Confused about Social Security retirement timing at 56 - early benefits vs. waiting to increase my average
Hello everyone! I'm new to planning for Social Security and feeling pretty overwhelmed. I'm 56 and thankfully still working, but saw someone mention they retired at 52 which got me thinking. Right now I'm actually making the highest salary of my career (about $87,000/year). Does continuing to work at this higher salary actually help my eventual SS benefit amount? I've heard something about them using a 35-year average? I've got a few other questions that might be basic but I'm confused about: - If I decide to claim early at 62, am I locked into that lower payment amount forever? - Is it okay to have personal savings alongside Social Security? Does that affect my benefit amount? - I was originally planning to work until at least 62, but now I'm wondering if waiting until my FRA would be significantly better? Sorry if these are obvious questions! Just trying to figure out how to maximize my retirement security. Any advice appreciated!
16 comments
Amina Bah
Welcome to retirement planning! Yes, your current higher earnings will likely help your eventual benefit. Social Security calculates your benefit based on your highest 35 years of earnings (adjusted for inflation). If you're earning more now than in previous years, each additional high-earning year will replace a lower-earning year in that calculation, potentially increasing your benefit. To answer your other questions: - Yes, if you claim at 62, your payment amount will be permanently reduced (about 30% less than your full retirement age benefit). - Personal savings don't affect your Social Security benefits at all! That's your money. - Waiting until your Full Retirement Age (probably 67 for you) would give you significantly more - and waiting until 70 gives you the maximum possible benefit (about 8% more per year you delay after FRA). Take some time to create a my Social Security account on ssa.gov if you haven't already. It will show your earnings history and projected benefits at different claiming ages.
0 coins
Paolo Marino
•Thank you so much! I didn't realize they use the highest 35 years - that makes me feel better about working these extra years. I actually had some years in my 20s where I earned very little, so I guess these higher-earning years will replace those. I'll definitely create that account you mentioned to see my projections.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
hi there! i claimed at 62 and kinda regret it now. locked in at a lower amount when i could really use the extra $$ now that everything's so expensive. my sister waited til 67 and gets almost $600 more than me every month! just something to think about
0 coins
Natasha Petrova
•The system is RIGGED to make us claim early! They know most people can't afford to wait, so they take the lower amount, and SSA saves billions. Meanwhile those who are wealthy enough to delay get rewarded with higher payments. The whole 35-year calculation is designed to benefit people with stable high-income careers too, not those of us who had to take breaks or work lower-wage jobs. It's completely UNFAIR!!!
0 coins
Javier Hernandez
I was in almost your exact situation 5 years ago. I was making about $92K at age 58, which was way more than my earlier years. I worked until 63.5 and it definitely boosted my benefit amount by continuing to work those high-earning years. One thing nobody's mentioned - your personal savings won't affect your Social Security amount, BUT if you have significant other income in retirement (like from a 401k or traditional IRA), some of your Social Security benefits might become taxable. Up to 85% of your SS benefits can be subject to income tax if your combined income is high enough. Also, if you're married, there are additional strategies to consider regarding when each spouse should claim. The higher earner often should delay as long as possible, especially if there's a significant age or earnings difference.
0 coins
Paolo Marino
•Wait, they tax Social Security benefits?? I had no idea. I do have a 401k through my employer with about $215,000 in it right now. Are you saying I'll get taxed on both my 401k withdrawals AND my Social Security? That seems like double taxation!
0 coins
Emma Davis
Not sure if anyone mentioned this yet, but you need to understand your "replacement rate" when making this decision. At 62, you get about 70% of your Full Retirement Age (FRA) benefit. At your FRA (probably 67), you get 100%. If you wait until 70, you get 124% of your FRA benefit. This difference is PERMANENT and SUBSTANTIAL. For example, if your FRA benefit would be $2,000/month, at 62 you'd get about $1,400/month. If you wait until 70, you'd get about $2,480/month. That's over $1,000 difference every month for the rest of your life! The breakeven point (where waiting starts to pay off) is usually around age 80-82. If you think you'll live past that, waiting is usually better financially speaking.
0 coins
LunarLegend
•I tried calling SS about this exact topic last month cuz I'm turning 62 soon. Spent 2 hrs on hold before giving up! Then my neighbor told me about Claimyr.com which got me through to an agent in like 20 mins. They have a video demo at https://youtu.be/Z-BRbJw3puU showing how it works. Agent was super helpful in explaining my personal benefit amounts at different ages. Totally worth it to get actual numbers from SSA for your specific situation!
0 coins
Malik Jackson
my husband started taking SS at 62 but he kept working part time. they kept taking away some of his benefits becuz of the earnings limit. nobody told us about that! just be careful if u plan to work while collecting before your FRA
0 coins
Amina Bah
•That's an excellent point about the earnings test! If you claim before your Full Retirement Age AND continue working, SSA will deduct $1 in benefits for every $2 you earn above the annual limit (which is $22,320 in 2025). Once you reach FRA, there's no earnings limit. The good news is that these "lost" benefits aren't truly lost forever. When you reach FRA, SSA recalculates your benefit to credit you for the months when benefits were withheld.
0 coins
Oliver Becker
do u have a pension? if u do u might get hit with WEP or GPO which can reduce ur ss benefit. happened to my buddy who worked for the state for 15 yrs
0 coins
Javier Hernandez
•Good question about WEP (Windfall Elimination Provision) and GPO (Government Pension Offset). These only apply if you have pension income from work where you didn't pay Social Security taxes, typically certain government jobs. If all your work has been in the private sector or you've always had Social Security taxes withheld, you don't need to worry about these provisions.
0 coins
Natasha Petrova
Everyone acts like waiting until 70 is always better, but that's NONSENSE! If you need the money at 62, take it! Life is short and UNPREDICTABLE. My brother waited to file and then died at 68 - got NOTHING after paying in his whole life! Plus the government keeps moving the goalposts - who knows if they'll change the rules again before you hit FRA? Take what you can get when you can get it!
0 coins
Emma Davis
•I understand your frustration, but I should clarify something important: If your brother was married, his spouse would be eligible for survivor benefits based on his work record. Also, if he had dependent children under 18 or disabled adult children, they would receive benefits. So his contributions weren't completely lost. You're right that personal circumstances matter enormously in this decision. Health status, family longevity, current financial needs, and marital status should all factor into the claiming decision. It's definitely not one-size-fits-all.
0 coins
Paolo Marino
Thank you all for the advice! This has given me a lot to think about. I'm definitely going to create that my Social Security account to see my actual numbers. Since I'm making good money right now and don't absolutely need to retire at 62, it sounds like waiting might be the better option for me. I think I need to do more research about how my taxes will work in retirement too. And I'll check out that Claimyr service to talk directly with SSA - I've tried calling before and it's impossible to get through! Really appreciate everyone sharing their experiences!
0 coins
Amina Bah
•You're welcome! One final thought - consider getting a retirement checkup with a financial advisor who understands Social Security claiming strategies. Many offer free initial consultations, and they can help you understand how your Social Security benefits will interact with your other retirement assets, potential tax implications, and how to create a withdrawal strategy that maximizes your overall retirement income. Best of luck with your planning!
0 coins