FAFSA repeatedly rejected for SAI calculation - grad student with separate tax filing spouse
I'm at my wit's end with this FAFSA nightmare! I'm an independent graduate student and have resubmitted my 2025-26 FAFSA application FIVE times since January 10th. Every single time, I get this vague message that 'SAI cannot be calculated' with zero explanation about what's wrong. My university financial aid office confirms they received the application but says they also can't calculate my SAI. The most frustrating part is my husband is listed as a contributor since we file taxes separately, and I'm wondering if that's causing the issue? I've triple-checked every answer multiple times. Has anyone experienced this problem with separate tax filing spouses? What specific sections should I focus on fixing? At this point, I'm worried I'll miss out on aid entirely for fall semester.
21 comments
Join the conversation
Ethan Scott
omg same thing happened to me!! took me like 2 months to figure out. check if you entered your husband's income correctly in the contributor section. there's like 3 different income fields and if they dont match up right the system just rejects without telling u why
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•Thanks for responding! I did enter his income in all the required fields. Do you remember which specific income fields were causing problems for you? Were there any specific sections where your numbers needed to match up?
0 coins
Lola Perez
I'm a financial aid counselor, and I see this issue frequently with married graduate students who file separately. The most common problems are: 1. Inconsistent reporting of assets - make sure household assets are correctly allocated between you and your contributor 2. Missing W-2 information - even with separate filing, the FAFSA now requires complete income documentation for both filers 3. Dependency verification mismatch - as a grad student you're independent, but the system sometimes flags separate-filing contributors incorrectly I recommend scheduling a meeting with your school's financial aid office and bringing copies of both tax returns and W-2s. They can help identify the specific fields causing the calculation failure.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•Thank you so much for the detailed response! I think the asset allocation might be the issue - we weren't sure how to divide joint savings accounts and retirement funds. Would it be better to just re-file the entire FAFSA from scratch instead of trying to correct the existing one at this point?
0 coins
Lola Perez
•For joint accounts, you generally report 50% of the value on your FAFSA unless there's documentation showing a different ownership percentage. Retirement accounts are reported differently based on type - some are excluded entirely. At this point, starting a new application might be cleaner than correcting the existing one, especially if you've submitted multiple times with the same errors. Just be sure to withdraw any pending applications first to avoid confusion in the system.
0 coins
Nathaniel Stewart
The FAFSA system is ABSOLUTE GARBAGE this year!!! My daughter's application got rejected 7 TIMES before we figured out the problem. The new system is completely broken and nobody at FSA seems to care!!! We spent HOURS on hold trying to get answers. The separate tax filing definitely complicates things - the new FAFSA doesn't handle non-traditional situations well AT ALL.
0 coins
Ethan Scott
•fr the new system is the worst. took me forever to get through to anyone who knew what they were talking about
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•It's somewhat comforting (though still frustrating) to know I'm not alone in this struggle. Did you ever manage to get through to someone at FSA who could actually help?
0 coins
Riya Sharma
I went through this exact situation last month! After multiple rejections, I discovered the contributor section was missing critical information about my spouse's untaxed income sources. For graduate students with separate-filing spouses, you need to carefully complete Section 3 about untaxed income and make sure your AGI from both tax returns matches what's reported. I finally gave up trying to solve it myself and used Claimyr to reach an actual FSA agent (claimyr.com). Their service connected me to a real person at FSA in about 20 minutes instead of waiting for hours. The agent went through my application line by line and found the exact fields causing the calculation error. They have a video demo showing how it works: https://youtu.be/TbC8dZQWYNQ
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•Thank you! I hadn't considered that untaxed income might be the issue. My husband does have some fellowship income that's partially untaxed, and I wasn't sure how to report that correctly. I'll check out that service if I can't get through on my own - at this point, I'd do anything to get this resolved.
0 coins
Santiago Diaz
have u tried usingg the FAFSA help center chat thing?? they helped me when i had a problem with my parents tax info not matching. its not great but better than nothing lol
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•I tried the chat feature twice but kept getting generic answers that didn't address my specific situation. It's like they have a script for common problems but can't handle anything more complex. Did you get a real person or just the automated responses?
0 coins
Millie Long
As someone who works with graduate student financial aid, here's a systematic approach to solve your issue: 1. Download and review your Student Aid Report (SAR) - often the error codes there provide more detail than the general messages 2. Specific to separate tax filers: - Verify tax filing status consistency across all sections - Confirm W-2 wages vs AGI numbers match for both you and spouse - Check that asset allocation follows the 50/50 split guideline - Review household size and support questions 3. Common graduate student pitfalls: - Incorrectly reporting fellowships/assistantships - Misunderstanding housing allowance reporting - Errors in education credits sections The 2025-26 FAFSA has specific validation checks between contributor and student sections that trigger SAI calculation failures without clear error messages.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•This is incredibly helpful! I didn't realize I could download a detailed SAR report to see more specific error codes. I'm pretty sure I made a mistake with reporting my teaching assistantship - I wasn't sure if it counted as untaxed income since part is tuition waiver. I'll review everything point by point using your list and see if I can identify where things don't align.
0 coins
KaiEsmeralda
My brother had similar problems with his grad school FAFSA. Turned out he needed to provide his spouse's FSA ID info even though they file separately? Idk the system is weird about contributor access or something. Might be worth checking if you completed that part correctly.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•That's interesting - my husband did create an FSA ID but we weren't sure if he needed to actually log in and approve something since we file separately. I'll double-check if there's a pending contributor approval on his account. Thanks for the tip!
0 coins
Riya Sharma
Have you checked if your application is stuck in verification? Sometimes the system flags applications for verification but doesn't clearly communicate it. For grad students with separate filing spouses, the FAFSA often requires additional verification due to the separate tax situations. Log into studentaid.gov and check the verification status specifically.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•I didn't think about verification being the issue since I never received a clear notification about it. I just checked my studentaid.gov account and don't see anything obvious about verification, but I'll click through all the sections again to make sure I'm not missing something. Would my school also be notified if verification was needed?
0 coins
Riya Sharma
•Yes, your school would be notified if verification was needed, but sometimes there's a communication gap. In my experience, it's worth directly asking your financial aid office if your application has been flagged for verification. They can see status details that might not be immediately visible to you in the student portal.
0 coins
Lola Perez
Update on your situation: I consulted with our graduate financial aid specialist. For the 2025-26 FAFSA, there's a known issue affecting graduate students with separate-filing contributors. The system sometimes fails to process applications when there's any discrepancy in financial information, particularly with retirement accounts and business income. My recommendation: 1. Start a fresh application 2. Have both your and your husband's tax documents ready side-by-side 3. Report retirement accounts on the correct person's profile (not split) 4. Be extremely precise with business income if either of you has any 5. Double-check the "support provided" section numbers The good news is that graduate student aid deadlines are typically later than undergraduate, so you should still have time to correct this for fall semester.
0 coins
Genevieve Cavalier
•Thank you for checking with a specialist! You're right about retirement accounts - we weren't sure how to handle my husband's 401k and my Roth IRA. I'll start fresh and make sure to report each account with the correct person rather than trying to split them. And yes, he does have some small business income so I'll be extra careful with that section. You've been incredibly helpful!
0 coins