Back to Arizona Unemployment

Adriana Cohn

Unemployment appeal won, employer appeals again - when are benefits paid?

So my situation has been a complete nightmare and I'm hoping someone here has gone through something similar. Got laid off from my logistics job back in January, filed for UI with Arizona DES, and my former employer contested it claiming I was terminated for misconduct. The first hearing officer sided with me - misconduct claim didn't hold up, I won the appeal. Started breathing again, right? Wrong. My employer filed ANOTHER appeal, kicking this whole thing up to the next level. Meanwhile I have zero income and my claim status hasn't budged. The part that's killing me is I genuinely don't know when Arizona DES is supposed to release my benefits. Like does the second appeal freeze everything again? Do I get the backdated weeks from when I first won? I've been filing my weekly claims this whole time like I'm supposed to but nothing is hitting my ReliaCard. I've searched everywhere and can't find a straight answer about the timeline for benefit payment after winning an unemployment appeal when the employer turns around and files their own. Anyone dealt with this exact situation?

The employer's second appeal - called a Board of Appeals review here in Arizona - does put a hold on benefit disbursement while that second review is pending. Arizona DES won't release the funds from your backdated weeks until the Board of Appeals either upholds your win or the employer withdraws. Keep filing those weekly certifications though, every single one, because the clock is running and you'll want every week accounted for when payment finally processes.

0 coins

My weekly certifications are all in - haven't missed one since January. So there's no way to get even a partial release of funds while the Board of Appeals is still reviewing?

0 coins

Same thing happened to my brother-in-law. Employer appealed twice and he had to wait the whole second round out. The second appeal takes longer too, like way longer than the first hearing.

0 coins

Partial release isn't something Arizona DES typically does while a second-level appeal is active, unfortunately. The whole disputed amount stays frozen. Once the Board issues its decision in your favor though, the backdated weeks should process within about 10-14 business days in most cases I've heard of.

0 coins

Claimyr got me through to an actual Arizona DES agent in about 20 minutes when I was stuck in a similar appeals limbo situation. The agent confirmed my backdated week count and told me exactly what was pending on the employer's side. Website is claimyr.com and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y - worth checking out if you need real answers from Arizona DES directly instead of guessing.

0 coins

Spending half my day redialing Arizona DES has gotten me nowhere so far. How recent was your experience with this? I want to make sure it still works the way you're describing.

0 coins

seconded, I used it a few months back for an adjudication issue and it worked. getting a live person at DES feels impossible otherwise

0 coins

Mine was about six weeks ago. The agent I reached actually looked up my Board of Appeals case number and confirmed the status. Way more useful than the portal info.

0 coins

Ask Arizona DES specifically: 'Is there a supersedeas order or automatic stay attached to the employer's second-level appeal?' - because that's what actually determines whether your payments are legally frozen or just administratively delayed. The reason it matters is those two situations have different remedies. An automatic stay means you wait it out. A pure administrative hold sometimes has a workaround if you can show financial hardship through a written request.

0 coins

Financial hardship request - that's the first time I've heard that option mentioned. What form or process does that go through at Arizona DES?

0 coins

The hardship angle is real but I'd want confirmation from DES directly that it applies to your specific appeal tier. Don't want you to get your hopes up chasing paperwork that doesn't apply.

0 coins

Agreed, it's not guaranteed. Some appeals officers have discretion, some don't. The question is worth asking explicitly on your next contact with Arizona DES - worst they can say is no.

0 coins

Weekly certifications filed while the Board of Appeals is pending - those weeks are accruing the whole time. When Arizona DES finally processes after a Board win, all those weeks hit at once. That lump sum can be significant depending on your weekly benefit amount. Just make sure your job search log is current because DES audits sometimes follow large retroactive payment releases.

0 coins

Job search log is current, three contacts per week every week. The lump sum thing is both exciting and stressful honestly - I didn't realize it could all hit at once like that.

0 coins

wait does it literally all hit the same day on your reliacard or does it stagger? asking because I had a different situation but big lump sums and my bank flagged it

0 coins

Usually processes as separate weekly deposits hitting in quick succession rather than one single transaction. Typically within the same few business days though. The ReliaCard shouldn't have an issue but if you have direct deposit to a bank account, some banks do flag it temporarily.

0 coins

My back pay came as individual weekly amounts posted one after another on the same day. Looked alarming on my bank statement but it was fine.

0 coins

Something a lot of people don't realize: once the Board of Appeals rules in your favor on round two, Arizona DES has to pay you interest on the delayed weeks in some circumstances. It doesn't always happen automatically - you sometimes have to request it. Not huge money but it's yours.

0 coins

Genuinely had no idea about interest on delayed benefits. What's the mechanism for requesting that - is there a specific form or just a written request?

0 coins

Usually a written request submitted through the Appeals portal referencing the Board decision date and your claim number. Some people report success, some don't - Arizona DES isn't exactly proactive about volunteering it.

0 coins

I actually never heard this before. Is this specific to employer appeals or any delayed payment situation?

0 coins

how long has the second appeal been going? because Arizona Board of Appeals for unemployment typically takes 60-90 days from when the employer filed. if you're past that window you should be getting close or they might have already issued a decision that just hasn't been communicated to you yet

0 coins

Employer filed the second appeal about 7 weeks ago according to my records. So I might be in the middle of the typical window still. Is there a way to check Board of Appeals status online or only by phone?

0 coins

Board of Appeals status isn't on the standard CACTUS portal as far as I know - at least mine wasn't visible there. Phone or written inquiry is usually how people find out.

0 coins

mine took 11 weeks total for board level, way longer than 60-90. depends on backlog apparently

0 coins

The job search requirement doesn't pause during an employer's second appeal - you need to keep logging three employer contacts per week just like normal. DES has denied backdated payments to people who assumed the appeal froze their ongoing obligations too. Keep everything documented.

0 coins

Three contacts per week, logged and dated - haven't stopped. Wasn't sure if the requirements stayed in force during this but I figured better safe than sorry.

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up. The appeal is about the money, not about your ongoing eligibility requirements. Those keep running in parallel the whole time.

0 coins

Exactly. Think of it as two separate tracks running simultaneously - the appeals track and your weekly eligibility track. Only the appeals track is disputed; your ongoing certification obligations are unaffected.

0 coins

went through almost this exact scenario last year, employer appealed my win twice, and what I learned was to get every communication from DES and the Board in writing or screenshot it. When my benefits finally processed there was a discrepancy in the week count and having my paper trail let me get it corrected without a full dispute process.

0 coins

Screenshots of everything - noted. Did your week count discrepancy happen because they lost track of certifications filed during the second appeal window specifically?

0 coins

Yes, exactly that. They had my pre-appeal weeks correct but two of the certifications I filed during the second appeal period weren't reflected in the initial payment. Having timestamps and confirmation numbers let me point to exactly which weeks were missing.

0 coins

this is such good advice. I keep a spreadsheet with every certification date, confirmation number, and week ending date. saved me once already

0 coins

Ask Arizona DES: 'What is the exact date the employer's Board of Appeals request was received and docketed?' - because the response timeline runs from that date, not from when you were notified. Sometimes there's a gap of a week or more between when they file and when you hear about it, which means you could be further along in the process than you think.

0 coins

That date gap hadn't occurred to me at all. So the employer could have filed it and I might have been notified a week later, meaning I'm actually further into the review window than my own records show?

0 coins

Exactly. DES dockets the appeal when they receive it from the employer. Your notification letter gets sent after. Worth confirming the docket date specifically.

0 coins

Good point. The official docket date is what the Board uses for their own internal timeline tracking too.

0 coins

DOES ANYONE KNOW if you can still get partial UI payments if the employer only appealed part of the disqualification period?? asking because my situation is similar but the employer is only disputing 8 of the 14 weeks and I don't know if the undisputed weeks can pay out

0 coins

Partial releases in that scenario are technically possible but DES sometimes freezes the whole claim anyway even when only partial weeks are disputed. Worth asking DES directly whether the undisputed weeks can be segregated and released.

0 coins

ugh okay. I'll try calling again. been impossible to get through

0 coins

Claimyr worked for me when I was in a similar phone-tag nightmare with Arizona DES - claimyr.com has a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y that shows how it connects you. Got through in under 30 minutes and was able to ask exactly this kind of specific question about my claim.

0 coins

okay I'll check that out because I've been redial city for three weeks and gotten nowhere

0 coins

The second appeal timeline varies A LOT depending on the Board's current docket backlog. Mine resolved in 11 weeks. Friend of mine had hers done in 5. Another person in a Facebook group I'm in waited 4 months. There's no published SLA for it which is infuriating.

0 coins

Four months with zero income is terrifying to think about. How did your friend's 5-week resolution happen - did she do anything specific to push it along or was it just luck of the draw?

0 coins

She said she submitted a written statement to the Board requesting expedited review citing financial hardship. Can't say for sure if that's what did it or if hers just moved fast anyway.

0 coins

the lack of a published timeline is one of the most maddening things about this whole system. at least tell people a range so they can plan

0 coins

okay dumb question maybe but when you say you won the first appeal - does that mean the original DES determination was reversed in your favor? or does winning mean something different at different stages because I'm confused about how the appeals ladder works

0 coins

First appeal: a Hearing Officer reviews the original DES decision. If you win there, the original disqualification gets reversed and DES is supposed to pay you. Employer can then escalate to the Board of Appeals, which is the second tier. Board of Appeals is the last administrative step before you'd go to actual court.

0 coins

okay that makes way more sense, so the original poster won with the hearing officer but now it's at the board of appeals level. got it.

0 coins

Correct. And the Board of Appeals reviews the Hearing Officer's decision on legal and procedural grounds mostly, not a whole new factual hearing from scratch. That's actually somewhat favorable for OP since the facts were already found in their favor.

0 coins

something nobody mentioned yet - once the Board rules in your favor (assuming they do), call DES immediately that same day if you can. don't wait for them to process automatically. having a live agent confirm the Board decision is in the system and manually flag your claim for payment release has in my experience moved things from 2 weeks to 3-4 days.

0 coins

Day-of phone call to push the payment flag - that's actionable. Did you have a specific department you asked for or just whoever picked up?

0 coins

Asked specifically for the Benefits Payment unit rather than general claims. The rep I got was actually knowledgeable and put a note on my file flagging the Board decision for immediate payment processing.

0 coins

Benefits Payment unit is the right call. General claims reps sometimes don't have visibility into the Appeals system and you end up getting bounced around.

0 coins

worth noting that your employer can't keep appealing forever. the Board of Appeals is the final administrative level in Arizona. if they lose there and want to pursue it further they'd have to file in Superior Court which is expensive and most employers don't bother over UI claims. so this second appeal is likely the last hurdle you'll face.

0 coins

Knowing this is the last administrative level is genuinely reassuring. The idea that this could keep going indefinitely was one of my bigger fears.

0 coins

Some employers use the appeals as a delay tactic knowing the claimant will eventually just give up or find other income. Don't let them outlast you - keep filing every week and document everything.

0 coins

The Superior Court thing is real - I've read about it happening but it's genuinely rare for UI amounts. Employers usually cut losses at the Board level.

0 coins

My cousin went through this in Arizona and I helped her navigate it. One thing that caught her off guard: when the backdated benefits finally paid out, Arizona DES sent her a 1099-G for the full amount including the months she had to wait. Make sure you're setting aside money for taxes because that lump sum counts as income for the year it's paid, not the year it was owed.

0 coins

Tax implications hadn't even entered my mind yet. So the entire lump sum gets reported on a 1099-G for the tax year it actually hits the account - not spread across the months it was accruing?

0 coins

Correct - my cousin got hit with a bigger tax bill than expected because a large back payment all hit in December. Might be worth consulting a tax person depending on how big your backpay amount ends up being.

0 coins

The 1099-G thing is so important and barely anyone mentions it until people are filing taxes and panicking

0 coins

Claimyr is genuinely the move here - claimyr.com - I used it specifically to ask about my status after a Board of Appeals decision came through and wanted to confirm payment timing directly with an Arizona DES agent. The video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y shows exactly how it works. Reached someone in about 25 minutes on a Tuesday which felt like a miracle compared to my previous attempts.

0 coins

Tuesday mid-morning worked well for you? I've been trying Fridays and getting nowhere. Might just be the day I'm picking.

0 coins

Tuesday and Wednesday mornings seemed better in my experience. Fridays and Mondays are brutal - either end-of-week backlog or start-of-week surge.

0 coins

I've heard Wednesday mornings are the sweet spot for DES phone lines. Seems to depend on the week though - there's no perfect formula

0 coins

one more thing to track - the Board of Appeals mails their decision to your address on file with DES. if your address has changed at all since you filed, update it immediately in your CACTUS portal profile. people miss decision letters because DES has an old address and then the response window for any further action starts ticking from the original mail date.

0 coins

Address is current - double-checked my CACTUS profile recently. But this is a really important point that I wouldn't have thought to verify.

0 coins

Also worth checking your email on file. Some correspondence goes both ways now and email notifications can go to spam if DES is sending from an unfamiliar domain.

0 coins

The decision date on the letter is what matters for any subsequent deadlines regardless of when you actually receive it. So confirming your address is on file correctly is genuinely important, not just a formality.

0 coins

just want to say hang in there, this whole process is designed to exhaust you into giving up. the fact that you've kept filing weekly certifications through all of this shows you're doing everything right. I know that doesn't pay bills but you're not making any mistakes here.

0 coins

Appreciate this more than I can say. It really does feel designed to wear you down.

0 coins

solidarity from someone who also survived the appeals gauntlet. it ends eventually

0 coins

genuinely this. the system makes you feel like you're doing something wrong when you're not. you just have to outlast it.

0 coins

Ask DES once the Board rules: 'What is the payment release authorization date for weeks held under case number X?' - because sometimes the Board issues a decision but the payment authorization is a separate internal step that takes a few extra days. Knowing whether payment authorization has been triggered yet vs just the decision being issued tells you which stage of the delay you're actually in.

0 coins

Payment release authorization as a distinct step from the Board decision itself - this is exactly the kind of granular detail I've been missing. I'll ask for that specific confirmation.

0 coins

This is the question I wish I'd known to ask. I waited two extra weeks because I was told the decision was issued but no one had triggered the payment authorization step internally. A five-minute phone call would have moved it.

0 coins

Payment authorization as a separate trigger step is real and not widely known. Arizona DES doesn't volunteer that information - you have to know to ask.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure