Got Medi-Cal card but letters say not eligible due to income — what's going on?
I'm so confused right now. A few weeks ago my BIC showed up in the mail, the actual Benefits Identification Card with my name on it. I was relieved because I'd been waiting and I even used it at a lab visit with no problem. But yesterday I got a Notice of Action in the mail saying I'm not eligible due to income and that my coverage is ending. How do I have a card AND a letter saying I don't qualify? My income hasn't changed since I applied. I reported everything honestly on the BenefitsCal application. Has this happened to anyone else? I don't know if I should call the county, appeal, do nothing, or what.
85 comments

Madison Allen
Renewal due date was what I needed to nail down on my own case — BenefitsCal just showed "pending" on mine and I had no idea when the form was actually due. Claimyr (claimyr.com) waits on hold with the Medi-Cal line for you so you end up talking directly to a live agent; there's a short video about reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent pulled up my case and told me the renewal form had to be in by the 14th of next month, and that nothing had come in yet from my end. Got it uploaded to BenefitsCal that same afternoon.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
The due date thing is what I keep missing too — I never know if BenefitsCal is showing me the actual deadline or just a processing date.
0 coins
Madison Allen
The agent was clear it was the actual due date for the form, not just an internal step. The Notice of Action would go out if nothing came in before that date.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Your situation sounds less urgent than the person who posted this, though — they already got the NOA saying ineligible. That's past the renewal stage.
0 coins
Emily Parker
Income-based denials after a card is already mailed happen when the county processes income verification after the initial approval. Basically, you got provisionally approved, the BIC went out, and then the county reviewed the income proof more closely and issued the denial NOA. That doesn't mean the determination is final — you have 90 days from the date on that Notice of Action to ask for a State Fair Hearing if you disagree with it.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorWait, so the card going out doesn't mean the approval was locked in? I had no idea it could get reversed like that.
0 coins
Emily Parker
The card is mailed once an approval goes through, but the county can still review and issue a corrected decision. The Notice of Action is what actually tells you your status and your rights, including the hearing deadline.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
90 days from the date on the NOA is what everyone keeps saying — is that the date at the top of the letter or the date it was mailed?
0 coins
Emily Parker
DHCS says 90 days from the date on the Notice of Action itself, so go by whatever date is printed on the letter, not the postmark.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Had something similar happen when my hours went up at work mid-year. The county got a data match from somewhere — not sure where — and issued me an NOA that said income was over the limit. I hadn't done anything wrong, it was just that my income had actually changed. Worth double-checking whether anything on your end changed even slightly, because sometimes a one-time payment or a small side job shows up in a way you didn't expect.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorNothing changed for me, same employer, same hours, same pay. I'm going to compare what I reported with what the NOA says the county used.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Comparing those two things is exactly the right move. If the number the county used doesn't match what you actually make, that's what you'd lay out at a State Fair Hearing.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
Data matches from outside sources tripping up cases is a real thing — it happened on my mom's renewal too, turned out to be old info from a prior year.
0 coins
Zara Perez
The 90-day hearing window the person above mentioned is real, but I'd also strongly suggest going to your county office in person or phoning them before you file the hearing request. Sometimes a worker can look at the case and catch an error faster than a full hearing process. The hearing is there if the county won't fix it, but a direct conversation with an eligibility worker is the first step.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorIs there anything I should bring to the county office? The NOA and my pay stubs, I assume?
0 coins
Zara Perez
Bring the NOA, whatever proof of income you have (pay stubs, an employer letter), and your ID. Ask the worker to explain what income figure the county used and where it came from.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Agree with going in person if you can — phone lines at the county office are brutal sometimes, and having the documents right there speeds things up.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Confused about something — are you sure this is a Medi-Cal NOA and not a letter from your health plan? Because I got a letter from my managed care plan once that looked like an official termination notice but it was actually about something in the plan itself, not my Medi-Cal eligibility.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorChecked again — it has the county's letterhead and says "Notice of Action" at the top with a hearing request form attached. Definitely the county, not my health plan.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Ok that makes it clearer. The attached hearing form is specific to the county eligibility decision. Your health plan sends its own notices for in-plan stuff, and those go through the plan's appeal process, not a State Fair Hearing for eligibility.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Good that you caught that distinction — a lot of people mix up the county's eligibility NOA with plan-level denial letters and end up filing with the wrong office.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
SAME THING HAPPENED TO ME last spring and I was absolutely panicked. Card came, used it twice, then the denial letter showed up. Mine turned out to be a clerical error — the county had entered a different income amount than what I sent in. Filed a hearing request AND went to the office, the worker found the mistake and issued a corrected NOA before the hearing date even arrived. Keep all your documents.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorThis is actually reassuring to hear. Did filing the hearing request while also going to the office cause any problems?
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
No problems at all. The worker told me the hearing request was fine to have in and that if the county fixed the case first, the hearing would just get withdrawn. Having it in protected my timeline.
0 coins
Gavin King
The hearing request is a safeguard, not an accusation — filing it doesn't mean you're committed to going through the full process, it just keeps the 90-day window open.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Eligibility based on income uses a specific federal poverty level chart that DHCS updates — it's on their site. If your income is very close to the limit, even a small data discrepancy can flip the decision. When you talk to the county, ask them specifically which FPL percentage your case was evaluated against and what income figure they used.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorWhere exactly does it list the FPL cutoffs? I want to see where my income falls before I go in.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
DHCS's site has an eligibility chart that shows the income ranges by household size. Look at their Help Center or the Apply section — it lays out the income ranges without giving you a single dollar figure since they update it.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Knowing your own number and comparing it to the chart before the meeting makes you look prepared and the worker tends to be more thorough when they see you've done the homework.
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
BenefitsCal was showing my old apartment as the address on my case even after I'd moved, and I didn't realize until a renewal form I never received caused my coverage to end. Used Claimyr to get a live agent on the phone and found out the address on the case hadn't been updated from my previous county. The worker told me how to report the address change and said the ICT to the new county was pending.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorAddress thing isn't my issue since I haven't moved, but the ICT part — what does that mean exactly?
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Inter-County Transfer — when you move to a different county, the case moves with you instead of starting from scratch. Your old county's managed care plan ends on the last day of that month, and you pick a new plan in the new county.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Worth reporting any address change within 10 days per DHCS rules, even if you just move across the street. Mail going to the wrong place is how most people miss renewal forms.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Phone line at my county Medi-Cal office rang for 45 minutes before disconnecting on me twice in a row. If you can't get through that way, the DHCS general Medi-Cal line is 1-800-541-5555. DHCS's site doesn't list hours for it so I don't know exactly when the best window is — I tried Tuesday morning and got through after a while.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorGood to know there's a second number. I'll try the county line first and use 1-800-541-5555 as a backup.
0 coins
Zara Perez
County office is better for your specific case because they have the file. The DHCS line is more general but can sometimes look up basics on a case if the county line is unavailable.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
I tried 1-800-541-5555 on a Monday and it took a long time to get through. Tuesday mid-morning worked a lot better in my experience.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Can I ask what the NOA says the reason is specifically? Mine once said "income exceeds limit" and another time it said "income information not received" — those are very different problems with very different fixes.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorMine says the household income exceeds the limit for the program I'm in. It lists a specific income figure that honestly doesn't match what I reported.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
That gap between what they listed and what you reported is your whole argument. Write down both numbers and bring documentation for yours — that's the core of what a worker or a hearing officer would look at.
0 coins
Emily Parker
If the income figure on the NOA is wrong, that's grounds for disputing the decision outright, not just requesting a review. A hearing officer who sees a document number mismatch tends to focus right on that.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Heard someone say you lose your coverage the day you get the denial letter — that isn't right. The NOA should have an effective date for when the coverage ends, and it's usually not the date the letter was printed. Check the NOA for the coverage end date, because you may have more time to fix this than you think.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorThe effective date on mine is the last day of this month, so I still have about three weeks of coverage while I work on this.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Three weeks is enough time to get to the county office and have a real conversation. If the error is clear, a corrected NOA can come before that date.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Mine was corrected before the end date too — the worker flagged it as a data entry error and the corrected notice came in about 10 days.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Share of cost showing up on my own NOA threw me completely — I genuinely thought it meant Medi-Cal was billing me monthly like a premium. Used Claimyr to reach a live Medi-Cal agent and found out the SOC on my notice only applies in months I actually use care, and I owe it to the provider, not to the state.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
The SOC confusion is so common — the letter doesn't explain it well at all and "share of cost" sounds exactly like a monthly premium.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
The agent also confirmed the SOC resets every month, so a month you don't see any provider, you owe nothing. That part was not obvious from the letter at all.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Important distinction there — the SOC goes to the provider before Medi-Cal pays its portion, and receipts for care outside the Medi-Cal network can even be taken to the county office to count toward it.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Worth noting that if you request a State Fair Hearing before your coverage end date, you may be able to keep your coverage active during the hearing process. That's called "aid paid pending" and you'd have to ask for it specifically when you file.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorAid paid pending — I've never heard that phrase. How do I actually ask for it?
0 coins
Ella Russell
When you request the State Fair Hearing, you tell them you want aid paid pending so your coverage continues while the hearing is open. The county or the hearing request form will have a place for that.
0 coins
Emily Parker
Aid paid pending is definitely something to ask about explicitly — it doesn't happen automatically just because you file the hearing request, you have to ask for it.
0 coins
Gavin King
Confirm before the coverage end date if you go that route — the timing matters a lot and the request needs to be in before coverage actually stops for it to apply.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
Application date and confirmation was something I had to chase down on my own case. BenefitsCal showed submitted but I had no NOA after 50 days and wasn't sure the application had actually been received in the county's system. Used Claimyr and ended up talking to a live agent who told me the application was in, confirmed the filing date, and said a document from me was still pending — my identity proof hadn't been linked to the file.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
50 days with no NOA is past the 45-day window for a standard application. Were you told anything about asking for a State Fair Hearing over the delay?
0 coins
Anna Stewart
The agent said I could request a State Fair Hearing for the delay since the 45 days had passed, but that if I got the identity document in quickly the case might resolve before that became necessary. Sent the document in and the NOA came about 8 days later.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Getting confirmation that a document was pending rather than just waiting blindly is the useful part — without that call you might have kept waiting and the 45 days could have stretched on indefinitely.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Appeals at the State Fair Hearing level are heard by a judge who isn't part of the county or Medi-Cal — that's worth knowing because some people think appealing just means asking the same county worker to look again. It's a separate process with a neutral decision maker.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorDidn't realize it was a different person entirely. I thought appealing just meant going back to the same office.
0 coins
Lucas Turner
The hearing is completely separate. You can also bring someone to help you — a friend, relative or advocate — as long as you give written permission. DHCS's site explains the hearing process and you can request one through the county office, online, or at 1-800-743-8525.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
The fact that it's a neutral judge makes it less intimidating than it sounds. The hearing can even be done by phone if going in person is a problem.
0 coins
Gavin King
My renewal last year went through without any issues but only because I called the county to confirm they had my income documents before the due date. The worker confirmed receipt and I never got a denial. If I hadn't phoned, I'd have been in the same situation — waiting for a letter that never came.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorProactive confirmation seems like the move. I'll ask the county to confirm what documents they have on file when I call about the income discrepancy.
0 coins
Gavin King
Ask them to read back the income figure they have on file. That's how you catch the mismatch before it becomes a formal dispute.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
BenefitsCal lets you submit a change report online if you need to correct your income information — reporting a change within 10 days is what DHCS asks for, and doing it in BenefitsCal is the fastest way to get it documented. That said, in a situation with an already-issued NOA, go to the county directly rather than relying on BenefitsCal alone.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorI'll do both — submit the corrected income info through BenefitsCal and go to the county in person with the documentation.
0 coins
Zara Perez
Doing it both ways creates a paper trail. The in-person visit gets a worker to look at it, and the BenefitsCal submission timestamps when you reported the correction.
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
BenefitsCal's sign-in page is https://benefitscal.com/Public/login if you haven't used it in a while and need to get back in.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
Had a family member get the same card-then-denial sequence because the county used a gross income figure instead of the net. Turned out Medi-Cal eligibility uses a specific income calculation — the worker at the hearing explained that certain deductions are considered. I'd double-check how the county calculated your income, not just what number they used.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
MAGI is the income calculation Medi-Cal uses for most adults — Modified Adjusted Gross Income. It's not just take-home pay and it's not the same as what shows on your pay stub. DHCS's eligibility chart and your county office can explain how it applies to your specific income type.
0 coins
Joshua Wood
That's exactly what the mix-up was for us — my family member's part-time income looked different depending on which calculation method the county used. The hearing officer caught the discrepancy.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
MAGI is the reason why comparing your pay stub directly to the NOA number doesn't always reveal the issue right away — the calculation has its own steps.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Dental coverage works differently from your main Medi-Cal — if your Medi-Cal eligibility is in dispute but active through the end of the month, your Medi-Cal Dental Program coverage should still be active during that time. Keep any dental appointments you have scheduled. Medi-Cal Dental has its own line at 1-800-322-6384 if there's ever a question about dental benefits specifically.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
AuthorGood to know — I have a cleaning scheduled for next week and was worried I'd need to cancel it.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Keep the appointment. Your coverage end date is the last day of the month, and if you're seen before then, Medi-Cal Dental should cover it. Bring your BIC just in case the dental office asks for it.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Dental approval starts from the day Medi-Cal is approved, so whatever coverage you had from your original approval date is still valid through the end date on the NOA.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Posting here in case anyone is following along — the managed care plan side of this is separate from the county eligibility decision. Even if your county case is under review, your plan doesn't automatically do anything different until the county sends them an updated eligibility status. So your plan's member services line and the county office are two different calls for two different things.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Two calls that often contradict each other too — plan member services sometimes says coverage is fine while the county has already issued a termination notice. Always go by what the county NOA says.
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Exactly right — the plan is downstream of the county eligibility decision. The county decides if you qualify, and the plan just provides services within that eligibility period.
0 coins
Katherine Harris
Went to the county office this morning with the NOA and three months of pay stubs. The worker confirmed the income figure on the NOA was different from what I submitted — it matched a figure from a prior employer I hadn't worked at in over a year. She's flagging it for correction and said a new NOA should come within about two weeks. Still going to request the State Fair Hearing in writing just to keep that timeline protected until I see the corrected notice.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Prior employer income showing up on a current case is exactly the kind of data match error that slips through. Glad the worker caught it same day.
0 coins
Emily Parker
Filing the hearing request while the correction is in progress is the right move — if the corrected NOA comes before the hearing date, the request just gets dropped. Keeps you protected either way.
0 coins
Zara Perez
Bring a copy of the hearing request to your county office too, so there's a record that you filed it within the 90 days. That timestamp matters if the correction takes longer than expected.
0 coins
Gavin King
Glad the visit worked out quickly — in-person with documentation in hand is almost always faster than trying to resolve something like that by phone or through BenefitsCal messages.
0 coins