Unemployment active issues turned down job commission pay on hold - what do I do?
So my situation is kind of a mess and I'm hoping someone here has dealt with something similar. I work in furniture sales and my pay is basically all commission - like 90% of what I take home comes from commission, with just a tiny base wage underneath it. When my hours got cut way back in January, I filed for UI through Arizona DES because my earnings dropped so much it made sense to file. Everything seemed fine at first, my claim got accepted and I started doing my weekly certifications. Then about two weeks in, my manager called me and offered to put me on a different floor section that would have had me working more hours but the commission structure there is terrible - like you're selling lower-margin items to a totally different customer base. I did the math and I actually would have brought home less money even with the extra hours because the commission rate was so much lower. So I declined the offer and explained my reasoning to my manager. Now my CACTUS portal is showing 'active issues' on my claim and my payments have been put on hold. I haven't received anything for going on 3 weeks. I'm guessing this is connected to turning down that job offer but I genuinely don't have a clue how to navigate this. Does Arizona DES actually consider a commission-only-type position within your same company a 'suitable work' offer? Is my whole claim at risk here? I've tried calling multiple times but can't get anyone on the phone.
78 comments

Drew Hathaway
Before I get into what I know about this - have you tried Claimyr to get through to Arizona DES on the phone? I know you said you can't reach anyone and that was exactly my situation a couple months ago when my claim had a flag on it. Claimyr basically gets you connected to an actual DES agent without you sitting on hold for hours. Their site is claimyr.com and there's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y - honestly wish I'd known about it sooner because my issue dragged on way longer than it needed to just because I couldn't talk to anyone.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
Author3 weeks of nobody picking up the phone is exactly why I need something like this. I'll check that video out tonight, thank you.
0 coins
Laila Prince
seconded on claimyr, saw it mentioned somewhere else on this forum and ended up using it when my adjudication dragged on. the hold music at DES will make you lose your mind
0 coins
Isabel Vega
does it work for people who have commission pay situations specifically or is it just general claim stuff? asking because my situation is similar to OPs
0 coins
Dominique Adams
The 3 weeks without payment you mentioned is a pretty specific window - that tells me the adjudication just started and hasn't concluded yet. What you're dealing with is a suitable work determination and the way those work is Arizona DES has to decide whether what your employer offered you actually qualified as work you were obligated to accept. The key thing to ask them when you get through is 'what wage standard was used to evaluate the offer against my previous earnings' - because that's the crux of your whole case. The rules around this say that suitable work generally has to pay wages reasonably comparable to what you were making, and in commission sales situations that gets complicated fast because DES typically looks at your average weekly earnings over your base period, not just your hourly rate. If your commission floor was substantially higher than what the new position would have paid based on realistic sales volume, you may have had legitimate grounds to decline.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorMy average weekly earnings from commission were around $1,100 on a good week, sometimes down to $650 on slow weeks. The new floor section my manager was talking about, I estimated maybe $400-500 weekly realistic take-home. That's a massive difference. Does that kind of gap actually matter to them?
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
the earnings comparison absolutely matters, the problem is you have to be the one to document it and present it. DES isn't going to do that math for you
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
this is the right track but also depends on how long OP had been in their current role. if you've been there long enough to have a solid earnings history that works in your favor
0 coins
TommyKapitz
I want to flag something that might be getting missed here. When you're talking about commission pay and an active issues flag, there's actually two separate things that might be happening at once on your claim. The first is the job refusal issue the others are talking about. But the second thing - and this caught me off guard when I went through something similar - is that DES sometimes puts a hold specifically because they need to verify your commission earnings in the first place. Commission pay doesn't come through on a standard wage record the same way a regular salary does, and sometimes the system flags it just because the numbers look weird compared to what your employer reported. So you might actually have two separate issues sitting on your claim right now, not just one.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorWait - so there could be a separate verification issue on top of the refusal flag? I hadn't even thought about that. My employer reports my commissions kind of inconsistently on my pay stubs too which probably doesn't help.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
this happened to me!! i had commission from tips essentially and DES had no idea what to do with my wage record it was a nightmare took 6 weeks to sort out
0 coins
Dominique Adams
This is a valid point and worth asking about specifically. When you get through to an agent ask them to read you all active issues on the claim, not just the most recent one. Sometimes there are multiple flags and agents only address what's most recent if you don't specifically ask.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
ugh this is making my head spin. the system seems designed to be as confusing as possible honestly
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
ok so i went through a job refusal disqualification last year, different industry but same basic situation. the thing that saved me was writing out exactly why the offer wasn't comparable pay. what you want to ask yourself before you talk to anyone at DES is 'how do I show that what they offered me was a different job, not just the same job in a different spot' - because that reframing matters. if the commission structure changes fundamentally, the sales cycle is different, the customer base is different, the product margin is different, you can make an argument that this wasn't really a continuation of your existing role - it was essentially a lateral move to a new position that happened to be in the same building. that argument doesn't always work but it's way stronger than just saying you thought you'd earn less.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorThat reframing actually makes a lot of sense for my situation because honestly the floor they wanted to move me to sells completely different merchandise, different customers, different everything. It really was a different job just under the same employer.
0 coins
Payton Black
this is good advice but OP needs to be careful about how they phrase this to DES because if it sounds too different they might question whether OP was really available for work in their usual occupation this whole time
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
fair point from 17 - there's a balance. you want to show the offer was different enough to not be suitable, but not so different that it makes your ongoing claim look weird
0 coins
Harold Oh
Something I wish someone had told me earlier - the hold on your payments during adjudication doesn't automatically mean you've been denied. It means they're evaluating. Keep filing your weekly certifications every single week without fail during this period. I made the mistake of stopping my weekly claims when I saw the hold because I figured nothing was going anywhere anyway. That was wrong. When my adjudication resolved in my favor, they calculated back pay only for the weeks I had actually filed. I lost two weeks of payments I would have been entitled to because I hadn't filed. Don't repeat my mistake. Also when you do eventually reach someone - Claimyr helped me get through after multiple days of failed attempts on my own - ask them specifically about maintaining your continued claims during the adjudication review period.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorFiling even during the hold - I genuinely didn't know that. I almost stopped last week because it felt pointless. Thank you for this, that could have cost me a lot.
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
THIS. so many people stop filing when they see a hold and then wonder why they don't get back pay. the weekly certification keeps your claim active it's not just a formality
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
yeah the system really should communicate this better. there's nowhere on the portal that tells you to keep filing when your payments are on hold. you just have to know
0 coins
Payton Black
Can we talk about the suitable work standard for a commission position because I see a lot of partial information floating around this thread. The question you should really be putting to Arizona DES is 'what does my base period wage average out to per week and how does the offered position compare to that benchmark' - not just your best weeks or your worst weeks. DES uses a specific calculation. For commission workers they typically look at your total wages in your base period divided out, which smooths out the variation. The good news for OP is that if your high commission weeks dominate your base period earnings, the average is going to be relatively high, and an offer that tops out at $400-500 against an average of maybe $750-900 is going to look pretty bad for the employer's argument that it was suitable work.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorMy base period would cover most of last year and I had a really strong spring and summer in sales. So the average probably does work in my favor for this.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
The base period calculation point is accurate. One thing to add - if OP's employer contests the suitability determination, the appeals process allows for submission of documentation including pay stubs and commission statements. Keep all of that.
0 coins
Summer Green
Also worth noting that if the adjudication doesn't go your way the first time you have appeal rights - 30 days from the determination notice. I had to appeal mine and found Claimyr really useful for checking on where the appeal was sitting because you just can't get status updates through the portal.
0 coins
Gael Robinson
im in furniture sales too lol this thread is weirdly relevant to my life. question for anyone here - does the same suitable work stuff apply if the offer comes from a different employer not your current one? like if a recruiter reaches out during your claim period?
0 coins
Payton Black
Different situation - job offers from outside employers during your claim period fall under a slightly different evaluation but the suitable work standard still applies. The wage comparison is similar but there are also factors like commute distance, skill match, and work conditions.
0 coins
Gael Robinson
ok good to know, was worried i had to take anything that came my way regardless of pay
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
you don't have to take anything regardless of pay, but document your reasoning whenever you decline something because DES can ask about any offer you turned down
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Something nobody's mentioned yet - the portal showing 'active issues' without any letter or notice attached, did you check your document inbox inside CACTUS? Not the main notifications tab but the actual correspondence section. Sometimes DES uploads the adjudication notice there and doesn't send a physical letter for days or even weeks after. If there's already a determination sitting in there and you missed the 30-day appeal window that's a problem. I'd check that before anything else today.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorJust checked and there's nothing in the correspondence section yet, just the active issues flag with no document attached. So at least I haven't missed a deadline.
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
ok that's actually good news in a weird way - means the investigation is still open and you can still potentially provide information before they make a determination. this is exactly when you want to be talking to an agent
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
the correspondence section being different from notifications tripped me up too. really non-obvious UI design on that portal
0 coins
Angel Campbell
okay so i had commission pay issues AND a refusal flag at the same time and the thing that really helped me was getting a written statement from a coworker who was already working the section my employer wanted to move me to. they wrote out what they were actually earning on that floor on average and I submitted it as evidence during my adjudication. DES can't just take my employer's word for what the section 'could' earn - actual earnings data from someone doing the job carries a lot of weight. just throwing that out there as a strategy if OP is looking for ways to build a case.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorA statement from a coworker already on that floor - that's genuinely clever. I actually know the guy who works that section and he complains about his earnings constantly. Might be worth asking him.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
this is a good move. documentation from someone actually in that role beats any projection the employer gives. real earnings vs estimated earnings is a strong argument
0 coins
TommyKapitz
just make sure the coworker is okay with it and understands what it's being used for - don't want to create workplace drama on top of everything else
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
idk why i'm surprised but it always shocks me how many moving parts there are to these claims. like you're already stressed about not having your full income and then you have to become an expert in adjudication procedures and wage calculations and suitable work standards just to get paid. the system really expects a lot from people who are already in a rough spot
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorEvery single day since the hold went on I've been googling something new I didn't know I needed to know. It's genuinely exhausting on top of everything else.
0 coins
Laila Prince
you said it. and then you can't even get anyone on the phone to explain what's happening. at least forums like this exist
0 coins
Gael Robinson
real. i've learned more about UI rules from random forum threads than from anything on the actual arizona des website
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Just to circle back to the commission verification issue the other commenter raised - my partner went through something like this. The question that finally got things moving for her was asking the agent 'can you tell me if there's a wage discrepancy flag separate from the job refusal issue' - basically naming the two possible issues separately so the agent had to address each one individually rather than just talking generally about the active issue. When they're vague it's usually because they're looking at something they can't fully explain over the phone without reading the whole file. Making them confirm or deny specific issues gets you better information.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorNaming the specific issues separately rather than asking generally - noted. I'll try to go into the call with that level of specificity.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
This is tactically solid. Agents often default to reading the status and not much else. Specific questions yield specific answers. Have a list of questions written out before the call.
0 coins
Payton Black
the wage discrepancy flag is also called a 'wage investigation' in some DES correspondence so if you see those words they're talking about the same thing
0 coins
Edward McBride
Does Arizona DES ever just drop the active issues flag on their own without you having to do anything? Like is it possible it resolves itself if I just wait it out? I have an active issues thing on my claim too and I've been kind of hoping it goes away
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
Some minor flags do resolve on their own when the system receives information it was waiting for - like employer wage confirmation. But a job refusal flag almost never self-resolves because it requires a human determination. Don't wait on that one.
0 coins
Edward McBride
ugh that's what i was afraid of. what's the fastest way to actually get someone to look at it
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
phone is honestly the most direct route - the portal doesn't give you a way to submit information proactively for most flag types, you need to talk to someone who can note your account
0 coins
Laila Prince
reading this thread and realizing i might have made a mistake a few months back. i turned down a callback from a former employer because the hours were different than what i had before and i just... didn't report that i turned it down on my weekly certification. i figured if i didn't mention it nothing would happen. now i'm paranoid. should i have reported that?
0 coins
Payton Black
The reporting question you're asking is an important one to take seriously - when an employer contacts you about a return to work, that's something DES asks about on weekly certifications. The honest answer is yes, contacts from former employers about returning to work are supposed to be disclosed. How you handle it now is a separate question from whether you should have disclosed it.
0 coins
Laila Prince
yeah i feel dumb about it now. i didn't realize a phone call counted as a 'job offer' for reporting purposes
0 coins
Dominique Adams
Intent matters somewhat here but I'd strongly suggest talking to a DES agent about this proactively rather than waiting for it to surface. Voluntary disclosure typically results in better outcomes than discovered omissions.
0 coins
Darcy Moore
I want to come back to the phone access problem because I think people are underselling how much it matters for commission/job refusal situations specifically. These are not the kind of issues that resolve well through the portal alone - they require an agent to actually work your case. I burned like two weeks trying to handle a similar situation through messages and the portal before someone in a different forum mentioned Claimyr. Using it got me through to an actual DES agent who could see my full claim file and explain exactly what was flagged. That conversation took maybe 20 minutes and moved things forward more than the previous two weeks of portal activity had. For anyone with active issues that involve judgment calls like suitable work, talking to a human is basically non-negotiable.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorTwo weeks of portal activity vs. one 20-minute phone call - that contrast says everything. I'm going to try to get through tomorrow morning.
0 coins
Edward McBride
ok i'm also going to try this for my flag situation. been avoiding calling because the hold times are brutal
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
the portal is fine for simple stuff like checking payment status but the moment you have anything complex it just becomes a wall
0 coins
Dana Doyle
Something that might actually help OP document the earnings comparison - if you have access to your pay stubs from the last year, go through and calculate what your actual average weekly commission was. Not including base pay, just commission, separately. Then try to get any information you can about realistic sales volume on the other floor - even anecdotal stuff from coworkers counts as a starting point. Build a one-page summary of that comparison before you talk to DES. It doesn't have to be a formal document, it just needs to show the numbers side by side. Agents are more likely to flag a case for favorable review when the claimant comes in with organized information rather than just a verbal argument.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorI actually do have all my pay stubs saved as PDFs from the whole year. Building that one-page comparison is something I can do tonight before I try to call tomorrow.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
having your numbers ready when they answer makes such a difference. they're dealing with hundreds of cases and if you can quickly show them why your situation is clear cut it moves faster
0 coins
Isabel Vega
also keep a copy of that document for yourself in case you need it for an appeal later. don't give DES your only copy of anything
0 coins
Liam Duke
wait i'm confused by something in this thread - when people say 'active issues' does that mean the same thing as being in adjudication? or are those two different statuses? my claim said adjudication for a while and now it says something else and i don't know if i should be worried
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Those two terms overlap but they're not exactly the same. 'Active issues' is what shows on the CACTUS claimant portal as a catch-all flag for anything that needs review. 'Adjudication' is what that review process is called internally - so if your claim had active issues it was probably in adjudication. They're different words for essentially the same situation from the claimant's perspective.
0 coins
Liam Duke
oh ok that actually makes sense. i thought adjudication meant something more serious like i was being investigated or something
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
a lot of people think adjudication sounds scarier than it is. it really just means someone has to look at something before they approve payment. that's it.
0 coins
Manny Lark
For what it's worth, I appealed a job refusal disqualification about 18 months ago and won. The hearing officer was really focused on one specific thing - whether the offered work was 'customary' for someone in my occupation and experience level. The way my attorney framed it, and I'm paraphrasing because I don't remember the exact legal language, was basically 'would any reasonable person in this person's professional position with their earnings history have considered this offer a step down' - and when you frame it that way with documentation, it's actually pretty intuitive for a hearing officer to follow. The formal appeal process exists for a reason and it's not as intimidating as it sounds, especially for commission workers where the suitable work standard is genuinely ambiguous.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorKnowing that someone actually won an appeal on a situation like this is genuinely encouraging. I'm hoping it doesn't get that far but it's good to know the option exists and can go in your favor.
0 coins
Payton Black
the 'customary occupation and earnings' standard is exactly right. it's also worth knowing that if OP's employer is in the wrong here, DES will note that in the determination and it creates a record
0 coins
Dana Doyle
most people never get to the appeal stage because adjudication resolves it first - but having the documentation ready that you'd use in an appeal also makes your adjudication case stronger, so it's worth preparing regardless
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
kinda random but has anyone else noticed that the CACTUS portal is basically useless for anything nuanced? like it's fine for filing your weekly cert but the moment you have an actual question you're just staring at status text that doesn't tell you anything. the whole thing could be so much better
0 coins
Louisa Ramirez
The portal was clearly not designed with complex claims in mind. It works for straightforward claims but anything involving adjudication, overpayments, or commission pay situations and you need to be on the phone with someone. That's just the reality.
0 coins
Rita Jacobs
right like why can't it at least tell you WHAT the active issue is. 'active issues' tells you nothing
0 coins
Amun-Ra Azra
i think they keep the portal vague on purpose to avoid people gaming the system? but it just punishes the people with legitimate issues
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Circling back to check on OP - did you end up getting through to anyone at DES? Curious what they said about the commission structure issue and whether the flag is a job refusal thing or also includes the wage verification angle.
0 coins
Sadie Benitez
AuthorGot through yesterday morning! Finally talked to an agent who pulled up my full claim. There ARE two separate active issues - exactly what someone earlier in this thread predicted. One is the job refusal adjudication and one is a wage record discrepancy because my employer reported my commissions in a weird way. The agent flagged both for review and told me to submit my pay stubs through the document upload in CACTUS. She said typical resolution timeline is 2-3 weeks but she noted my account manually which apparently speeds things up. Still waiting but finally feel like something is actually happening.
0 coins
TommyKapitz
Two issues at once, exactly what I was worried about for you. Really glad you got through and got actual information. The manual notation from the agent is a good sign - that means a human has seen your case and initiated something rather than it just sitting in a queue.
0 coins
Marilyn Dixon
this is the best possible update - you have information, you have next steps, you have documentation submitted. the worst part of these situations is not knowing. now you know.
0 coins
Angel Campbell
keep your coworker contact info handy in case you need that corroborating earnings statement later. hopefully not but good to have ready
0 coins