Back to Medi-Cal

Amun-Ra Azra

Can Medi-Cal deny a peer to peer review for medication — what do I do next?

My doctor prescribed a medication last month that my Medi-Cal managed care plan denied. The office submitted a prior authorization and that got denied too. My doctor said she would do a peer to peer review — where she calls the plan's doctor directly to argue for the prescription — and I was counting on that going through. Yesterday her office told me the plan refused to even schedule the peer to peer and my doctor is frustrated. I don't know if the plan is allowed to do that. I've had Medi-Cal for two years, never had an issue like this, and now I'm looking at paying out of pocket for something I genuinely need. Is there a process above the plan that I can go to, or is this just how it goes?

Your plan denying the prior authorization is one thing, but refusing to let your doctor speak to their doctor at all sounds like it's worth pushing back on hard. When a plan denies a service, you have the right to appeal that decision to the plan itself — they're supposed to give you a written denial with a date on it, and you have 60 days from that date to file an appeal. If the plan's appeal doesn't go your way, you can then ask for a State Fair Hearing, and you'd have 120 days from the plan's written decision to do that. The peer to peer is something between your doctor and the plan, so I'd focus on the appeals route you control directly — it doesn't depend on the plan agreeing to schedule anything.

0 coins

60 days from the date on the denial letter — that's what I need to remember. I haven't gotten a written denial for the peer to peer refusal specifically, only for the prior authorization. Does the 60-day clock run from the PA denial or do I need a separate letter for the appeal?

0 coins

The PA denial letter is what starts it. That written denial from the plan is your starting point for the appeal — file it off that date.

0 coins

Agree that the written denial is what matters. File the appeal before that 60-day window closes and document everything — dates you called, what the plan's rep said, the date the peer to peer was refused. It all helps if this ends up at a State Fair Hearing.

0 coins

Had the same situation with a specialty medication — plan denied PA, my doctor tried to schedule a peer to peer, plan kept stalling and never confirmed it. Ended up with weeks going by and nothing resolved. Eventually I filed the appeal directly myself without waiting for the peer to peer to happen, and the plan responded in writing within 30 days. That written answer from the plan was what I needed to then request a State Fair Hearing. Don't wait for the peer to peer — start the appeal clock yourself now.

0 coins

Weeks of stalling and no confirmation — that's exactly what's happening here. I'll file the appeal on my own now. Did you end up needing to do the State Fair Hearing or did the plan overturn at the appeal stage?

0 coins

Plan upheld their denial at the appeal. I did go to the State Fair Hearing. It was a phone hearing, took a few weeks to get scheduled, and a judge who had nothing to do with the plan or Medi-Cal reviewed it. My doctor submitted a letter explaining why this medication specifically. The judge ruled in my favor. It took time but it worked.

0 coins

Phone hearing option is really useful when you can't take time off work to go in person. Good to know the judge is independent of the plan.

0 coins

Benefits Identification Card never showed up after my Medi-Cal was approved in September, and I needed it to pick up a prescription. The pharmacy said they couldn't process my coverage without it. I tried the Medi-Cal line three times over two weeks and couldn't get through — busy signal twice and then a long hold that ended without reaching anyone. A friend suggested Claimyr (claimyr.com), which holds the line on your behalf so you end up on the phone with a live Medi-Cal agent. Video on how that works for reaching a live person: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent pulled up my case and confirmed the BIC had been mailed but to an old address still on file from a previous county. She told me to report the address update to my county office and request a replacement card. I went into the county office the next afternoon and had it sorted.

0 coins

The wrong address issue is something I hadn't thought about — my renewal came to my current address fine but I should double-check the address my plan has on file just in case there's a mismatch somewhere.

0 coins

Address mismatches between what the county has and what a health plan has happen more than people realize. When you move, you report to the county, but sometimes the update takes a little while to flow to the plan. Worth confirming both.

0 coins

Pharmacy turning you away because the BIC never came sounds incredibly stressful. Glad the county office fixed it fast once you had the right information.

0 coins

The appeals process is real but I want to flag something about timing. When you file a plan appeal, ask for an expedited appeal if waiting longer would seriously harm your health. An expedited appeal is faster than the standard 30-day process. Your doctor can also submit a note supporting the expedited request. If your medication is for something urgent or ongoing, that matters a lot.

0 coins

Expedited — I didn't know that option existed. My doctor's office would absolutely write something supporting urgency. I'm going to ask them about that when I call to tell them I'm filing the appeal myself.

0 coins

The expedited path is worth taking when the medication is genuinely time-sensitive. The plan has to respond faster when it's granted. Your doctor's support letter makes a real difference in getting that designation.

0 coins

The plan denied my expedited request once and I had to go back and get more specific documentation from my doctor about why the delay itself was harmful — not just that the medication was important, but that waiting 30 days specifically caused risk. That specificity helped the second time.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something — if Medi-Cal denies it, is that the county saying no or the health plan saying no? Because I thought Medi-Cal was just the government program and the health plan was separate. Are you appealing to the county or to the plan?

0 coins

Medi-Cal is the program, but most members get their actual care through a managed care health plan that contracts with the state. The plan makes the coverage decisions for most services — so a PA denial comes from the plan, not the county office. You appeal to the plan first. If that doesn't work, you go to a State Fair Hearing, which is run by the state, not the plan or the county.

0 coins

Ok so the county office and the health plan are genuinely two different things. The county handles my eligibility and the plan handles whether specific treatments are covered. I had been thinking of them as the same office this whole time.

0 coins

Exactly right. County office = am I eligible, do I have Medi-Cal, is my renewal done. Health plan = is this specific medication or procedure covered under my plan. Different phone numbers, different appeal processes, different timelines. Knowing which one you need saves a lot of wasted calls.

0 coins

Something that helped me when I was going through a denial was calling the Medi-Cal Managed Care Office of the Ombudsman. They're separate from your plan and they help members deal with managed care plan issues — they're at 1-888-452-8609. They can't decide your appeal for you but they can walk you through the process and sometimes help move things along. Worth a call while your appeal is pending.

0 coins

1-888-452-8609 — writing that down right now. Having someone who can walk me through the process while the appeal is in motion would help a lot. I've been piecing all of this together from different sources.

0 coins

The Ombudsman line was way easier to reach than my plan's member services when I had my denial situation. They were patient and clear about what documents to include in the appeal letter.

0 coins

Didn't know that number existed. The Ombudsman being separate from both the county and the plan makes sense — you'd want someone neutral when the plan is the problem.

0 coins

So my doctor never mentioned a peer to peer review to me during my own PA denial. I found out from this thread that it was an option. Now I'm realizing maybe my denial last year could have gone differently if I had known to ask. How do patients even find out about these things?

0 coins

Honestly a lot of people don't, until they're already deep in a denial situation. Your doctor's office is supposed to know the options, but they're busy and sometimes don't explain them. When you get a denial, ask the plan's member services specifically what your options are — they're required to tell you about the appeals process in the denial letter itself.

0 coins

The denial letter I got last year had a lot of small print but I didn't read it carefully. I think the appeals information was in there and I just didn't see it. Definitely reading everything more carefully going forward.

0 coins

Has anyone had the plan deny a peer to peer and then had it approved on appeal without the peer to peer ever happening? Curious whether the peer to peer matters if the appeal goes through its own process anyway.

0 coins

My appeal went forward without the peer to peer happening and was decided on the written documentation alone — my doctor's letter and the medical records she submitted. The peer to peer would have been faster if the plan had agreed to it, but it isn't required for the appeal to succeed.

0 coins

The appeal is its own track. The peer to peer is informal and quick if both sides agree to it, but the formal appeal and State Fair Hearing route doesn't depend on it. The written record — denial letter, your doctor's clinical notes, any supporting documentation — is what the appeal and the hearing judge both look at.

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. The peer to peer felt like the only path and now I know there's a whole separate formal track. My situation is different from the OP's but I've been worried about a PA on a renewal for a long medication I've been on for years.

0 coins

The plan dragged it out for WEEKS on my prior auth and nobody told me I could ask for an expedited appeal during that time. By the time I figured it out the standard 30-day window was already running. The managed care system makes you do so much research just to use a benefit you're already entitled to. I had to figure out the Ombudsman number on my own too — it should be on the first page of every denial letter, not buried.

0 coins

The Ombudsman number really should be more visible. The denial letters I've seen put the appeal instructions in the smallest print possible. The system does seem to count on members not knowing their options.

0 coins

WEEKS of back and forth with member services and I was never once told about expedited appeals either. I only found out when my doctor's office mentioned it.

0 coins

The buried information problem is real — I read my denial notice three times and didn't see the word 'expedited' anywhere in it. I'm going to ask the plan directly when I call to file the appeal.

0 coins

Moving from Sacramento County to Fresno County two months ago meant my old managed care plan ended, and I needed to enroll in a plan in Fresno. My county transfer was supposed to happen automatically but BenefitsCal still showed my old plan weeks later. I tried the Medi-Cal line a few times and kept running into long holds that ended without getting through. I ended up using Claimyr, which holds for you while you wait and puts you on with a live Medi-Cal agent. The worker confirmed my Inter-County Transfer had processed and that my Fresno County plan enrollment was pending with Health Care Options — she told me to call 1-800-430-4263 to follow up on the enrollment. I did that the same day and got my new plan sorted.

0 coins

Health Care Options at 1-800-430-4263 for the plan change — that number keeps coming up in this thread and I should save it in case my plan situation changes after this appeal.

0 coins

The ICT went through on the county side fine, it was just the plan enrollment piece that lagged. Health Care Options handles that side. Worth knowing they're the right number for plan questions specifically, not the county office.

0 coins

I always thought one phone call to the county covered everything — now I know Health Care Options is the separate number for plan enrollment. Good to have both.

0 coins

Is the State Fair Hearing process really open to anybody on Medi-Cal or is it only for certain kinds of denials? I've heard people say it's only for eligibility stuff, not for coverage decisions the health plan makes.

0 coins

State Fair Hearings cover both. An eligibility decision — the county denying your Medi-Cal or ending it — yes. But also a plan's denial of a service after you've exhausted the plan's own appeal. After the plan issues its written decision on your appeal, you have 120 days to request a State Fair Hearing. It's the same 1-800-743-8525 number either way, or you can go through the county office. The hearing is in front of a judge who is independent of both the plan and the county.

0 coins

120 days after the plan's written appeal decision — that's a longer window than I thought. I assumed it was 90 days for everything.

0 coins

The 90 days is for eligibility decisions — the county denying or ending your Medi-Cal coverage. The 120 days is specifically for plan service denials after the plan-level appeal. Different clocks for different decisions, which is confusing but worth knowing when you're counting days.

0 coins

My plan denied a prior auth last spring and I called member services and they told me verbally that peer to peers 'weren't guaranteed' — which I took to mean they were optional on the plan's end. Ended up just filing the appeal without it. Went to a State Fair Hearing eventually. What I wish I had done earlier was contact the Ombudsman the day the peer to peer was refused, not months later when I was already exhausted from the process.

0 coins

Contacting the Ombudsman early is the right call. They can't force the plan to do anything but their involvement sometimes changes how the plan responds to the appeal. Having that documentation that you reached out also helps if the case goes to a hearing.

0 coins

The hearing judge asked me a lot about the timeline — when I first contacted the plan, when I filed the appeal, what the plan said at each step. Having written notes with dates would have helped me answer those questions better than I did.

0 coins

Writing down every date and what was said — that's something I'm starting today. Date the PA was denied, date my doctor's office said the peer to peer was refused, date I'm filing the appeal.

0 coins

There is a lot of good information in here. For anyone still confused on the basic path: the plan denies the PA, you file an appeal with the plan within 60 days of their written denial, the plan responds within 30 days (faster if expedited), if the plan upholds the denial you request a State Fair Hearing within 120 days of that written decision. The Ombudsman at 1-888-452-8609 can help at any stage. That's the core process.

0 coins

60 days to appeal, 30 days for plan response, 120 days to request the hearing after that. Having those numbers laid out in order finally makes the whole process make sense to me.

0 coins

I'd add: ask for expedited at the appeal stage if waiting 30 days is a health risk. It doesn't always get granted but it costs nothing to ask and your doctor's support makes it more likely.

0 coins

Expedited appeals being an option is the detail that changes things the most. I went through a standard 30-day appeal window for something that really could have been expedited and I didn't know. Glad it's being said clearly here.

0 coins

To add to what's been said — when you file the appeal yourself, put it in writing, even if the plan says you can do it by phone. A written appeal creates a paper trail that becomes important if you end up at a State Fair Hearing. Include the date of the denial, your doctor's name, the medication or treatment, and a brief statement that the plan refused to schedule a peer to peer review. Keep a copy.

0 coins

Written appeal with the date, the medication, the doctor's name, and the peer to peer refusal noted — I can do that. I'll send it certified mail so I have proof of delivery too.

0 coins

Certified mail is exactly right. Or if the plan has a secure member portal for submitting appeals, that also creates a timestamped record. Either way you want something that shows when it was received.

0 coins

The timestamped record matters especially if the plan tries to argue later that you filed outside the 60-day window. Document delivery, not just sending.

0 coins

Didn't realize the peer to peer was between the doctors and not something a patient requests directly. I always thought it was something I was supposed to arrange. So the plan refusing to schedule it really is on the plan's side, not something I did wrong in my own situation last year?

0 coins

The peer to peer is a doctor-to-doctor conversation — your prescribing doctor calls the plan's medical reviewer to discuss the clinical reasons for the medication. The patient doesn't set it up. The plan's refusal to schedule it is on the plan's side entirely. What you can control is the formal appeal, which is entirely your right as the member.

0 coins

That changes how I understood my denial last year. I thought I had missed a step I was supposed to take. Turns out I didn't miss anything — the plan just never scheduled it and I didn't know to file the appeal on my own track.

0 coins

A lot of members go through exactly that — they wait for the peer to peer to resolve it and the window to appeal quietly closes. The appeal clock doesn't pause while the peer to peer is being scheduled or refused. That's the part worth knowing upfront.

0 coins

Proof of my employment change took longer than I expected to get in order, and by the time I uploaded it to BenefitsCal my renewal was already past the due date. I could see on BenefitsCal that something was flagged but I couldn't tell whether the county had received the documents or was still waiting on them. I tried calling twice and both times I was on hold for over 30 minutes before the call dropped. I used Claimyr to reach a live Medi-Cal agent, and she confirmed the county was still waiting for one more document — my most recent pay stub, not the letter I had uploaded. I got that submitted through BenefitsCal the same afternoon.

0 coins

The 'flagged but unclear what it means' problem in BenefitsCal is something I've run into too. Knowing the exact document that's still missing is so much more useful than a vague pending status.

0 coins

Pay stub versus the employment letter — those being different things matters because the county is specific about what it's asking for. Getting the exact name of the missing document instead of guessing saves time and prevents submitting the wrong thing twice.

0 coins

Dropped after 30 minutes twice in a row is genuinely demoralizing. At that point you've spent an hour trying to fix a one-document issue.

0 coins

For people dealing with this — if your medication is denied and you're waiting on the appeal, ask your doctor if there's a clinically similar medication that IS on the plan's formulary. Sometimes there's a covered alternative that can bridge the gap while the appeal is in process. Your doctor would know whether that's medically appropriate for your situation. It doesn't mean giving up on the appeal.

0 coins

My doctor already checked the formulary and said there isn't a comparable alternative — that's part of why she pushed so hard for the PA and wanted to do the peer to peer. But for people who do have an alternative, that's genuinely useful to know.

0 coins

The lack of a formulary alternative actually strengthens your appeal. If there's no covered substitute and your doctor documents that, that's exactly the kind of clinical argument that carries weight at a State Fair Hearing.

0 coins

No covered alternative and medical documentation of why — that combination was part of what won my hearing. The hearing judge asked specifically whether the plan's denial had addressed the absence of alternatives and the plan's written record hadn't.

0 coins

Renewal form question on my own case — the envelope came in October but I was away for work for two weeks and missed submitting it by the due date. Coverage ended at the end of October. I wasn't sure if it was too late to do anything without starting a whole new application. I used Claimyr to reach a Medi-Cal agent, and she told me my case was still within 90 days of the coverage end date and I could submit all the renewal information without applying again. If the county confirmed I still qualified, my coverage would go back without a gap. I went to the county office the next morning with everything they needed.

0 coins

90 days after coverage ends to submit without reapplying — that's such a critical thing to know and I genuinely would not have remembered that detail under stress.

0 coins

The agent was clear that the 90 days started from when coverage ended, not from when I noticed. I was about six weeks in so there was time, but it was still a push to get everything together fast.

0 coins

The 90-day reinstatement window with no gap in coverage is one of the most important things in the whole Medi-Cal system and most members have no idea it exists until coverage is already gone. Worth knowing before you ever need it.

0 coins

Quick question for anyone who's been through the State Fair Hearing — the judge being independent of the plan and the county, does that mean the judge actually understands medical issues or are they more of a legal/process referee? I'm trying to understand what kind of argument works at a hearing.

0 coins

The hearing in my experience was both. The judge reviewed whether the plan followed its own process correctly and whether the clinical reasons for denial held up. My doctor's letter explaining why this specific medication was medically necessary — not just useful, but necessary — was what mattered most. Clear, specific medical language from your doctor carries a lot of weight.

0 coins

The judge in my case asked very specific questions about what the plan's written denial said and whether the plan had addressed my doctor's clinical reasoning. The plan's denial in my case was mostly boilerplate and the judge noticed that.

0 coins

Boilerplate denial language versus specific clinical reasoning from the treating doctor — that's the contrast the judge is looking for. That helps me understand what to put in the appeal letter now, before it even gets to a hearing.

0 coins

Has the county Medi-Cal office ever gotten involved in a plan's coverage denial, or is it really fully separate? I keep thinking if I call the county and explain my situation they can do something, but reading this thread it sounds like the county handles eligibility and the plan handles coverage.

0 coins

Exactly right — the county office manages eligibility: do you have Medi-Cal, when does it renew, what address is on file. Coverage decisions — whether a medication or procedure is covered — that's the plan. The county office can't override the plan's denial. For plan decisions you go to the plan's appeal process, then the State Fair Hearing. The Ombudsman at 1-888-452-8609 is the right bridge when it's the plan causing the problem.

0 coins

Calling the county for a plan denial, calling the plan for a renewal question — I've definitely made both of those mistakes. No wonder nothing got resolved quickly.

0 coins

Those misdirected calls are incredibly common. The county office's number and the plan's member services number being different — and both separate from the Ombudsman — is something a lot of members figure out the hard way. Keep all three numbers saved.

0 coins

Posting an update: filed the written appeal with the plan today, certified mail, and included my doctor's letter explaining why there's no formulary alternative. I also requested expedited review and asked her to submit a supporting note on urgency. I called the Ombudsman line and they were very helpful — walked me through what to expect in the plan's response and what to include if it goes to a State Fair Hearing. I feel like I actually have a path forward now instead of just waiting to see what the plan does.

0 coins

Certified mail, expedited request, the Ombudsman already looped in — that's a solid position. The plan knowing there's already Ombudsman involvement sometimes changes the tone of their response.

0 coins

Doctor's letter noting no formulary alternative, submitted with the expedited request — that combination is strong. Keep copies of everything you sent and note the date and tracking number.

0 coins

The update is good to hear. Coming back to say the Ombudsman was helpful is useful for other people reading this thread who are deciding whether to call that number.

0 coins

Medi-Cal AI

Expert Assistant
Secure