Back to Washington Unemployment

Naila Gordon

Unemployment denied after quitting for new job that was rescinded - Washington ESD appeal help

So I'm about three weeks into what has turned into a complete nightmare with Washington ESD and I honestly don't know what to do next. I had been working at a distribution warehouse for almost two years when I got a solid job offer from a logistics company - better pay, better hours, actual benefits. I gave my two weeks notice, left on good terms with my employer, and was supposed to start the new position on a Monday. That Friday before my start date, the hiring manager called and said the position had been "eliminated due to budget restructuring." Just like that. No job to go back to, no new job to start, nothing. I filed for UI benefits with Washington ESD immediately. Seemed like a no-brainer - I didn't quit because I was unhappy or lazy, I quit because I had a confirmed job lined up and that job evaporated. Well, Washington ESD sent me a disqualification notice saying I voluntarily left my work without good cause. The notice doesn't mention the rescinded offer at all, it just says I quit. I've never dealt with anything like this before. I have the original offer letter, emails confirming my start date, and the voicemail from the hiring manager telling me the position was pulled. I know there has to be some provision for this situation because it's not like I just walked off the job on a whim. Has anyone actually fought this kind of denial? What documentation do I need and how do I even start the appeal process with Washington ESD?

Week four of my own ESD ordeal here, different issue but I know exactly how disorienting that disqualification letter feels when you know you did everything right. Your situation actually has a specific legal footing in Washington state - when someone leaves a job because they have a bona fide offer of new work, and that offer gets pulled through no fault of theirs, Washington ESD is supposed to treat that as a qualifying separation. The key question you need to ask ESD is: 'Was my separation truly voluntary given that the only reason I left was a confirmed written job offer that was subsequently rescinded by the employer before my start date?' That framing matters because it shifts the analysis from 'did you quit' to 'were the circumstances beyond your control.' Keep every piece of documentation you mentioned - the offer letter, the email chain confirming your start date, that voicemail especially. You have 30 days from the date on the disqualification notice to file your appeal, so don't sit on this. The appeal goes to the Office of Administrative Hearings, not back to ESD directly.

0 coins

Retail job, six weeks in limbo - just want to add that the voicemail piece is huge. I'd transcribe it word for word and note the date and time. Administrative law judges at OAH hearings actually pay attention to that kind of contemporaneous evidence.

0 coins

My adjudication dragged three weeks and I learned the hard way - file the appeal IN WRITING even if ESD says you can do it by phone. Written appeal creates a paper trail that phone calls don't.

0 coins

Final week of my standby period and I've been watching this forum constantly - your situation came up in a conversation I had with a WorkSource counselor actually. She said the rescinded-offer scenario trips people up because the initial ESD intake interview focuses on 'why did you leave your last employer' and claimants say 'I had another job lined up' and the interviewer checks 'voluntary quit' and moves on without documenting the rescission. The adjudicator then only sees the voluntary quit notation. What happened at your intake call - did you specifically explain that the new job was pulled before you started?

0 coins

Two weeks before this nightmare started I had no idea intake calls even existed as a formal step - I just answered the questions online when I filed. I did mention the rescinded offer in the text box but I don't know if whoever reviewed it actually read it. That might be exactly why the determination came back so wrong.

0 coins

Dental office scheduler here, week two of my own claim - the online text boxes are genuinely read by humans but the character limit makes people write too briefly. 'Job offer rescinded' in a text box reads differently than a full explanation with documentation attached.

0 coins

Benefits office where I volunteer sees this constantly - short text entries get flagged faster as voluntary quits than detailed ones. The more specific you are the harder it is to rubber-stamp a denial.

0 coins

Stuck on week five waiting for my appeal hearing date and I want to flag something practical before you get deeper into this. Getting any ESD agent on the phone to actually review your file notes before the hearing is nearly impossible right now - I tried for two weeks straight and kept hitting the automated system or getting disconnected. Someone in a different thread pointed me to Claimyr (claimyr.com) and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows exactly how it works. Basically it handles the hold queue for you and calls you when an actual ESD agent is on the line. I used it to reach someone who could look at my file and confirm what notes the adjudicator had actually recorded - turned out there was a factual error in my record I never would have caught otherwise. For your situation, getting an agent to confirm what your intake record actually says about the rescinded offer could be really important before you write your appeal statement.

0 coins

Haven't heard of that before - my whole thing has been trying to get through on the main ESD line and failing every single time. If it actually connects you to a live agent that would change everything for me right now.

0 coins

Got my disqualification reversed last month - confirming what's in your actual ESD file notes before you appeal is genuinely smart because sometimes the adjudicator recorded something factually wrong and you can address that head-on in your appeal statement.

0 coins

Service technician, just hit the 30-day mark on my claim - tried Claimyr after seeing it mentioned here too, got through to ESD within the same day. The agent I reached was actually able to flag my file for supervisor review while I was on the call.

0 coins

My termination appeal wrapped up last month so I want to give you the OAH hearing breakdown since that's probably where you're headed. Ask yourself before that hearing: 'What would a reasonable person have done in my exact position - would they have stayed at a stable job rather than accept a written offer from an established company?' That question is essentially what the administrative law judge is going to work through. The legal standard in Washington is whether you had 'good cause' to quit, and accepting a bona fide written job offer absolutely qualifies as good cause under RCW 50.20.050. The rescission then makes your situation even stronger because you didn't just quit on a whim AND land somewhere better - you quit for legitimate reasons and ended up with nothing through zero fault of yours. Bring printed copies of everything. Judges at OAH hearings have seen rescinded-offer cases before and they know the standard.

0 coins

Manufacturing plant, got my hearing notice two days ago - does the written offer have to be on company letterhead or is an emailed PDF acceptable? Mine's just an email with the job title and salary spelled out.

0 coins

Email offer is totally fine - OAH hearings accept digital evidence routinely. What matters is that it shows the position, the start date, and ideally the compensation, and that it came from a verifiable company email domain.

0 coins

Reading this after getting my hearing date finally - I have all three: letterhead offer letter, email confirmation of start date, and the voicemail from the hiring manager. Sounds like I'm in a decent position evidentially at least.

0 coins

Just got past the identity verification step on my claim this week so still early but I wanted to push back slightly on something. I've seen people say the rescinded offer is an automatic win at OAH and I don't think that's quite right. You still have to establish that the offer was genuine and not conditional - like if the offer letter had language saying employment was 'contingent on background check completion' or something similar, ESD could argue the offer wasn't truly firm. OP do you know if yours had any contingency language?

0 coins

Checked my offer letter again this morning - no contingency language at all, it states a specific start date and salary, and the follow-up emails are all treating it as confirmed. The hiring manager's voicemail explicitly says 'the position has been eliminated' not anything about me personally.

0 coins

Finishing my second week post-approval and that's an important distinction you're raising - conditional vs. unconditional offers do get treated differently. OP's situation sounds clean based on what they've described though.

0 coins

Halfway through my own appeal waiting period - also want to mention I used Claimyr to get ESD on the line and specifically asked the agent to read me what the adjudicator had written about whether the original offer was verified. Turned out ESD had never even tried to contact the new employer to confirm the offer existed. That's something you can raise in your appeal too.

0 coins

About ten days out from my disqualification notice and doing a lot of research - for anyone hitting the same wall OP hit trying to get a human at ESD, the Claimyr service (claimyr.com) came up repeatedly in my research. What appealed to me is that it handles the hold process and the callback so you're not burning hours redial-and-waiting. For something like a rescinded-offer denial where there's a factual record issue to correct, actually talking to an agent before you finalize your appeal statement seems worth it.

0 coins

Three weeks post-disqualification myself and I will say getting ESD on the phone even once to hear your file notes read back to you is completely different from just guessing what the adjudicator wrote. The agents can't reverse decisions but they can tell you what's in the record.

0 coins

At the standby review stage on my claim now - what the agent told you your file says often shapes how you frame your appeal. If the adjudicator wrote 'claimant quit without mention of alternate employment' you address that head-on. If they wrote 'alternate employment mentioned, reason unclear' that's a different opening.

0 coins

Got my packet from OAH this week so right in the thick of it - one thing I wish someone had told me earlier is that ESD will also submit their own documents to the OAH judge before the hearing. You're entitled to see those documents before the hearing and you should request them as soon as possible. Sometimes ESD's submitted packet contains only the initial claim form and intake notes, which means they're essentially just defending the adjudicator's original determination without the documentation you have. Knowing what's in their packet lets you structure your testimony to fill the gaps.

0 coins

Just submitted my appeal yesterday so this is really timely - how do I request ESD's document packet? Does that go through OAH or directly to ESD?

0 coins

Request goes through OAH - there's a form or you can write to the assigned hearing officer directly. They should automatically send you both parties' exhibit lists before the hearing but requesting it proactively speeds things up.

0 coins

Day two after filing my own OAH appeal and confirming this is accurate - OAH hearings are a lot less intimidating when you've seen what ESD is actually planning to present. Sometimes their packet is surprisingly thin.

0 coins

FOUR WEEKS trying to get ESD to pick up the phone before my hearing and I am DONE being polite about it. The main line hangs up after the hold music. The alternate numbers loop back to the same system. The online message portal says 'response within 5-7 business days' and then nothing arrives. I had a simple factual question about whether my file showed my new employer's contact information and I literally could not get a human to answer it. The system is set up to exhaust people into giving up and it WORKS.

0 coins

After my own wall of failed calls - that's genuinely what it feels like, I won't argue with you. The workaround I described upthread (Claimyr) is specifically for this situation. I know it feels like you shouldn't have to use a third-party service to reach a government agency but practically speaking it's the difference between getting a question answered before your hearing or not.

0 coins

Spent three weeks trying every number and option before I even looked for alternatives - fine, I'll try it. If it gets me five minutes with an agent to confirm my file I'll consider it a win.

0 coins

Dental office, my second hearing attempt coming up - the phone system being this broken is a real substantive problem not just an inconvenience because information in your file that you can't access and correct before a hearing can tank a winnable case.

0 coins

Just cleared week three of adjudication on a different issue but I've been reading about rescinded-offer denials for a while. Worth noting that at your OAH hearing you can also subpoena the new employer to produce records confirming the offer was real and was rescinded. Most employers won't fight a subpoena for a document they already sent you, and having the new employer's HR department confirm the rescission directly removes any ambiguity about whether the offer was genuine. Administrative law judges have subpoena authority and the process is simpler than it sounds.

0 coins

Never would have thought about subpoenaing the new employer - in my case I think I have enough documentation already but this is a genuinely useful tool to know about if ESD tries to question whether the offer was real.

0 coins

Retail job appeal stage here - I'd add that even without a subpoena, a simple signed letter from the new employer's HR confirming the position was eliminated carries real weight. Some employers will provide that voluntarily if you explain the unemployment situation.

0 coins

Exactly - the subpoena option exists if they won't cooperate voluntarily, but many employers will just write a brief statement because they know the rescission wasn't your fault either.

0 coins

My claim got stuck at the identity verification stage for two weeks before I even got to adjudication so I've been in this system longer than most. I went through an OAH appeal for a different reason and won, and the single most useful thing I did in prep was get an ESD agent on the phone to walk through what was actually in my claim file before I wrote my appeal statement. I used Claimyr for that - the hold time problem is real and consistent, and that service just removes that obstacle. For a rescinded-offer case specifically, knowing whether ESD ever attempted to verify the new employer's existence changes your entire argument structure at the hearing.

0 coins

Manufacturing plant, appeal hearing in eight days - when the agent walked through your file did they tell you everything the adjudicator had written or just the determination summary?

0 coins

They read me the actual adjudicator notes, not just the determination letter. There was a line in my notes that said something the adjudicator assumed about my separation that was factually wrong - addressing that in my opening statement at the hearing made a real difference.

0 coins

Benefits work, week two of helping someone else with their claim - adjudicator notes being different from the determination letter is something a lot of claimants don't realize. The letter just states the conclusion. The notes show the reasoning, and that's where errors hide.

0 coins

Just passed the two-week mark after getting my disqualification and honestly your post made me feel less alone even though our situations aren't identical. I quit a hotel job for what seemed like a solid offer at a property management company and they rescinded it citing 'hiring freeze.' ESD denied me too and my denial letter is almost word for word what you described. I haven't filed my appeal yet because I keep second-guessing myself - like what if the judge decides the offer wasn't solid enough even though I have a signed letter and three confirming emails?

0 coins

Property management background here, appeal filed last week - file the appeal. Worst case you lose the appeal and you're in exactly the same position you're in now. Best case you win and get back-paid benefits for all the weeks you waited. The documentation you're describing sounds strong.

0 coins

My sister keeps telling me the same thing and I keep stalling - the second-guessing is real. Okay. Filing today.

0 coins

Three weeks post-disqualification myself - the anxiety about whether your evidence is 'enough' is totally normal but signed offer letter plus three confirming emails is genuinely solid. File it.

0 coins

Got my separation paperwork sorted out just this week so very new to all this - quick clarifying question. Everyone keeps saying 'appeal within 30 days' but does that 30 days run from the date on the letter or the date you received it? Mine sat in my spam folder for a few days before I noticed it.

0 coins

Closing out my appeal this week so very familiar with the timeline - ESD's official position is that the 30 days runs from the date on the determination notice, not the date you opened it. If your letter date was more than 25 days ago I'd file today rather than tomorrow. If you're genuinely outside the 30 days you can request a late-appeal exception and explain the spam folder situation with documentation but that's a harder path.

0 coins

Checking right now - letter is dated nine days ago so I have time. Thank you for the actual number, I couldn't find it clearly stated anywhere on the ESD website.

0 coins

Disqualification reversed last month and confirming the 30-day clock from the letter date is accurate and ESD does not give informal extensions. Treat that date like a hard deadline.

0 coins

Finished week seven and my hearing finally happened yesterday - wanted to drop back in this thread because OP's situation is close to what I went through. I won my OAH hearing on a rescinded-offer case. The administrative law judge explicitly said that leaving stable employment for a confirmed job offer that is then rescinded meets the 'good cause' standard under Washington law. The documentation that made the difference: the written offer with start date, one email from the new employer after the offer confirming logistics, and a written statement I got from the new employer's HR manager explaining the position was eliminated company-wide. That last piece was what the judge cited in her decision.

0 coins

Reading this right before my own hearing in four days - this is exactly what I needed to hear. I have all three of those things. Thank you for coming back to report.

0 coins

Just filed my appeal today partly because of this thread - hearing that someone actually won this specific fact pattern helps more than I can say.

0 coins

Come back and report your outcomes. These threads helped me when I was in week two wondering if I had any chance at all.

0 coins

Appeal filed a week ago and I'm in a similar rescinded-offer situation - the specific citation to the judge saying 'confirmed job offer that is then rescinded meets good cause' is exactly the kind of language I'm going to build my appeal statement around. Really appreciate you sharing.

0 coins

Washington Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure