Can I get unemployment if employer denies remote work after moving to a new city? Washington ESD question
Okay so here's my situation and I genuinely don't know what to do. I relocated from Seattle to Spokane back in February for family reasons - my mom had some health issues and I needed to be closer. My job at the time was fully remote, had been for almost two years, so I figured it was no big deal. I told my manager, HR seemed fine with it initially, everything was going smoothly. Then about six weeks after the move, HR comes back and says actually the company has a policy requiring employees to live within 50 miles of the Seattle office and since I'm now in Spokane I'm out of compliance. They gave me two options: relocate back or lose my position. I obviously can't just uproot everything again, especially with my mom's situation. So they terminated me. Now I've filed a claim with Washington ESD and it's sitting in adjudication. The adjudicator is apparently looking into whether I quit or was fired, since the circumstances are kind of murky. I didn't quit - I was terminated for not returning. But ESD might see the original move as me creating the situation that led to the termination. I have documentation showing the job was remote for two years, that I told HR about the move and they didn't object at first, and that I was let go rather than resigning. Has anyone been through something like this? Can I get unemployment if employer denies remote work after moving to a new city and then terminates you over a policy they never enforced before? I feel like I have a legitimate case but the adjudication process has me really anxious.
75 comments

Amara Adebayo
Wait, did they ever send you anything in writing saying remote work from Spokane was approved? That detail could make or break this whole thing honestly. The adjudicator is basically going to be asking who set the expectation - if HR verbally told you it was fine and then reversed course six weeks later, that works in your favor. The core question ESD looks at in a situation like this is whether the employee took a reasonable action based on what they were told. You moved, HR didn't stop you, six weeks passed. That silence matters. Under Washington ESD rules, when an employer terminates you for violating a policy they never actually enforced or communicated clearly, the misconduct standard is harder for them to prove. Misconduct has to be a deliberate disregard of the employer's known expectations - if they never made the expectation known, that argument falls apart. Make sure your adjudication response includes every date and every communication you had with HR about this.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorHonestly not in writing from HR - they said it verbally and I have some emails where I mentioned being in Spokane and they responded normally about work stuff, nothing about the policy. Would those count as implied approval?
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Hmm, not sure I fully agree that silence always equals approval in ESD's eyes - I think they look at the specific circumstances more than a general rule about silence. But the emails where they responded normally to work matters without raising the policy issue, those are genuinely useful as circumstantial evidence.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
Have you been able to actually talk to anyone at Washington ESD about where your adjudication stands? Because I know from painful experience that the online portal tells you almost nothing useful. I was in adjudication for weeks on a separation issue and the status page just said 'pending' the entire time with zero updates. What finally moved things for me was getting an actual agent on the phone. I used a service called Claimyr - you can find it at claimyr.com - and they got me connected to a live ESD agent when I'd been failing to get through on my own for days. There's a video showing how it works at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ. Once I actually spoke to someone they were able to tell me exactly what documentation the adjudicator needed and I got my claim resolved within a week of that call. With a complicated separation like yours involving a move and a policy dispute, talking to an actual human at ESD is way more valuable than waiting for a letter.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorEvery time I call I either get the busy signal recording or I get placed on hold for so long I eventually hang up. I'll look into that service - at this point I really need to know what the adjudicator is actually looking at.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Is that service legitimate? First time I'm hearing of it and I'm always wary of things that promise to get you through government phone lines faster.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Mansour
Yeah it's real, that's how I found it too - someone mentioned it on a thread like this and I was skeptical but it actually worked. Got connected to ESD same day.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Okay so the question you'd want to put to ESD directly is something like: does the reason for my termination count as misconduct under Washington state UI law, and if not, am I eligible even though the move contributed to the situation? Here's why that framing matters - ESD treats misconduct and voluntary quit as two completely different disqualification paths, and your situation touches both without cleanly fitting either. If the employer is claiming misconduct, they have to show you willfully violated a known rule. If ESD decides you effectively quit by moving, they'd look at whether the move was for compelling personal reasons. Your mom's health situation could actually qualify as a compelling reason for moving under Washington UI rules if you documented it. So you might have a path even on the voluntary quit angle - but you need to know which theory ESD is actually pursuing before you can respond to it properly.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorThat's really clarifying actually - I didn't realize there were two separate ways this could be analyzed. I've been focused entirely on the misconduct angle.
0 coins
StormChaser
Hmm, one thing I'd question slightly - is a parent's health situation clearly enough documented as a compelling reason or does it need to be a spouse or dependent? I thought the bar was higher for voluntary quits related to family matters.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Good catch - Washington ESD does look more favorably on immediate household members but a parent's serious illness has been accepted in past cases. It's not guaranteed but it's worth raising. The documentation matters a lot.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Does this mean the OP should bring up both angles in their adjudication response or just focus on one?
0 coins
Ava Williams
Wait, something about this whole situation that I keep thinking about - why did HR wait SIX WEEKS to enforce this policy? Like if there's a 50 mile radius rule that's supposedly a real company policy, wouldn't their system have flagged it immediately when you updated your address in payroll? That gap is really suspicious and I'd argue it in my response. Either the policy wasn't being actively enforced at all, which basically means it wasn't a real policy in practice, or someone only looked into it after the fact for a different reason. Either way that's worth raising.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorI've wondered the same thing. I did update my address in their HR portal when I moved and nothing happened for over a month.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
Not sure the reason for the delay matters as much as whether the policy was written down somewhere - ESD adjudicators tend to focus on whether a written policy existed and whether the employee knew about it, more than on when enforcement happened. Though the delay definitely helps the credibility argument.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
ugh I went through something kind of similar last year and it was a NIGHTMARE. Not exactly the same but I moved cities and my employer suddenly started caring about things they'd never cared about before and I ended up terminated. My adjudication took almost 8 weeks because there was a whole dispute about whether I quit or was fired. The thing that saved me was that I had kept every single email and I mean every single one. When ESD finally made their determination they sided with me because I had timestamps showing I never initiated any resignation conversation - the employer did all the initiating. Keep everything. Screenshot everything. Download your work emails if you can.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorEight weeks is terrifying to hear but I'm glad it worked out for you. I've been saving everything I can find.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
This is such good advice honestly. I lost a benefits dispute once partly because I relied on verbal conversations I couldn't prove happened. Paper trail wins every time with government agencies.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Exactly - and honestly even internal Slack messages or Teams chats if your company uses those. I included screenshots of chat conversations in my adjudication packet and I think they helped.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Okay a thing people might be confused about here - 'adjudication' doesn't mean you've been denied. I see people panic when they hear that word and I get it, it sounds ominous. It just means ESD is doing a deeper review because the separation circumstances aren't straightforward. For situations involving potential policy violations or moves, ESD almost always puts it in adjudication automatically. It doesn't mean they think you're at fault. The adjudicator will reach out or issue a questionnaire and you should respond as completely as possible, not just answer the minimum. More detail is almost always better than less when you're trying to show your side of a complicated separation.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorThat actually helps a lot to hear. I've been treating 'adjudication' like it basically means 'probably denied' in my head.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Hmm, I'd add one small caveat - while adjudication doesn't mean denial, the response you give to the adjudicator's questionnaire genuinely can determine the outcome, so the anxiety isn't completely misplaced. Worth treating that questionnaire as seriously as you'd treat a legal document.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Quick question first - did Washington ESD send you a questionnaire yet or are you still waiting for one? Because the process varies. Some people get a questionnaire within days of their claim going to adjudication, others wait weeks before hearing anything. If you haven't gotten one yet, the adjudicator likely hasn't started on your specific claim yet - there's apparently a significant queue right now. When you do get it, the question you should be thinking about framing your answer around is essentially: what did you reasonably understand your employment arrangement to be, and did you do anything to violate that understanding? Walk them through it chronologically. Date by date. Don't assume they know any context.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorI got a letter with a questionnaire about ten days ago and submitted my response last week. So now I'm just waiting for their determination.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Okay that's actually good - you're in the waiting phase after responding which is the most agonizing part but at least you've submitted your side. Usually you'd hear back within two to three weeks of submitting, though that timeline varies.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
While you're waiting it's worth trying to reach ESD to confirm they received your questionnaire response. The portal doesn't always update properly and I've heard of people whose faxed or mailed responses got lost. I had a claim issue where I was just sitting waiting and it turned out my response hadn't been associated with my file. When I was going through my own adjudication nightmare I found Claimyr at claimyr.com to be the only way I could actually confirm anything with a live agent - seriously spent days failing to get through on my own before that. There's a walkthrough video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ if you want to see what it's like before trying it.
0 coins
StormChaser
The 'policy never enforced' argument is actually pretty strong in Washington, just want to give you a bit more context on why. The question you'd want an ESD agent to answer for you is whether a termination based on a policy that was apparently waived by employer conduct can support a misconduct finding. And the reason that question matters is that Washington's UI statutes have been interpreted in a way where consistent employer behavior creates a kind of de facto modified policy. If your employer allowed you to work remotely from Spokane for six weeks, responded to your work product, paid you normally, and said nothing about a violation, they arguably waived enforcement of that specific provision for your situation. That's not guaranteed to win but it's a real argument and I've seen adjudicators accept it.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorI didn't know there was actual legal precedent for this kind of waiver argument. That's really encouraging.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Not sure I'd call it 'legal precedent' exactly since these are administrative determinations not court rulings, but the principle is sound - ESD adjudicators do look at employer behavior and not just the written policy text.
0 coins
StormChaser
Fair point, 'precedent' was loose language on my part. More accurate to say it's a recognized argument in Washington ESD adjudication determinations, which don't have the same binding precedent structure as court decisions.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
So my situation wasn't exactly the same but I want to share what I went through because I think it might help. I relocated for a family reason too and my employer initially seemed okay with it and then did a 180. What I didn't realize was how important it was to respond to ESD's questionnaire by being really specific about the timeline - not vague like 'HR seemed fine with it' but actual specifics like 'on March 14th I emailed Jane Smith at HR to notify her of my address change and she replied the same day about an unrelated work matter without raising any concerns.' The more specific and documentable your timeline, the harder it is for the employer's side to dispute it. Also - request your employer's response to ESD under public records if you can. You have a right to know what they told the adjudicator.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorWait I can actually request what the employer told ESD? I didn't know that was possible - how do I do that?
0 coins
Keisha Brown
You'd submit a public records request to Washington ESD specifically. It takes some time but you can get the employer's separation statement. It's useful especially if you're preparing an appeal because you can see exactly what claims they made.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
This is a good tip though I'd note the timing matters - requesting records during active adjudication might not get you the information fast enough to affect the initial determination. It's more useful if you end up needing to appeal.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Has anyone actually won a case like this where the move was the indirect cause of the termination? I'm genuinely curious because it feels like ESD could go either way and I don't want to give false hope or false doom here. The OP's situation seems legitimately complex.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
Yes - I've seen multiple threads where people won in similar circumstances. The key factor seems to be whether the employee was transparent about the move with the employer and whether the employer's response was immediate or delayed. Delayed enforcement typically helps the employee's case.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Also worth noting that even if the initial determination goes against the OP, the appeal process exists and frankly the appeal success rate for well-documented cases is higher than people expect. It's not over if the first decision is unfavorable.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
That's good to know actually - I think a lot of people give up after the first denial without realizing appeals are a real option.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Something else worth considering - when you file your weekly claims while adjudication is ongoing, make absolutely sure you're completing all your job search activities and logging them correctly. I know it feels weird to be doing job searches while waiting to find out if you even qualify, but if adjudication resolves in your favor and you haven't been filing weekly claims throughout, you won't be paid for those weeks retroactively in the same way. ESD expects you to continue filing weekly claims and meeting job search requirements during adjudication. Missing weeks or incomplete job search logs can create a whole new problem even after you win the adjudication.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorI have been filing weekly claims - should I be doing three job search activities per week or is it still the same requirement?
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Washington ESD currently requires three job search activities per week as the standard. Make sure you're documenting the employer name, contact method, date, and position applied for. The online system has a job search log built in but keep your own records too.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
This is such an underrated point. So many people get their adjudication resolved and then find out they have gaps in their weekly claims that complicate their back pay calculation. File every week no matter what.
0 coins
Paolo Esposito
Okay something practical for right now while you're in this waiting period - if you need to actually confirm the status of your adjudication or find out if the adjudicator has any additional questions, the phone is honestly the only reliable way to do it. I know everyone says this but actually getting through is a different story. I'd been trying for over a week on my own claim and finally used Claimyr - it's at claimyr.com and there's a demonstration video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ - and within a few hours I had an agent on the line who could actually look at my file. They told me there was a follow-up question from the adjudicator that had never been sent to me because of a contact info issue. If I hadn't called I would have just kept waiting and waiting for a determination that was sitting there waiting on me. Worth checking in given your timeline.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorThat's actually really worrying to think about - what if there's a follow-up sitting out there that I haven't seen? I'm going to try calling this week and check that service out if I can't get through on my own.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
This is a genuinely good practical tip, the contact info issue is more common than people think. Any time you have a pending adjudication you should be making sure ESD can reach you by whatever method they have on file.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Just want to flag something that might complicate this further - did you update your address with Washington ESD when you moved to Spokane? Because if ESD has your old Seattle address on file and they mailed something you haven't received, that could be affecting your adjudication timeline without you knowing it.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorOh good point - I did update my address in the ESD online portal when I filed my initial claim from Spokane so they should have the right address. But I'll double-check that it's correct.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Good - also check that your phone number and email are current. ESD can reach out through multiple channels and you want all of them pointing to you correctly.
0 coins
Ava Williams
This is a really underappreciated thing. I've seen so many people miss adjudication questionnaires because an old address was still on file. Such a simple thing that creates such a big mess.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Okay this is probably a dumb question but I'm going to ask it anyway - when the adjudicator makes their decision, does it go to the employer too? Like will the company know exactly what ESD decided and why? I'm wondering because the OP might have ongoing reasons to care about their relationship with this employer.
0 coins
StormChaser
Not a dumb question - yes, both parties to the separation get notified of the determination. The employer can also appeal if ESD determines the claimant is eligible, so it's not over even after a favorable initial determination if the employer decides to contest it.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorThat's good to know and also slightly stressful - though at this point I think the relationship is already pretty done regardless of how ESD rules.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Worth knowing too that employer appeals are relatively rare for individual claim amounts - large employers with lots of claims sometimes appeal as a matter of policy, but for a single claim they often don't bother. Not a guarantee, just the reality of how it usually plays out.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
How long has it been since you submitted your questionnaire response? I'm asking because two weeks is typically when you should start wondering and three weeks is when I'd start pushing to get an update.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorIt's been about nine days since I submitted. So not quite at the two-week mark yet but getting there.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
Okay you've got a little time then before it makes sense to start following up aggressively. Use that time to organize your documentation in case they come back with follow-up questions.
0 coins
Ava Williams
Can I ask - did your employer give you any written notice of termination that specifically cited the location policy? Because if the termination letter or email says 'terminated for violating remote work location policy' that's actually useful documentation for you, not against you. It confirms you were terminated, not that you quit, and it names a policy that ESD can then evaluate for whether proper notice was given.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorYes - they sent an email saying my employment was being ended due to 'failure to maintain required proximity to the Seattle office per company policy.' I have that saved.
0 coins
Ava Williams
That's genuinely good evidence. That email is essentially your employer confirming the termination and citing the specific policy. Pair that with evidence that the policy wasn't communicated to you before the move and you have a solid paper trail.
0 coins
Amara Adebayo
Agreed - that termination email is probably the single most important document in this whole situation. Make absolutely sure it's part of your adjudication submission if you haven't already included it.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
Something I'm curious about for my own knowledge - does it matter if the move was within Washington state versus out of state for how ESD handles this? Like is there any different treatment for someone who moved from Seattle to Spokane versus someone who moved to a different state entirely?
0 coins
StormChaser
For Washington ESD eligibility specifically the main thing that matters is whether you're able and available to work in Washington, not where within the state you are. Moving within Washington is basically a non-issue from an eligibility standpoint. Moving out of state is a different conversation.
0 coins
Sofia Gomez
Good distinction - and in this case the OP staying in Washington is actually helpful because there's no question about their ongoing eligibility to work and claim benefits in the state. The only issue is the separation circumstances, not their current location.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Something that might come up in the adjudicator's review that I haven't seen mentioned yet - they might look at whether the relocation created a situation where you were no longer able to perform the job even if the remote work issue had been resolved. Like if the job required occasional in-person presence that was now logistically impossible from Spokane. If that's the case you'd want to get ahead of that in your documentation by clarifying whether the position was truly 100% remote for all purposes or only most purposes.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorThe position was listed as fully remote when I was hired and there hadn't been a single in-person requirement in the two years I held it. I have my original offer letter that says remote.
0 coins
Connor O'Neill
Perfect - that offer letter is crucial. Keep it handy. It establishes the fundamental nature of the position from day one.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Yeah the original offer letter specifying remote status is basically the foundation of the whole argument. If the company hired you as remote and you stayed remote, the location policy enforcement has a lot less ground to stand on.
0 coins
LunarEclipse
Wanted to come back and add one more thing since this thread is so active - if the determination comes back against you, please don't just accept it. The appeal process through the Office of Administrative Hearings is genuinely worth pursuing for a case like this. You'd have a hearing with an administrative law judge and you can present your documentation directly. The employer has to show up and make their case too. A lot of initial adjudication denials get reversed on appeal, especially in complex separation cases like yours where the facts are nuanced. File the appeal within 30 days of the determination notice date no matter what.
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorThank you for this - I will absolutely appeal if the initial decision goes against me. I feel like I have a legitimate case and I'm not going to just walk away from it.
0 coins
Keisha Brown
This is the right attitude. The appeal is a full independent review, not just a rubber stamp on the adjudicator's decision. You can win on appeal even if the initial determination goes against you.
0 coins
Zainab Ibrahim
The 30-day deadline is really important and worth repeating. Missing that window can mean losing your right to appeal even if you have a strong case.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Just checking back - any update on your situation? Did you hear anything from ESD?
0 coins
PixelWarrior
AuthorNot yet - still waiting. It'll be two weeks tomorrow since I submitted my questionnaire response. Going to try calling ESD later this week to confirm everything was received and see if I can get any status update.
0 coins
Miguel Castro
Fingers crossed for you. This situation sounds like you have a genuinely solid case. Keep us posted.
0 coins
Dylan Evans
Hope it works out - come back and update the thread when you hear something. These kinds of resolved cases are helpful for people who come across this thread later in similar situations.
0 coins