Back to Arizona Unemployment

Hiroshi Nakamura

Confused about taxes withheld on unemployment checks in Arizona DES

So I've been on unemployment for about two months now and I'm starting to stress about tax season. When I was working at my logistics job I always had a decent chunk withheld for federal and state taxes automatically, and now I'm not sure how any of that works with my UI benefits. I never thought about this when I first filed - I was just relieved to get approved after the whole adjudication process took forever. But now I'm realizing I have no idea if Arizona DES is withholding anything from my weekly payments or if I'm going to get hit with a huge bill in April. I opted into direct deposit so I never even see a physical check with any breakdown on it. Can anyone explain how taxes withheld on unemployment checks actually works here in Arizona? Like do I have to request the withholding, is it automatic, or am I just going to owe everything at the end of the year?

Wait, you haven't set up withholding yet? I'd check your CACTUS portal account settings right this second if I were you, because you can elect to have federal taxes taken out and that decision affects everything come April. Arizona doesn't withhold state income tax on UI benefits - the state doesn't tax unemployment - but federal is a different story, they'll tax it as regular income. Here's the thing though, I know reaching Arizona DES by phone to ask about this stuff can be a nightmare. When I had questions about my withholding election I actually used Claimyr - it works by navigating the hold system so you end up speaking directly with an Arizona DES agent. The site is claimyr.com and there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y that shows how it works. Way better than sitting on hold for three hours.

0 coins

Not sure I'd say Arizona doesn't tax unemployment at all - worth double-checking that claim because I thought Arizona does actually tax it. I looked into this last year when I was on UI and my accountant mentioned something about it.

0 coins

Fair point on that, let me clarify - Arizona DOES tax unemployment income at the state level, I had that backwards. You can opt into state withholding too through your CACTUS portal. Sorry for the confusion there, definitely get that sorted out.

0 coins

Oh no I had no idea about any of this. So I could owe both federal AND state taxes at the end of the year if nothing is being withheld? How do I find the withholding setting in CACTUS exactly?

0 coins

Hmm, is your withholding situation totally blank right now? When you first file for Arizona DES unemployment, withholding is NOT set up automatically - you have to actively choose it. The federal withholding rate on UI benefits is 10%, which is what the IRS allows for unemployment. For state you can elect Arizona withholding too but I honestly don't know the exact percentage off the top of my head. The main thing I'd do first in your position is log into CACTUS and go to your payment options or account settings, there should be a withholding election section in there. If you chose nothing during your initial claim setup then nothing has been coming out.

0 coins

Wait so the 10% federal is optional too? I genuinely thought it would just be automatic like with a paycheck. So I might have weeks and weeks of benefits sitting there with zero taxes withheld?

0 coins

Yeah it's definitely optional which trips up a lot of people. The IRS treats unemployment compensation as taxable income but unlike an employer there's no automatic requirement for Arizona DES to withhold unless you asked for it. Some states do it differently but that's how it works here.

0 coins

This is one of those things nobody tells you when you file. I went almost six weeks before I realized I hadn't elected withholding. Had to scramble to set it up and I still owe from those early weeks.

0 coins

Can I jump in with something? The form you're looking for is essentially a voluntary withholding request - think of it like a W-4 but for your unemployment benefits. Arizona DES lets you choose 10% federal withholding and separately there's an option for state. Once you submit it in CACTUS it applies going forward but it won't apply retroactively to what you've already received. Those past weeks you'll need to handle yourself, either by making estimated tax payments to the IRS or just setting money aside. The IRS has a pay online option at irs.gov if you want to make a quarterly payment to avoid a penalty in April.

0 coins

Okay this is making more sense. So for the weeks I already got paid without withholding, I should maybe go make an estimated payment now to cover myself? I had no idea this was a thing.

0 coins

That's exactly right - quarterly estimated taxes exist for situations exactly like this. The deadlines are usually mid-April, mid-June, mid-September, and mid-January. If you missed the first couple you can still make a payment now and it'll reduce what you owe even if there's a small penalty for being late on those quarters.

0 coins

This thread is gold, I had the same exact confusion when I started on UI two years ago. Nobody at the DES office explained any of this to me during the process.

0 coins

Okay real talk - I went through almost this exact scenario last spring and the most useful thing I did was just get an Arizona DES agent on the phone to walk me through my account settings. The withholding stuff seemed confusing in the portal but once someone explained which exact menu to click it took about two minutes. I ended up using Claimyr to get through since the regular DES line had me waiting forever - worth it to actually talk to someone who could confirm what was set up on my account.

0 coins

How long did all that take once you actually got an agent? I'm wondering if it's faster to just figure out the portal myself or get someone to walk me through it.

0 coins

Honestly the portal is doable on your own if you know where to look, but having an agent confirm it was done correctly gave me peace of mind. I'm the type who second-guesses myself so talking to someone official helped.

0 coins

Same. I tried to do mine through the portal alone and kept second-guessing whether I'd actually saved the change or just navigated away. An agent confirmed it on their end which is what I needed.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the 1099-G they send at the end of the year shows what was actually withheld? I got one last year and I remember it had two boxes but I wasn't sure what the second one was for.

0 coins

Yes! Box 4 on the 1099-G is federal income tax withheld and Box 11 is for state withholding if any was taken out. If those boxes are blank or zero it means nothing was withheld during the year. Arizona DES mails those out in January and you can also find them in your CACTUS portal.

0 coins

Okay so if I look at my 1099-G and those boxes are zero I'll know I owe the full amount on whatever I got. That's actually really helpful to know going into it.

0 coins

Good to know about the 1099-G. I hadn't even thought about that form yet. I assume Arizona DES sends it without you having to request it?

0 coins

They mail it automatically but I'd still check CACTUS to download a copy in case the mailed one gets lost or delayed. Happened to me and I had to request a duplicate which took extra time.

0 coins

NOBODY warned me about this when I filed!! I went six months without withholding because I assumed it was automatic and ended up owing over $1,800 combined federal and state. I literally cried when my tax person told me. Arizona DES should make this REQUIRED reading when you first sign up, it's ridiculous that it's buried in the portal settings.

0 coins

That's genuinely awful and I'm sorry that happened. The system really should default to withholding or at minimum ask you during the initial claim setup in a way that makes it obvious. Burying it in account settings is a failure on Arizona DES's part.

0 coins

Exactly! And when I called to ask about it I couldn't get anyone on the phone for days. By the time I finally got through I'd already missed a whole quarter of estimated payments I could have made.

0 coins

This is the most common horror story I see on here. It's always the same thing - people find out in February what they should have known in June.

0 coins

Quick clarifying question because I see this come up a lot - is the withholding percentage on UI benefits the same as what gets taken from a regular paycheck? Because on my old job my federal withholding was way more than 10%.

0 coins

Different calculation entirely. With a regular paycheck the withholding amount depends on your W-4 elections, pay frequency, and income level which can push it well above 10%. For unemployment the voluntary federal withholding is a flat 10% regardless of your situation. It's lower than what most employed people see taken out but it's something, and something is way better than nothing.

0 coins

That makes sense actually. So if someone is in a higher tax bracket they might actually still owe even with the 10% withheld because their real rate is higher?

0 coins

Exactly right. If your total income for the year puts you in a 22% or higher bracket then 10% withholding won't cover the full tax on those benefits. Worth running the numbers or talking to a tax person if you've had a mix of employment income and UI during the same year.

0 coins

This happened to me. I was employed for half the year and on UI for the other half, and even with 10% federal withheld from my benefits I still owed because my employment income bumped my overall bracket.

0 coins

So wait I'm confused about something - does it matter when in the year you start getting unemployment? Like if someone starts collecting in October do they have less time to fix the withholding situation before taxes are due compared to someone who starts in January?

0 coins

Technically the tax burden is the same regardless of when in the year you start - all UI benefits received in a calendar year show up on your 1099-G for that year. But you're right that someone starting in October has fewer weeks of unwithheld payments before year-end, so the total amount they might owe could be less just because they received fewer weeks of benefits before they figured it out.

0 coins

Oh okay so it's just about total amount received not timing specifically. That makes sense I was overthinking it.

0 coins

Can I add something for OP? Beyond just setting up withholding going forward, make sure you can actually get into your CACTUS account to make the change because sometimes people get locked out or hit verification issues. I had a whole mess with my account access and couldn't update anything for two weeks. I tried Claimyr after getting nowhere with the DES phone line, and I ended up talking to an Arizona DES agent who unlocked my account while I was on the phone with them - then I could immediately go in and set up my withholding.

0 coins

Ugh that's one more thing to worry about. My CACTUS login has been fine so far but I've heard people getting locked out randomly. Did the agent actually fix the account access issue in real time?

0 coins

Yes they did it right then. I could refresh my browser while still on the call and my account was accessible again. Much faster than waiting for an email resolution which apparently can take several business days.

0 coins

The account lockout thing is so common. Seems like any time someone resets their password or changes their email it triggers some kind of security hold. Good to know you can get it sorted over the phone.

0 coins

To bring it back around to the original question with some clarity - Arizona DES unemployment benefits are taxable at both the federal and state level. Federal voluntary withholding is a flat 10% if you elect it. Arizona state income tax also applies to UI benefits and you can elect state withholding through your CACTUS account as well. Neither is automatic so if you didn't actively choose withholding when you filed you're accumulating a tax liability with every payment. The fix going forward is simple - update your withholding election in CACTUS. For what you've already received without withholding, consider making a federal estimated payment at irs.gov and an Arizona estimated payment at aztaxes.gov to stay ahead of it.

0 coins

This is the clearest summary I've seen in this whole thread, thank you. I'm going to log into CACTUS right now and find that withholding setting. And then figure out the estimated payment situation for the weeks I already missed.

0 coins

Bookmarking this comment for the next time someone in my family asks me about UI taxes. This comes up constantly and having it laid out simply is really useful.

0 coins

The aztaxes.gov tip is good - a lot of people don't know you can make Arizona estimated payments online separately from your federal ones. Definitely easier than mailing a check.

0 coins

Has anyone actually calculated whether it's better to do the 10% federal withholding through Arizona DES or just handle it yourself through estimated payments? I feel like making quarterly payments gives you more control over the timing.

0 coins

Honestly? For most people on UI the 10% automatic withholding is safer because it removes the temptation to spend money you're mentally earmarking for taxes. Quarterly estimated payments require discipline and remembering four separate deadlines. If you're someone who can reliably set aside 10-15% of each payment and actually make those quarterly deposits then estimated payments give you flexibility. But for most people the set-it-and-forget-it withholding election is the better choice.

0 coins

That's fair. I'm probably the type to tell myself I'll make the estimated payment and then life happens and suddenly it's April and I haven't done it yet. Automatic withholding probably is safer for me.

0 coins

You're definitely not alone in that. The number of people who plan to do estimated payments and don't follow through is... probably most of them. The IRS penalty for underpayment isn't catastrophic but it stings enough to be annoying.

0 coins

Random question - if I get a part time job while on UI and report my earnings like I'm supposed to, do taxes get complicated because I'd have two sources of income? My employer would be withholding from my wages normally but then the UI side is separate.

0 coins

Good thing to think through ahead of time. Your employer handles their own withholding through normal payroll, and your Arizona DES UI benefits are a completely separate tax situation. At the end of the year you'd have a W-2 from your employer and a 1099-G from Arizona DES. If your employer withholding is calibrated for your wage income only, it might not cover the tax on the combined wage-plus-UI total. If your combined income bumps you into a higher bracket that's when you can end up owing more than expected.

0 coins

So I might want to tell my employer to withhold a little extra on my wages to compensate for the UI income? Like adjust my W-4?

0 coins

Exactly that. There's a line on the W-4 where you can request additional withholding per paycheck. Even adding $20 or $30 per check can offset the UI tax liability so you're not scrambling in April.

0 coins

This is actually what my tax person recommended when I was doing the part-time-while-on-UI thing. Small extra withholding from the employer paycheck made the whole situation much tidier at filing time.

0 coins

Late to this thread but adding my two cents - I was in this exact spot nine months ago and what finally got it resolved was talking to someone at Arizona DES directly. I had used Claimyr to reach an agent and she confirmed my withholding had never been activated even though I thought I'd set it up. Turned out my CACTUS session had timed out before the change saved and I had no idea. That conversation saved me from another few months of zero withholding.

0 coins

Oh that's a terrifying thought - thinking you set it up but it not actually saving. I'm going to log in and double-check that my change actually saved and shows up in my account.

0 coins

Yes please do that. The portal doesn't always give a super obvious confirmation when settings save. Looking for the updated election to show in your account profile is the safest way to confirm it.

0 coins

CACTUS timing out mid-action is such a known issue. I've had it happen with other settings changes too. Always good to verify after any change saves rather than just assuming it went through.

0 coins

Does the withholding election carry over if your claim gets extended or if you file a new claim after going back to work and then losing the job again? Or do you have to set it up fresh each time?

0 coins

Good question and I wish I knew the definitive answer. My understanding is that withholding elections can reset when you open a new benefit year or file a fresh claim. When I reopened my claim last year I went back in and re-elected withholding just to be safe even though I thought it might carry over. Definitely worth verifying rather than assuming.

0 coins

Yeah I'll just check every time I reopen or extend a claim. Not worth risking it.

0 coins

This is the kind of thing worth confirming with an Arizona DES agent if you're unsure, especially because getting it wrong has a delayed consequence you won't discover until tax season.

0 coins

Just want to point out for anyone finding this thread later - the place to update withholding is in your CACTUS portal at uibenefits.az.gov, not through some paper form or by mailing anything in. Everything is done online through your account. I see people confused about this sometimes thinking they need to submit a form separately.

0 coins

Is there actually no paper option at all? Like for people who have trouble with the online portal?

0 coins

There may be a paper process but I honestly don't know the details of it. The online portal is what Arizona DES pushes everyone toward and it's what I know works. For the paper route I'd call Arizona DES to ask specifically.

0 coins

The online portal really is the standard path. For accessibility issues Arizona DES does have accommodations but I'd contact them to find out what's available for specific situations.

0 coins

Something I wish someone had told me when I first filed - set a calendar reminder every January to check for your 1099-G in CACTUS. Arizona DES usually posts them in mid to late January and you need them to file your taxes. I've seen people delay their whole tax filing because they were waiting on a 1099-G that was already sitting in their portal account.

0 coins

That's a great tip. I'll set that reminder now while I'm thinking about it. Last thing I need is to be scrambling for a form I could have grabbed online.

0 coins

Also make sure your address in CACTUS is current if you've moved. The mailed 1099-G goes to whatever address is on file and I've seen people miss it because they forgot to update their address after moving.

0 coins

Both of these - the portal check and the address update - are things that should be in a checklist somewhere for first-time UI claimants. So much of this stuff you only learn after making the mistake once.

0 coins

Real quick - has anyone had Arizona DES mess up the 1099-G amount? Like report more or less than you actually received?

0 coins

It happens, though not super commonly. If you think there's a discrepancy the first thing I'd do is total up your own payment history from CACTUS and compare it to Box 1 on the 1099-G. If the numbers don't match you'll need to contact Arizona DES to request a corrected 1099-G which is called a 1099-G corrected form. Don't file your taxes with numbers you believe are wrong - that creates a bigger headache later.

0 coins

Good to know. I keep a spreadsheet of my weekly payments anyway so I can cross-reference. Sounds like that habit is actually useful come tax time.

0 coins

The spreadsheet habit is great. Even just keeping your payment confirmation emails or screenshots from CACTUS gives you a paper trail if you ever need to dispute a 1099-G amount.

0 coins

Coming in late but this question about taxes withheld on unemployment checks genuinely trips up so many people. I've helped three separate family members through this confusion in the last couple years. The short version I give everyone now: nothing is automatic, you have to elect it, do it in CACTUS as soon as possible, and don't assume it got set up during your original filing.

0 coins

That's a really clean summary and honestly what I wish I'd been told before I started collecting. Going to update my withholding election today and then make an estimated payment to cover the weeks I missed.

0 coins

You're ahead of a lot of people just by figuring this out now rather than in February. Good luck!

0 coins

Genuinely the most common financial mistake I see new UI claimants make. The good news is it's fixable, just takes a little proactive work like you're doing.

0 coins

Does anyone know if Arizona has a specific income threshold below which the UI benefits just aren't taxed? Like if someone only received a few hundred dollars do they still need to report it?

0 coins

Technically all unemployment compensation is taxable income regardless of amount and should be reported on your federal return. There's no threshold below which UI benefits magically become non-taxable. That said, whether you owe any actual tax depends on your total income, deductions, and filing status for the year. Someone with very low total income might end up owing zero despite technically having taxable UI income, but you still report it.

0 coins

Got it, so report it always and let the math determine if you actually owe anything. That makes sense.

0 coins

This is the right answer. I made the mistake of not reporting a small UI amount one year thinking it was too small to matter. It wasn't a disaster but it created a correction situation I had to deal with.

0 coins

UPDATE: I logged into CACTUS and confirmed that I had zero withholding elected - absolutely nothing had been set up. I've now turned on both the federal 10% and state withholding. I also went to irs.gov and made an estimated payment to cover roughly what I should have had withheld from my first several weeks of benefits. Thanks everyone in this thread - this could have been a really ugly April if I hadn't figured this out now.

0 coins

Really glad you sorted it out! The estimated payment move is exactly right - covers your past exposure and now going forward the automatic withholding has you covered.

0 coins

This is the best outcome. Future you is going to be really happy you dealt with this proactively instead of discovering it at tax time.

0 coins

Great follow-through. And honestly, taking thirty minutes to handle this now saves hours of stress in February. Well done.

0 coins

Bookmarking this whole thread. This is one of the more useful conversations I've seen on here about UI taxes.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure