< Back to FAFSA

Mary Bates

Is filing FAFSA worth it if we might not qualify for aid? First-time parent confused

OK so I'm totally new to this college financial stuff and feel pretty lost. My daughter is applying to colleges for fall 2025 and everyone keeps saying "make sure you file the FAFSA" but is it actually necessary? We make decent money (household income around $140k) and have some savings, so I'm wondering if we'll even qualify for anything. I've read posts where families went through all the hassle and got literally $0 in aid. I don't want to waste hours on paperwork just to get nothing. Plus the new SAI calculation seems confusing as heck. Can someone explain the actual BENEFIT of filling this thing out if we're probably not going to qualify for need-based aid? Sorry if this is a dumb question - just a confused first-time college parent here!

YES, absolutely file the FAFSA regardless of income! There are several important reasons: 1. Many colleges require the FAFSA for ANY type of aid, including merit scholarships that aren't based on financial need 2. Federal Direct Unsubsidized loans (which aren't need-based) require FAFSA filing 3. You might be surprised - the SAI calculation takes into account family size, number of college students, and other factors beyond just income 4. Some schools with high costs have very generous aid formulas and consider families making up to $200K as potentially qualifying 5. Your financial situation could change (job loss, medical expenses, etc.), and having FAFSA already filed makes adjustments easier The form is much simpler now than in previous years! Plan about 45 minutes if you have your tax documents handy.

0 coins

Thank you so much! I had no idea about the merit scholarships possibly requiring FAFSA. That's really helpful. My daughter has good grades so hopefully she might qualify for some of those. Are there deadlines I should be aware of? I keep hearing different dates.

0 coins

we didnt file last year for my son and REGRETTED IT BIG TIME!!! his school wouldnt even let him get the unsub loans without fafsa on file. ended up filing late and it was a whole mess. just do it now and save urself the headache

0 coins

I was in your exact position last year! Household income $150k, thought we'd get nothing. But we have two kids in college simultaneously, and that made a HUGE difference in the calculation. Ended up getting some grants at the private schools (nothing at state schools though). Also, IMPORTANT: Many colleges use the FAFSA as the gateway to their institutional scholarships - even if you don't qualify for federal aid, the college might have their own funds they distribute. Some won't even CONSIDER your child for certain scholarships without that FAFSA on file. So yes, absolutely worth the time.

0 coins

That's really good to know! We only have the one child, but some of the schools she's looking at are private with higher costs. I was thinking we'd just focus on the state schools, but maybe we should keep options open.

0 coins

Definitely keep options open! Sometimes private schools end up cheaper than state schools after institutional aid. My daughter got a $25,000/year scholarship at a private university that required FAFSA filing even though we didn't qualify for federal grants. Made it comparable to our state school cost.

0 coins

no you dont HAVE to file fafsa but your basically throwing away free money if you dont lol. even rich ppl can get some aid sometimes.

0 coins

Financial aid professional here! Beyond what others mentioned, there are a few more reasons to file: 1. The federal loan programs (which many middle/upper-income families use) REQUIRE a FAFSA, even if you don't qualify for need-based aid 2. Some state grant programs have higher income thresholds than federal programs 3. If multiple children attend college simultaneously, your SAI gets divided 4. Some schools won't package ANY institutional aid without a FAFSA 5. Having a FAFSA on file makes it easier if you need to appeal aid decisions later The form takes about 30-45 minutes with the new streamlined version if you have tax returns handy. Most families making $140K will qualify for something, even if it's just unsubsidized loans.

0 coins

This is super helpful, thank you! When you say "state grant programs" - are these automatic if we qualify, or do we need to apply separately for those after doing FAFSA?

0 coins

Most state grant programs use FAFSA data automatically, but a few states (like Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Vermont) have supplemental forms. Your daughter's colleges will usually guide you through any additional requirements after receiving your FAFSA. The financial aid office at each school is your best resource for specific requirements.

0 coins

I was in identical situation last year and WISH someone had told me to file earlier!!!! We make about $135k and I thought "why bother" but my son's top choice school wouldn't even CONSIDER him for their presidential merit scholarship without FAFSA on file. By the time I realized this, we were past priority deadlines. DON'T MAKE MY MISTAKE!!!

0 coins

Oh no, that's awful! Did your son still get to attend his top choice school? I'm worried about missing deadlines now.

0 coins

Yes but we're paying about $8k more per year than we might have with that scholarship. File ASAP - many schools have priority deadlines as early as December for the best aid packages!

0 coins

Trying to reach someone at Federal Student Aid to get answers about FAFSA eligibility is IMPOSSIBLE. Waited on hold for 2.5 hours last week and got disconnected! Finally used a service called Claimyr that got me through to an agent in 20 minutes. They connected me right away and I was able to ask all my questions about our unusual situation (self-employed with business losses). Saved me hours of frustration. There's a video showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ and the website is claimyr.com if anyone else is struggling to reach FSA. So much easier than waiting for hours.

0 coins

Thanks for the tip! I do have some specific questions about reporting our 401k and some investment properties we have. Might be worth using this instead of waiting forever on hold.

0 coins

THE ENTIRE FINANCIAL AID SYSTEM IS A SCAM!!! We filed FAFSA for 3 YEARS and got NOTHING but loans with ridiculous interest rates. Complete waste of time. The government just wants your financial info.

0 coins

I understand your frustration, but federal student loan interest rates are actually set by Congress and are the same for everyone. They're typically lower than private loans. While the system isn't perfect, FAFSA is still the gateway to most financial aid options and worth completing.

0 coins

maybe for SOME people but middle class families get CRUSHED. We made just enough to get zero grants but not enough to actually afford the ridiculous tuition. The whole system punishes people who work hard.

0 coins

Quick tip about filing: The 2025-2026 FAFSA will use your 2023 tax information (they always use tax info from two years prior). So have your 2023 tax return handy when you fill it out. And make sure both you AND your daughter create FSA IDs before starting - that alone can take a few days to process.

0 coins

Thank you! That's really helpful. Good to know about the FSA IDs taking time to process - I would have probably tried to do everything at once and gotten frustrated.

0 coins

lol yeh do it, it's like buying a lottery ticket that's free. might win something might not but costs nothing to try ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

0 coins

One more important point: Even families with higher incomes often use Parent PLUS loans to help pay for college, and you need a completed FAFSA on file to access those. Many families use a combination of the student's Direct loans (from FAFSA) and Parent PLUS loans to bridge gaps. So file the FAFSA even if you just want access to the federal loan programs!

0 coins

I've heard about Parent PLUS loans but wasn't sure how they worked. Do they have better rates than just getting a private loan? We're hoping to mostly cash flow college but might need some loans to fill gaps.

0 coins

Parent PLUS loans currently have a 8.05% interest rate plus a ~4% origination fee. Private loans might offer better rates if you have excellent credit, but PLUS loans have more flexible repayment options and forgiveness possibilities in certain situations. Worth comparing both options once you know your actual costs.

0 coins

FAFSA AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,095 users helped today