Can I exclude one employer from unemployment application - Washington ESD question
Okay so I've been going back and forth on this for days and need someone to just tell me straight. I worked two jobs this past year - one at a distribution warehouse where I was laid off when they downsized their night shift crew, and another at a small catering company where I quit because the owner kept changing my schedule without notice and eventually cut my hours down to basically nothing. The catering situation is complicated and I know if Washington ESD looks at that separation, it's probably going to trigger some kind of review or disqualification issue. My main question is can I exclude one employer from unemployment application? Like can I just leave the catering job off entirely and only report the warehouse layoff? I want to make sure I'm not accidentally tanking my own claim by including something that looks bad, but I also don't know if leaving it out is worse. My weekly wages from both jobs combined were pretty significant so I'm worried about how the base year is going to calculate too. Has anyone actually navigated this kind of two-employer situation before?
74 comments

Joshua Wood
Claimyr actually helped me get through to a live Washington ESD agent when I was dealing with something similar - multiple employers, complicated separation. I'd been trying to call for over a week and couldn't get anyone. Used claimyr.com, watched their demo video at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ and within the same day I was actually talking to a rep who walked me through exactly how my two jobs would be treated on my claim. Worth looking into before you make any decisions about what to include or leave out, because an agent can tell you specifically how your catering situation would be evaluated.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorThe part about getting through same day - does that actually work consistently or did you just get lucky with timing?
0 coins
Justin Evans
seconded on claimyr, used it last spring when my adjudication dragged past 5 weeks, got through on the second try
0 coins
Emily Parker
How long does it usually take once you start the process? Asking because I need to reach ESD this week specifically.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Both jobs show up in Washington ESD's records whether you list them or not. Employers report wages to the state quarterly, so when ESD pulls your base year wage data they're going to see every employer who paid into the system on your behalf. Leaving one off doesn't make it disappear from their side - it just makes you look like you were trying to hide something, which is way worse than whatever happened with the catering company.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorThe quarterly wage reporting piece - so they would literally see the catering job even if I left it blank on my application?
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Tried to leave off a short stint at a restaurant once thinking it wouldn't matter, got a letter asking me to explain the gap in my employment history. Had to submit a whole written statement. Just list everything.
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
This is accurate. ESD cross-references wage records from every employer in your base year. There's no way around it.
0 coins
Zara Perez
yeah i learned this the hard way too, they always find out
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Quit situations get looked at differently depending on why you quit, not just that you quit. Spent three months fighting my own voluntary quit disqualification before I figured out that 'substantial change in working conditions' is actually a valid reason ESD accepts. Hours getting cut way down and schedule changes without notice - those fall under that category pretty commonly. Your catering situation might not be as damaging as you think if you document what actually changed.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether the hours being cut would count as substantial enough - like how much of a reduction are we talking for them to consider it valid?
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
My hours went from 32 a week down to 11 and ESD counted that as a material change. They ask for documentation though, like old schedules, texts from your manager, that kind of thing.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Same kind of thing happened to my cousin, she quit after they moved her from full time to like 2 days a week, ESD approved her claim no problem after she sent in her old pay stubs showing the difference
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
What messed me up initially was thinking the reason I left each job would be evaluated separately and the bad one would cancel out the good one. That's not how it works. The warehouse layoff is a qualifying separation - that's solid. The catering quit might result in a disqualification for those particular wages, but it doesn't necessarily blow up your whole claim. You could still be eligible based on the warehouse separation alone depending on how the wage calculations fall.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether my warehouse wages alone would be enough to meet the minimum threshold without the catering wages factored in - I honestly don't even know what the threshold is.
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Washington ESD requires at least 680 hours worked during your base year to qualify. If your warehouse job alone gets you there, you're in decent shape even if the catering wages get disqualified.
0 coins
Gavin King
wait hours not dollars? i thought it was based on how much you earned not how many hours
0 coins
Ezra Collins
Washington uses an hours-based system, not a dollar-based one like most other states. 680 hours minimum in your base year. The dollar amount affects your weekly benefit amount but not whether you qualify initially.
0 coins
Nathan Kim
Ran into a wall trying to get answers on this exact issue - two jobs, one clean layoff, one messy quit - and the ESD phone lines were useless for two straight weeks. Eventually someone on a different forum mentioned Claimyr and I figured I had nothing to lose. The site is claimyr.com and there's a video walkthrough at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ that shows how it works. Got connected to an actual ESD agent who explained that my quit from the second job would be evaluated independently and wouldn't automatically disqualify me from benefits based on the layoff. That one phone call answered everything I'd been agonizing over for weeks.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether they can actually explain how your specific employers get treated, or is it more just general information?
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
In my experience ESD agents on the phone can get pretty specific if you have your claim ID ready and they can pull up your file
0 coins
Lucas Turner
The agent I reached through Claimyr actually looked at my base year breakdown with me in real time and told me exactly which quarter had the most wages. Really useful for understanding your benefit amount calculation.
0 coins
Justin Evans
Filed with two employers last fall and both separations went through adjudication separately. The layoff cleared in about 10 days. The quit took another 3 weeks because they had to contact my former employer to verify my reason for leaving. Ended up getting approved for both, but even if I hadn't, the layoff benefits would've kicked in regardless. Just want to set realistic expectations - it takes longer with two separations.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorThree weeks for the quit adjudication - were you still getting any payments during that waiting period or was everything on hold?
0 coins
Justin Evans
The layoff portion processed normally. Only the wages tied to the quit were in limbo. So yes, partial payments came through while the second part was still being reviewed.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
That's good to know actually, I assumed it was all or nothing
0 coins
Anna Stewart
same, didn't realize they could process them separately like that
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Something nobody mentioned yet - even if ESD disqualifies you for the quit, it only disqualifies you for a specific number of weeks, not permanently. After that penalty period runs out you can still collect benefits. So worst case scenario with the catering job is a temporary delay, not a complete denial.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorHow many weeks does the penalty period typically run for a voluntary quit without good cause?
0 coins
Victoria Scott
Usually five to ten weeks depending on the circumstances. After that the disqualification lifts automatically.
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Mine was 7 weeks for a quit, though I've heard it varies. ESD should send you a determination letter that tells you the exact number.
0 coins
Emily Parker
My sister just went through almost this exact scenario, two jobs, one layoff one quit. She spent a week panicking about the quit before actually calling ESD. Turns out her quit qualified under the good cause provision because her commute had doubled when the company relocated. She would've left the job off the application entirely if I hadn't stopped her. Definitely list everything.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorThe good cause provision seems broader than I thought - I was assuming it was only for like unsafe working conditions or discrimination
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Good cause covers a lot more than people realize. Health and safety issues, yes, but also schedule changes, pay cuts, relocation of the workplace, reduction in hours, hostile work environment - ESD evaluates each situation individually.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
I had no idea about the relocation one, definitely gonna remember that
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
Something worth knowing about how the base year works: Washington ESD looks at the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters. If you were working at the catering company mostly in an earlier quarter and the warehouse was more recent, the wage weights might look different than you're expecting. Worth checking esd.wa.gov to see your actual base year window before making assumptions about how much each employer contributes.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether there's a tool on the ESD website that actually shows your wage breakdown by employer and quarter, or is that something you only see after you file?
0 coins
Benjamin Johnson
After you file and log into your account you can see your base year wage summary. Before filing, you'd need to contact ESD or look at your own pay stubs and W-2s to estimate it.
0 coins
Zara Perez
Yeah the wage breakdown section in the portal is actually pretty clear once your claim is active, way easier to read than I expected
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Got burned by a similar assumption early on. Filed and left off a part-time job thinking it was too small to matter. ESD sent me a request for information letter two weeks later asking about wages from that employer. Had to explain the whole thing in writing, which delayed my claim by almost a month. The delay alone wasn't worth trying to simplify things upfront.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether the request for information letter is the same thing as going into adjudication or is that a separate process?
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Different things. The letter was just asking for clarification about wages. Adjudication is when they're actually investigating whether your separation qualifies. I eventually hit adjudication too but that was about the separation reason, not the wages.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Good distinction. A lot of people think any delay means adjudication but ESD sends various types of letters for different reasons.
0 coins
Ella Russell
Just to reinforce what others said - Washington ESD uses a system where they already have your wage records from every employer that paid state unemployment taxes. When you apply, you're not telling them about employers they don't know about, you're confirming what they already have. Trying to omit one is like crossing out a line on a document they already have a copy of.
0 coins
Kai Rivera
That's a really useful way to frame it, never thought about it that way
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorOkay this actually makes it crystal clear, I was operating under the wrong mental model entirely
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Before I found Claimyr I genuinely considered not listing my second employer for the same reason you're describing. Spent probably four hours trying to get through to ESD by phone before someone pointed me to claimyr.com - there's a demo at https://youtu.be/7DieNd3C7zQ. The agent I finally reached confirmed that omitting an employer from your application can be treated as misrepresentation, which carries way heavier penalties than whatever issue you're trying to avoid. Just not worth it. List everything and let ESD evaluate the separations properly.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorMisrepresentation penalties - is that something that could actually result in having to repay benefits or is it more like a warning?
0 coins
Kaylee Cook
Overpayment plus penalties plus potential fraud classification. It escalates fast. The evaluation of a messy quit is way less bad than a misrepresentation finding.
0 coins
Morgan Washington
Yeah fraud findings can get referred to the attorney general office, I know someone who had to deal with that, it was a whole nightmare
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Applied with three employers once - layoff, end of contract, and a part-time job I still had. The still-working situation complicated things but ESD handled it. The point is they're set up to deal with multi-employer situations, it's not unusual for them and the system accounts for it.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorStill working at one job while claiming based on another - I didn't even realize that was possible
0 coins
Eleanor Foster
Partial employment is a whole thing. You report earnings each week and they adjust your benefit amount accordingly. Worth reading up on if you end up with any part-time work while claiming.
0 coins
Gavin King
wait so you can work part time and still collect? genuinely didn't know that
0 coins
Layla Sanders
The documentation thing is worth preparing for regardless. Collected every text, email, and scheduling screenshot from the catering job before I filed my claim for a similar situation. Having that ready meant when ESD contacted my former employer and they disputed my reason for leaving, I already had evidence to upload. Made the adjudication go way smoother.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether you upload that documentation proactively when you file or do you wait until ESD asks for it?
0 coins
Layla Sanders
Waited until they asked, which was through a secure message in my ESD account. But having it organized beforehand meant I could respond within a day instead of scrambling.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
Proactive upload is also an option in some cases. When you file you can add notes and sometimes attach documentation depending on the separation type. If your situation is complicated enough, getting it in front of them early can't hurt.
0 coins
Anna Stewart
just wanna say reading this thread was incredibly helpful, been lurking here for two days trying to figure out my own two-job situation and this answered like every question I had
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorGlad it's useful - when I posted I honestly just expected one or two responses, not this whole breakdown. Good luck with your claim.
0 coins
Justin Evans
This sub is genuinely good for pre-claim research, way better than trying to parse the ESD website
0 coins
Aaliyah Reed
Real talk the ESD website has gotten better but their FAQ section still doesn't cover these multi-employer edge cases very well
0 coins
Morgan Washington
One thing I want to flag that I don't think anyone mentioned: the reason you give for leaving the catering job on your application should match what you tell ESD if they contact you later. Whatever you write initially becomes part of the record. So take your time writing the separation reason clearly - 'reduction in hours and unilateral schedule changes' is more specific and defensible than just 'quit' or 'left voluntarily.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorWhether there's a character limit on the separation reason field or can you write a full explanation?
0 coins
Morgan Washington
There's a text box that allows for a decent amount of text. Use it. The more context you give, the better your starting position before adjudication even begins.
0 coins
Emily Parker
My sister's advocate told her the same thing. First written record sets the tone for the whole review.
0 coins
Zara Perez
For what it's worth my claim with two separations took about six weeks total to fully resolve. Got partial benefits during that time based on the clean separation. By week seven everything was sorted and my full weekly amount was confirmed. It's slow but it does move forward eventually.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorSix weeks is longer than I was hoping but honestly knowing that there's an end point helps a lot
0 coins
Kai Rivera
Yeah the uncertainty is the worst part, knowing a rough timeline at least lets you plan
0 coins
Gavin King
six weeks feels long when you have bills lol but good to know it resolves
0 coins
Lucas Turner
Claimyr actually got me connected to ESD on a day when I'd already tried calling four times and been disconnected. The agent walked me through what they call a 'combined wage' situation, which is basically what you have. They confirmed both employers would be listed in my base year calculation and my separations would be reviewed individually. Total call time was maybe 25 minutes and I had actual answers instead of just anxiety. The site is claimyr.com if you haven't used it yet.
0 coins
Madison Allen
AuthorCombined wage situation - is that a specific ESD term or just how the agent described it?
0 coins
Lucas Turner
That's what the agent called it. It's the standard situation of having multiple employers within your base year period contributing to your overall wage calculation.
0 coins
Mohammed Khan
Yeah ESD agents tend to use that phrasing. Worth knowing for when you call so you can confirm that's what they're looking at for your claim.
0 coins