Back to Covered California

Zoe Gonzalez

Medi-Cal says no longer eligible MAGI but income under limit why

Got a notice last month saying I'm no longer eligible for Medi-Cal under MAGI rules. The thing is, I pulled up the federal poverty level charts and my income is definitely under the threshold. Single adult household, I work part time at a restaurant and do some weekend catering gigs on the side. The letter just says I no longer qualify and gives me a date when coverage ends. No explanation of what changed or what I did wrong. I've been on Medi-Cal for about two years without any issues. I did my renewal paperwork through the county portal back in September and thought everything was fine. Now this notice shows up and I genuinely don't understand it. Did they count my catering income differently? Is there a different income calculation for MAGI that I'm not aware of? And what am I supposed to do about health coverage now if this doesn't get resolved quickly? The letter mentions something about Covered California but I'm not sure if that's just a generic thing they put on all these notices or if I'm actually supposed to do something there.

Application status on my case sat at submitted for over three weeks before I got a letter that made no sense either. The county portal just showed pending with no detail. I ended up letting Claimyr (claimyr.com) handle the hold time while I was at work, and the Covered California representative I reached told me the application had gone to the county for a Medi-Cal determination and listed the exact date it was submitted — which was two days later than I thought, which explained the gap. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at Covered California: https://youtu.be/9y0sXw7pbJU What the rep also confirmed is that the one application checks both programs at once — so if the county decides someone doesn't qualify for Medi-Cal, that same application can open a path to a Covered California plan. The notice about Covered California at the bottom of your letter is not generic filler. It's telling you that you now have a window to enroll through Covered California, and that window is 90 days from when Medi-Cal ends.

0 coins

90 days from when Medi-Cal ends — that's actually useful to know. The letter gives an end date so I can count from there. Did the representative say anything about whether the financial help would apply automatically or whether that's a separate thing to figure out?

0 coins

Financial help through Covered California isn't automatic — you have to go through the application and the eligibility results tell you what you qualify for. Shop and Compare on Covered California's site can give you an estimate before you even start.

0 coins

Makes sense that it's not just handed to me. I'll look at Shop and Compare first so I at least know what I'm walking into before I apply.

0 coins

MAGI stands for modified adjusted gross income and it is not the same calculation as just looking at a poverty level chart. That's where a lot of people get tripped up. The catering side income you mentioned — if that wasn't reported to the county consistently and then showed up in a tax record or wage match, the county may have recalculated your total income using a different figure than what you thought you reported. The MAGI rules count wages, tips, self-employment income, and a few other things, and the county does data matches during renewal to verify what was entered against outside sources.

0 coins

The catering work is cash-based and I honestly wasn't sure how to report it since it varies so much week to week. Could that inconsistency be what flagged things?

0 coins

Exactly that kind of inconsistency can cause a mismatch when the county checks records. For Medi-Cal questions you'd need to go to your county Medi-Cal office directly — they're the ones who handled the determination, and Covered California's service center won't be able to change a Medi-Cal decision. But understanding what income you're supposed to count is a good first step before you do anything else.

0 coins

Tips count as income under MAGI rules too, not just the base catering pay. Easy thing to miss if you're not used to tracking it separately.

0 coins

Didn't realize tips were specifically counted. I definitely wasn't reporting those consistently. Starting to see why the numbers might not have matched.

0 coins

Medi-Cal renewals go through the county on the person's own schedule, not on the standard open enrollment calendar. So even if you renewed in September without any issues showing up at the time, the county can still run a data match afterward and send a termination if something doesn't line up. The county portal showing no problems in September doesn't mean the case was fully closed — it means the renewal packet was received. The actual eligibility review can take longer.

0 coins

County portal said the same thing for my mom's case, looked totally fine and then a termination letter showed up six weeks later. She had to go in person to the office to sort it out.

0 coins

In-person visits to the county office are really the most direct way to understand a Medi-Cal determination. The county decides Medi-Cal, not Covered California, so the county office is where the explanation lives.

0 coins

The notice mentioning Covered California is specifically required by state law when Medi-Cal ends and the person might qualify for a marketplace plan instead. It is not boilerplate. It should include an access code or case number, and there is a deadline on there — take both seriously. If you use that access code when you apply through Covered California, the system already has some of your information and you won't have to start completely from scratch.

0 coins

Mine does have a code and a deadline on it. I wasn't sure whether the code actually did anything but if it pre-fills information that saves me a step.

0 coins

Access code on those Medi-Cal transition notices is legitimate — used one myself and it pulled in household and address info. Still had to review and confirm everything but it was a faster start.

0 coins

Review everything it pulls in carefully. Income and household details from a Medi-Cal case may not reflect what you'd report on a Covered California application, since the program rules are a little different on what counts.

0 coins

Start date on my Covered California plan was what I needed to confirm after I enrolled through one of those transition notices. The plan should start the first of the month after you pick it, but I wanted to make sure there was no gap between when Medi-Cal ended and the new plan kicked in. Claimyr sat on hold for me one afternoon and the representative pulled up my case and read out exactly which date my new plan was set to start — it lined up with the day after my Medi-Cal end date, which was what I was hoping for.

0 coins

Gap between Medi-Cal ending and a new plan starting is exactly what I'm worried about. Good to know that the start date can be confirmed by calling.

0 coins

Choosing the plan quickly after Medi-Cal ends is really important for keeping that gap as small as possible. Covered California's site says coverage typically starts the first of the month after you choose a plan, so the sooner you pick, the better the timing.

0 coins

Picking fast was what made the difference in my case. I enrolled within a week of getting the notice and the start date matched up without any gap.

0 coins

There's a distinction worth flagging between disputing the Medi-Cal termination and just moving forward with Covered California. If you think the county made an error in the eligibility determination, you have the right to appeal that through the county — not through Covered California. Covered California handles appeals about its own enrollment decisions, financial help amounts, and special enrollment. A Medi-Cal determination appeal goes elsewhere. The two processes are separate and running them in parallel is possible — you can appeal the Medi-Cal decision AND apply to Covered California at the same time.

0 coins

Running both at the same time hadn't occurred to me. So I could be appealing the Medi-Cal termination with the county while also enrolling in a Covered California plan in case the appeal takes a while?

0 coins

Correct. And given how long county appeal processes can take, having a Covered California plan in place while the Medi-Cal question is being sorted out means you won't be uninsured during that period.

0 coins

Filing an appeal with the county while already enrolled through Covered California is exactly what my neighbor did last year. Covered California let her enroll without waiting for the county process to finish.

0 coins

Self-employment income including catering work is counted under MAGI at net — meaning after business expenses, not gross. So if you had supply costs, transportation, or equipment for the catering jobs and you weren't deducting those when you reported income to the county, your reported income may have looked higher than the actual net. That's not a Covered California rule, it's how the income calculation works for both programs. Worth knowing before you report income on a Covered California application so you're using the right number.

0 coins

Net after expenses is a detail I completely missed. I was just reporting what I got paid without thinking about what I spent to do the work. That could have made my income look higher than it actually was.

0 coins

Exactly. And for the Covered California application, they want the income you expect to earn this year, not last year's figure. So if your catering work has changed recently, use a current estimate, not a tax return number.

0 coins

Used last year's tax return for my self-employment income when I should have used a current year estimate and ended up getting less financial help than I was actually entitled to. Had to report a change mid-year to fix it.

0 coins

The 90-day window from Medi-Cal ending is a special enrollment period, not the regular open enrollment. The difference matters because outside of open enrollment, only people who have a qualifying life event can enroll. Losing Medi-Cal is specifically listed as one of those qualifying events, so you don't have to wait until November to sign up. You have 90 days from the date coverage ends.

0 coins

Losing Medi-Cal being a qualifying event is something I did not know until I was already in that situation. Spent two weeks thinking I had to wait for open enrollment and almost let the window close.

0 coins

Two weeks of that window is not much to lose but the 90-day period is forgiving enough that catching it at two weeks still leaves plenty of time. The important thing is not to assume you have to wait until November.

0 coins

Really glad this was clarified because I definitely assumed I had to wait until open enrollment. 90 days is actually enough time to understand my options before I commit to something.

0 coins

MAGI income calculation catching people off guard is a consistent theme on this forum. For anyone reading: tips, cash payments for services, and irregular gig income all count under MAGI, and the county checks wages reported to the Employment Development Department and sometimes IRS data during renewals. When those numbers don't match what someone reported, the case gets flagged and the determination goes against the person even if their actual net income is under the limit. That's not Covered California's rule — it's how Medi-Cal determines eligibility, through the county.

0 coins

EDD reporting is something I hadn't thought about at all. If the county is matching against EDD records and my catering work showed up there differently than I reported, that would explain the mismatch.

0 coins

Restaurant wages would go through EDD without question. Cash catering income might or might not appear depending on how the client reported it. The county sees whatever data exists and compares it to what you submitted.

0 coins

Renewal deadline on my account looked like it had already passed when I signed in after getting a notice I didn't understand. The plan it had me enrolled in was not what I picked the year before — it had renewed me into something with a higher premium. I used Claimyr to reach a Covered California representative and they pulled up the renewal and read out the deadline date and which plan the renewal had defaulted to, which turned out to be my same plan after all — the premium had just gone up because of changes to the federal subsidies, not because the plan switched.

0 coins

Premium going up because of federal subsidy changes and not a plan switch is something I'll need to watch for if I do end up enrolling. Good to know those are separate things.

0 coins

Enhanced premium tax credits that were in place through 2025 ended, so a lot of people saw premiums jump at the start of this year even without changing plans. Shop and Compare will give you a current estimate so you're not surprised.

0 coins

Exact same thing happened with my renewal — plan stayed the same but the number on the bill went up. Took a few phone calls to understand it wasn't a billing error.

0 coins

Covered California's application asks for expected income this year, not what you earned last year. For someone with fluctuating catering income, that estimate can be tricky. The site says to use what you expect to earn, so think through your typical months and average it out as best you can. If income changes significantly mid-year, you can report that change in your account within 30 days and your financial help will be recalculated.

0 coins

30-day window to report income changes is reassuring since my catering work is not predictable. I was worried I'd have to lock in a number and be stuck with it all year.

0 coins

You're not locked in. The application is a starting estimate and you update it when things change. The important thing is to report changes rather than wait and deal with a bigger correction at tax time.

0 coins

Waited until tax time to reconcile and ended up with a repayment amount on my return because I had underestimated income. Reporting changes during the year is definitely the better approach.

0 coins

Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum — the coverage levels at Covered California work differently from Medi-Cal. Medi-Cal has essentially no premiums for most people. With a Covered California plan, even with financial help, there's usually a monthly premium, and the metal tier you pick changes how the costs split between you and the plan. For someone coming off Medi-Cal, Silver plans often make the most sense if income qualifies for cost-sharing reductions, since those reduce the deductible and out-of-pocket costs, not just the monthly premium.

0 coins

Cost-sharing reductions being separate from the premium reduction is a distinction I didn't understand. So even if my premium is low because of financial help, a Silver plan could also lower what I pay when I actually use the insurance?

0 coins

Exactly. Enhanced Silver plans specifically bring down the deductible and copays for people under 250% of the FPL. Shop and Compare shows which plans include that extra help based on your income.

0 coins

Went from Medi-Cal to a Silver plan and the cost-sharing reductions made a big difference. The premium with financial help was manageable and the deductible was much lower than I expected for a marketplace plan.

0 coins

County Medi-Cal office is the right place to ask why the determination went the way it did — Covered California's service center handles enrollment questions but cannot change a Medi-Cal eligibility decision. These are genuinely two separate systems. If you want to understand the specific reason the county found you ineligible, you need to call or visit your county office and ask them to walk through the determination with you.

0 coins

County office being the right place for the Medi-Cal question makes sense. I think I was hoping Covered California could explain both but that's not how it works.

0 coins

Covered California can get you enrolled in a plan from their side. The Medi-Cal determination explanation stays with the county. Worth doing both contacts separately.

0 coins

Certified enrollers can help with the Covered California side of this for free. If the application feels complicated — especially with the self-employment income piece — an enroller can sit with you and make sure the income is entered correctly from the start. Find them on Covered California's Find an Enroller page. They're certified by Covered California and there's no charge.

0 coins

Free help with the application is definitely something I want to take advantage of. The income reporting piece specifically is where I think I've been making errors and having someone review it before I submit would help.

0 coins

Enroller will also know how to handle the transition from Medi-Cal and make sure the access code from your notice is used correctly.

0 coins

Used an enroller when I first applied and they caught an income reporting error that would have changed my financial help significantly. Definitely worth finding one before submitting.

0 coins

Your account at Covered California will show the eligibility results after you apply, and that's where you'll see specifically what financial help you qualify for and which plans it applies to. The notice from Medi-Cal and the eligibility results from Covered California are two separate documents from two separate systems — don't assume the financial help on the Covered California side will mirror anything from the Medi-Cal side.

0 coins

Keeping those two separate in my head is going to be important. The Medi-Cal notice is from the county, the Covered California results are from their system. Got it.

0 coins

And the 1095-A at the end of the year comes from Covered California, not from the county. Medi-Cal doesn't issue a 1095-A. If you end up on a Covered California plan this year, that's the form you'll need for your taxes.

0 coins

Months of coverage that show no financial help on a 1095-A can look like an error but sometimes they're correct — if a payment was missed at some point, the plan may have been briefly interrupted. That's something the person above mentioned about their renewal situation and it's a separate issue, but good to track your payment history with the insurance company once you're enrolled so you're not surprised at tax time.

0 coins

Payment history with the insurance company is not something I knew I'd need to track. Where does that information even come from — the insurer or Covered California?

0 coins

Bill and payment records come from the insurance company directly. Covered California handles enrollment and the eligibility side. For anything about the bill, the membership card, or what the plan covers, you contact the insurance company.

0 coins

Went through this transition from Medi-Cal to Covered California two years ago and the part that tripped me up was assuming I could just call Covered California to fix the Medi-Cal termination. After finally talking to the county office in person, I understood that the county had matched my income against an older tax record that didn't reflect a job I had quit. The income looked higher than it was because they were using data I hadn't updated. County corrected it and my Medi-Cal was reinstated, but it took about six weeks.

0 coins

Six weeks is a long time to be without coverage. That's the scenario I'm most worried about, which is why the Covered California option as a backup makes more sense to me now.

0 coins

Having a Covered California plan active while the county sorted things out was what I did in the end. It meant paying a premium for a couple months but it was better than having nothing if something unexpected came up health-wise.

0 coins

Covering yourself through Covered California while appealing the Medi-Cal decision is the practical approach. The two processes don't interfere with each other.

0 coins

Shop and Compare tool is worth running before you do anything else on the Covered California side. Plug in your household size and estimated income and it shows you what plans are available and roughly what financial help might look like. No account needed to browse — you only have to log in when you're ready to actually apply.

0 coins

No account needed to browse is something I didn't know. I'll start there before I even think about the application so I have a realistic idea of what plans would cost me.

0 coins

Browsing first also helps you decide whether the Covered California option makes sense to pursue while you sort out the Medi-Cal question, or whether the premium is going to be a problem regardless of financial help.

0 coins

Minimum coverage plan is an option if you're under 30 or qualify for a hardship exemption, but it has very limited benefits compared to the full metal tier plans. For someone coming off Medi-Cal who's been used to comprehensive coverage, a Silver plan is usually a much closer match in terms of what it actually pays for when you use it. The minimum coverage plan doesn't come with cost-sharing reductions even if your income would otherwise qualify you for Enhanced Silver.

0 coins

Sticking with a full plan rather than the minimum coverage option is probably the right move. I'd rather have real coverage while the Medi-Cal appeal is pending.

0 coins

Also worth noting: since January 2026 Bronze plans count as high-deductible health plans, which makes them HSA-eligible. If that's relevant to your situation it's a factor when comparing Bronze vs. Silver.

0 coins

HSA eligibility with Bronze plans is a newer change that a lot of people haven't caught yet. Good detail for anyone comparing plans.

0 coins

Address change is something to double-check before you apply through Covered California. If your address is different from what the county had on file for Medi-Cal, make sure the Covered California application reflects your current address. The 1095-A and any notices will go to whatever address the account shows.

0 coins

Address is the same, but I'll double-check everything the access code pulls in before I confirm anything on the application.

0 coins

Good practice to verify every pre-filled field. Household size especially — sometimes the county data reflects a different household composition than what you'd put on a Covered California application.

0 coins

Related posts

Covered California AI

Expert Assistant
Secure