Back to USCIS

Clay blendedgen

Employment based I-485 removal proceedings terminate court case adjust before immigration judge — my situation

Filing an I-485 for employment-based adjustment of status is complicated enough on its own. Doing it while also having removal proceedings active in immigration court is a whole different level. My employer filed an I-140 that got approved, and my priority date is current, but I've had an open removal case in court for a couple of years now. An immigration attorney told me the judge can handle the adjustment directly, but I'm seeing contradictory information everywhere about whether I need to terminate the court case first or whether I can adjust before the immigration judge. Has anyone actually gone through employment based i-485 removal proceedings terminate court case adjust before immigration judge? Trying to understand what actually happens procedurally and what USCIS's piece of this is, if any, since the attorney is saying the court does it not USCIS. Would really appreciate hearing from anyone who's dealt with this.

April of this year my employment-based I-485 had been pending at the Nebraska Service Center for fourteen months with zero movement in the online account. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live person at the Contact Center — it handles the hold time on the phone line so you end up talking to a representative. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at USCIS: https://youtu.be/eSz742AOvHc. The representative pulled up my file and confirmed the date my Green Card had been mailed, which the online account still wasn't showing. Knowing the card was actually in transit let me stop worrying about whether the whole case had stalled.

0 coins

Fourteen months with no movement would wreck me. Glad the rep at least had the mailing date on their end even when the account wasn't showing it.

0 coins

Appreciate you sharing that. My situation is a bit different since it's the removal proceedings angle that's the hold-up, but good to know the Contact Center can actually see card mailing dates even when the online account lags.

0 coins

The attorney is right that in removal proceedings the immigration judge has the authority to grant adjustment of status on an employment-based case if you're otherwise eligible — that's the adjustment before the judge path. USCIS is a separate lane. If your case is in proceedings and you file the I-485 with USCIS instead, USCIS will generally decline jurisdiction and send it back because the court has the case. The judge handles it, not the service center. What your attorney should be doing is filing the adjustment application with the court, not with USCIS.

0 coins

So USCIS literally won't take the I-485 if I'm in proceedings — they'd just reject it? Or do they accept it and then terminate their own review?

0 coins

They can accept it and then find they lack jurisdiction, which wastes time and filing fees. The cleaner path, and what most practitioners do, is to go straight to the judge. Your attorney is steering you right on that part.

0 coins

Came here to say exactly this. The court has exclusive jurisdiction once proceedings are open. Filing with the service center by mistake is a costly detour.

0 coins

Two months before my removal hearing my attorney filed all the supporting documents with the court. The I-140 approval notice, the priority date evidence, the affidavit of support — everything that would normally go to USCIS in an I-485 package goes to the judge instead. It took me a while to get my head around the fact that USCIS wasn't in the picture at that point.

0 coins

Walk me through what happened at the actual hearing, if you don't mind. Did the judge approve it on the spot or was there a continuance?

0 coins

The judge wanted additional documentation about my employer's ability to pay, so there was a continuance to a second hearing. At the second one it was granted. The whole process from filing with the court to the second hearing was about eight months.

0 coins

Eight months is actually not bad for a court adjustment. Some of these cases drag out much longer depending on the court's docket.

0 coins

The 'terminate and refile with USCIS' option does exist and sometimes attorneys recommend it, but it means asking the court to terminate proceedings without prejudice, then filing the I-485 with USCIS like a normal adjustment case. The tradeoff is you lose the court's protection while the USCIS case is pending, and if something goes wrong you might face proceedings again with less favorable circumstances. Most employment-based people in proceedings with a current priority date just go the adjustment-before-the-judge route for that reason.

0 coins

That risk of losing the court's protection is what I keep coming back to. If I terminate and something goes sideways at USCIS — an RFE I can't fully respond to, a denial — I'm back in a worse spot.

0 coins

Exactly. The judge path keeps everything in one place. It's also worth knowing that if the judge denies the adjustment, you can appeal that through the immigration court system, not through USCIS's I-290B process, so the form types and timelines are completely different.

0 coins

i didnt know there were two different paths at all, thought everyone just filed the i-485 with uscis no matter what. guess i was wrong about that

0 coins

85 days is what I had to respond to the RFE on my employment-based I-485 — I counted from the date on the notice and panicked thinking I had way less. The notice itself printed the deadline, and I nearly missed reading that line. If anyone in this thread gets an RFE at any point in an employment-based case, everything USCIS asks for goes in one submission, not in batches.

0 coins

The 84-day window is real and officers can't extend it beyond that. A partial response is treated as asking for a decision on whatever's already in the file, so sending a first batch and planning a second is a trap.

0 coins

Mine wasn't 84 days exactly — USCIS adds 3 days when they mail it, so 87 from when I actually received it. Though I went by the printed deadline date to be safe.

0 coins

wait so if i send half the documents now and the rest in two weeks thats basically like not responding fully? i have an rfe open right now and i thought partial was better than nothing

0 coins

Partial is treated by USCIS as a complete response — meaning they'll decide on what you gave them, not wait for the rest. Get everything together and send it all at once before that printed deadline.

0 coins

USCIS isn't completely irrelevant even when the judge handles the adjustment. The I-765 for a work permit can still be filed with USCIS as a standalone if you need employment authorization while the court case is pending. Proceedings don't automatically kill your ability to apply for certain benefits.

0 coins

Had no idea about the standalone I-765 being available. My EAD actually expired two months ago and I've been in limbo. Would filing a new I-765 require any special notation about the removal proceedings?

0 coins

Your attorney needs to identify the right eligibility category on the I-765 — there are specific ones for people in proceedings. This is not a form to self-file when you have an open court case. But yes, the EAD process runs through USCIS independently of what the judge is doing.

0 coins

This is a really important point. EAD and the I-485 are separate filings with separate timelines even in a normal case, and proceedings make it more layered.

0 coins

The online account showed my employer-based I-485 as 'case received' for nine months without a single update. Used Claimyr to reach a representative, who found a typographical error on my receipt notice — my employer's name was garbled in the system — and took a report for it on the call. The representative said a corrected notice would come by mail, and it did about three weeks later.

0 coins

Nine months with just 'case received' would have me calling every week. Good that the rep caught the typo — a garbled employer name in an employment-based case seems like it could cause real downstream issues.

0 coins

That was my concern too. The representative confirmed it was a data-entry issue on USCIS's side, so no new I-765 or fee was needed, they just corrected their own error.

0 coins

Typos on USCIS notices are more common than people think. The case inquiry tool on USCIS's site is supposed to handle those but I've had better luck talking to someone directly.

0 coins

Something worth flagging for the original poster: if the I-140 is from a specific employer and that employer goes under or lays you off while the court case is still pending, the portability rules under AC21 get complicated in a removal proceedings context. The employment relationship matters to the judge too, not just to USCIS. This is very much attorney territory, not forum territory.

0 coins

My employer is stable, fortunately, but I hadn't thought about the portability angle at all. Flagging this for my attorney conversation next week.

0 coins

Even if the employer is solid now, it's worth asking your attorney explicitly about what documentation to keep current — pay stubs, employer letters — because that evidence is what the judge looks at to verify the job offer is still real.

0 coins

Went through this two years ago with an employment-based case while in proceedings. The judge granted the adjustment at the second hearing, the case with the court terminated at that point, and USCIS processed the Green Card issuance from there. The card came in the mail about ten weeks after the judge's order. So USCIS does come back into the picture at the end, just not for the decision itself.

0 coins

Ten weeks from the judge's order to card in hand is helpful to know. I've been imagining this taking forever even after a grant.

0 coins

The ten weeks was my experience; your mileage may vary. The judge's order goes to USCIS and they issue the card. What I will say is keep an eye on the USCIS online account after the order, because that's where the card tracking number shows up when it ships.

0 coins

This whole chain of events — judge grants, USCIS issues the card — is exactly the part I couldn't find clearly explained anywhere. Appreciate someone spelling it out.

0 coins

The 30-day window on a Notice of Intent to Deny confused me when I first saw one — I had been thinking it was the same as an RFE with a longer deadline, but those are two different documents with different response times. An RFE gives up to 84 days, a NOID gives 30 (33 from the mail date). They look similar but the deadlines are very different. If you get either one in an employment-based case, that deadline on the face of the notice is what matters.

0 coins

i thought an rfe and a noid were basically the same thing too, good to know theyre not

0 coins

An RFE is asking for more evidence. A NOID is saying USCIS is planning to deny and here's why — you get to respond but the bar is higher and the deadline is shorter. Very different situations to be in.

0 coins

The form numbers are both I-797E for the RFE and I-797 for the NOID, which doesn't help with the confusion since people just see 'I-797' on both. Reading the actual header on the notice is how you tell.

0 coins

In proceedings the immigration court's docket is what drives the timeline, not USCIS processing times. USCIS's processing times page won't tell you anything useful for an in-court adjustment. Some courts have backlogs of two or three years, some move faster. The judge's next available hearing date is the real bottleneck.

0 coins

My next hearing is in four months. Attorney says it may take two hearings, so we're looking at potentially eight to twelve months total, which lines up with what someone else described earlier in this thread.

0 coins

Four months to the first hearing and a possible second one is a pretty common timeline. Having all the documentation ready before the first hearing gives you the best shot at the judge being satisfied at that appearance.

0 coins

The court docket point is so important. People check USCIS's processing times and panic, not realizing the whole process is at the court, not a service center.

0 coins

November of last year the Nebraska Service Center had my employer-based I-485 sitting quiet for over a year. Claimyr is what I used to reach a live rep at the Contact Center — the representative pulled up my case and read off the actual receipt date and confirmed Nebraska had the case, which matched my I-797C but I wanted to hear it confirmed. The rep didn't have news about a decision timeline, which isn't something they'd share anyway, but at least I knew the case was where it should be.

0 coins

Nebraska having the case confirmed by a rep sounds like basic info but it genuinely would calm me down to hear that said out loud. Sometimes you just need the confirmation that it hasn't been lost.

0 coins

Exactly. The receipt notice says Nebraska and the rep confirmed Nebraska. Nothing fancy, but that's what I needed at that point in the process.

0 coins

wait can i ask something — if the judge adjusts the status does that mean the green card is conditional or permanent? i thought conditional green cards only happened in marriage cases

0 coins

Conditional residence with the two-year card and the I-751 is specifically for marriage-based cases when the marriage was under two years old at the time of approval. Employment-based adjustment doesn't produce a conditional card. The judge grants full lawful permanent residence in an employment-based case.

0 coins

ok that makes way more sense, i was mixing up the two totally different situations. thanks for clearing it up.

0 coins

The I-751 for removing conditions is entirely a marriage-based thing. Employment-based people never see that form in their own case unless they also have a marriage-based derivative applicant on the same I-485, which is a different situation entirely.

0 coins

Address updates matter a lot even in a court-track case. USCIS still needs a current address for mailing the Green Card after the judge's order, and noncitizens in the United States have to report a move within ten days of moving. The online account's address tool and a paper AR-11 by mail are both ways to do it. A postal forwarding order doesn't update the address with USCIS, and USCIS's mail doesn't forward.

0 coins

Moved about six months ago and updated with USCIS through the online account, so I think I'm covered there. Good reminder though — I hadn't connected the card mailing step with needing USCIS to have the right address at that stage.

0 coins

Updating in the online account is the right move. The AR-11 on paper also works but the online tool is faster and you get confirmation.

0 coins

The biometrics appointment is one part that USCIS handles even for in-court adjustment cases — they still schedule a biometrics appointment at a local ASC for fingerprints. The appointment notice is an I-797C. If you miss it without rescheduling, USCIS can consider the application abandoned, so that appointment matters even if everything else is at the court.

0 coins

Had my biometrics already, about two months after the original I-485 was filed with USCIS before anyone had flagged the jurisdiction issue. So that part is done at least.

0 coins

Then you're ahead of that step. Keep the receipt notice for that appointment in your records since the court will want to know biometrics are cleared.

0 coins

The judge in my case asked specifically whether biometrics had been completed before scheduling the adjustment hearing. Having the confirmation ready made the first hearing much smoother.

0 coins

Appeals and motions in immigration court are on a completely different track than USCIS's I-290B. If the judge denies the adjustment, the appeal goes to the Board of Immigration Appeals, not to the USCIS office that handled the I-140. I know someone who filed an I-290B thinking that covered the court denial and lost weeks of time. The denial notice from the court itself explains the appeal path.

0 coins

That's genuinely alarming — the I-290B going to the wrong place after a court denial. I'll make sure my attorney and I are clear on which track any appeal would go through before we even get to the hearing.

0 coins

Read the denial notice top to bottom if that ever happens. The notice spells out what can be filed and where. For anything USCIS decided — the I-140 approval, any evidence issues with USCIS's piece — the I-290B within 30 days (33 from the mail date) is correct. For the judge's decision on adjustment, the Board of Immigration Appeals is the right door.

0 coins

The 33-day window from the mail date is what catches people. They count from the date printed on the notice instead of adding 3 days for mail, and suddenly they think they have more time than they do.

0 coins

Priority date staying current is the piece everyone focuses on, but the I-140 petition itself needs to stay approved too. If an employer withdraws the I-140 before the adjustment is granted, that creates a serious problem. AC21 portability can help if you've had the I-485 pending for 180 days or more, but that's one more thing to have your attorney watch.

0 coins

My I-140 has been approved for over two years and the employer is not planning to withdraw it, but I'll bring up the 180-day portability threshold with my attorney as a checkpoint.

0 coins

Two years approved and a stable employer is a good position. The portability clock starts from when the I-485 was filed, not when the I-140 was approved, so confirm with your attorney when that 180-day mark hit.

0 coins

kinda stressed reading all this because my employment i-485 is at a service center and nobody mentioned court to me at all. do i need to check if i have proceedings i dont know about

0 coins

Removal proceedings aren't something that happens without you knowing — you'd have received a Notice to Appear and had to go to court. If you've never received that document and never appeared before an immigration judge, your case is at the service center with normal jurisdiction and this thread's court-track discussion doesn't apply to you.

0 coins

oh ok that makes sense, i definitely would know if id been to court. guess im on the normal uscis track then, sorry for the panic

0 coins

The Notice to Appear is the document that opens proceedings. Very easy to tell whether you're in court — you'd have that notice and a court date. Regular I-485 filers at a service center don't have one.

0 coins

An I-765 renewal filed less than 90 days before the EAD expires is not filed too late — USCIS actually advises filing at least 90 days early to avoid a gap. So if someone in proceedings has an expiring EAD and files a renewal through USCIS while the court case proceeds, filing it 90 or more days out is what USCIS recommends to try to avoid working without authorization while waiting.

0 coins

Mine expired two months ago so I'm already in a gap. Attorney is handling the standalone I-765 filing now. Wish I had known the 90-day guidance earlier.

0 coins

For anyone with an expiring EAD: the renewal I-765 can be filed at that 90-day mark without waiting until closer to the expiration date. The card won't come early but the application can go in early.

0 coins

The form's page on USCIS's site has the current filing fee since it changed in 2026 — always check there before preparing the renewal package.

0 coins

The travel question is one almost everyone in a pending adjustment situation gets wrong at some point. With an open I-485 and removal proceedings, leaving the United States without proper documentation can have serious consequences. This is a question for the attorney, not the forum, but it's worth raising before any travel plan comes up.

0 coins

Hadn't planned any travel but good flag. I'll make sure my attorney and I discuss the advance parole question specifically given the proceedings context.

0 coins

Raising it before any trip comes up, not after, is the right instinct. The advance parole process runs through USCIS on Form I-131, but whether it's safe to travel with proceedings open is a legal question only an attorney familiar with your case can answer.

0 coins

Every time travel comes up in a removal proceedings thread someone finds out the hard way. Good that it's being flagged early here.

0 coins

Related posts

USCIS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure