Back to Medi-Cal

Nina Fitzgerald

Can I have Medi-Cal and a private off exchange plan at the same time?

My hours got cut at work in September and my income dropped enough that I qualified for Medi-Cal, so I applied and got approved last month. But I never canceled the private plan I was already paying for through my employer's marketplace — it's not a Covered CA plan, it's a separate off-exchange plan I found on my own. Now I'm wondering if having both is even allowed or if it causes some problem with my Medi-Cal case. The county hasn't said anything yet and my BIC arrived fine, but I want to make sure I'm not doing something wrong before renewal comes around. Has anyone dealt with carrying both at once?

Carrying both is allowed — Medi-Cal doesn't require you to drop other coverage first. The rule the county cares about is that you tell them about it. Other health coverage has to be reported to the county, so if you didn't put it on the application, you want to let them know within 10 days. When you have both, most providers will bill the private plan first and Medi-Cal second. The county will note it on your case and it's pretty common for people between jobs or on reduced hours to end up in this situation.

0 coins

Hours dropped to part-time in September, so I didn't think to put the private plan on the application. I'll go into BenefitsCal and report it now. Is there a specific section for that or just the general update form?

0 coins

In BenefitsCal you'd report it as a change to your coverage information — there's no separate spot just for the other plan, you just log in at https://benefitscal.com/Public/login and report the change. If you're not sure what it needs from you, the county office can walk you through it by phone.

0 coins

Agreed that reporting is the move here. I had a job plan and Medi-Cal at the same time for about four months and nobody flagged me for having both, but when my renewal came the county asked about it and I was glad I'd already told them.

0 coins

October's Notice of Action on my case listed the approval date but nothing about whether I had to drop my off-exchange plan, so I wasn't sure either. I tried the Medi-Cal line a few times and it rang for a long time with no answer. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) — it waits on hold with the Medi-Cal line so you end up talking to a live agent. Video on reaching a live person at Medi-Cal: https://youtu.be/NXjJFZObk3g. The agent pulled up my Notice of Action and told me the date it was issued and that the case showed my private plan was already on file from my application. That settled the question for me — I hadn't missed anything.

0 coins

Mine didn't have that detail on it, the Notice of Action just said approved. Good to know the agent can actually pull what's in the case and not just read from a script.

0 coins

The Medi-Cal line being hard to get through is a consistent problem. I spent most of a Tuesday morning on it before I got anyone.

0 coins

Tuesday morning was rough for me too. I tried a few times across different days before I went the Claimyr route.

0 coins

My friend had both and she said Medi-Cal won't pay for things her private plan already covered, which makes sense — it's supposed to fill the gaps. She kept hers because her kids were on Medi-Cal separately and she was on the private plan, so they all ended up covered differently.

0 coins

The gap-filling part is accurate. Medi-Cal generally acts as the payer of last resort, so the private plan goes first and Medi-Cal picks up what's left depending on what's covered.

0 coins

Wait so do you still get the BIC and use it even if you have another plan? I thought maybe you only used one or the other.

0 coins

You still use the BIC — your providers need it to bill Medi-Cal for whatever the other plan doesn't cover. Keep both cards handy and give them both when you check in somewhere.

0 coins

I got confused about this for a while because I thought any private plan I had would automatically cancel my Medi-Cal. That's not how it works. The two can run at the same time and the county just wants to know. Where people get in trouble is not reporting the other coverage and then at renewal the county sees something they didn't put down.

0 coins

The not-reporting part is what gets people. I know someone who forgot to list a job plan at renewal and had a whole back-and-forth with the county about it. It got sorted but it delayed things.

0 coins

Okay this is making me feel better about having not put it on the application. As long as I report it now, within the 10-day window, I should be fine.

0 coins

Honestly the whole two-plans thing confused me because I thought off-exchange meant it couldn't interact with Medi-Cal at all. I was mixing it up with the Covered CA restriction, where you can't have both a Covered CA plan and Medi-Cal at the same time. Off-exchange is different.

0 coins

This is a really important distinction. Covered CA and Medi-Cal are separate programs — if the county determines you qualify for Medi-Cal, you wouldn't be in a Covered CA plan at the same time. But an off-exchange private plan you're paying for yourself is a different situation. That's just other health coverage, and the county treats it as something to report, not something that disqualifies you.

0 coins

Yeah I was definitely getting those mixed up. I went in thinking they all worked the same way but the off-exchange one is just a private plan you bought, not one the state marketplace sold you.

0 coins

I made the same mistake. Called the county thinking my private plan was going to get me kicked off Medi-Cal and the worker just said to report it and that was it.

0 coins

The 10-day reporting rule applies to any change, and picking up other health coverage during the year counts. I reported a new job plan in August by just updating through BenefitsCal and the county sent a letter acknowledging it. Nothing else changed on my case.

0 coins

BenefitsCal sent you a letter after, or the county did? I want to make sure I'm watching for the right thing.

0 coins

The county sent a letter, technically a Notice of Action, confirming the update was noted. BenefitsCal just showed the submission went through.

0 coins

Good to know about the letter. I reported a change earlier this year and didn't realize I'd get a notice about it, so I almost threw it out thinking it was junk mail.

0 coins

My situation was a little different — I had Medi-Cal and was also on a parent's plan. Same idea though. The county needed to know about it and when my renewal came they asked if I still had the other coverage. Having both didn't end my Medi-Cal, it just means they coordinate which plan pays first.

0 coins

Coordination of benefits is the official term for it. Medi-Cal calls itself the last resort payer, meaning it steps in after everything else has gone through.

0 coins

Right, and in practice I found most billing offices knew exactly what to do with both — they're used to people on Medi-Cal also having something else.

0 coins

Coverage had stopped on my case for a few months earlier this year because of a renewal form I didn't get in time. When I finally got everything together I wasn't sure if I was still inside the window to fix it without starting over. The Medi-Cal line just kept ringing so I tried Claimyr — ended up talking to an agent who checked my case and confirmed I was still inside the 90-day period to submit the missing information without filing a new application. That was a relief because I had an appointment coming up.

0 coins

The 90-day window for getting coverage reinstated is something I hadn't heard of before reading this. That's really useful to know in case anything ever goes wrong with my renewal.

0 coins

The agent was clear that it only works if you still qualify, but at least you don't have to start the whole process from scratch within that window. I got my information in and the county reinstated it.

0 coins

Had a gap in mine once too and panicked thinking I'd lost it for good. Ended up being fixable, just took a few weeks to process.

0 coins

The private plan question comes up a lot at open enrollment time when people are trying to decide whether to keep paying for a plan if they just got Medi-Cal approved. The answer I always tell people is: you can keep both, just tell the county. If you're paying out of pocket for the private plan and you're on Medi-Cal, it's worth asking yourself whether the private plan is worth the cost, but that's your call, not the county's.

0 coins

My situation exactly at open enrollment last year. I kept the private plan through December just to get through some scheduled appointments, then dropped it in January when I felt more settled. County never had an issue with it.

0 coins

Does the private plan affect what Medi-Cal will and won't cover? Like does having it make Medi-Cal cover less?

0 coins

Medi-Cal still covers what it covers — having other insurance doesn't shrink your Medi-Cal benefits. What changes is the billing order: the private plan goes first. For anything the private plan doesn't cover or covers partially, Medi-Cal can still step in.

0 coins

I want to flag one thing the previous comments didn't mention: if your employer is contributing to that private plan, that's considered other health coverage and is definitely something the county wants on record. I had to list my employer's contribution amount on the renewal form.

0 coins

Mine is partly employer-paid, so I'll make sure to include that detail when I report it. Good point.

0 coins

The renewal form does ask about employer-sponsored coverage specifically. If the plan is offered through work, even if you're paying some of the premium yourself, it goes in that section.

0 coins

Dropped from full-time to 20 hours in the spring and ended up in this same two-plan situation. At the time I was scared the county would say I had to pick one, but the worker I eventually reached said as long as the coverage was reported, the case was fine. The county doesn't tell you to drop a plan you're paying for.

0 coins

That's consistent with what mine said. The county isn't monitoring whether your private plan is worth keeping financially — that's up to you.

0 coins

Exactly. The county cares whether you disclosed it, not whether you're being smart about your money.

0 coins

Undisclosed other coverage is what causes headaches at renewal. Disclosed coverage is basically a non-issue.

0 coins

Had a job plan and Medi-Cal overlap for about three months when I started a new job mid-year. Providers were sometimes confused about which to bill first but it always worked out. The only hassle was making sure the dental office knew to send it to Medi-Cal Dental after the private plan paid. The two programs don't always talk to each other automatically.

0 coins

Medi-Cal Dental being separate from the main Medi-Cal coverage trips a lot of people up. Dental providers need to bill Medi-Cal Dental specifically, at 1-800-322-6384, not just Medi-Cal generally.

0 coins

My dentist's office knew the number but they had to be reminded I had the BIC for dental too. After that it went fine.

0 coins

The dental piece is worth mentioning to every provider upfront. I had a cleaning where the office billed the wrong program first and it took two months to sort out.

0 coins

Does any of this change at the six-month check that's coming in 2027? I keep seeing that mentioned and I don't know if it means they're going to look more closely at other coverage you have.

0 coins

The six-month eligibility checks starting in 2027 are for adults 19 to 64 in the income-based group. What they're checking is whether you still qualify, not specifically whether you have other coverage — though income changes would matter. DHCS's Medi-Cal Changes page has the details if you want to read the official version.

0 coins

Okay so it's really about income, not whether you have a second plan. That makes more sense.

0 coins

Reporting other coverage now puts you in a better position for any check down the road. If the county already has it on file, there's nothing surprising to explain.

0 coins

Health plan assigned on my case wasn't one I recognized and I wasn't sure if having a private plan too was what caused the mix-up. I reached a Medi-Cal agent through Claimyr — waited and ended up on the phone with someone who pulled up my file and told me which managed care plan my case showed and that my private plan being on record didn't affect the assignment. The assignment happens by county and what plans are available there.

0 coins

I hadn't thought about whether having other coverage affects which managed care plan you get assigned to. Good to know it doesn't — that would have been confusing.

0 coins

The agent said the private plan was just noted as other coverage. The managed care assignment is completely separate. I ended up switching through Health Care Options anyway because there was another plan in my county I preferred.

0 coins

Health Care Options is 1-800-430-4263 for anyone who needs to switch plans. You have 30 days after approval to pick one, or they assign you.

0 coins

The managed care plan thing is what I was most confused about when I first got approved. I thought my private plan was my Medi-Cal plan. They're not the same thing. Medi-Cal assigns you to a managed care plan for your county and that's what you use for Medi-Cal-covered visits, separate from whatever private plan you might have.

0 coins

I made that exact mistake. Showed up at a doctor's office with just my private plan card and had no idea I also had a Medi-Cal managed care plan I was supposed to be using.

0 coins

Same. The packet that comes in the mail with the plan information kind of looks like junk so I almost didn't open it. The Health Care Options mailer has the plan choices in it.

0 coins

Reporting the coverage online in BenefitsCal was faster for me than trying to call. I logged in, went to report a change, added the other plan information, and it submitted in a few minutes. The county sent a Notice of Action about two weeks later acknowledging it.

0 coins

Two weeks feels manageable. I'll do it today since I'm already past the 10-day window technically.

0 coins

Getting it in late is still better than not getting it in at all. The county can note when it was submitted.

0 coins

Late is better than never with these things. The county isn't going to penalize you for fixing it once you know about the rule.

0 coins

I was nervous to have both because I thought my private insurance company might find out I was on Medi-Cal and cancel my plan or raise my rate. Does that happen?

0 coins

That's not something a county Medi-Cal worker handles — a question about what your private plan's terms say would be one for the plan itself. The county only cares about you reporting it. What the private plan does on their end is between you and them.

0 coins

Makes sense, I'll check the plan's terms. I was overthinking the Medi-Cal side of it.

0 coins

Worth knowing for the renewal coming up: the renewal form in the yellow envelope will ask about all health coverage you currently have. Having the other plan already reported means you can just confirm it rather than scrambling to explain it at renewal time. I learned that the hard way when my renewal form came and I hadn't reported a job plan I picked up mid-year.

0 coins

The yellow envelope is the one that needs to be sent back — not to be confused with the auto renewal letter, where you don't have to do anything. If you get the yellow envelope, fill it out before the due date on the form or coverage ends.

0 coins

Yes and the due date is printed right on the form, easy to miss if you're opening it fast. Mark it somewhere.

0 coins

I nearly missed mine because I saw 'renewal' and assumed it was just informational. It was not.

0 coins

For the original question: having both is fine, reporting is mandatory, and once it's on file the county treats it as coordination of benefits going forward. At renewal you'll confirm it's still active and that's essentially it. The situation you're in is common and the system is set up to handle it.

0 coins

Reported it in BenefitsCal this afternoon. Feels better having it done. I'll watch for a Notice of Action in the mail confirming it.

0 coins

That's the right step. When the notice comes, check that it shows the coverage correctly and reach out to the county office if anything looks off.

0 coins

Keeping the notice when it arrives is worth doing. It's your documentation that you reported it.

0 coins

Medi-Cal AI

Expert Assistant
Secure