Back to Arizona Unemployment

Carmen Vega

Can you get fired for unemployment marijuana use in Arizona DES claims?

So here's my situation and I'm genuinely not sure how screwed I am. I worked at a logistics company for about two years, got let go last month after a random drug screen came back positive for marijuana. Arizona is a weird state about this because weed is legal here recreationally now, but my employer had a zero-tolerance policy in their handbook. I smoked on my own time, off the clock, never showed up impaired or anything like that. HR told me it was 'misconduct' and that I wouldn't be eligible for unemployment. I filed anyway because honestly I need the money while I job hunt and figured I'd see what happens. Now my claim is sitting in adjudication and I have no idea what Arizona DES is actually going to decide. Has anyone gone through something similar? Like does the fact that marijuana is legal in AZ actually help my case or does the employer's policy override everything?

What kind of policy did they have you sign? That's the piece that's gonna matter here. Arizona DES adjudication on these marijuana cases basically comes down to whether your employer had a written zero-tolerance policy AND whether you signed something acknowledging it. If it was just buried in an employee handbook you got on day one and never specifically signed off on, that's actually a different situation than if you signed a drug policy agreement. Legal recreational use in AZ doesn't automatically protect you from employer policies in private workplaces, but how they documented that policy matters a lot to how DES looks at the misconduct question.

0 coins

The handbook thing - I did sign something when I was hired saying I read and understood the handbook. Does that count as signing the drug policy specifically or is it different?

0 coins

Signing a general handbook acknowledgment usually counts. DES will look at whether you had reasonable notice of the rule you broke. That said, a few cases have gone the claimant's way when the policy wasn't clearly explained as grounds for termination - worth noting in your adjudication response if you get a chance to submit one.

0 coins

My brother went through almost this exact thing last year at a warehouse and lost his appeal. The handbook signature was what got him. Just being real with you.

0 coins

Okay so the legal weed part is kind of a red herring here unfortunately. Arizona's recreational legalization doesn't require employers to accommodate off-duty marijuana use, and Arizona DES follows a standard that basically asks whether you knew the rule, whether you broke it, and whether that was deliberate. If all three are yes, they tend to call it misconduct. The tricky part is 'deliberate' - you weren't trying to get fired, you were using something legal. Some adjudicators weigh that, some don't. Your best bet right now is to respond to any DES questionnaire they send during adjudication as thoroughly as possible and document that you were off-duty, not impaired at work, and the substance is legal under state law even if company policy restricted it.

0 coins

They did send me a questionnaire - I already submitted it. I mentioned all the off-duty stuff and that I wasn't impaired. Now just waiting I guess.

0 coins

The impaired at work piece is huge actually. If you have coworkers who could attest you were never showing up messed up that might matter at the appeal stage if it goes that far.

0 coins

Yep this is right. I work in HR at a different company and the deliberate misconduct standard is genuinely what DES hangs most of these cases on. It's not a slam dunk either way.

0 coins

How long has your claim been in adjudication at this point? Mine sat there forever on a misconduct question and I couldn't get anyone on the phone to tell me anything. A coworker mentioned Claimyr - basically it navigates the hold system so you actually end up speaking to a live Arizona DES agent instead of getting disconnected after an hour. I used it when I needed to know if my adjudication was even being reviewed yet, and the agent I reached gave me a timeline and told me exactly what documents they still needed. claimyr.com has info on it, there's also a video at https://youtu.be/vwA1GGuV83Y that shows how it works. Honestly for a misconduct determination where the details really matter, talking to an actual DES agent is worth it.

0 coins

Mine's been in adjudication about 18 days now. No update on the portal at all, just says 'pending determination.' Getting pretty anxious about it.

0 coins

18 days on a misconduct adjudication isn't unusual but it's also when talking to someone actually helps. The agent I spoke to told me things the portal never showed.

0 coins

Does that work even when the DES lines are slammed? I've tried calling three times this week and got disconnected every single time before I even hit the queue.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of situation it's for - the DES phone lines are brutal right now and this was the only way I actually got through to talk to someone.

0 coins

Quick clarification on something above - the 'deliberate' misconduct standard in Arizona doesn't mean you intended to get fired, it means you intentionally did the act that violated the policy. So if you knowingly smoked weed knowing you were subject to random testing and had signed a zero-tolerance acknowledgment, DES can find that the act was deliberate even if firing wasn't your goal. That's how most of these marijuana misconduct cases get decided against claimants unfortunately. Doesn't mean you lose automatically, but want you to have accurate expectations going in.

0 coins

That interpretation is what I was afraid of. So basically 'deliberate' means I chose to do the thing, not that I chose to get fired.

0 coins

Exactly that. And the reason it matters for your situation specifically is you said you knew about the zero-tolerance policy - that's what completes the triangle for DES. Knowing the rule existed, using anyway, and the company catching it.

0 coins

Is there any argument that the policy itself conflicts with state law? Like does the AZ recreational marijuana law have any employee protections built into it?

0 coins

Arizona's prop 207 that legalized recreational marijuana does not include off-duty use protections for employees. Some states do have those, like Nevada and California have certain protections - but Arizona's law doesn't have that language. So your employer's policy is enforceable here and DES recognizes that.

0 coins

Something nobody's mentioned yet - did you try to fight this internally at your company before it got to DES? Like did they offer any kind of EAP or last-chance agreement or did they just go straight to termination? I ask because in my adjudication last year (different issue, not drug related) I used Claimyr to reach a DES agent and she specifically asked me whether the employer had followed their own progressive discipline policy before firing me. The fact that they skipped steps in their own process ended up helping my case. Might be worth thinking about whether your company followed their own handbook termination procedures.

0 coins

Straight to termination, no warning, no EAP offer. HR said zero-tolerance means zero steps.

0 coins

That's worth bringing up if you appeal. 'Zero-tolerance' in a handbook doesn't always legally waive progressive discipline requirements if other parts of the handbook describe a discipline process. DES sometimes looks at whether the employer was consistent in applying their own rules.

0 coins

Ooh the consistency angle is real. If your company fired you for a first offense but kept someone else who also violated a policy with just a warning, that inconsistency can matter at a hearing.

0 coins

Wait I'm confused about something in this thread - are people saying marijuana is legal in AZ or not? Because I thought it still wasn't federally?

0 coins

State level vs federal is what's tripping you up here. Arizona passed Prop 207 in 2020 - recreational marijuana is legal under AZ state law. It's still federally illegal but that doesn't affect state unemployment determinations which are under state law, not federal law. So for Arizona DES purposes, the state law is what's relevant.

0 coins

Oh okay so DES goes by state law got it. That makes more sense then.

0 coins

Right, and even under state law AZ didn't add worker protections for marijuana use, so private employers can still ban it and fire for it. Legal to use, still possible to fire over.

0 coins

Just gonna say this whole thing is infuriating from a policy perspective. You used something legal on your own time, you weren't hurting anyone, and now you might not get unemployment benefits. The system hasn't caught up to the law at all. Hope you get approved OP but honestly Arizona DES has been denying these left and right from what I've seen in various places online.

0 coins

Totally agree it feels unfair but the legal framework actually makes sense from the employer's side - they can have safety-sensitive positions where impairment is a real risk. The problem is it gets applied even to jobs where impairment risk is low.

0 coins

The logistics company part specifically though - are we talking warehouse and forklifts or desk job logistics? Because those feel like very different risk levels.

0 coins

Mostly warehouse, so I get the safety argument even if I still think it's a stretch. I genuinely was never impaired at work, that's the frustrating part to prove.

0 coins

For anyone searching this thread later - there's actually a decent amount of variation in how individual DES adjudicators handle marijuana misconduct cases. I've seen people post their outcomes and it's not 100% denial across the board. The cases that seem to go for the claimant often have one of these elements: employer couldn't document the written policy clearly, employer didn't consistently apply the rule to other employees, or the job didn't involve any safety-sensitive functions. Having all three working against you is tougher but not impossible.

0 coins

Okay one of three potentially on my side - the safety-sensitive argument is weaker for my specific role than for someone operating heavy machinery full time. I did some forklift work but it wasn't my primary job function.

0 coins

That's actually worth documenting. If your job description or records show your primary duties weren't safety-sensitive, that could shade the analysis even if you sometimes used a forklift.

0 coins

Is there a way to check what an adjudicator decided in similar past cases? Like is there a database of Arizona DES misconduct decisions?

0 coins

DES doesn't publish individual adjudication decisions publicly. Appeal decisions that went to a formal hearing and then to the appeals board sometimes show up in searchable legal databases but those are the minority of cases.

0 coins

Filing the claim was absolutely the right call regardless of outcome. Even if DES initially denies you on misconduct grounds, you have 30 days from the determination notice to file an appeal and request a hearing. At the hearing you can present your side in person to an appeals referee who reviews everything fresh - it's not just rubber-stamping the initial adjudication call. A lot of people give up after the first denial and that's a mistake because the hearing stage genuinely can go differently.

0 coins

30 days from the written determination - good to know. So if I get denied I shouldn't just assume it's over.

0 coins

Definitely not over at denial. The hearing is a real proceeding, they take testimony, you can present evidence, your employer has to show up and explain their decision too. Employers sometimes don't send anyone and that changes things.

0 coins

My brother (the warehouse situation I mentioned earlier) actually won at the hearing level after losing the initial adjudication. He found a note in his file showing HR had let someone else off with a warning for a minor policy violation, which the referee said showed inconsistent enforcement. First decision isn't final.

0 coins

While you're waiting on adjudication are you still filing your weekly claims? Because I almost made the mistake of stopping when my claim was under review thinking there was no point and someone here saved me - you need to keep filing or you won't get paid for those weeks even if you're approved retroactively.

0 coins

Yes still filing every week, good call flagging this though because I definitely thought about stopping.

0 coins

The number of people who don't know this is wild. File every single week no matter what your claim status says.

0 coins

Can confirm this from painful experience. I stopped filing for three weeks assuming I'd be denied and then got approved and lost those weeks entirely. File every week always.

0 coins

Real question for anyone following this - what's the actual wait time looking like for marijuana misconduct adjudications right now? Mine has been pending for 26 days on a similar situation and I've been trying to get information from DES with zero luck. I actually heard about Claimyr from a friend last week and finally got a live agent at Arizona DES on the phone after weeks of busy signals and disconnections. The agent told me my adjudication was assigned to someone and expected to resolve within 10 business days. Wouldn't have known that without getting someone on the phone - check claimyr.com if you're stuck in that same loop.

0 coins

26 days and still waiting, that's rough. Getting a timeline from an actual agent sounds huge, I might look into that.

0 coins

10 business days from when though - from when you called or from when it was assigned?

0 coins

From when it was assigned, which turned out to be about two weeks earlier. So I was actually close to a resolution already and didn't know it. That's the kind of info you just can't get from the portal.

0 coins

Curious about the job search requirements while this is all pending - do you still have to be doing your three job search activities per week even during adjudication on a misconduct claim? Because I wasn't sure if the misconduct question kind of paused everything.

0 coins

Your job search log requirements don't pause during adjudication. You still need to complete three employer contacts each week you file a claim. If you're approved, they can audit those search records, so keep documenting every application and contact with dates and employer names.

0 coins

Three contacts per week even during this limbo period, good to know. I had completely stopped thinking it didn't matter yet.

0 coins

This is a really common misconception and people get tripped up on it. Keep your job search log current from week one, adjudication pending or not.

0 coins

One thing I'd push back on slightly in this thread - a few people are treating DES adjudicators like they're all going to interpret this the same way, but the reality is there's real human variation. I've heard of identical situations going both ways depending on who picks up the case. That's partly why getting someone on the phone at DES to understand where your specific case stands is valuable - not to influence the decision but just to know what's actually happening and whether there's anything you can submit that helps your position.

0 coins

The human variation point is real and honestly kind of uncomfortable to think about. Same facts, different outcome depending on who reviews it.

0 coins

Which is exactly why the appeal/hearing process exists - it's a check on that inconsistency. If you lose and think the determination was wrong, the hearing is your chance to get a second set of eyes.

0 coins

Has anyone had luck submitting additional documentation after the initial questionnaire? Like can I still send things to DES during adjudication or is that window closed?

0 coins

You can typically contact DES to add information while adjudication is ongoing - once a determination is issued it's harder. If you have something relevant, now is the time to try to get it in front of whoever is reviewing your case.

0 coins

Coming at this from a slightly different angle - even if you end up getting denied, the period you spend appealing isn't wasted. You can keep job hunting, keep filing your weekly claims, and if you win the appeal all those weeks get paid out. The financial pressure is real but the system does have a path that could work out even if the first answer is no.

0 coins

That retroactive payment piece helps me feel less panicked about the timeline at least. Good to know I'm not just losing those weeks forever if the appeal takes a while.

0 coins

Exactly - the weekly filings you're doing now are creating the record of weeks owed if you win. Keep filing, keep the job search log, build the case in parallel.

0 coins

Just want to update this thread since it was helpful to me too - found it while searching my situation (got let go from a construction company for the same thing). I ended up using Claimyr to get through to Arizona DES after trying on my own for two weeks straight. Got an agent who explained that my specific job duties - I was doing mostly administrative work, not on the tools - were going to be a factor in how they evaluated the safety-sensitive question. Didn't get a determination yet but at least I know what they're looking at. If you're in the Phoenix area and can't get through, it's worth trying - claimyr.com.

0 coins

Administrative vs tools distinction is interesting - so they actually look at your real day-to-day duties not just the job title?

0 coins

That's what the agent told me. My title said 'site coordinator' which sounds hands-on but I was mostly scheduling and paperwork. She said that context matters for the safety rationale behind the policy.

0 coins

This thread has been incredibly useful for a weirdly specific situation I'm now also in. Bookmarking this for when my adjudication comes back.

0 coins

How did you get fired exactly - like did they call you in and tell you on the spot or did you get a letter? I ask because how they documented the termination and what reason they gave you IN WRITING matters for how your employer responds to the DES questionnaire they also have to fill out.

0 coins

They called me into HR, told me verbally it was due to the failed drug test, and gave me a termination letter that said 'violation of company drug and alcohol policy' as the reason. So they put it in writing.

0 coins

Okay so the written reason matches what they're going to tell DES - no ambiguity there. That's actually cleaner than situations where employers put a vague reason in writing and then tell DES something different. At least you know what you're dealing with.

0 coins

The employer putting the reason in writing is a double-edged sword - it confirms misconduct on paper but it also pins them to that exact story. If anything about how they handled it deviated from their own policy, there's clear documentation to point to.

0 coins

This whole thread should be pinned or something. I found it at 2am spiraling about my own situation (not marijuana but a different alleged misconduct termination) and it actually calmed me down having actual information instead of just anxiety.

0 coins

I was in that exact same 2am spiral when I first posted. Glad it helped even a little.

0 coins

That's genuinely what these threads are for. The DES process is confusing and scary and official documentation doesn't explain it in human terms. Good luck to everyone in here dealing with this stuff.

0 coins

Final question for the thread - is there a way to know when adjudication is wrapping up before the portal updates? Like any indicator to watch for?

0 coins

Watch your CACTUS portal for any new document uploads or status changes, and sometimes you get a letter in the mail that arrives before the portal updates. Keep checking both.

0 coins

Something worth knowing going forward with job hunting - a lot of employers in Arizona are starting to remove marijuana from their standard pre-employment drug panels, especially for non-safety-sensitive positions. So while this situation with your old employer is what it is, the landscape is changing for future jobs. Some employers specifically note in job postings now that they don't test for marijuana.

0 coins

That's actually a silver lining I hadn't thought about. Good to know the job search landscape is shifting a bit.

0 coins

Industries vary a lot though. Transportation, construction, healthcare - still very much testing. Tech, marketing, a lot of office environments - pulling it from panels more and more. Worth reading job postings carefully.

0 coins

The inconsistency across industries is frustrating but at least it's moving in a direction. Five years ago this wasn't even a conversation.

0 coins

Final thought from me - whatever DES decides, you did everything right procedurally. Filed the claim, submitted the questionnaire, keeping up weekly claims and job search requirements. That's all you can control. The adjudication process takes as long as it takes and the appeal is there if you need it. Good luck.

0 coins

Thanks for this. This thread has honestly been more informative than anything I found on the official DES website. I'll post an update when I get a determination.

0 coins

Please do update - these outcome posts help the next person who searches this exact situation and finds the thread.

0 coins

Rooting for you. Keep filing those weekly claims no matter what.

0 coins

Arizona Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure