that still be valid, or does it need to be replaced?

0 coins

The BIC doesn't have an expiration date the way a standard insurance card does, but if coverage lapsed and gets reinstated, confirming with the county that the BIC on file is current and the number is active is worth doing. If there's any question, the county can issue a new one.

0 coins

The county office is where you'd go if the card has wrong information or needs to be reissued. Worth mentioning when you go in with the renewal information — just ask them to confirm the BIC is good.

0 coins

DHCS has a Medi-Cal Changes page that covers what's coming in 2027 and beyond. For dual-eligible members your dad's age, most of the upcoming changes like the work rules and the six-month eligibility checks for the income-based adult group won't apply. He's 71 so he falls outside the 19-to-64 age range those rules cover. Focusing on getting the renewal sorted and the surgery authorized is the right priority for his situation.

0 coins

That's actually a relief to hear — we'd seen some mentions of changes coming and weren't sure if they'd affect him. Sounds like for now the main thing is the renewal and then the surgery coverage.

0 coins

Exactly. Get the coverage reinstated, update the address, confirm the health plan on the case, then work with the plan on the referral and authorization. That's the order that makes sense.

0 coins

And if anything unexpected comes back from the county or the plan in writing, the Notice of Action or the plan's written decision is what tells you your options and deadlines. Don't let those letters sit — the deadlines run from the date on the notice, not the date you open it.

0 coins

Dental coverage is separate but worth mentioning for a 71-year-old — Medi-Cal Dental is its own program and has a separate number, 1-800-322-6384. If his dental care has also been disrupted by the coverage gap, that's the line to call about dental specifically. For the surgery and medical coverage, the county office and the managed care plan are the right contacts.

0 coins

Good to know there's a separate dental line. His dentist also mentioned trouble billing recently, so that might be part of the same address and coverage issue.

0 coins

If the dental billing issue started around the same time the coverage lapsed, reinstating the Medi-Cal coverage and updating the address should help on the dental side too. Medi-Cal Dental benefits start from the date of approval and your dad's dental coverage should come back when the Medi-Cal case is reinstated.

0 coins

BenefitsCal is also worth logging into to see what the case currently shows — the renewal due date, the plan on file, any pending items. The sign-in is at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login if you haven't used it. Even with the address issue, the account should still be accessible and you can see what the county has on file and submit a change of address right there.

0 coins

We set up a BenefitsCal account when he applied originally but haven't logged in since. I'll check tonight and see what it shows for the renewal status and address.

0 coins

The account will show you the renewal due date and any items listed as needed. Updating the address in BenefitsCal and submitting the renewal information there would take care of two things at once. Keep a copy of anything you submit.

0 coins

If the account shows the old address, update it first before submitting anything else. That way any notice the county sends after the submission will come to the right place.

0 coins

Medi-Cal AI

Expert Assistant
Secure