Back to California EBT

NeonNebula

Why am I charged 5 cents fee on energy drinks with EBT?

Bought a four-pack of energy drinks at the grocery store yesterday and the receipt showed my food benefits paid the drink price fine, but then there was a separate 5-cent charge per can on top. The cashier said it was some kind of deposit fee. My card covered it but I didn't expect that extra charge and now I'm second-guessing whether I even should have been paying it. Is that normal when you use EBT for drinks? I've never noticed it before and I always buy the same brand.

That five cents per can is the California Redemption Value, what most people call the CRV. It's the bottle deposit California puts on canned and bottled drinks so you can return the empties later and get the money back. The good news for your situation: food benefits on your EBT card can pay the CRV on a drink when it's part of an eligible food purchase. So what you paid is correct — the charge goes through on your food benefits, not as a penalty or a store fee.

0 coins

Ok that actually clears it up. I had no idea food benefits could cover that deposit. So every time I buy canned drinks it's going to add those five-cent charges per can?

0 coins

Yep, every eligible canned or bottled drink will carry the CRV. Five cents for most cans under 24 ounces, though I won't pretend to know the exact tiers — that's a California law thing, not an EBT rule. The important part is your food benefits can cover it, and you can bring the empties back to a recycling center to get the deposit money back.

0 coins

Didn't know you could get the CRV back! I've been throwing the cans away. Do you get cash back at the recycling place or does it go back to the card?

0 coins

Three transactions showed up on my card history that I didn't recognize — two on the same day at a store across town. Had been trying to reach the EBT helpline for days and kept getting stuck in the automated menu without getting to anyone. Ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to the helpline, and I ended up talking to a representative who pulled up my transaction history and read me the exact dates, amounts and store names for all three charges. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at California EBT: https://youtu.be/iYFSA6RTlOI. The rep confirmed two of them were unauthorized so she told me to report them to my county office within 90 days and to change my PIN right away.

0 coins

Two unauthorized transactions is really alarming. Did the representative say whether it looked like skimming or someone who got my card info another way?

0 coins

The rep couldn't tell me how the info was taken — they just confirmed the transactions were there and that the dates matched what ebtEDGE was showing me. She said to change the PIN today and report the specific transactions to the county. I changed the PIN through ebtEDGE that same afternoon.

0 coins

Changing the PIN right after is key. I had a similar situation and the county office told me to also freeze the card in ebtEDGE between shopping trips so it can't be used even if someone else has the number.

0 coins

Going back to the original question about the fee — a store can't add a fee of their own to an EBT purchase, can't set a minimum purchase you have to hit before using the card, and can't charge sales tax on eligible food items. The CRV deposit is different though. That's not a store fee, it's a state deposit program, and it does get charged on eligible drinks bought with food benefits.

0 coins

Good to know there's a difference between the CRV and an actual store fee. I was worried the cashier was doing something wrong.

0 coins

My store once tried to tell me I needed to spend a certain amount before using EBT. That's not allowed at all. The CRV thing is totally separate from that kind of nonsense.

0 coins

Stores that try minimum purchase requirements for EBT are violating the rules. The CRV really is the one thing that gets added legitimately because it comes from California's recycling law, not from the store.

0 coins

Had the same five-cent confusion at a gas station convenience store last year. I thought the cashier charged me wrong and I actually asked them to void and redo the transaction. They were patient about it but it turned out the charge was right both times. The CRV showed up the same both times. Felt a little embarrassed but at least I know now.

0 coins

Honestly I'd have done the same thing. Five cents seems small but when you're watching every dollar on a food budget it looks suspicious.

0 coins

This is exactly what I was thinking. I didn't want to make a scene at the register but I was really confused looking at the receipt later.

0 coins

Worth knowing: the CRV on energy drinks comes up because most of them are in cans or bottles that qualify under the California recycling program. If you're buying a drink in a container that isn't in the program — some paper cartons, certain pouches — you won't see the CRV charge. The five cents (or more for larger containers) is printed right on the can usually, so you can spot it before you check out.

0 coins

Didn't realize the size changes the deposit amount. I've only ever bought the standard sized cans so I guess five cents is what I've always been paying without noticing.

0 coins

Now that you mention it, I do see that little CRV mark on the cans. I never connected it to what shows up on the receipt.

0 coins

My kids' juice boxes don't get the CRV and I always thought that was just how juice worked. Makes sense now that it's the container type that matters.

0 coins

The cashier was actually right to charge the CRV. Some stores ring it up differently — some list it as 'CRV' on the receipt, some say 'CA Redemption Value', some just show it as a per-unit line item. If the receipt broke it out as a separate line per can, that's normal, not an extra store charge.

0 coins

Mine said something like 'CA Redemption' on each line. I thought it was a tax at first.

0 coins

The 'CA Redemption' label is what most of the big chains print. Smaller stores sometimes just fold it into the price with no separate line, which makes it even harder to spot.

0 coins

Seen it called at least four different things on receipts at different stores. All the same thing though.

0 coins

Card in my county office's mail slot on a Tuesday, and by Friday I still hadn't gotten a replacement in my mailbox. I'd ordered it through ebtEDGE but couldn't tell if the order actually went through or just timed out. Kept hitting the automated system at the helpline and not reaching anyone. Claimyr got me to a live representative at the helpline, and the rep checked my account and confirmed the replacement card had been ordered and gave me the exact date it was processed, which was the day I submitted in ebtEDGE. She said to allow up to five days not counting Sundays and holidays.

0 coins

Five days not counting Sundays — that timeline is longer than I expected. Good to know the rep could actually confirm the order date though.

0 coins

My replacement took right at that five-day mark. Got anxious around day three but it showed up. If it goes past five business days, that's when I'd push harder.

0 coins

The rep also mentioned I could have ordered it at the county office in person if I needed it faster, though she didn't say how that timeline would compare.

0 coins

To add onto what folks said about the CRV — when you bring those cans back to a recycling center, the refund you get is actual cash, it doesn't go back onto your EBT card. So you paid the CRV with food benefits but you reclaim it in cash at the recycler. Some people use that money to stretch their budget a little. Not related to EBT rules specifically but useful to know.

0 coins

That cash back part is handy. My neighbor stacks cans for weeks and brings them all in at once. Gets a decent amount that way.

0 coins

Huh, I didn't know the refund was cash and not back to the card. That's actually a nice side benefit if you remember to save the cans.

0 coins

The cashier said the EBT card can be used for energy drinks and I wanted to double check that — are energy drinks actually eligible food items? I thought there were restrictions on what counts as food.

0 coins

Energy drinks are generally eligible as food items as long as they have a nutrition facts label, which most do. Drinks that are sold only as a supplement with a supplement facts label instead of nutrition facts don't qualify, but standard energy drink cans from the grocery aisle usually pass. If you're ever unsure about a specific product, the fastest check is whether it has a nutrition facts label on the can.

0 coins

Had a brand once that rang up as ineligible and the cashier had to remove it. It had the supplement label instead of nutrition facts. The machine catches it usually.

0 coins

Makes sense. The ones I buy have the nutrition facts label on the side so I think I'm fine. Good to know the register catches it if something is off.

0 coins

My card was declined on energy drinks once and I panicked thinking I was buying something I wasn't allowed to. Turns out the register just had a glitch and the second swipe went through fine. The CRV still showed up on the second receipt. Moral of the story: a declined transaction on a specific item isn't always about eligibility.

0 coins

The declined-then-fine thing happens to me sometimes with the chip card. I never know if it's the item or the reader.

0 coins

Chip reads can fail on the first attempt for a lot of reasons unrelated to what's in your cart. CDSS actually says to try another register or terminal if the chip keeps refusing before assuming the card itself is the problem.

0 coins

Bit of a different situation — I tried to use my card online at one of the stores that takes EBT for delivery and there was no CRV added in the cart at all. I bought the same energy drink brand I get in the store. Not sure if the online store just doesn't add it or if it gets charged differently.

0 coins

Online purchases through the stores that accept EBT online are handled differently and I honestly don't know the exact answer about CRV in that context. Worth asking the store directly or checking your order receipt carefully.

0 coins

I've noticed the same thing on online orders — some items ring up slightly different than in-store. No idea if that's intentional or a gap in how the online system handles the deposit.

0 coins

Might just be an online store thing then, not something I should be worried about on my EBT account itself.

0 coins

Card not" valid was what the terminal showed at two different grocery stores, two days after I got my new chip card in the mail. Called the helpline and the automated system'wasn t getting me to a person. Used Claimyr and ended up on the phone with a representative who confirmed my card was showing as active in the system — she said the chip card does not need any activation call and my benefits had already transferred to it automatically. She told me to try inserting instead of tapping and to ask the cashier to try a differentterminal.

0 coins

Had the exact same card-not-valid message on my new chip card. Inserting instead of tapping fixed it at one of the stores. The tap function seems to be hit or miss depending on the store's reader.

0 coins

Glad to know the chip card doesn't need an activation call. I was worried I had missed a step when mine came.

0 coins

The flyer CDSS included with my chip card said the same thing — no activation call needed, benefits carry over automatically, and your PIN stays what it was. Some stores are still catching up on tap compatibility so inserting is the safer move for now.

0 coins

To get back to the energy drink question — the fact that a store charges CRV on energy drinks bought with EBT is actually a signal that the transaction went through correctly. If the item were ineligible, the register would reject it before it even hit your food balance. The CRV charge appearing means your food benefits covered the drink and then the CRV layered on top as the deposit.

0 coins

That framing makes it click. The CRV being there means the drink went through fine, it's not an error.

0 coins

Okay this actually makes me feel better about how the register works. The machine catches the ineligible stuff so if it let the drink through, you're good.

0 coins

An ATM near me gave me less cash than it deducted from my account — I noticed because the balance in ebtEDGE afterward was lower than expected. Called the EBT helpline directly and went through the automated system twice without getting to anyone who could help. Tried Claimyr on the third attempt and reached a representative who said the helpline takes that kind of claim directly and that neither the ATM owner nor the bank can hand over the difference — the claim goes through the helpline. She noted it on my account.

0 coins

Didn't know you file that kind of claim through the helpline rather than going to the ATM owner. I would have gone straight to the ATM location if that happened to me.

0 coins

The rep was clear that the ATM owner can't resolve it — the claim has to go through the EBT helpline. Saved me a wasted trip.

0 coins

Had a friend who wasted two weeks arguing with the ATM location over something similar. The helpline is exactly where that claim belongs.

0 coins

Something the original post made me think about: a lot of people assume the five-cent charge is a store mistake or some kind of surcharge for using EBT, and they don't say anything because they don't want to hold up the line. The cashier did the right thing by explaining it, actually. CRV confusion seems to trip up a lot of people who are new to buying drinks with the card.

0 coins

Agree with that — the first time I saw it I thought the cashier had hit a button wrong. If nobody explains the CRV it really does look like a mystery charge.

0 coins

I would have just let it go if the cashier hadn't said anything. Good that she did.

0 coins

Had a question since this came up — does the CRV count toward any kind of limit on what food benefits can pay in a single transaction, or is it just added on top with no cap?

0 coins

No separate limit that I know of for the CRV specifically — it's treated as part of an eligible purchase and comes out of your food balance with the rest. If your food balance covers the total including the CRV, it goes through. If you don't have enough to cover everything including the CRV, it'll be like any other case where the balance runs short.

0 coins

That makes sense. So it's just part of the total and the food balance has to cover it like everything else in the cart.

0 coins

Worth mentioning that the CRV also shows up on water bottles and juice if they're in eligible containers. First time I bought a case of bottled water with EBT I was confused by the extra line items. It's not specific to energy drinks even though that seems to be where people notice it first.

0 coins

Cases of water are where I noticed it first too, actually. So many cans or bottles at once and suddenly there's a whole extra dollar-something in CRV on the receipt.

0 coins

Juice boxes in my experience don't get it but big juice bottles do. It really is about the container.

0 coins

A cashier once told me EBT doesn't pay the CRV and that I'd have to pay it separately with another method. That was wrong — my food benefits covered it fine at that same store when I tried again on a different register. The cashier was confused, not the register.

0 coins

Cashier misinformation about EBT is way more common than it should be. Glad you tried again instead of just paying out of pocket.

0 coins

The rule is that food benefits cover the CRV on an eligible drink. What that cashier said wasn't right. Good that the second register just handled it correctly without any debate.

0 coins

If you ever want to double-check a charge that looks off, the transaction history in ebtEDGE goes back 365 days and shows every deduction. You can pull up that purchase and see what your food balance was before and after, which makes it easy to confirm whether the CRV hit your food account the way it should have or if something else came off at the same time.

0 coins

I haven't used the transaction history much but this is a good reason to. I'm going to check that yesterday's energy drink purchase looks normal in ebtEDGE.

0 coins

The 365-day history is so useful for this. I caught an overcharge at a store once just by checking the totals in ebtEDGE against my receipts.

0 coins

The recycling deposit and the EBT rules around it get confusing because it looks like a fee but it isn't — it's money you're paying into the state's recycling program and you get it back when you return the containers. The store isn't keeping it. Completely different from a surcharge, which stores can't add to EBT purchases.

0 coins

The store isn't keeping the CRV — that's the part I was fuzzy on. It makes it feel less like being charged extra and more like putting money aside for the cans you're going to return.

0 coins

Now I actually want to start saving my cans. Never thought of the CRV as money I could get back but that's exactly what it is.

0 coins

Just to loop back to the freeze feature someone mentioned earlier: freezing the card in ebtEDGE only blocks new purchases and transactions, it doesn't affect your balance and you just unfreeze it when you're ready to shop. If you're worried about unauthorized purchases appearing on your account, the freeze buys you time while you sort things out without losing access to your benefits.

0 coins

Using the freeze between shopping trips has become a habit for me. Takes two seconds in the app and I feel a lot better about the card's security.

0 coins

Turning on the out-of-state block in ebtEDGE is worth doing too if you're not traveling. Covers a different angle than the freeze but both are there for free and take no time to set up.

0 coins

California EBT AI

Expert Assistant
Secure