Back to USCIS

Mateo Hernandez

I-765 C09 EAD approved but card not produced after a year — what to do

So my I-765 was filed under category C09 (pending I-485) and got approved about a year ago. The online account showed 'card was produced' for maybe two or three days and then flipped back to 'approved' — no card in the mail, no tracking number ever appeared, nothing. I've been waiting and refreshing and nothing has changed in almost twelve months since the approval. Has anyone dealt with this where the EAD got approved but then the card production notice just vanished? Do I need to file a whole new I-765 or is there a way to get them to reissue without starting over?

The status flipping from 'card was produced' back to 'approved' is a known headache. What that usually means is the card came off the production line and then got flagged before it was mailed — could be a data mismatch, could be something else. Either way, at the point where it's been this long with no tracking number showing in your account, the path forward is a case inquiry through USCIS's site, specifically the option for not receiving your card by mail. That opens a formal inquiry without you having to refile. A new I-765 is a last resort and also means paying a new filing fee, so try the inquiry route first.

0 coins

Agreed that the inquiry is the first move. After the inquiry USCIS may attempt a second delivery or they determine the card needs to be reissued — in which case a new I-765 is generally what's required. Keep the inquiry reference number from whatever confirmation you get.

0 coins

Okay filing the case inquiry now. The option that fits is definitely 'did not receive card by mail' since the tracking number never actually appeared. I'll post back with whatever response I get.

0 coins

A year is a genuinely long time for this. I had the same flip on my EAD — 'card was produced' then back to 'approved' — but mine resolved in about six weeks after the inquiry. A year with no movement at all sounds like the card may have been lost before it ever shipped.

0 coins

Worth knowing before you file that inquiry: the tracking number for a card shows up in the USCIS online account when the card is actually mailed, not when it's produced. Production and mailing are two separate steps. If production showed briefly and then disappeared from the status, it's very possible the card was pulled before USCIS ever handed it to the postal service, which is why there's no tracking number at all. The inquiry should ask USCIS to look into whether the card was ever actually mailed.

0 coins

I didn't know production and mailing were separate steps — I assumed 'card was produced' meant it was already on its way. Good to know that for my own I-90 situation where I'm waiting on a replacement card.

0 coins

That explains a lot actually. The tracking number genuinely never appeared at any point, so the card probably never left the facility. The inquiry is definitely the right move then.

0 coins

USCIS's cards go by USPS Priority Mail with delivery confirmation, so if the tracking number never showed in the account, the card almost certainly wasn't handed off to the postal service at all. The inquiry is your documentation that you reported the non-delivery.

0 coins

November of last year my account showed 'card was mailed' on my EAD and then went quiet — no tracking, no card. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at the Contact Center on the phone without sitting through the automated menus. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at USCIS: https://youtu.be/eSz742AOvHc. The representative pulled up my case and told me the last notice on file was an approval notice dated the prior September, and that no mailing date had been recorded for the card at all. She opened an inquiry on the spot and gave me a reference number. Within about three weeks I had a tracking number showing in my account.

0 coins

Three weeks after the inquiry is way faster than I expected. I'll try the online inquiry first and if nothing moves I'll give that a shot to get someone on the phone who can actually open something on the spot.

0 coins

The automated system sent me to Case Status Online every time I tried to ask about my card situation, which told me nothing I didn't already know. Getting a live person who can actually open an inquiry on the call is a different level of useful.

0 coins

Had the same experience with the automated system just reading back the status I could already see. Phoning in and pressing for a live representative was the only way I got any actual information about where my card was.

0 coins

I want to correct something that gets said a lot in threads like this: a lot of people think that when the status goes back to 'approved' after showing 'card was produced,' it means the application got un-approved or went back into review. It doesn't. The underlying approval is still there. The status flip is specific to the card production workflow, not the adjudication. Your C09 EAD is still approved; it just means the physical card had a production problem before mailing.

0 coins

I had convinced myself my EAD was going to get denied after the status flip and was panicking for two weeks before someone explained this to me. The approval itself doesn't change.

0 coins

Genuinely relieved to hear that. I was starting to wonder if something had gone wrong with the underlying I-485 and that was why the EAD card never materialized.

0 coins

The I-485 and the I-765 are separate applications even when filed together. An issue with the EAD card production doesn't touch the I-485 at all. They're tracked under different receipt numbers.

0 coins

When I filed my own case inquiry for a missing EAD card, the confirmation email came within a couple of days but the actual response from USCIS took about a month. If you don't hear anything after 30 days, go back through the Contact Center or Emma — the chat on USCIS's site — and reference the inquiry you already opened. Having that reference number makes it much easier for a Tier 1 representative to pull up what was done on the case.

0 coins

The reference number thing is real. First time I phoned without one the representative couldn't find anything. Second time I had the reference number and they located the inquiry in about 30 seconds.

0 coins

Keeping the reference number somewhere I'll actually find it in a month. Good advice.

0 coins

A friend of mine kept refreshing Case Status Online for months waiting for her EAD tracking to appear and nothing changed. Eventually she went through Emma and a live chat agent was able to tell her the card had been returned to USCIS by the postal service because the address on file was slightly off — an apartment number transposed. If you moved or if there's any chance your address in the USCIS online account isn't exactly right, check that before the inquiry goes in. USCIS doesn't forward mail and the postal service doesn't forward USCIS cards either.

0 coins

Address issues cause more missing card problems than people realize. Checking the address in the online account should honestly be the first step before anything else.

0 coins

Address in my account is correct — I double checked when the tracking never appeared. But this is a good thing for anyone else reading to verify before filing an inquiry.

0 coins

Apartment numbers and unit designations are the most common culprit. USCIS mailing labels are generated from exactly what's in the system, so even a missing 'APT' versus '#' can cause a return.

0 coins

While you're waiting on the EAD inquiry to resolve, check whether your I-485 has biometrics or an interview scheduled. If your I-765 was filed concurrently with the I-485 under C09, the EAD reissuance shouldn't require a new biometrics appointment — but you'd want to make sure nothing else on the underlying I-485 is sitting unattended while the card situation gets sorted.

0 coins

Good point. The EAD card issue and the I-485 moving forward are independent. I let a biometrics notice sit too long once because I was focused on something else and it caused a whole separate headache.

0 coins

Checked the I-485 side of things — biometrics were done a while ago. The I-485 itself is still pending but no RFE or anything concerning. So the EAD card is the only outstanding issue right now.

0 coins

Worth sharing — a biometrics appointment I had for a related application got cancelled with no notice in the mail. After Emma kept looping me back to Case Status Online I tried Claimyr to reach the Contact Center. The representative found the appointment had been rescheduled in the system to a different ASC and rescheduled it again to one closer to me on that same call, with a reference number. Having the receipt number ready made the whole thing go faster.

0 coins

Cancelled appointments with no notice are genuinely the worst because you don't know if you missed something or if USCIS just quietly moved it. Getting a live person to look at the actual appointment record on the case is the only real way to find out what happened.

0 coins

The ASC on the rescheduled appointment not matching the original one is something I didn't know was possible. Good to know a representative can sort that out on the call.

0 coins

My I-765 C09 EAD was in a similar limbo — approved, card produced showing briefly, then gone. Filed the case inquiry and nothing moved for six weeks. I eventually phoned the Contact Center and the Tier 1 representative told me that since the card had never actually been mailed, they were sending the issue to a Tier 2 officer, and that I'd receive a message in my USCIS online account with next steps. The message came about two weeks after that call, confirming a reissuance was initiated without me having to file a new I-765.

0 coins

Reissuance without a new I-765 is exactly what you'd want in this situation. Good to know Tier 2 can initiate that when the card never shipped to begin with.

0 coins

This is very encouraging. If the inquiry doesn't resolve it, knowing that Tier 2 can initiate reissuance without a whole new filing is a huge relief. Did the account update when the reissuance started or did you only find out through the message?

0 coins

The message in the online account came first, then the status updated to 'card was produced' again a few days later and this time a tracking number appeared. The whole sequence finally worked the second time.

0 coins

So the original approval was never in jeopardy, the card just had to go through production again. That's actually reassuring for anyone in this situation.

0 coins

USCIS IS A NIGHTMARE FOR THIS. I had my EAD card bounce through 'produced' three times before it actually shipped. Each time the status flipped back and I had to open another inquiry. Three inquiries total over eight months. The Contact Center rep on the third call was the first one who actually escalated it to Tier 2 instead of just logging another ticket. That Tier 2 escalation was what finally got the card out the door. If your first inquiry doesn't move things, ask explicitly for Tier 2 escalation on your next call.

0 coins

Eight months and three inquiries is an extreme case but the advice about asking for Tier 2 escalation is real. Tier 1 can open inquiries, but Tier 2 officers can actually act on a case in certain situations. If the first inquiry produces nothing, naming Tier 2 specifically on the next call is worth doing.

0 coins

The difference between Tier 1 logging a note and Tier 2 actually doing something on the production end is significant. First two calls I ever made to the Contact Center didn't go anywhere because I didn't know to ask for escalation.

0 coins

There's something I used to believe that turned out to be wrong: I thought the USPS missing mail process would apply to USCIS cards the same way it applies to regular packages. It doesn't — if the card never shipped, there's nothing to trace with USPS. The only path is through USCIS directly. USPS's missing mail steps are only relevant when the tracking number shows the card as delivered but it never showed up physically. When there's no tracking number at all, the whole thing stays within USCIS's inquiry system.

0 coins

Went through the USPS missing mail process for my EAD and got nowhere, then found out the tracking number had never appeared in my account either. The USPS process only works if there's a tracking number to look up — the postal service has no record of a package that was never handed to them.

0 coins

Worth repeating clearly: no tracking number means the card never left USCIS. USPS can't help in that case. The inquiry with USCIS is the only starting point.

0 coins

I'd been considering going to USPS too, so glad I saw this before wasting time there. No tracking number means I should stay entirely within the USCIS inquiry process.

0 coins

Filed an inquiry for my EAD card that showed produced-then-nothing, got a canned response after three weeks saying they'd look into it. Waited another month, nothing. Filed a second inquiry. Got the same canned response again. It wasn't until I went through the Contact Center and had a live person actually read the notes on the case that anything happened. The representative saw there was a production error flag on the card and sent the case to Tier 2. Sometimes the inquiry system just loops and you have to get a person on the phone to break the cycle.

0 coins

Two canned responses with nothing changing is exactly what happened to me too. The inquiry system is good for documenting that you reported the issue but it doesn't always move anything. A live representative who can read actual case notes is what changes things.

0 coins

How long from the Tier 2 escalation to seeing the tracking number in your account? Just trying to gauge timelines for my own similar situation.

0 coins

About three weeks from the escalation call to the tracking number appearing. The reissuance itself happened faster than the original production, which I thought was interesting.

0 coins

For anyone who's already filed the inquiry and gotten a response saying they're looking into it — the response in your USCIS online account is what to watch, not just your email. USCIS may send the follow-up only through the account message center and not by email, so if you're checking your inbox and seeing nothing, log into the account directly and check the messages there.

0 coins

Missed a message from USCIS for two weeks because I was only checking email. The account message center had a request for additional information that I didn't see until I logged in directly.

0 coins

Didn't realize messages might come only in the account without an email notification. Checking the account message center now — nothing yet, but I'll make a habit of logging in regularly.

0 coins

About eight months after my EAD showed 'approved' with no tracking number appearing, I tried Claimyr to reach a live representative at the Contact Center. The rep looked at the card record and confirmed a mailing date had been assigned but no handoff to USPS had ever been recorded — meaning the card sat in limbo at the production stage. She noted the mailing date discrepancy and I got a secure message in my account the following week saying a new card had been initiated.

0 coins

A mailing date in the system with no actual postal handoff is a strange inconsistency. At least the representative was able to see that discrepancy and document it.

0 coins

This is reassuring — the representative being able to see those production records directly is what I need. If the online inquiry doesn't produce results in a reasonable time I'll try to get someone on the phone who can read the actual card record.

0 coins

People sometimes get the C09 category mixed up and think it means they filed their EAD separately from the I-485. C09 specifically means the EAD is based on a pending adjustment of status under INA 245 — in other words, it's because the I-485 itself is pending. It's not a standalone category. I mention this because if you're ever in a situation where the I-485 itself gets denied, the C09 EAD basis goes away too. Not relevant to the card production issue, but worth understanding the connection.

0 coins

The dependency on the I-485 is real. As long as the I-485 is pending, the C09 basis is valid and the EAD should be reissued without question. The card production failure doesn't affect eligibility at all.

0 coins

Had someone in another thread convinced that C09 was just a generic pending category and not tied to the I-485. Knowing the specific statutory basis actually matters if anything about the underlying adjustment changes.

0 coins

Went through almost exactly this situation last year — EAD approved, card produced showed for about four days, then disappeared, no tracking. Filed inquiry, got canned response, filed second inquiry, got same canned response. Eventually the Contact Center representative told me USCIS would send written instructions through the online account. Two weeks later there was a message in the account with a reference number for a reissuance. Card arrived about a month after that. Total time from first inquiry to card in hand was close to five months.

0 coins

Five months is a long time but at least it resolved without a new I-765. The reissuance path is definitely better than starting over with a new filing and a new fee.

0 coins

Five months is painful but this is the clearest timeline I've seen in this thread. I'm going to file the inquiry today and document every step in case I need to escalate later.

0 coins

There's another scenario worth mentioning: if the card was produced but the name or date of birth on it was wrong — which does happen — USCIS pulls it before mailing and that causes the status flip. If that's what happened on your case, it's technically a typographical error and USCIS is supposed to correct it without requiring a new I-765 or a new fee. But you'd only find out it was an error if you get a live person who can read the production record. I had a wrong middle name on a card I never received and that turned out to be exactly what had happened.

0 coins

A typo on the card causing the production to get pulled before mailing — I never would have guessed that was a possibility. The status flip actually makes more sense in that context.

0 coins

After about six months of inquiry emails going nowhere, I tried Claimyr to reach the Contact Center. The representative found the typographical error on the card record — my middle name had been transposed — and reported it on the call. I got a message in my online account about two weeks later confirming the corrected card was being produced.

0 coins

Now I'm wondering if a typo is exactly what happened on mine. The status flip is consistent with that. I'll ask specifically about the card record when I get someone on the phone.

0 coins

One thing that helped me keep track of everything during my own EAD card saga: I kept a simple document with the date of every status change, every inquiry filed, every reference number, and every phone call. When I finally got a live representative who could help, being able to say 'the status changed on this date, I filed an inquiry on this date, got a response on this date' made the conversation much more productive than trying to remember it all.

0 coins

The date log idea is genuinely useful. Representatives at the Contact Center can see the case history but having your own log means you can fill in gaps and confirm things aren't being confused with someone else's case.

0 coins

Starting the log today. Got the receipt numbers for both the I-765 and the I-485, the dates of the status changes, and I'll add every inquiry from here on. Good call.

0 coins

Having the receipt number and the dates of status changes ready when you call makes a noticeable difference in how quickly the representative can find what they need.

0 coins

My EAD card took forever and I kept second-guessing whether I should just file a new I-765 to get it over with. What stopped me was realizing a new filing means a new fee and a new processing clock, while reissuance through the inquiry process keeps the original approval in place. The reissuance route is almost always the right call when the card never arrived after approval.

0 coins

The new filing fee and starting the clock over are real costs. If the approval exists and the issue is only with the physical card, reissuance is the path to stay on. USCIS's own inquiry system is built for exactly this.

0 coins

This was my concern too — that filing a new I-765 would mean I-485 isn't pending anymore or something complicated. But if the original approval stands and reissuance is on the table, that's the route I'm taking.

0 coins

The I-485 being pending is actually what keeps the C09 basis active for reissuance. As long as the I-485 hasn't been decided, USCIS can reissue the EAD under the same basis. If the I-485 gets approved while the EAD reissuance is in process, you'd be a permanent resident and the EAD wouldn't matter anymore anyway. And if the I-485 gets denied — which hopefully doesn't apply — that's when the C09 basis would disappear.

0 coins

If the I-485 gets approved mid-reissuance, the EAD becomes moot — that's a scenario most people in this situation would happily take. Permanent residence makes the work permit irrelevant.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about the I-485 approval making the EAD irrelevant. In an ideal world the I-485 gets approved while USCIS is still figuring out the card and the EAD question resolves itself.

0 coins

At this point if the I-485 gets approved I'd be thrilled about the EAD being irrelevant. For now though the EAD is what I'm working with and I need it to actually exist as a physical card.

0 coins

After reading through all of this, the sequence seems pretty clear: file the case inquiry first, wait about 30 days for a substantive response in the USCIS online account message center, escalate to the Contact Center with a live representative if nothing moves, ask the representative about the card production record specifically and whether there's any error or flag on it, and push for Tier 2 escalation if the representative can only log a ticket rather than act on the case. Hopefully the original poster gets a resolution faster than some of the timelines in this thread.

0 coins

That sequence is accurate and matches what worked for most people in this thread. The key is not stopping after the first inquiry if it doesn't move anything — the escalation path is what actually breaks the logjam.

0 coins

Inquiry filed about an hour ago. Receipt number saved, date logged, case inquiry reference number copied down. I'll post an update when I hear something — whether that's a tracking number, a reissuance message, or a need to escalate further.

0 coins

Related posts

USCIS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure