Back to USCIS

Dylan Hughes

EB1C I-485 San Diego field office approval timeline after RFE — what actually happened on our case

Finally posting because I spent weeks searching and couldn't find anything current on this. Filed the I-485 concurrent with the I-140 EB1C (multinational manager category) about 22 months ago. Everything was going fine until month 11 when we got an RFE asking for additional evidence on the managerial capacity — pay stubs, org charts, letters from the company abroad, the whole deal. We responded within the window they gave us, submitted everything together in one package as required. Then silence. The online account showed the response received but nothing moved for another six months. We're in San Diego so the case is at the field office there. Last week the case status finally updated — approved. So I'm posting the timeline in case it helps anyone else waiting after an RFE on an EB1C. Happy to answer what I can.

Roughly 11 months from RFE response to approval — that matches what a few others have reported for employment-based cases at field offices. The important thing you did was send everything at once. The rule on RFE responses is that everything goes in one submission; a partial response is treated as asking USCIS to decide on whatever is already in the file. Sending the org charts and the company letters together with the pay stubs in one package was exactly right. Congratulations on the approval.

0 coins

Appreciate that — yes, we were very deliberate about waiting until every document was ready before submitting anything. Our attorney was clear that splitting it would be treated as a final response.

0 coins

The 'one package' rule tripped me up on my own I-485 RFE last year. I uploaded one document early thinking it would show I was responsive, and my attorney had to clarify with USCIS that the full response was coming. Stressful. Never doing that again.

0 coins

Glad it worked out. The notice itself actually prints the deadline date — that's the date to plan around, not any estimate someone gives you online.

0 coins

Sometime in month 14 of waiting after my own EB1C RFE response, the address on file for my case was still the old apartment — I'd moved during the long wait and wasn't sure if USCIS had the update. I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person at the Contact Center on the line. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at USCIS: https://youtu.be/eSz742AOvHc. The representative pulled up my case and confirmed the address USCIS had on file — it was still the old one. She walked me through what I needed to do, and I updated it through the online account that same day using the address change tool there.

0 coins

Address during a long wait was something we worried about too. We moved about eight months into the wait and updated through the online account immediately. Good to know the representative could confirm what address they had.

0 coins

Worth noting for anyone reading — updating your address with the post office doesn't update it with USCIS. USCIS mail doesn't get forwarded. The online account has the address change tool for that, or paper AR-11 by mail.

0 coins

Learned that the hard way when my EAD renewal notice went to my old address. The post office didn't forward it. Had to contact the Contact Center to sort out what happened.

0 coins

EB1C cases are interesting because the managerial capacity question is exactly what adjudicators dig into at the I-485 stage too, not just the I-140. The RFE asking for org charts and foreign company letters is pretty typical for multinational manager petitions. How detailed did your org chart need to be? Did they want signatures on the foreign company letters or just company letterhead?

0 coins

Org chart had to show the full reporting structure — the poster's direct reports, their managers, and the layers above. The foreign company letters needed company letterhead and were signed by HR and the direct supervisor there. No notarization required for ours but our attorney said requirements vary.

0 coins

The HR letter plus supervisor letter combination makes sense. Some adjudicators also want headcount numbers in the org chart showing how many people each manager oversees. Sounds like yours covered that.

0 coins

Our EB1C petition had the same level of detail requested. Attorney said the key is showing the person spent the majority of time on managerial functions, not technical work. The org chart alone isn't enough without the letters backing it up.

0 coins

22 months total for the I-485 and you're at the San Diego field office — did you ever get called in for an interview, or was it approved without one? I'm at month 16 on a similar case and keep wondering if an interview notice is coming or if it'll just move straight to approval.

0 coins

No interview for us — approved without one. That said, I know other EB1C filers who did get interviewed. I don't think there's a reliable way to predict it in advance.

0 coins

That's helpful to know. Month 16 and the online account just says 'case is being actively reviewed.' No interview notice yet so maybe it goes straight through. I'll keep watching the account.

0 coins

Whether an interview gets scheduled varies. USCIS can request one at any point, and the notice for it comes as an I-797C. Watching the online account for updates is the right move.

0 coins

Waiting 11 months after an RFE response with no updates in the online account sounds absolutely brutal. I'm at month 7 post-RFE-response on my own employment-based case and already checking the account twice a day. How did you stay sane during the wait?

0 coins

Honestly, checking less helped. Set a reminder to look once a week instead of daily. The account rarely updates mid-process and obsessing over the same status message doesn't change anything.

0 coins

Twice a day is probably too much. You're right. I'll try to cut it down. The status message hasn't changed in two months so more checking isn't going to make it move.

0 coins

Seven months post-RFE-response with no movement felt identical to our experience. The status stayed the same until about a week before approval when it shifted to 'new card is being produced.' Went from frozen to done very fast at the end.

0 coins

Posting because I had a question that might be relevant here — at the RFE response stage, did you submit through the USCIS online account or by mail? We're preparing our response now and trying to figure out which route is safer for an I-485 that was filed on paper.

0 coins

Ours was filed on paper, so the RFE response went by mail as well. If your original filing was on paper you generally respond by mail to the address on the RFE notice itself — the notice prints where to send it.

0 coins

The notice does print an address — I just wanted to confirm that paper-filed cases respond by mail and not through the account. That clears it up.

0 coins

Paper-filed I-485 means the response goes by mail to the address printed on the RFE. Online-filed cases can upload directly in the account. The RFE notice itself will make clear which applies.

0 coins

We mailed ours with a tracking number so we had confirmation of delivery. Peace of mind when you're submitting a full package of original documents.

0 coins

TWENTY TWO MONTHS. And people wonder why applicants are stressed. The system takes that long and the online account just says 'being reviewed' the whole time with zero other information. No indication of where in the queue you are, nothing. Congrats on the approval but honestly the timeline is exhausting just to read.

0 coins

Hard to argue with that. The lack of any intermediate updates during the review period is genuinely frustrating. The processing times page on USCIS's site gives ranges but it doesn't tell you where your specific case is.

0 coins

The processing times page at least tells you the range for the form. For field office cases the range can be enormous. Some cases at the same office move in 12 months, others take 24. No way to know which yours will be.

0 coins

Field offices handle their queues differently and USCIS doesn't publish case-by-case estimates. The only real data points come from people posting their own timelines, which is exactly why threads like this one matter.

0 coins

About four months before my own EB1C I-485 approval came through, an interview notice showed up in my online account that I hadn't expected. I wanted to confirm the date and which office was listed on it, so I ended up talking to a Claimyr representative about my case. The representative confirmed the interview date and that the case was assigned to the San Diego field office — consistent with what was in my account. Went to the interview and the approval followed about six weeks later.

0 coins

Six weeks from interview to approval is a good outcome. How long was the interview itself? Did they ask much beyond what was in the initial petition?

0 coins

The interview was about 30 minutes. Officer reviewed the managerial role questions — similar to what the RFE had asked about — and asked about my current employment status. Standard questions from the I-485 as well. Nothing that felt like a curveball.

0 coins

Knowing the interview covered the same ground as the RFE is actually reassuring. If the RFE response was solid, the interview isn't starting fresh — the officer already has that record.

0 coins

30 minutes for an EB1C interview at that office seems about right based on what others have said. The interview notice coming through the online account first is consistent with how USCIS sends them.

0 coins

After our RFE response was submitted, the online account updated to show 'response received' within about a week. Then nothing for months. Did you have any other activity in the account during those six quiet months — messages, requests, anything — or was it completely static?

0 coins

Completely static. 'Response received' stayed for the entire six-month period. No messages, no requests, no other notices. The card production notice was the next thing we saw.

0 coins

Card is being' produced was also the signal for us that something had moved. Sounds like'that s the standard jump — from frozen status to card production with nothing inbetween.

0 coins

The tracking number for the card shows up in the online account when it's mailed. USCIS uses USPS Priority Mail with delivery confirmation for Green Cards so you can track it once that number appears.

0 coins

Reading the timeline here — the RFE came at month 11 — did you have biometrics done before the RFE arrived or after? Our biometrics were done early but I'm wondering if a pending biometrics step could be what's causing our case to sit without movement.

0 coins

Biometrics were done at the ASC around month three, well before the RFE arrived at month 11. By the time the RFE came the biometrics step was long finished.

0 coins

Three months for biometrics makes sense. Ours were done at month four. So biometrics isn't the reason cases stall post-RFE — the review of the response itself takes the time.

0 coins

Biometrics happen fairly early in the process and USCIS schedules them by sending an appointment notice — an I-797C — with the date, time and the Application Support Center location. That step and the RFE review are separate parts of the process.

0 coins

Concurrent filing of I-140 and I-485 — did USCIS adjudicate the I-140 first and then the I-485, or did both decisions come together? I've seen conflicting things about whether concurrent filers get a separate approval notice for the I-140 before the I-485 moves.

0 coins

We got separate notices — I-140 approval came about four months before the I-485 approval. For us the I-140 was clearly adjudicated first and then the I-485 continued independently.

0 coins

Separate notices for separate decisions makes sense. I'd read somewhere that concurrent filers sometimes only see one combined notice but that must have been wrong or outdated.

0 coins

The I-140 is a petition filed by the employer; the I-485 is the applicant's adjustment application. They're separate filings and get separate notices. Concurrent filing just means they're sent in together, not that they get one combined decision.

0 coins

Confusing the two notices is easy when you're new to this. The I-797C for the I-140 and the I-797C for the I-485 look similar but have different receipt numbers. Keep them separate in your files.

0 coins

Months 12 through 17 of waiting on our EB1C case had me convinced something was wrong. I sent a secure message through the online account asking for a status update. Got a message back saying the case was being reviewed and to allow additional time. Not exactly informative but at least confirmation that the case was active.

0 coins

We sent a similar message around month 15. Same kind of response — actively reviewed, allow more time. At least it's something, even if it doesn't tell you much.

0 coins

The message in the account is the main way to reach USCIS in writing without calling. It's not fast and the replies are generic but it does create a record that you asked.

0 coins

The online account message is one option; the Contact Center is another if you need a live person. The Contact Center handles case status questions and can tell you what's on the case — same day, real time.

0 coins

Did the approval notice — the I-797 — come before or after the Green Card itself arrived in the mail? Ours just approved and I'm tracking both and not sure which typically comes first.

0 coins

For us the approval notice arrived a few days before the card itself showed up. The tracking number for the card appeared in the online account first, then the card arrived, then the paper notice came a couple days later.

0 coins

So tracking number in the account is the earliest signal, then the card, then the paper notice. Good to know what order to expect.

0 coins

USCIS mails Green Cards by USPS Priority Mail with delivery confirmation. The tracking number showing in the account means the card has been sent. If the USPS tracking shows delivered but nothing arrives, that's when you'd contact the Contact Center or file a case inquiry.

0 coins

The I-797D is the approval notice that comes with the card, technically. If your USPS tracking shows delivered but the card never comes, start with USPS's missing mail process first, then contact USCIS.

0 coins

Eleven months between submitting the RFE response and approval is a long stretch but not unheard of for field office employment-based cases. The processing times page on USCIS's site shows ranges for field offices by form, but individual cases vary. What matters is that the response was complete and submitted all at once.

0 coins

Checking the processing times page regularly is worth doing — the ranges do shift over time and sometimes field offices get faster or slower seasonally.

0 coins

The page updates and can shift month to month. It won't tell you where your specific case sits in the queue but it gives a sense of the overall pace at that office.

0 coins

Approval came through for us too, but the Green Card never showed up in the mail. The tracking number in the online account showed delivered but nothing was in the mailbox. I went through USPS's missing mail steps first — no result. Then I used Claimyr to reach a live person at the Contact Center, and the representative opened an inquiry on our case for a card that hadn't been received. She said USCIS would look into it and we'd hear back through the account.

0 coins

That's the nightmare scenario after a long wait — approval finally comes and then the card goes missing. Glad the representative was able to open an inquiry. Did anything come through the account after that?

0 coins

About three weeks after the inquiry was opened, a message appeared in the account with next steps. It confirmed USCIS was reviewing the delivery issue and would follow up. Still waiting on the actual resolution but at least it's moving.

0 coins

USPS missing mail is the right first step when tracking shows delivered. After that, the Contact Center or the case inquiry tool on USCIS's site is the right path. Glad you got the inquiry opened.

0 coins

Delivery confirmation showing 'delivered' but nothing in hand is more common than it should be. The inquiry process exists exactly for this — USCIS may attempt a second delivery or, if that doesn't resolve it, a new form is typically needed to reissue the card.

0 coins

For anyone wondering about expedite requests on a pending I-485 after an RFE — USCIS does consider them for things like severe financial loss or urgent humanitarian situations. An expedite doesn't decide the case; it just moves it up the queue. And you'd need to show the reason with supporting evidence when you ask. No guarantee either way.

0 coins

Seven months post-RFE-response and I looked into an expedite. Didn't qualify under any of the criteria clearly enough to feel confident asking. The financial loss category is real but you need documentation showing it.

0 coins

The expedite request goes through the Contact Center, Emma on USCIS's site, or a secure message in the online account with the receipt number and evidence attached. You put the case for it; USCIS decides and generally doesn't give a reason either way.

0 coins

Expedites for employment-based cases on financial loss grounds — employers sometimes write letters. Whether it moves the case is unpredictable but submitting the request with real documentation is the approach.

0 coins

Concurrent filing question that came up for me: we filed the I-765 and the I-131 together with the I-485. The EAD came through in about four months. When the I-485 is eventually approved, does the EAD just become moot, or does anything need to be done with it?

0 coins

Once the I-485 approves and the Green Card arrives, the Green Card is your status document going forward. The EAD served its purpose during the adjustment period. No action needed on it once the card comes.

0 coins

Makes sense — the EAD covered the gap during the wait and the Green Card takes over. No form to file or card to return or anything like that.

0 coins

Exactly right. The I-765 and I-131 filed with the I-485 are specifically for the adjustment period. Once the I-485 approves and the permanent resident card is in hand, those documents have done their job.

0 coins

What civil surgeon form did you need for the I-485 and was it still valid by the time the case approved? We're at month 10 and starting to wonder if the medical exam could expire before we're done.

0 coins

The medical is on Form I-693, completed by a civil surgeon. Ours was done and submitted with the initial filing. By month 22 of the case the form had been in USCIS's hands the whole time — once it's submitted with the application it's part of the file.

0 coins

So once the I-693 is submitted with the I-485 it's in the file and doesn't need to be redone? That's reassuring for a long-pending case.

0 coins

For specific questions about whether a medical exam result is still valid for your case, the form's page on USCIS's site is the right place to check, and an attorney can advise if there's any concern.

0 coins

EB1C approvals after long RFE waits feel rare enough that people post about them. The timeline you've laid out — concurrent filing, biometrics early, RFE at month 11, response submitted complete, six months of silence, approval — is actually a really useful data point. Field office employment-based cases don't get nearly as many public timelines as service center cases.

0 coins

Exactly why I posted. Service center timelines are everywhere. Field office EB1C data is scarce. If the month-by-month breakdown helps one person calibrate their expectations, it was worth writing out.

0 coins

Field office timelines for I-485 are hard to find because there are fewer of them and they vary so much by office. Having a San Diego EB1C timeline with an RFE in it is genuinely useful data for anyone in the same situation.

0 coins

Agreed. The more complete the timeline the more useful it is. Knowing biometrics came at month three, RFE at month 11, response submitted complete, six months of review, approval — that's an actual map, not just 'it took about two years'.

0 coins

Related posts

USCIS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure