Back to USCIS

StarGazer101

I-485 family based pending 3 years after second medical RFE should I contact congressman — where do I even start

We're at three years on my wife's I-485, family based through her parent who is a U.S. citizen. The case has been sitting at the field office for what feels like forever. About eight months ago we got a request for evidence asking for an updated medical exam — the first one had expired. We sent in a full I-693 from a civil surgeon along with every other supporting document on the list. Then four months later, a second RFE, this time asking for specific vaccination records that the civil surgeon had flagged as incomplete on the first submission. We responded to that one too, about six weeks ago. Now the case status online hasn't moved at all. No interview notice, no approval, nothing. Someone at my wife's job mentioned that people in long-pending situations contact their congressional representative's office to ask for a case status update. Is that actually something that helps? And separately — are we supposed to be doing anything else right now, or just waiting? I genuinely don't know if three years with two medical RFEs on a family based I-485 is unusual or if this is just how it goes.

Last notice on our case was dated four months before we finally got any movement, and I had no idea what had actually been received on the USCIS side until I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the phone. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at USCIS: https://youtu.be/eSz742AOvHc. The representative pulled up the case and confirmed the exact date the last notice had been generated and which office was holding it — that alone told us the case hadn't been lost, it was just sitting in queue at the field office. For your situation, the representative could tell you whether the response to that second medical RFE was actually logged as received and what the most recent notice on file is. That's the first thing I'd want to know before doing anything else.

0 coins

Did the representative say anything about whether the field office had flagged the RFE response or just that it was received? Asking because we're in a similar spot and I keep wondering if 'received' means someone actually looked at it.

0 coins

The representative on our case confirmed receipt and the date it was logged — she didn't go into what happened after that, which makes sense, the actual review is the officer's job. But knowing it was logged was enough to stop us from filing a duplicate.

0 coins

Honestly this is the most useful thing in this thread. Knowing your response was actually received vs. just mailed is a huge difference when you're staring at a status page that hasn't changed.

0 coins

Two medical RFEs on one I-485 is frustrating but not unheard of. The civil surgeon's I-693 has an expiration window, and if the first one aged out before the officer reviewed it, they'd ask for a new one. The second RFE about vaccinations is a separate issue — that's usually because the civil surgeon's initial submission left something blank or the documentation for a specific vaccine wasn't there. As long as you responded to both before the deadline printed on each notice, the case is still active and the officer is supposed to have everything they need now. The processing times page on USCIS's site is worth checking for your specific form and field office to get a rough sense of where things stand, but I wouldn't read too much into the case status not updating after six weeks — that page can be slow to reflect anything.

0 coins

Is there anything on the processing times page that shows specifically how long medical RFE responses take to get reviewed, or is it just a general number for the whole I-485?

0 coins

Just a general number for the I-485 from that field office — it doesn't break out RFE processing separately. It gives you a range, and if your receipt date is well outside that range, that's when USCIS says you can submit a case inquiry.

0 coins

Worth double-checking whether your receipt date actually falls outside the posted range before you try anything. Some people submit inquiries too early and just get an automated response saying the case is within normal processing.

0 coins

Contacting your congressional representative is a real option — their constituent services office sends what's called a congressional inquiry to USCIS on your behalf. I did it when our case crossed the two-year mark with no movement. What happened was the representative's office faxed an inquiry, USCIS acknowledged it, and then about six weeks later we got an interview notice. I can't say the inquiry caused the interview, but the timing was what it was. It costs nothing, takes maybe an hour to fill out the form on the representative's site, and doesn't hurt your case in any way.

0 coins

Did the congressional office ask you for anything specific to submit the inquiry, like the receipt number or a copy of the receipt notice?

0 coins

They wanted the receipt number, the applicant's full name, date of birth, and a brief description of the situation. Some offices have an online form, others ask you to email a caseworker. Worth looking at your representative's website to see which.

0 coins

We did the same thing — constituent services at our senator's office sent the inquiry. We got a letter back from USCIS within about a month saying the case was under review. Not an approval, just an acknowledgment, but it felt like something actually moved.

0 coins

Is there any risk of doing both a congressional inquiry AND a case inquiry through USCIS at the same time, or do you have to pick one?

0 coins

Three years on a family based I-485 after two medical RFEs — have you checked whether the case is outside the posted processing time for your field office yet? Because that threshold matters. USCIS's own site says a case inquiry is appropriate once you're past the posted time for your form and office. If you're outside that window, you can submit what USCIS calls an e-Request directly on their site, without calling. It's specifically designed for situations where a case has gone past the normal range. The inquiry goes to the field office and they're supposed to respond. It's a quieter step than a congressional inquiry and sometimes that's the right first move.

0 coins

Where does the e-Request show up — in the USCIS online account or is it a separate thing on USCIS's site?

0 coins

It's a separate case inquiry tool on USCIS's site, not inside the online account itself. You put in the receipt number and select the reason — 'case outside normal processing time' is one of the options.

0 coins

Had no idea that option existed. We spent two months trying to get through on the phone before someone told us about the e-Request.

0 coins

Wait — are both RFE responses definitely showing as received in your USCIS online account? Because on our I-485 we responded to an RFE by mail and the online account showed 'response received' within about two weeks. If your account still shows just 'response requested' or something like that, it might mean the second response hasn't been logged yet, which would be a different kind of problem than a slow review.

0 coins

Checked the online account just now and it does show the response was received. The status update happened about three weeks after we mailed the response. So at least that part seems fine.

0 coins

Okay that's actually a relief — the case is live and they have everything. At that point it really is a waiting game unless you're outside the posted processing time, which is when you have more options.

0 coins

Same thing happened to us — the account updated about three weeks after mailing. The delay between mailing and the account update had me convinced it was lost.

0 coins

Depending on how your wife's I-485 was filed, is she currently working? If the EAD tied to the I-485 is about to expire, that's a whole separate thing to watch. The I-765 renewal should be filed at least 90 days before the current EAD expires. Some people get so focused on the main case that the work authorization piece slips. Just flagging it since you mentioned three years — that's at least one renewal cycle if she started working on the initial EAD.

0 coins

Good point and yes, we did renew the EAD last year. That part we had covered. The I-485 itself is the one with no movement.

0 coins

Good to hear. As long as the EAD is current and the advance parole is in order if she travels, the pending I-485 doesn't disrupt day-to-day life at least. Stressful to be waiting this long though.

0 coins

The EAD thing is real — we almost let ours expire because we were so focused on trying to get updates on the main case. Set a reminder 90 days out from whatever the expiration date is.

0 coins

I know someone who went through three medical RFEs — different field office, different family situation — and what their attorney told them was that multiple medical RFEs in a row usually mean the civil surgeon's paperwork has a recurring issue. After the third one they switched civil surgeons and the new I-693 sailed through. I'm not saying yours has that problem, but if a third RFE comes back for another medical issue, it might be worth having an immigration attorney look at the I-693 submissions before responding again.

0 coins

The civil surgeon point is worth taking seriously. The I-693 is only valid for a specific window and there are USCIS-designated civil surgeons whose forms tend to be more complete. Not all civil surgeons file these regularly, and an officer can tell pretty quickly if the form has gaps.

0 coins

We used a different civil surgeon for the second I-693 after the first RFE, so hopefully that helped. The second one actually walked through each vaccination line item with us before submitting to make sure nothing was blank.

0 coins

Switching civil surgeons after the first RFE was the right call. That second I-693 being thorough is a good sign — hopefully no third ask.

0 coins

Appointment at our local ASC had to be moved because of a work conflict — the online account let me reschedule once but the second time I tried, it said I couldn't do it online anymore. Ended up reaching a live person at the Contact Center through Claimyr and the representative rescheduled it on the call and gave me a reference number. The new ASC date was a few weeks out, which was fine. For whatever it's worth, the Contact Center representative also confirmed the field office that had our I-485 — same one that had been sitting on it, so at least nothing had been transferred without our knowing.

0 coins

Did you have to explain why you needed to reschedule a second time, or did the representative just do it?

0 coins

She asked for a brief reason and I explained the work conflict. She noted it and rescheduled without any issue. The reference number she gave was the important part — I kept that in case anything came up later.

0 coins

Two reschedules is apparently the limit for doing it online — after that it goes to the Contact Center. Good to know there's still a way to do it, it's just one more step.

0 coins

For the congressional inquiry question — there's nothing in USCIS's rules that says you can't do both a case inquiry through their site and a congressional inquiry at the same time. They're separate channels. The e-Request goes directly to USCIS; the congressional inquiry goes through your representative's office and then to USCIS. Some people do both when a case is very delayed. Whether one interferes with the other is hard to say, but neither one stops the other from going through.

0 coins

Is there any risk of a congressional inquiry being seen negatively by an officer reviewing the case?

0 coins

There's no USCIS rule that says a congressional inquiry hurts a case. Officers are supposed to respond to them and then the case proceeds as normal. The inquiry doesn't change what's in the file, it just puts a spotlight on the fact that the case exists and is pending.

0 coins

Exactly what I found when we did it. The officer who eventually interviewed us had the congressional inquiry on file but it didn't come up at the interview at all — the case was reviewed on its own merits.

0 coins

Has the address on the I-485 been consistent throughout? Three years is a long time and if there was a move in between, a notice could have gone to an old address. USCIS doesn't forward mail and a change of address with the post office doesn't update it with USCIS. If a notice went to a wrong address, the online account might not reflect it correctly.

0 coins

We've been at the same address since before she filed so that shouldn't be an issue. But it's a good thing to check — I can see how that would cause a silent delay if a notice went nowhere.

0 coins

The online account has an address tool for updating it on pending cases. Good habit to verify what USCIS has on file even if nothing changed, just to confirm it matches.

0 coins

Address issue was actually what held up our case for about four months. USCIS sent a notice to our old apartment and we never saw it until we phoned the Contact Center and found out a notice had been sent.

0 coins

Two RFEs on the medical is unusual enough that it might be worth at least a one-time consultation with an immigration attorney. Not because you necessarily did anything wrong, but because an attorney can look at both RFE responses, the current I-693, and the case timeline and tell you if there's something specific to address proactively before the next contact with USCIS. After three years I'd want someone with more visibility into what field officers look for on the medical piece.

0 coins

Is there anything specific we should bring to a consultation — both RFE notices, our responses, the I-693 forms?

0 coins

Both RFE notices and your written responses, both I-693 forms, the receipt notice, and any other notices you've received. An attorney can review the whole picture in one meeting and tell you if there are gaps the officer might still flag.

0 coins

Worth getting the USCIS online account printout of your case history too — it shows every notice generated and can confirm dates that match what you think was sent vs. received.

0 coins

Six weeks since the last response went in — that's genuinely not that long in USCIS time, as frustrating as it feels. The case status not moving after six weeks of an RFE response doesn't tell you much. What matters more is whether you're outside the posted processing time for your field office when you count from the receipt date, not from when you responded to the RFE. The original receipt date is the one that determines whether you're within range.

0 coins

The original receipt date was about three years ago, so yes, we're well past what the processing times page shows for our field office. The page shows about 20 months as the posted range.

0 coins

If your receipt date is three years old and the posted time is 20 months, you're clearly outside the range. That means the e-Request and the congressional inquiry are both appropriate options right now, not something you have to wait longer to try.

0 coins

20 months posted and three years actual is a significant gap. That's exactly the kind of situation the case inquiry tool and the congressional office exist for.

0 coins

Has the case ever been transferred between service centers or field offices? Sometimes on longer cases, especially with RFEs, the file can move between offices and each transfer resets what shows up in the status. If the online account shows a different office than the one on the original receipt notice, that could explain some of the silence.

0 coins

The receipt notice listed one field office and the online account still shows the same one. No transfer that we can see.

0 coins

Good — a transfer would have added another layer. If it's been at the same office for three years, the congressional inquiry might be the most direct way to get eyes on it, since the inquiry goes specifically to that office's constituent liaison.

0 coins

For the medical piece specifically — does the online account show that both the RFE responses were received with the same receipt number, or did the second RFE generate a separate tracking entry? Asking because the second I-693 is a supplement to the main I-485 file, and sometimes it shows up under a different notice entry in the account rather than updating the main case status.

0 coins

Both RFE responses show under the same receipt number in the account. Each one has its own 'response received' entry with a different date, but they're linked to the same case.

0 coins

That's what you want to see. Both responses logged under the same receipt number means the officer has everything in one file. The case just needs an officer to actually pick it up and finish the review.

0 coins

Green card hadn't come after what USCIS said was an approval — the online account showed no tracking and the notice I'd gotten said the card was ordered. Used Claimyr to reach the Contact Center and the representative found the exact date the card had been mailed and gave me the USPS tracking number. Turned out it had been delivered to a neighbor's box. For your situation with the pending I-485, the same kind of call could at least confirm whether any internal action has happened that hasn't shown up in the account yet.

0 coins

Did the representative find that through the receipt number, or did she need anything else to pull up the mailing date?

0 coins

Just the receipt number and the applicant's name. She found it in about two minutes.

0 coins

Knowing a card was mailed and having a tracking number is so much better than just watching the account and guessing. That's a situation where phoning is clearly the right move.

0 coins

Two medical RFEs and no interview in three years — has anyone had the interview scheduled before or after the medical issues were fully resolved? I'm wondering if the field office interviews some I-485 cases and then finishes reviewing the medical, or if they won't schedule an interview until the whole I-693 is clean.

0 coins

Field offices generally want the medical complete before the interview because the officer goes through the whole case at the interview. If there are outstanding medical issues, some offices wait to schedule rather than have to continue the interview.

0 coins

So responding to the second medical RFE fully might actually be what triggers the interview notice — the officer sees everything is in order and schedules it. That makes the current wait more logical, at least.

0 coins

Whether it triggers it or the congressional inquiry does, the end result is the same. The case has everything it needs, so the interview should be next.

0 coins

Slight correction to something mentioned earlier about reaching out to the Contact Center — Tier 1 there handles things like checking on a pending case and what notices have been sent, but if the concern is something more specific to the pending I-485 review itself, the representative may send it to a Tier 2 officer rather than resolving it on the spot. That doesn't mean anything is wrong, it just means the inquiry gets escalated to an immigration officer. Worth knowing going in so you're not surprised if the first representative doesn't have a final answer.

0 coins

Is there a way to ask specifically for Tier 2 when you call, or does Tier 1 decide whether to escalate?

0 coins

Tier 1 decides whether to escalate based on what you're asking about. You can explain the situation clearly and they'll determine if it needs to go higher. You can't route directly to Tier 2 by asking.

0 coins

The escalation is actually useful — Tier 2 is USCIS immigration officers, so if the inquiry does go up, the person looking at it has real authority to look at the case details.

0 coins

Name on the I-485 receipt notice — is it spelled correctly on every document in the file? Three years in, with two RFE cycles, it might be worth checking that the applicant's name is consistent across the receipt notice, the I-693, and any other supporting documents. A discrepancy between how the name appears on the medical forms versus the petition can sometimes stall a case at the officer review stage without triggering a formal RFE. I had a name issue on a notice from USCIS's side — a letter transposed — and I ended up speaking with a representative who reported the typographical error on the call. The case moved within a few weeks after that correction was logged.

0 coins

We've checked every document and the name is consistent across the board. Nothing transposed or missing.

0 coins

Good. It's one of those things that's easy to overlook on a long-pending case. Consistent names across the I-485, the I-693, and the petition removes at least one potential source of quiet delay.

0 coins

After six weeks of silence following an RFE response, the practical next steps as people have laid out here: check the processing times page to confirm you're outside the posted range for your field office, submit an e-Request through USCIS's site if you are, and contact your congressional representative's constituent services office. Those two moves together are the most direct way to get the case looked at without waiting another six months. An attorney consultation to review the medical submissions wouldn't hurt either, especially given the two-RFE history.

0 coins

This is a helpful summary. I think we're going to do the e-Request this week, contact the congressional office as well, and book an attorney consultation to review the I-693 submissions. Having a plan feels better than just refreshing the case status page.

0 coins

That's a solid approach. The case has everything it needs — it just needs attention from the right person at the right time. The e-Request and congressional inquiry both serve that function.

0 coins

Definitely the right instinct. Doing all three in parallel isn't excessive given the timeline — it shows you're engaged and that the case matters, without stepping over any lines.

0 coins

To anyone reading this who's confused about the difference between an RFE and a NOID — they are not the same thing and the response rules are different. An RFE gives you up to 84 days to respond (87 if you count from when it was mailed) and you can send in documents. A NOID is a notice that USCIS intends to deny the case — same window for a response, but only 30 days (33 from mailing), and it's a much more serious notice that usually means you need an attorney right away. This case sounds like it got RFEs, not NOIDs, so don't panic — but if anyone ever gets a NOID instead of an RFE, treat it differently.

0 coins

Is a NOID common after multiple medical RFEs, or is an RFE the typical way they flag medical issues?

0 coins

Multiple medical RFEs are more common than a NOID for medical issues — the RFE is USCIS asking for more, and the NOID comes later only if they've determined there's a reason to deny. If the case has only had RFEs, that's the right track still.

0 coins

Glad you said this — I've seen people on other threads treat an RFE like a near-denial and panic unnecessarily. They're genuinely different situations with different levels of urgency.

0 coins

Related posts

USCIS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure